If Song Jiang does not accept Zhao an, what will happen to the heroes of Liangshan in the end?

I think if Song Jiang lives or dies, he won't recruit peace. Then it is very likely that the heroes of Liangshan will finally win the world. The main reason for this is because there were many peasant uprisings at that time, so ruthless people may have turmoil in the world, and Liangshan itself is very strong, so there is a chance to unify the world.

Even if Song Jiang does not accept Zhao'an, the heroes of Liangshan will eventually be disbanded. Liangshan is not a territory that can be self-sufficient and can expand outward, Song Jiang has to rely on borrowing food every time he fights, and there are many small detachments in Liangshan, and after a long time, there will naturally be many contradictions. So even if Song Jiang doesn't recruit An, Liangshan won't last long.

As a result, the imperial court sent more troops to sweep Liangshan, and wiped out all the heroes of Liangshan, and if they did not submit to the imperial court, they would only die, because the rulers at that time would not allow such a situation to occur.

With the skills of the heroes of Liangshan and the elite soldiers under him, it is enough to fight against the imperial court. But Song Jiang only wanted to recruit An, and the imperial court at that time had nothing to do with Liangshan, and if he didn't recruit An, the Song Dynasty might perish ahead of schedule.

Their final outcome is also unable to escape the end of being wiped out, without him, the universal law of history.

Song Jiang is Xiao Li in the county seat, and he eventually became the boss of the Liangshan Group, and there is indeed something different about it. Some netizens asked such a question, if Song Jiang insists on greetings, what will happen to the ending of Liangshan Group? The author believes that Song Jiang has reached the stage where he needs to make a choice when he covers up the poisoned arrow and dies.

If Song Jiang insists on not accepting recruitment, how will the heroes of Liangshan end? Expert: There will only be one ending in front of Matsue on a few paths:

First, maintain the status quo of Liangshan, and the Liangshan camp will be built more solidly. second, to take the initiative to merge with larger groups; Third, it was merged by a larger group.

Fourth, the tug-of-war with the court was eventually wiped out. In recent years, new perspectives have been put forward by historical experts. If Songjiang does not accept the bid, Liangshan 108 will only be an ending, and there will be infighting, the Liangshan clique will collapse, and it will eventually be wiped out by the imperial court.

If Song Jiang insists on not accepting recruitment, how will the heroes of Liangshan end? Expert: There will only be one ending, he finally became the boss of the Liangshan Group, and there is indeed something different about him.

Some netizens asked such a question, if Song Jiang insists on greetings, what will happen to the ending of Liangshan Group? The author believes that Song Jiang has reached the stage where he needs to make a choice when he covers up the poisoned arrow and dies.

**The era in "Water Margin" takes place during the reign of Huizong of the Northern Song Dynasty, but the first 80 episodes do not specify the specific era. Until the 82nd "Liangshan Bo Fenjin Damai City, Song Gongming's Whole Gang was Recruited", Shutai Committee and Zhang Shuya Xiang Liangshan read out the Angui order. The edict said.

Ji Xue: After I ascended the throne, I ruled the world with benevolence and righteousness, and fought with industry and commerce. ......So the edict wants to know.

Decree of February 1, Spring of Xuanhua 4. He eventually became the boss of the Yangsan Group, and there is something really different about him. Some netizens asked such a question, if Song Jiang insists on greetings, what will happen to the ending of Liangshan Group?

The author believes that Song Jiang has reached the stage where he needs to make a choice when he covers up the poisoned arrow and dies.

If Song Jiang did not accept Zhao'an, the imperial court would have sent troops to attack Liangshan. Even if it is impossible to exterminate the heroes of Liangshan, a blockade will be imposed on Liangshan, and there will be civil strife in Liangshan due to the lack of food, and it will be difficult to escape the end of destruction.

may eventually be surrounded and suppressed by the imperial court, after all, it is similar to the identity of a "mountain bandit", not a righteous party.

If they hadn't accepted Zhao'an, the heroes of Liangshan would have ended up like this, because the imperial court would definitely do its best to exterminate them.

If the heroes of Liangshan led by Song Jiang did not choose Zhao'an, then they would only face two results, one is to confront the Song Dynasty to the end, and the other is to collude with the local government and develop together. Let's talk about what the final result will be in these two modes.

The first confronted the Song Dynasty to the end.

Although the heroes of Liangshan seem to be united in worship, but because the reasons for going up the mountain are different, and their life experiences before going up the mountain are different, they may be able to unite in a short time, but after a long time, I am afraid that there will be a gap. They can win for a while, but they can't win for a lifetime. Even if the imperial court was corrupt, there was still a regular army.

In addition, if they refuse to recruit an and refuse to obey, then they will all be trapped in Liangshan by the imperial court, and if they cut off their food and grass supply, they will only end up in destruction. In this case, they will not end better than being recruited.

The second is collusion with the local government.

As with the previous situation, due to the different experiences of these people, everyone's attitude towards the imperial court, and the attitude towards the people is also completely different, when there is a foreign enemy invasion, they can be unanimous with the outside world, but after there is no foreign enemy, when they begin to face production and life, it is likely that there will be disagreements, if they collude with the local government, then there will be a large number of heroes who do not agree, and then maybe someone will go down the mountain and leave.

However, as Yue and Chen said in the later biography, the development of Liangshan will definitely face a major reshuffle in the domestic situation in the end. In order to deal with this situation, Liang Shan of course has to be a wall-riding faction, so maintaining the balance of Song and Jin is a long-term solution. However, the general trend of the world will be combined for a long time, and once the balance is broken, Zhao'an will have to be put on the agenda sooner or later.

Therefore, with the conditions of Liangshan, it is most likely to be eliminated, and how long it can survive only depends on the leadership level of the leadership and the senior generals.

If you don't accept Zhao'an, the ending of these Liangshan heroes will be very good, because these people are very righteous martial arts and relatively strong, so they will still live freely on Liangshan.

will perish. Because the heroes of Liangshan can't twist their arms and thighs after all, they will all be destroyed in the end, and there will be no good end.

The ending will be very miserable, and their strength is completely incomparable to that of the troops, and it is easy to be eliminated.

Many Liangshan heroes.

The arrangement? In "Water Margin".

, everyone knows that Song Jiang spent a lot of effort in order to recruit An, but he was worried that the heroes of Liangshan would not be willing. But through the development of things later, we found that in fact, most of the heroes in Liangshan supported Song Jiang Zhao'an, why? The reason is very simple, mainly reflected in the following aspects.

First of all, the reason why they occupy the mountain as kings is because they have committed a crime, if they can clear their problems through Zhao'an, it will definitely be good, and through Zhao'an, they can also be officials, wouldn't it be even better, so of course they support Song Jiang.

Secondly, it is impossible for a good man in Liangshan to be a bandit for a lifetime, if the trouble gets worse and worse, the imperial court will clean it up one day. Can a bunch of grass coars confront the imperial court? Chance.

At a glance, it is sure to lose and lose. These people are also forced or forced by circumstances to become bandits. You can't let your children and grandchildren be bandits, that's not the life of a normal person.

You think that after you become a bandit, you will definitely have a home that you can't go back to, and your relatives won't be able to recognize each other. The descendants of the future will be despised by the world, because they are the descendants of bandits.

In the end, why didn't the heroes of Liangshan go to Fang La.

Or Tian Hu. Wang Qing, but they all came to Liangshan? Tian Hu, Wang Qing and Fang La's subordinate brothers had no idea of recruiting An, but they were all wiped out. In the book, Fang La is recruited to the end, Tong Guan.

He beheaded all the 5,000 who had surrendered. Therefore, whether the heroes of Liangshan are alive or dead, as long as they are recruited, they are at least nominally loyal to the country and are no longer thieves. Therefore, most of the heroes in Liangshan will support Song Jiang Zhao'an.

Except for a few people who were really forced to go to Liangshan, most of them were not, such as the generals of the imperial court, and those who were sent to Liangshan by the Song River, of course, these people supported Zhao'an. And for Liangshan, although he has strong combat effectiveness now, what will he do when he gets old in a few years, so Liangshan can either conquer the city like Fang La and establish his own dynasty, or he can only recruit An.

Many Liangshan heroes don't like Zhao'an, in fact, the reason is very simple, the majority overwhelms the minority, that is to say, within the Liangshan heroes, Song Jiang is not the only one who advocates Zhao'an. In the end, we still have to obey Song Jiang's arrangement.

Because most people want to recruit An, and only a few people don't want to recruit An, so in the end, they all followed Song Jiang and surrendered.

The safety of obeying Song Jiang mainly stems from a righteous character, and there are many Liangshan heroes who themselves come from the imperial court, so they don't have much objection

Song Jiang doesn't go to Zhao'an, and Liangshan may not have a good end. It's not good to say, Liangshan mainly has to rob his house to live, and he is a gang of bandits who occupy the mountain as the king. No matter how powerful the bandits were, sooner or later they were exterminated by the imperial court, Gao Yu was defeated, but later Tong Guan was able to take out an army of 200,000 to conquer Fang La, which shows that the imperial court is not without troops, but just underestimates Liangshan's gang a little.

If you don't recruit An, although it is very happy to get it in a short time, but in the long run, it is indeed not a way.

Liangshanbo is different from Jiangnan La, Fang La wants to establish himself as the king, so he entangled people and horses to invade everywhere, is to occupy the city and the local people, with the city and land, to achieve actual rule and control of an area, then you can collect taxes everywhere, so it is a necessary element of a stable regime, and it is precisely because of this that Fang La dares to use the name of the emperor. But on the other hand, Liangshan has no place to cultivate, and there is no territory except for Liangshan Shuibo, so it will naturally not last long.

Besides, if Song Jiang didn't agree to recruit An, what about the others? We didn't know until Liangshan that there were ordinary people who were oppressed by the imperial court and forced to go to Liangshan, and those who were forced to become Langshan Hospital by the people of Liangshan were cornered. Qin Ming of the thunderbolt fire, Xu Ning, who broke the chain of horses, including Lu Junyi, the second master of Liangshan, were all forced and deceived by Song Jiang and Wu Yonglian to bring them to Liangshan, and these people are not necessarily willing to be bandits for the rest of their lives.

Song Jiang did not accept Zhao'an, it was nothing more than two endings, one was killed by the imperial court, and the other was consumed by internal friction. Although the Liangshan brothers all emphasize righteousness and seem to be united, there are still factional contradictions in it, Wu Song and Lu Zhishen did not agree when recruiting An, and they did not agree with the generals who did not recruit An, and it was estimated that those generals who went up the mountain were also unwilling, so it was difficult for Liangshan to stabilize, and something would happen sooner or later.

I think it will definitely be more miserable, under the circumstances at that time, if the heroes of Liangshan were not recruited, then they would still be regarded as bandits by the imperial court, and they would still be exterminated one day, and the reputation of being arrested at that time was not as good as the reputation of the battlefield after Zhao'an.

First of all, Song Jiang wants to rely on the imperial court, if Song Jiang did not agree to recruit An, the first officers and soldiers will not keep the heroes of Liangshan to grow up, and will gather troops to eliminate them uniformly. This may make the ** army empty for many years, but the final outcome of Liangshan will be similar to total annihilation.

If Song Jiang did not agree to An Zhao'an at that time, the ending of the heroes of Liangshan would also be very miserable, because the imperial court would not let a group of bandits live in peace, so the imperial court would always take Liangshan down.

No, it is normal for Liangshan heroes to be recruited, because at that time, after all, they were burdened with the name of bandits, and if they were not recruited, they would only face the danger of being wiped out.

The heroes of Liangshan continued to be bandits in the mountains, and in the end, they would inevitably be exterminated. Maybe the ending is not as good as Zhao'an. To put it bluntly, Liangshan is a bandit den, not even a separatist force, and it is facing the entire Song Dynasty, and the strength of the two sides is immediately superior.

I think the end will be similar, but choose one to come early, or choose the other to come late, bandit origins are often looked down upon, especially in the Song Dynasty, which emphasized dignity and humility.

The outcome is similar, and most may die from infighting. competed for the next speaker, and finally fell apart