If Zhang Zuolin does not die, what will Japan s development in the Northeast look like?

Updated on history 2024-02-27
11 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Zhang Dashuai was born in a green forest and was unruly, and it was okay to give some privileges to the great powers on his own territory, but he definitely couldn't tolerate becoming Pu Yi and Wang Jingwei. When Guo Songlin rebelled, Zhang Zuolin promised to give the Japanese great privileges in order to borrow troops from Japan to quell the rebellion, but afterwards the bearded handsome man played a scoundrel and did not admit it, and the Japanese did not dare to make public what to do with Zhang Dashuai. Li Dazhao was too pro-Soviet, Zhang Zuolin dared to send troops to break into the Soviet embassy, arrest Li Dazhao and hang him, and the Soviets did not dare to do anything to Zhang Dashuai.

    From these two incidents, it is enough to see Zhang Dashuai's tough character, and it can also be reflected that the Japanese and Soviets are very jealous of Zhang Dashuai. At that time, Japan had 10,000 troops in the Northeast, but the Northeast Army had more than 200,000, and the equipment was no worse than that of Little Japan.

    If Zhang Dashuai hadn't died of assassination, and had figured out that Zhang Dashao was a soft commodity, Little Japan would never have dared to occupy the Northeast. After 918, Little Japan provoked two more incidents, the North China Incident and the Shanghai Incident, both of which were hit hard. Especially in the North China Incident, the primitive 29th Army, which was equipped, beat Little Japan quite badly.

    After suffering these two heavy blows, little Japan was relatively honest before the full-scale invasion of China, and did not dare to provoke a big incident. From the perspective of the world situation before World War II, Germany will open up in Europe sooner or later, and small Japan will also make a move in Asia sooner or later, and the first to encounter Japanese aggression will definitely be China's northeast. However, unlike the rise of Germany, Japan was in an economic crisis before 918, and it was precisely because of the ease of standing in Northeast China that little Japan survived the crisis.

    Therefore, if Japan had not stood in the northeast, it is very likely that when World War II broke out, it would have been economically in crisis and unable to provoke World War II. History can't be assumed, everything is speculation, but if Zhang Dashuai doesn't die, I personally think that at least there will be no puppet Manchukuo.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Zhang Zuolin was killed in order to get rid of Japanese control, if he did not die, then Japan's control of the northeast would be suppressed, and with Zhang Zuolin's character, if Japan came really, I am afraid it would not be without resistance.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    The Northeast will not fall so quickly, Zhang Zuolin is fighting the world by himself, it is impossible not to resist, he will fight to the death with the Japanese, little Japan will not be so arrogant, and the invasion of China will be delayed a little!

    If Zhang Zuolin could have enough time to build the Northeast, refine the troops, and properly unite with other forces in China, he might have knocked Little Japan away.

    I think Zhang Zuolin is better than Zhang Xueliang! Stronger in the face of aggression!

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    China is still in civil strife. It must be known that Zhang Xueliang's change of banner in the northeast enabled Chiang Kai-shek's Northern Expedition to successfully and temporarily unify China. And Japan will sooner or later have to do it in the Northeast, 29 years of the Middle East Road made Zhang Xueliang see that if there is a military conflict between China and the Soviet Union or China and Japan, it will not be able to help, and the fall of the Northeast is difficult to avoid, of course, with Zhang Zuolin's character, the war may be more cruel.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Zhang Zuolin is just a puppet of Japan, he doesn't die, it's in the way. After all, Zhang Zuolin is a Northeast man, is he willing to become the cannon fodder of Japan? Just think about what Wang Jingwei looks like. If Zhang Zuolin is alive, it will be even more difficult for Japan to control Manchuria.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    If Zhang Zuolin does not die, it is possible that the Japanese forces will be suppressed in the northeast, but Zhang Zuolin's strength alone is not enough to suppress Japan, and it can only delay the pace of Japanese aggression.

  7. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    must be restricted, Zhang is not easy to bully. Born as a bandit, it's not easy to mess with.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    If Zhang Zuolin hadn't died, Japan probably wouldn't have occupied the Northeast so quickly, he was a warlord leader, and he would definitely not have fought with Japan to the death.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Zhang Jianyuan Zuolin may be able to defend the Northeast if he is alive.

    There is no doubt that with Zhang Zuolin here, Japan does not dare to attack the northeast with such an open fire. After all, Japan is a little afraid of Zhang Zuolin. However, even so, Zhang Zuolin may not be able to stop Japan's covetousness of the three eastern provinces.

    Zhang Zuo and Li Shilin could only delay the time for Japan to launch aggression and make Japan pay a greater price, and it was impossible to occupy the northeast without blood.

    Under the rule of Zhang Zuolin, the Northeast was regarded as the strongest branch in the Beiyang system at that time, and with the assistance of Yang Yuting and others, the economic and military development of the Northeast was also good, and the grain was self-sufficient. He not only saved more than 300,000 troops of the Northeast Army, but also built the largest arsenal in Asia at that time, which could produce some guns and ammunition for his own use, as well as heavy artillery and more than 300 tanks.

    It has also formed an aviation unit with more than 260 aircraft, and also has its own navy, although compared with the army and air force, the navy is worse, but it is also a sparrow, although it is small, and it has all kinds of organs. Such a family background is also relatively solid. Therefore, the Japanese are not only afraid of Zhang Zuolin's personal skills, but also a little afraid of his family background.

    Zhang Zuolin Profile:

    Zhang Zuolin is known as the king of the Northeast, and has been deeply cultivated in the Northeast for decades. Zhang Zuolin was born in the green forest, and he has a bandit nature and domineering. He is well versed in the way of thick blackness, and he plays treacherous and slippery very well.

    On the one hand, he relied on the support of the Japanese to plot his own development, and on the other hand, he was able to grasp the excellent balance between advance and retreat in the face of the aggressiveness of the Japanese, and wandered on the edge of making the Japanese want to completely tear their faces and be reluctant to give up his dilemma.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    I think that Zhang Zuolin is more than ninety percent sure that he can hold on, more than 200,000 troops and advanced arsenals are not false, and the Japanese later fully invaded China by relying on the economy and ** left by the Northeast. Japan began to have less troops, and the economy collapsed during that time. The maximum number of troops that can be mobilized will not exceed 150,000.

    Although Japan's combat effectiveness was good, the Northeast Army at that time was not weak. There is an advanced sail chain**, and I think it can resist the Japanese who were sold at the time. The later Japanese army could not resist.

    Because not a single soldier was wasted to take the northeast, the Japanese were given great confidence and expanded their army in an all-round way. The economy and ** have also settled. Zhang Zuolin will be able to defend the Northeast if he doesn't die, and it's hard to say if he goes back 40 years.

    Because I don't know that then Japan will have a smart car tour, and there will be no economic expansion and production**.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    I think that even if Zhang Zuolin had not died at that time, the Japanese army would still have been able to occupy the northeast at that time. It's just that the only difference between Zhang Zuolin and Zhang Xueliang in terms of military command is that the Japanese will occupy the northeast very late. Because Zhang Zuolin is a very military planner, he will definitely do everything possible to delay the Japanese army's occupation of Northeast China.

    In 1931, Shenyang was occupied by the Japanese army in just one day, and in a short period of time, the Japanese occupied the entire Northeast and began to use the Northeast as a base for the Japanese army. You must know that the main reason why Northeast China was occupied by the Japanese army so quickly at that time was that Zhang Xueliang issued an order not to resist。It is equivalent to saying that before the fight started, they took the initiative to surrender to the Japanese army.

    It was because of his order that many people thought he was actually a coward. Today, there are still many people who can't forgive Zhang Xueliang for this behavior. After all, Zhang Xueliang's military leadership ability was far inferior to that of his father Zhang Zuolin, and some people would have imagined that if Zhang Zuolin was still alive in the world at that time, then he would definitely stop the Japanese army's offensive and change the practice of Japanese aggression at that time.

    But I personally think that if Zhang Zuolin is still alive in this world, then it will not be able to stop the Japanese offensive plan. You must know that the combat effectiveness of the Northeast Army at that time was very weak, and there was no way to compete with the Japanese army at all. At that time, Zhang Zuolin led 100,000 Northeast Army and 30,000 Soviet troops to fight but did not win the war.

    From this, we can see the difference in military strength, and it can also be seen that even if Zhang Zuolin led his Northeast army to fight at that time, it would be difficult for Japan to give up the plan to attack the Northeast, but the only smart thing Zhang Zuolin had was that he would know how to weigh it better than Zhang Xueliang, and he would definitely maneuver between Japan and the Soviet Union and let the two contain each other.

Related questions
13 answers2024-02-27

Zhang Zuolin's plan was to go south to enter the customs by force and unify the whole country, so he actively built the northeast. His cooperation with the Japanese was only temporary, and he just wanted to borrow the strength of the Japanese. Therefore, Zhang Zuolin refused to further agree to the conditions of the Japanese and betrayed Manchuria. >>>More

4 answers2024-02-27

No. Where to register for the exam there.

Select the exam level and center. >>>More

7 answers2024-02-27

More than 10 consecutive years in Japan.

Have been a resident in Japan for at least 10 consecutive years, and have worked or resided for 5 consecutive years. In Japan, there are no criminal offenses, fines, etc., and there are legal tax obligations. >>>More

14 answers2024-02-27

Pu Yi's status in Japan is not high at all. Aside from hanging a title, he doesn't have much power and influence. Although Pu Yi claimed to be "the ruling state of Manchukuo," he was only a puppet of this "country." >>>More

9 answers2024-02-27

Things to consider when choosing a location for real estate investment in Japan. >>>More