If Lu Meng listened to Sun Quan s release of Guan Yu, what would happen to the Three Kingdoms?

Updated on history 2024-03-01
26 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Guan Yu was a famous general in the late Eastern Han Dynasty and a representative of both wisdom and bravery. Guan Yu lost Jingzhou at the last moment, and had Lü Meng of Eastern Wu capture, and was finally killed by Lü Meng. If Lü Meng did not kill Guan Yu ruthlessly, but let him return to Shu, then Eastern Wu would be defeated by Shu soon after, and the Central Plains would also have a great chance of being unified by Shu Han, because after Guan Yu's death, a series of things that were unfavorable to Shu occurred one after another, resulting in a decline in Shu's national strength.

    1. The defeat of Guan Yu in the war of Dangping Wu made Jingzhou lost. For Liu Bei, who had just established the Shu Han regime, he already had the strength to compete for the world, and he had just defeated Cao Cao, and the morale of the Shu army was very strong. And Jingzhou is Liu Bei's first step in dividing the world, so Liu Bei will inevitably fight to the death with Sun Quan for Jingzhou.

    Before, it was because of insufficient strength that I used the excuse of Jingzhou. If the Shu army was the vanguard of Guan Yu, in the battle of Yiling, Lu Xun would not be able to burn the company camp for 700 miles, and Guan Yu's force value was unrivaled at that time, so with the Shu army joined by Guan Yu, it would also be a horse and a flat river, and directly level Dongwu. <>

    Second, unify the world because after Guan Yu's death, Liu Bei sent troops to Eastern Wu, during which the five tiger generals lost 3, only Zhao Yun and Ma Chao remained, and also lost countless troops and financial resources. This was undoubtedly a fatal blow to the newly established Shu Han regime, and it would take a long time for Shu to recover. If Guan Yu is released back to Shu, Shu's national strength will not be significantly damaged, and Shu can destroy Eastern Wu, and the national strength will be even stronger.

    After that, the Cao Cao group in the north formed a momentum of front and back attack, and the two big cities of Chang'an and Luoyang could be captured at the same time, and Wei would definitely not be able to parry, so the unification of the Central Plains was just around the corner. <>

    The Battle of Yiling was the most influential battle after the three divisions of the world, and it directly announced that Shu had entered a recovery period from defeat. If Lü Meng listened to Sun Quan's words and let the tiger return to the mountain, the power of Liu Bei's group would not be significantly weakened, and he could take Eastern Wu first, and then Cao Cao, and then complete the goal of supporting the Han Dynasty. But after Guan Yu was killed and the battle of Yiling was lost, the situation was very unfavorable to Shu.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    If this is the case, then the time for the destruction of Shu may be postponed, which is tantamount to letting the tiger return to the mountain. The triumph may continue for some time.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    The three countries will continue to maintain a strong position. If Lü Meng listened to Sun Quan's words and let Guan Yu go, then Guan Yu would continue to confront Eastern Wu and Wei after returning to Shu, and the situation of the three kingdoms would continue to be maintained.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    The situation in the Three Kingdoms will not change much, and Liu Bei will still find an excuse to launch the Battle of Yiling, because this is an inevitable battle for Shu Han to get out of the predicament.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    First, it is impossible to release Guan Yu, because Cao Cao released Guan Yu, and Guan Yu in turn attacked Cao Wei even more. The second person who wants to kill Guan Yu is Sun Quan, Liu Bei doesn't plan to pay it back as soon as he borrows Jingzhou, and he still wants to attack Eastern Wu, if it weren't for Guan Yu's water war, he would have attacked Sun Quan a long time ago. Therefore, no matter what, Guan Yu will die.

    Even if Guan Yu didn't fight Cao Wei and wasn't killed, Shu Han wouldn't be able to unify the Three Kingdoms. Zhuge Liang planned a good policy for Liu Bei before he left the mountain, that is, he could only divide the world into three parts. At best, it was destroyed a few years later.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Sun Quan used the method of "knowing with affection, moving with reason, coercion and temptation" to enlighten Lu Meng with his own experience. , so that Lu Meng was convinced, worked his own, and studied hard.

    Sun Quan persuaded him to learn, and pointed out to Lu Meng the necessity of "learning", that is, because of his important identity as "being in charge of affairs", he "must not learn"; Then he appeared to point out the possibility of "learning". So that Lu Meng has no excuse, "it is the beginning of learning".

    Sun Quan persuaded Lü Meng to learn to be concise and powerful

    Dialogue-based, the characters' language is concise and expressive, highly expressive, and free of redundancy. For example, the study of Lu Meng can only be summarized in the sentence "Meng Nai began to learn", and there is no mention of what books he read and how he worked hard. In the following article, the conversation between Lu Meng and the two is only explained with the sentence "discuss with Meng", what topics the two are talking about, and what opinions Lu Meng has that makes Lu Su respectful are omitted and not written.

    In addition, other languages outside the dialogue are also very concise and concise, such as "Wuxia Amun" and "Impressive Treatment" are used today because of their conciseness.

    Also, in terms of plot development, Sun Quan's deliberate persuasion finally made Lu Meng go to school, and his profound knowledge after learning amazed Lu Su, and Lu Meng sighed with his confident words of "Shibei three days, that is, more impressive", the context is interlocking, the connection is natural, the cause and effect, and it is orderly.

  7. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Lü Meng directly forced Guan Yu to death, which was tantamount to not obeying Sun Quan's orders. and led the troubled waters to Eastern Wu, making Liu Bei angry with Sun Quan. An army of vengeance has been summoned.

    How could Sun Quan not hate Lu Meng. It is not possible to be executed on the surface, after all, it is meritorious to capture Jingzhou, and it is poisoned or other conspiracies to be executed during the banquet. The pen of the historian only writes what the prince wants to see.

    Something I want future generations to see.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Because Lü Meng didn't like Guan Yu very much, and leaving Guan Yu was a great threat to Eastern Wu, Lü Meng would rather disobey Sun Quan's order to kill Guan Yu.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Because he wanted revenge, Guan Yu had insulted him, and he was more cautious, so he would never be soft when he could get rid of Guan Yu.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    That's because he and Guan Yu themselves have a certain grudge, and secondly, because only when Guan Yu dies can he have a chance to get ahead.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    is because Guan Yu is also a very important general, if he can defeat Guan Yu, he can also cut off the wings of the enemy, and he can also make himself more famous.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    How can an ambitious person endure this? In addition to Zhou Yu, there is also Lu on it. Although the two had different views on the recovery of Jingzhou, they had a good relationship with Lü Meng. Lü Meng's purpose in killing Guan Yu was to avenge Lu Su and Zhou Yu.

    When Guan Yu humiliated Sun Quan, Sun Quan wanted to give his son to Guan Yu as a son-in-law in order to strengthen Sun Liu's alliance. As a result, he was humiliated by Guan Yu. At that time, Guan Yu was only the commander, and Wu Quan was Guan Gong.

    Although Sun Quan endured such humiliation, Lü Meng did not. In fact, most of the reason why Lu Meng hated Guan Yu so much was because of another person, Zhou Yu. Zhou Yu and Lu Meng have always been friends.

    At that time, Zhou Yu was already the governor of Suzhou, and Lü Meng was just an ordinary young general who defeated Li. Although there was a gap in their status, Zhou Yu attached great importance to and supported Lu Meng. It can be said that Lu Meng and Zhou Yu are close brothers.

    Jingzhou was originally the territory of the state of Wu. Sun Quan agreed to lend Jingzhou to Liu Bei, but Liu Bei was later reluctant to return it. Zhou Yu attacked Jingzhou several times, but failed many times.

    Zhou Yu was wounded by an arrow during the attack on Jingzhou, and eventually died due to repeated arrow wounds. This made Lü Meng have a strong resentment towards Shu and Guan Yu. In order to win back Jingzhou from Suzhou and avenge his brothers Zhou Yu, Yu Qing and Li Lümeng, he will not miss the great opportunity to kill Guan Yu.

    After Lu Bu's death, Guan Yu became very domineering. He believes that all the generals in the world are men. In addition, Guan Yu was even more arrogant when he won the battle with Cao Wei.

    Guan Yu humiliated Lü Meng and other Wu generals. Even if Sun Quan proposed to his son and hoped that Ku Dou would marry Guan Yu's daughter, Guan Yu also laughed at "how can a tiger's daughter marry a dog", which made Minister Sun Quan lose face.

    Lu Meng Guan Yu was killed, which can be said to be a new hatred and an old hatred. If Shu occupied Jingzhou and did not return it, Guan Yu would insult Jingzhou's generals and even King Wu. Who can stand it!

    Lü Meng is currently unknown. According to Guan Yu, he is a nobody. However, Lu Meng wanted Guan Yu to know that they had not deceived the young man into becoming poor.

    In the end, Guan Yu's self-esteem was hurt.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    It's because Lu Meng is a violent temper, Sun Quan can tolerate Dongwu for Chenkai, but his brother Lu Meng has already had murderous intentions towards Guan Pei Yuyu a long time ago, so whoever occupies Jingzhou will become Lu Meng's enemy later, and Lu Meng will help his good friend to take revenge.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    Because Lu Meng's stool was just to carry Sun Quan's pot. The middle school emphasized that Guan Yu could not be killed because Liu Bei was acting. In order not to tear the jujube with Liu Bei, but Guan Yu is very powerful and can't stay. He can only let Lu Meng carry this pot.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    Because there was a personal enmity between Lu Meng and Guan Yu, he killed Guan Yu in order to take revenge.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    Because Lu Meng was more short-tempered, it was also for revenge, so Lu Meng wanted to kill Guan Yu.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    In "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", when Lü Meng died, Zhang Zhao once said to Lu Xun: "The lord asked the Metropolitan Governor to take Jingzhou, and if he took Jingzhou, he would hurt Guan Yu, but the Metropolitan Governor insisted on going his own way, killing Guan Yu, and forcing Eastern Wu into danger, and his death could be regarded as retribution."

    From these words, it can be seen that Lü Meng did not obey Sun Quan's orders and insisted on going his own way, plus when he died, Lü Meng's face was blue and purple, and the corners of his mouth were dirty, which can be inferred: Lü Meng was poisoned by Sun Quan for disobeying the king's orders.

    So why did Sun Quan poison Lu Meng? There are a number of reasons for this:

    Lü Meng disobeyed Sun Quan's wishes and led the troubles to Eastern WuAt that time, the most beneficial thing for Shu Han and Eastern Wu was the union, Lü Meng snatched the territory of Jingzhou, which was already somewhat unfavorable to Soochow, but Lü Meng killed Guan Yu, Sun Quan didn't dare to kill him, for fear of getting into trouble, but Lü Meng did it, which Cao Cao was willing to see, and Sun Quan later gave Guan Yu's head to Cao Cao, and also intended to lead the disaster to Cao Cao.

    Secondly, after Lü Meng attacked Jingzhou, he set up an altar to commemorate Zhou Yu, in order to repay Zhou Yu's kindness of knowing that year, rather than repaying Sun Quan's kindness, and later Lu Xun came and transmitted Sun Quan's order: After taking Jingzhou, he will be stationed to recuperate, and Guan Yu cannot be killed".However, Lu Meng ordered people to close the city gate, did not let Lu Xun enter the city to pass the order, and asked people to hunt down Guan Yu, which was obviously disobeying the king's order.

    Finally,Lu Meng killed Guan Yu with selfish motives, because Guan Yu was an invincible god of war at that timeIf you kill Guan Yu, you will be famous all over the world, but it's a pity that it's such a desire that Lu Meng was poisoned in the end, which is really a pity!

    Why do you think Sun Quan poisoned Lu Meng?

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-20

    Mainly because Liu Bei was inevitably furious after Guan Yu's death at that time, he naturally needed someone to take the blame, and Lu Meng was favored by Sun Quan.

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-19

    In the face of the coming anger of Shu, Sun Quan immediately fell ruthlessly, and it was not cost-effective to have a head-on confrontation with Shu, so he set two strategies, the first was to celebrate Lu Meng's successSun Quan drank poisoned wine and poisoned him to death, to appease the anger of Shu, second, he immediately sent someone to send Guan Yu's head to Cao Cao**, hoping to blame Wei State.

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-18

    If Lü Meng did not kill Guan Yu, Liu Bei would not have led a large army to attack Wu, but would continue to maintain the Sun Lian alliance.

  21. Anonymous users2024-01-17

    Sun Quan was actually a ruthless person, and in the face of the anger of the Shu Kingdom, he also decided to poison Lu Meng and wanted to kill the anger of the Pingxi Shu Kingdom.

  22. Anonymous users2024-01-16

    Sun Quan knew that Guan Yu was dead and Liu Bei would definitely come to take revenge, so he took Lu Meng as a substitute for the dead ghost.

  23. Anonymous users2024-01-15

    Sun Quan is too stupid, he thinks that if he wins Jingzhou, he will be able to get the world, even if he catches Guan Yu again, he does not kill him.

  24. Anonymous users2024-01-14

    Guan Yu once humiliated Lu Meng, and Lu Meng was bent on killing Guan Yu to take revenge, so he had to kill Guan Yu.

  25. Anonymous users2024-01-13

    Take off Guan Yu's head,Then Liu Bei will definitely not let go of Wu GuoEven if the strength of the two sides is equal, they will use the strength of the whole country to attack Wu. When the time comes, the gains will outweigh the losses. Sun Quan had already warned Lü Meng not to just chase him and not to kill him, but Lü Meng did not listen to his advice.

    Sun Quan immediately thought of harming Sun Quan and blaming Wei for the matter.

  26. Anonymous users2024-01-12

    Why did Sun Quan kill Lü Meng? Lü Meng's death is very strange, in the battle of Jingzhou that year, Lü Meng killed Guan Yu, who was the mighty world, and Lü Meng's death and Guan Yu's death are actually subtly linked. As the governor of Eastern Wu, Lü Meng was a famous general of Wu in history, with power in his hands and military power, and his determination to kill Guan Yu made Lü Meng's reputation revived.

    Under normal circumstances, Sun Quan has a lot of vigilance against Lu Meng, and Lu Meng's death is related to Sun Quan!

    The Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms, Wu Shu, and the Biography of Lü Meng recorded such a sentence: At the age of forty-two, he died in the inner hall, and the time was very sad, and he was degraded for it. Lu Meng was only forty-two years old when he died, which can be described as an untimely death and an early death of illnessThere was Sun Quan's bad intentions behind him, and he didn't find any excuse to execute Lu Meng openly, so he had to find some ghostly means to deal with Lu Meng, for what purpose?

    Regain Lü Meng's military power. For Sun Quan, the suspicion is very serious, and those who can threaten their status do not end well, and Lu Xun, who made the first contribution in the battle of Yiling, also died of anger in Sun Quan's scolding. There is also the whole thing to put Guan Yu's death on Lu Meng, and there is nothing to hold a dead person accountable.

    For Cao Cao, Guan Yu is Liu Bei's left arm and right arm, and the thoughtful Cao Cao will not easily kill Guan Yu, lest Liu Bei be an enemy with him and let Dongwu reap the benefits of the fisherman. The entanglement of the Three Kingdoms is inseparable from love and hate, since he wants Guan Yu to die, Cao Cao's best is to borrow the knife of Eastern Wu to kill Guan Yu, the fact is that Sun Quan and Lu Meng are really determined to attack Guan Yu, interlocking, and resourceful about the Three Kingdoms.

    As for why Sun Quan wanted to kill Lu Meng, the biggest reason was to get rid of the troubles one by one, as the lord of the power to plot too much, this is also a thing that existed in various dynasties later, you fight for me.

Related questions
7 answers2024-03-01

Sun Quan's father, Sun Jian, and his brother, Sun Ce, laid the foundation of Jiangdong. After Sun Ce's death, Sun Quan took power and became a prince. Later, Sun Quan and Liu Bei united to defeat Cao Cao's army in Chibi and established the Sun-Liu Alliance. >>>More

19 answers2024-03-01

Colleague. It is also the relationship between the former Metropolitan Governor and the successor Metropolitan Governor.

4 answers2024-03-01

1.(1) Fault.

2) Promise. 3) Tell. >>>More

5 answers2024-03-01

Sun Quan said to Lu Meng: "You are now in an important position, you must not study!" "Lu Meng shirked his busy military affairs and didn't have time. >>>More

27 answers2024-03-01

Yes, it was indeed recommended by Lu Meng, when Sun Quan seized Jingzhou and killed Guan Yu, Liu Bei did not listen to Zhuge Liang's advice because of the revenge of his second brother, and Xingliangchuan 700,000 soldiers came to annihilate the Wu State, Wu King Sun Quan was frightened when he heard it, and wanted to return to Jingzhou to let Liu Bei withdraw his troops, but Liu Bei was extremely resentful, and said: "I must destroy the Wu State and avenge the second brother." "There is no way, Sun Quan can only send troops to block, but how can Wu have a general who can resist the generals of Shu, Wu lost several generals in a row, and lost several battles in a row, Sun Quan immediately discussed with Lu Meng, so Lu Meng recommended Lu Xun to resist Liu Bei, Sun Quan followed, and Lu Xun lived up to his expectations, because of Liu Bei's light enemy, Lu Xun burned Liu Bei's camp for 700 miles and repelled the Shu army, so Lu Xun was deeply loved by Sun Quan, and was later named the governor. >>>More