Which was more iron fisted in the rule of the Ming Dynasty or the Qing Dynasty

There are strengths and weaknesses of each other, and it is difficult to distinguish between them.

There is no doubt that it is the Qing Dynasty, but with a pig's tail, I don't know how many real men in China have died unjustly!

The internal rule was the Qing Dynasty, and the establishment of the Military Aircraft Department marked the peak of imperial power.

The external rule was still the Qing Dynasty, and the strict racial hierarchy was its greatest feature.

Bright! Agents are on the rampage! Jinyiwei, East Factory, West Factory......

As for the Qing Dynasty, it depends on whether it is for the Manchus or the Han Chinese.

For example, the Qing Dynasty was more ruthless in shaving the hair of the Han people.

Even the hairstyle and clothes are in charge, invincible, unprecedented.

The Qing Dynasty, the Ming Dynasty was still very enlightened.

Actually, I think it's the Qing Dynasty, because the rule of the Qing Dynasty came according to the policy of closing the country to the outside world, and you said that the internal suppression and external closure are not considered an iron fist?

In essence, the Ming Dynasty was wiped out by the Qing Dynasty, and Li Zicheng was just a kick in the door.

The public opinion in the field of historiography is that the Qing Dynasty was the pinnacle and master of China's feudal dynasties.

The Ming Dynasty was powerful, militarily the Ming Dynasty was much stronger than the Qing Dynasty, the military technology was high, and the civilian group of the Ming Dynasty was incomparable to any period in history.

At that time, the Ming Dynasty was worried about internal and external troubles, with Li Zicheng inside and Qing soldiers outside, and it was difficult to protect itself. If there is Yuan Chonghuan, the Ming Dynasty can still last for decades. The Qing Dynasty is also very powerful, and it is also worthy of praise to be able to destroy the army of a dynasty!

The Ming Dynasty was much better than the Qing Dynasty, at least the Ming Dynasty was able to defeat the Japanese invaders, and the Ming Dynasty was an open country, for example, Zheng He went to the West, which was to exchange practices with the world. During the Ming Dynasty, China was powerful in the world.

The Ming Dynasty, only one, the Ming Dynasty is the most hardened dynasty in the history of our country, it has never succumbed to foreign invaders, and it has never been the so-called peace policy, or darkness, or faint monarchy, but the Ming Dynasty is definitely a hard dynasty.

It is said that in the Sino-Japanese First Sino-Japanese War, Japan fought under the banner of restoring China and sweeping away the Manchus In the history of the wilderness, it is said that when the Eight-Nation Alliance invaded China, the muskets left by the Ming Dynasty were more advanced than theirs when they were found in the arsenal, but the Qing army would not use them, and if there was no Li Zicheng and Huang Taiji, the Ming Dynasty would not have extinguished the fire.

The Qing Dynasty was a garbage dynasty, bringing us only eternal shame, pain, and more than 1,000 unequal treaties.

Qing Dynasty, there are few good emperors in the Ming Dynasty, except for Zhu Yuanzhang and Zhu Di. Other emperors were either keen on women or keen on painting. Most of them are cowardly and not domineering enough.

Qing Dynasty that was not bad. There is also the prosperous era of Kangqian. It's just that other countries developed during the Qing Dynasty.

The Qing Dynasty's international timing was not good.

It should be the Qing Dynasty, the national economy during the Kangxi, Yongzheng and Qianlong periods of the Qing Dynasty, and the military strength reached an unprecedented strength. However, an era has the limitations of an era, and the course of history cannot be stopped, and it is destined to be replaced.

The quality of the successive emperors of the Qing Dynasty was generally higher than that of the emperors of the Ming Dynasty.

Qing Dynasty. One Kangxi is enough.

The two dynasties had their own strengths and weaknesses.

The Qing Dynasty was good The Qing Dynasty was about foreign countries entering the Central Plains, and because of its foreign identity, it would definitely be resisted by many Han people, but it was still able to gain a foothold, which was his strength, no matter what method he used. The policy of the imperial examination to secure the people has absorbed a large number of Han scholars, and the culture has flourished and developed. Most of the territory of present-day China was established during the Qing Dynasty.

Tell the truth about the Qing Dynasty.

In the early stage of the Ming Dynasty, there were 13 million people, and in the middle and late Jiajing periods, there were only 5.6 million people in the actual control area.

The Qing Dynasty had 11 million territories until its fall.

Intelligence, which appeared before the middle of the Ming Dynasty's Great Confucianism, was definitely more peaceful than before the middle of the Qing Dynasty; Although there were uprisings in the Ming Dynasty everywhere, only Tang Sai'er and Li Zicheng in the later period were relatively large. The Qing Dynasty had the Tianli Sect and the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom, and judging from the history books, the Qing Dynasty did a little better.

At the end of the Ming Dynasty, at least there was no need to cut land and seek peace like the Qing Dynasty, and let others slaughter it.

At the end of the Ming Dynasty, at least one more Zheng Chenggong recovered Taiwan.

At the end of the Qing Dynasty and the end of the Ming Dynasty, it was destroyed by a peasant uprising. At the end of the Qing Dynasty, it was possible to quell the chaos, collect Ili, and destroy the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom, so it can be said that even in the late Qing Dynasty, it was a powerful empire in Chinese history. As for the Western powers, it was a pure accident, can you imagine that there would be an industrial revolution?

Can you imagine that Newton would be smashed open by an apple? This is completely different from the budding capitalism in China. Even so, Qing is not dead.

At the end of the Qing Dynasty, it was richer! Lots of ** ah! After the Opium War, it began to flow out.

Then you have to analyze it in several aspects, economic, political, cultural, military and many other aspects. It should be mainly analyzed from the economic point of view, in fact, the last years of the Qing Dynasty were quite powerful, and a large number of ** inflows, which is not at all as simple as the germination of capitalism often said in textbooks.

In fact, this can be written**, and the problems are very wide-ranging.

It's hard to say, it stands to reason that China's economy began to decline after the Ming Dynasty, and it should be getting worse and worse, but the population at the end of the Qing Dynasty was more than that at the end of the Ming Dynasty, and there was a certain progress in productivity! In response to the trend of world development, it should be stronger in the late Qing Dynasty! But that's relative!