I don t know guitar and piano, can I compose music in the future? Help! It s about the future

It's unlikely, at least you have to be able to memorize the score you sing, composition is not so simple, music theory must be understood, maybe you can find a very good person who can listen to the music and keep the score to help you.

Composition is a course, like English, mathematics, and foreign languages, and needs to be studied specifically, if it is a self-entertaining composition, you can find some composition books to learn by yourself, but if it is about the future, it is still recommended that you start from harmony, find a teacher to take classes, or go to ** college to audit and study, you sing better, indicating that your musicality is very good, as long as you study steadily, you will definitely succeed

If you know staves, you can do it, and if you can compose music, it's almost the same, and you have to have confidence in yourself

I'll go, you can learn this slowly in the future, you can sing it if you sing well, wow, clams, support, if you become popular in the future, don't forget me. It is also good to be able to sing and play instruments, but it doesn't have to be able to do so.

Hello, I suggest you learn harmony This is the most basic composition Piano and guitar can't know both, oh doesn't need to be good, just understand, hehe.

If your pitch is very good! No, you don't!

If your pitch is a little bit inaccurate, then you need to rely on the instrument.

If you can read the music and reflect the harmony! No, you don't!

If not, it's better to learn the piano and use it instead of your eyes.

The above is that you know very well what kind of sound (sound) your song will be, if you can do it, you really don't need to use musical instruments to assist, I don't know what your situation is, tell me about my method.

I don't use any instruments when composing, I feel like I write it directly on paper, using simple notation (fast, convenient).

The tune is ok, and then transcribed onto the staff, with harmony (in fact, the harmony has been roughly decided when writing the tune).

At this time, look at the whole score and revise the original tentative harmony.

Finally, when I want to listen to the full effect, I will use MIDI to take care of this task, here is a digression, the early MIDI is more mature is PCM sound, there is no sampled sound source, which makes me love and hate, sometimes it should be like this, but it can't achieve the relationship of timbre, sometimes it can't have such an effect (real people, real instruments), it can actually be the relationship of timbre.

This is, if all your conditions are OK, you don't need musical instruments, but I seem to have accumulated these conditions after learning (practicing) various musical instruments, so I don't have back pain when I stand and talk, hehe!

If you really want to learn to compose, you must know how to play the piano, because composition is not only about writing a melody score, but also about writing a score. To test the effect of a work, it is very difficult to express it without a piano.

Of course, amateur composers writing a single part piece of music are another matter.

MIDI's words don't need to understand a single instrument, anyway, you're not reading staves, it's a piano rolling window, what's the difference between understanding and not understanding?? It's just that if you don't know an instrument, you will learn it slower than someone who knows an instrument, because you can't know chords or something.

If it's a real composition department, it's not okay to not understand a single instrument.

It's not necessary for melody alone, but given the importance of chords in **, it's best to have a kind of instrument at hand.

If you're a professional, you must know how to play the piano.,There's a lot of things you need to play and experience by yourself in the accumulation process.,And you can't always write a piece that you can't play.。。

For general pop songs, it is better to know a little instrument, even the simplest piano or guitar. Because composition involves a harmonic progression and melodic direction. And if you want to memorize these scales, you have to refer to the standard scales on the instrument, unless you are a Beethoven who is not hung up, and you don't have to listen to it to know which one is which.

I am a student at ** Academy, studying composition and vocal music. We can talk about it in detail.

No, you don't! But your knowledge of music theory and composition skills should be good enough so that the piece you write can form a whole in your mind, even if it is a symphony that doesn't need an instrument, you will form the whole work in your mind.

In my case, I don't usually write music with the help of an instrument, unless I need to record it as a solo instrument; The main thing is to write staves. Now that you have a computer, you can write music directly on the software and play it back to achieve the same effect as playing an instrument.

You don't need to know how to play an instrument when composing, it's good to know music theory and have talent, and MIDI or something depends on the keyboard.

To learn composition formally, you must know how to play an instrument, and it is best to be proficient in several instruments.

I thank you. Have you ever seen a composer who has never held a book and nibbled on it? Or do you think learning ** is what?

The first thing to learn is singing and musical instruments, how do you learn to eliminate these two? Holding a book and nibbling on music theory? Memorize them one by one?

Even if you memorize English, you should also pay attention to listening and speaking. Those who learn to compose can not sing, but the instrument is very important, playing a certain instrument in person and listening to and analyzing are two different things, the first floor is right, no wonder there are so many ** people so rubbish now, it turns out that there are no ** literacy people at all. To learn to compose, you have to know how to play an instrument, unless you are someone who doesn't know anything and writes something that you call melody.

By the way, assuming you don't know how to p, you can imagine what it's like to write a symphony, huh. Can you imagine it? I'm afraid I can't even understand the scores of various musical instruments fluently.

Hello, the composition is more complicated, let me briefly say:

1. Determine the key, usually pop music is the natural major and minor key. Therefore, if it is a minor key, the beginning and end should be "6", and the middle melody is free to play. If it is a major key, the ending should be "1", and the middle part should be played freely.

2. Inspiration, the melody fluctuates like thoughts with emotional ups and downs.

3. Arrangement, if you want to complete the song, you should write an accompaniment. Usually the pop formula can be applied: - add or delete changes as needed).

Guitar: It is recommended to practice more scales (learn a few more scales), practice more 24 fingerings, and practice more rhythms (including chord presses).

Basic Music Theory" by Li Chongguang.

and Vocal Music" by Sposobin.

Musical Instrument Law" by Liang Guangcheng.

Fundamentals of Composition, by Schoenberg.

The Structural Function of Harmony by Schoenberg.

Hope it helps.

** With Composition Technique (Team) - Melody in the Sky.

To compose. Let's get a solid foundation in music science first, and harmony again!

Always pay attention to gathering inspiration. You open a notebook of inspirations, and the first thing is to record the wonderful things that pop up unintentionally. Second, be a guitar pickpocket and record the guitar jokes in your favorite songs by hearing.