Behind Zhang Fei s killing, who do you think is the mastermind behind it?

The death of Zhang Fei described in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms itself is full of loopholes and cannot withstand scrutiny.

First of all, Zhang Fan and the others were whipped until they vomited blood in their mouths, even if they were iron men, it was impossible for them to still be alive, they should be bedridden. What is the concept of fifty lashes? Ordinary people are basically scrapped after ten lashes, and they have no ability to act.

Secondly, the method by which the two of them entered Zhang Fei's tent was "to lie and tell secrets", even if the guard at the door was a fool, he should know that he had to report Zhang Fei before letting them in.

The second is that the two of them escaped easily, just like they could fly with wings.

Here's my guess:

It is possible that Zhang Fan and the others were not optimistic that Shu would be able to win against Wu, and they didn't want to become cannon fodder, so they took the lead in killing Zhang Fei. In fact, after Wu backstabbed Guan Yu, his national strength was stronger than that of Shu. At that time, many people were not optimistic about Shu and did not think that Shu could win.

The two should not have been assassinated, but directly led the army to rebel, otherwise it would be impossible for them to escape smoothly with Zhang Fei's head. The most likely way to do this is to find an excuse for Zhang Fei to inspect their barracks and kill him in one fell swoop.

A slap doesn't make a sound, and the saying is abused. Zhang Fei was murdered, so Zhang Fei himself has a problem, and this logic is wrong. In fact, in criminal cases, the reason why the victim is victimized is often not related to the victim's own behavior, but purely because of evil thoughts.

In history, there are many people like Zhang Da and Fan Qiang who defect to the enemy and sell their masters to seek glory, and their motives are basically for glory and wealth. Even if Zhang Fei has a grudge against them, it is not the main motive for their actions.

Although it is not written in the history books, after people like Zhang Da and Fan Qiang surrendered to Wu State, would they have the face to say that because Zhang Fei's head is valuable, they killed Zhang Fei for glory and wealth?

Of course not, they naturally made up all kinds of lies about Zhang Fei. to show how wronged they are, and how justified their behavior is.

Chen Shou said that "Yu is rigid and self-contained, violent and ungraceful, defeats with shortness, and is always reasonable", obviously he has also heard some rumors.

Liu Bei said, "Qing torture and killing are not only too bad, but also whipped the Laos athletes, and the order is left and right, and this way to take trouble is also." ”

Cheng Yu said: "Yu treats soldiers well and is proud of scholars, and Fei respects and loves gentlemen and does not care for villains." ”

To put it bluntly, Zhang Fei's implementation of military law is too strict, and it is easy to offend people. In reality, there are many such stern people, and it is not a big problem. You must know that Zhang Fei was in his fifties when he died, which was a long life at that time.

If this kind of character flaw was really so serious, it would have been killed a long time ago, how could it have lived so long.

I think it's Sun Quan. Because Guan Yu had just died at that time, Sun Quan knew that Liu Bei wanted to avenge Guan Yu and would definitely let Zhang Fei be the vanguard. If Sun Quan wants to hit Liu Bei hard, killing Zhang Fei is the best way, so Zhang Fei's death should definitely be a game set up by Sun Quan.

It's Sun Quan. Because after killing Zhang Fei, he went directly to Dongwu. Moreover, killing Zhang Fei weakened the Shu State to a certain extent, and the interests of Eastern Wu were the greatest.

Behind Zhang Fei's killing, it is possible that the mastermind is Liu Bei, Liu Bei thinks that Guan Yu and Zhang Fei's status is too high, so he kills him.

Who killed Zhang Fei, Zhang Fei was a famous general of Shu Han during the Three Kingdoms period, and in his early years, he was like-minded with Liu Bei and Guan Yu, and formed an alliance of life and death in Zhuo, known as the "Taoyuan Three Alliances". Zhang Fei has a far-reaching influence among the people, setting a model for future generations of "loyalty regardless of death, righteousness and dedication". So who killed Zhang Fei?

After Guan Yu's death, Zhang Fei was bent on avenging his brother, and he had a great temper, often beating and scolding his subordinates, who hated him deeply and sneaked in to assassinate him while he was asleep at night.

Zhang Fei was killed by his generals Fan Jiang and Zhang Da.

Zhang Fei (c. 166-221) was a native of Zhuo County, Youzhou (now Zhuozhou City, Hebei), and a famous general of the Shu Han Dynasty during the Three Kingdoms period. Because of its bravery, it is known as "ten thousand enemies" with Guan Yu. Yu is a few years older, and Fei Brother is a brother.

In 184, the Yellow Turban Rebellion broke out, and Liu Bei organized a volunteer army in Zhuo County to participate in the war to extinguish the Yellow Turban Army. The three of them are like brothers, and they sleep in the same bed, and when Liu Bei attends various banquets, he and Guan Yu stand beside Liu Bei all day long.

In 197, after Cao Cao attacked Lü Bu and Lü Bu was defeated, Zhang Fei was appointed as a Zhonglang general. In 200 AD, Liu Beiyi brought the matter to leak, led Guan Yu and Zhang Fei to escape, and killed Pi Tai Shouche, Liu Bei was defeated, Guan Yu was captured, and Liu Bei and Zhang Fei defected to Yuan Shao. In 208, when Liu Bei was defeated and retreated at Changban Slope, Zhang Fei only led 20 cavalry to break down, and no one in Cao's army dared to approach, so Liu Bei was able to avoid difficulties.

Zhang Fei was originally short-tempered, and he looked down on people with low status, so he was not good for his subordinates. Before he died, he was in a bad mood because Guan Yu was killed, and two of his subordinates were slower to whip them, which made these two people have the idea of killing him to ask for merit from Eastern Wu, and put it into practice.

Because Guan Yu was killed by Sun Quan, he was very angry and very sad, after all, brothers for many years, born and died together! So on the way to avenge my brother, I drank all day long, and every time I got drunk, I vented my emotions to my subordinates and whipped my subordinates! In the long run, his subordinates couldn't bear it anymore and killed him after he got drunk again!

In order to avenge Guan Yu and force his subordinates to raise things, two of his subordinates were often beaten, and they refused to accept it, and killed him one night while he was drunk and asleep

I have doubts about this now, it stands to reason that in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Zhang Fei is a butcher, uneducated, and short-tempered, such a person is too strict with soldiers when training, and it is normal to physically punish soldiers and whip soldiers at every turn, and it is normal for such a person to be killed by his subordinates; Question: I have read the Romance of the Three Kingdoms and the research of historians and found that Zhang Fei is actually a very literate person, not a butcher, he is very proficient in calligraphy, painting and poetry, to put it bluntly, he is a person with a lot of connotation, such a person, the soldier should not be what is said in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, so what is the fuse that killed him by his subordinates in the official history? I really don't understand, I've always wanted to ask why such a person was killed by his own subordinates, and what was the purpose of the person who killed him to do this?