Ma Chao, as a five tiger general, is brave and brave in both civil and military affairs, why was he

Updated on history 2024-02-25
34 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    The reason why Ma Chao was hidden by Liu Bei was because he did not have high emotional intelligence, was particularly easy to be provoked by others, lacked the ability to think independently, and was easily emotional.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Although Ma Chao is very talented, his character is very bad, so he was hidden by Liu Beixue and not valued by him.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    I think Ma Chao has both cultural relics, but he is very easy to be provoked, and the reason why he was hidden by Liu Bei is because Liu Bei does not trust him enough.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    Because although Ma Chao has both cultural relics and is brave, he is unruly and his loyalty is doubtful, so Liu Bei does not dare to reuse him.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    The main reason why Liu Bei does not reuse Ma Chao is because of his character problems. Some people even commented that Ma Chao was Lu Bu's second.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Ma Chao has both ability and talent, but he has his own plans. Liu Bei will not let a dissident person take power and dig his own grave.

  7. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    The main Ma Chao's identity is relatively special, secondly, Ma Chao has no self-knowledge, and finally Ma Chao killed his parents, wife and children in the name of saving his father, which is really unfilial.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    In fact, it is not, Liu Bei is also worried that Ma Chao will rebel, Ma Chao also had ideas at that time, and he was also very floating after Liu Bei's death.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    The identity is noble and talented, which in itself cannot be easily reused by Liu Bei, who has the identity of a prince, and Ma Chao's own character is problematic, let alone easily reused by any force in troubled times.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Because for Liu Bei, Ma Chao is actually an unstable factor, after all, his father started as a rebel.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    is indeed a brave and unscrupulous person, so it is impossible for Liu Bei to reuse Ma Chao, and he is especially afraid of his so-called sense of justice.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    No. Liu Bei felt that he had never really taken refuge in him. That's why I haven't reused him.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    Finally, there is another reason, that is, Ma Chao's starting point is too high, and if the official position is not high, it will not be justified. After all, although Ma Chao is very down, he is after Ma Teng, and Ma Teng and Liu Bei have a good relationship, Ma Chao should actually call Liu Bei uncle. What's more, after Ma Chao became the door, the official position was too low to explain.

    So in the end, Ma Chaoguan worshiped the hussar general. And to be honest, Ma Chao has made a lot of achievements.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    Ma Chao is among the five tiger generals, and his military exploits for Liu Bei are to guard the south for many years, suppress the southern barbarians, and the Qiang people regard Ma Chao as a god.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    Ma Chao was born in the Longxi clan and has high political prestige. After he joined Liu Bei's camp, his greatest contribution was to take Yizhou for Shu and lay the foundation for Liu Bei to become king in Hanzhong.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    Ma Chao is among the five tiger generals. He became famous as a young man and participated in the Battle of Tongguan in the midst of following Liu Bei. Helped Liu Bei complete his great cause.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    failed to shine, fled in all directions after being defeated by Cao Cao, and after taking refuge in Liu Bei, he could only guard the frontier, knowing that he died of illness.

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-20

    Because after Liu Bei named Ma Chao as the general of the Five Tigers, Ma Chao basically did nothing, and did not have any power, and died early.

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-19

    This is because Ma Chao has not been reused by Liu Bei, and he is timid in doing things, since he arrived in Shuhan, he has not been able to give full play to his talents.

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-18

    This is because he is very wooden by nature, even if others say bad things about him, he will not refute it if he knows it.

  21. Anonymous users2024-01-17

    After Ma Chao went to Hanzhong to attach to Zhang Lu, he saw that Zhang Lu would only stick to the land, and thought that it was not enough to work with him, and heard that Liu Bei was besieging Liu Zhang in Chengdu, so he wrote a secret letter to surrender, when Ma Chao led the troops to the city of Chengdu, Liu Bei's group of soldiers was more general, plus Fa Zheng and Zhang Song as internal responses, a series of operations to seize Yizhou were relatively smooth, but in the last battle to capture Chengdu, Liu Bei encountered trouble, Chengdu City is strong, and the savings are huge, look at the King of Hanzhong persuasion table, Ma Chao is ranked first, At that time, the official was General Pingxi, because the only one in Liu Bei's camp who had been a prince was Ma Chao, and Ma Chao was a representative of the Kansai warlords. He had a lot of influence in Liangzhou.

    <> Ma Chao is the same, he is famous and has a high official rank, so he ranks first in the seal that supports Liu Bei as the king of Hanzhong. Liu Bei naturally wanted to make him General Zuo, although he didn't have much power at that time, but he was once the leader of the Xiliang Army after all, and now he still has prestige in the Xiliang region. Liu Bei wants to use his prestige in Xiliang to guard there, otherwise he will have to worry about the future.

    Before taking refuge in Liu Bei, Ma Chao had already become a partial general, and later he was a self-proclaimed general of the state pastor and the expedition to the west. In fact, as the eldest son of Ma Teng, the emperor of Liangzhou, Ma Chao does have the capital to be a state pastor. Liu Bei's siege of Yucheng took a year, and Pang Tong was damaged, and Liu Bei suffered heavy losses; And Chengdu is the capital of Yizhou, very strong, the defensive force of 30,000 people, grain and grass can be paid for a year, if the attack, Liu Bei may go bankrupt, in fact, Liu Bei has never had a five tiger general, the five tiger generals are just Luo Guanzhong to Liu Bei's five generals title, because the five people are passed together, so they are called the five tiger generals.

    In the Shu Han Dynasty, it can be said that one person is above 10,000 people, and even Guan Yu once wrote to ask Zhuge Liang if Ma Chao had real talent and learning, Zhuge Liang was very intelligent and replied, similar to Zhang Fei and Zhao Yun, but slightly inferior to Yun Chang.

  22. Anonymous users2024-01-16

    In the last battle to capture Chengdu, Liu Bei ran into trouble. Chengdu is a sturdy city with a lot of savings. Looking at the table of the king of Hanzhong again, Ma Chao ranked first, and the ** at that time was the general at that time, because the only one in Liu Bei's camp who had been a prince was Ma Chao, the representative of the Kansai warlords.

  23. Anonymous users2024-01-15

    is because he thinks Ma Chao is also a talented person, but not an attractive person. So keep him, but also to stabilize him. I don't want him to be my opponent.

  24. Anonymous users2024-01-14

    Because Ma Chao's skills are very strong. So he must be given the title of five tiger generals.

  25. Anonymous users2024-01-13

    Because he has a very high status in the heart of Xiliang Army, even surpassing Liu Bei. Liu Bei was afraid that his popularity in other troops would threaten his position. As a superior, you will have such suspicions.

  26. Anonymous users2024-01-12

    Because Ma Chao did not defect to Liu Bei willingly, in addition, Ma Chao has a very high opinion of himself, is unwilling to obey the command of others, and often makes claims, so Liu Bei is still not very at ease with him.

  27. Anonymous users2024-01-11

    Ma Chao's ability is relatively strong, Liu Bei has a strong sense of vigilance against him, Ma Chao has repeatedly betrayed the master, Liu Bei naturally does not dare to reuse, Ma Chao has a big problem in dealing with the world, and there are almost no friends.

  28. Anonymous users2024-01-10

    Ma Chao, the word Mengqi, the son of Ma Teng, the commander of the Eastern Han Dynasty, the famous general of the late Eastern Han Dynasty and the founding of the Shu Han Dynasty, was known as one of the five tiger generals in later generations. Before following Liu Bei, it can be said that Ma Chao, who had almost no military exploits after joining Shu Han, had such a high status in the Shu Han regime? I think there are a few reasons for this.

    First, the battle is brave. Ma Chao's force is definitely the top among all the generals of the Three Kingdoms. The ancients once commented on Lu Bu in the front and Ma Chao in the back.

    That is to say, Ma Chao and Lu Bu are of the same grade. Ma Chao can be regarded as a young and famous, earlier with his father to crusade against Guo Yuan, Guo Yuan's army was halfway across the Fen River, encountered Ma Chao led the army to intercept and kill. During the battle, Ma Chao was wounded by an arrow in his foot, and immediately wrapped his leg with a cloth arrow, continued to lead the army to fight, broke Yuan's army, and killed Guo Yuan.

    It is enough to see how brave Ma Chao is in battle. But it does not affect his influence and status among military generals. Ma Chao became one of the four great generals of Shu Han, Liu Bei valued Ma Chao's deterrent, and if he wanted to bully Shu Han, Wei and Wu had to take it easy.

    Second, it has a deterrent effect. When Ma Chao gathered an army of 100,000 and fought with Cao Cao at Tongguan, Cao Cao, who broke Cao's army in Weishui, would have died if he hadn't been under the protection of Xu Zhu. This made many generals worship Ma Chao and be afraid.

    Liu Bei attacked Chengdu and could not attack it for a long time. As a result, after getting Ma Chao, let Ma Chao shout under the city. Knowing that Liu Bei had such a fierce general, Liu Zhang's subordinates immediately surrendered.

    It can be seen that Ma Chao was a deterrent at that time. With Ma Chao here, how dare Wei Wu act rashly.

    Third, the book is loyal. Ma Chao and Liu Bei, a big reason is to take revenge. And the grievances and hatreds between Liu Bei and Cao Cao must be known to everyone.

    With such a lord, there is no hope of revenge for the state, how can he be disloyal. That's why Liu Bei attaches so much importance to him.

    Fourth, the status is noble. Ma Chao is also regarded as the canonization of the Han Dynasty, and he is also the queen of the famous Han general Ma Yuan. Unlike other generals of Shu Han who were born recklessly, Liu Bei's rebellion was originally in the name of the Han Dynasty, so it was in line with political strategy to give Ma Chao a knighthood.

    Fifth, the sycophants are well shot. Liu Bei is the king, and Ma Chao is indispensable. After Liu Bei took Hanzhong, more than 120 Shu Han ** led by Ma Chao jointly signed "The King of Hanzhong and the Emperor of Han" to persuade Liu Bei to become the king of Hanzhong.

    Liu Bei was called the queen, and Ma Chao was promoted to General Zuo in the world. I have to say that Ma Chao's wisdom is not just in fighting.

    Sixth, I think the most important point is to be angry with Cao Cao. Cao Cao is a person who will take revenge. Ma Chao almost killed him in Weishui, and killed his entire family when he returned.

    But Ma Chao is still alive, Shu Han's strength is very strong, and he won't be able to kill Ma Chao for a while. Liu Bei values Ma Chao so much, Cao Cao's brain tumor, it is estimated that it has nothing to do with Liu Bei's trick.

  29. Anonymous users2024-01-09

    Because Ma Chao's influence is very great, at least he used to be a prince, and he was also the first person to write to support Liu Feng and raise the title of emperor, so Liu Bei still put him in the Five Tigers to bury the silver withered.

  30. Anonymous users2024-01-08

    Because Ma judged that the strength of Zen Chao was worthy of recognition, and there were still a large number of soldiers digging dust, if he did not reward him, he might become suspicious and cause unnecessary trouble.

  31. Anonymous users2024-01-07

    In short, there was no chance to show him. Why is there no chance, on the one hand, the strength of Shu is limited, and on the other hand, there are too many veteran cadres who have been fighting in the north and south along Liu Bei for decades.

    By the time Ma Chao surrendered, the battle in Yizhou had basically ended. There are two main strategic directions in Shu, China and Korea and Gyeongju. Jingzhou will become Guan Yu, and China and South Korea advocate that Liu Bei himself should stop He.

    When Ma Chaohe joined, Guan Yu would compete with Shu, from Ma Chao to Gyeongju, it was too difficult for Guan Yu's deputy general, and it was impossible to lead Guan Yu. So his stage is only the battlefield between China and South Korea.

    In fact, Ma Chao was still involved in the Sino-Korean War. Liu Bei sent Zhang Fei, Ma Chao, Wu Lan and others to debate. Pai Zhao Hong refused.

    Cao Hong wants to break Wu Lan and cut off Kui. In March, Zhang Fei, Ma Chao China and South Korea. "There is not much description of the First World War, but as the former scattered oak outpost of Liu Bei's personal expedition, as a common battalion of equipment (you must know that there is no opportunity for individual soldiers to practice equipment in this period), the troops under his command will not be too much, and there is no room to play.

    In other words, the strength of Shu was limited and it failed to rank at the top. After that, when Zhang Wu founded the Shu Han Dynasty in the first year, he gave Ma Chao the position of Patriarch of Ning Liangzhu, and he believed that the Northwest wanted to do something with his prestige.

    Unfortunately, in July of the first year of Zhang Wu, Liu Bei went to capture Eastern Wu. This time, Wei Yan, Ma Chao and other uncles did not accompany the army and stayed on the front line of China and South Korea (Ma Chao was the pastor of Liangzhou, and Wei Yan was Hanzhong County). What's even more unfortunate is that Liu Bei was defeated in June of Zhang Wu's 2nd year, and he lost all his family money, but Ma Chao may never have it again.

    Ma Chao died in Zhang Wu two years ago, and on his deathbed, Liu Biao Toma Dai) also saw a lot of Liu Bei suspicious, and if he couldn't reuse it, he couldn't fully agree.

    For Liu Bei, at least in terms of employing people, it can be said that he is magnificent. As long as Liu Bei has the ability, he can be judged by the relatively poor strength of the Shu State that Liu Bei dared to appoint. Although he has tossed Ma Chao for half a lifetime, the displaced people have reached the point of extinction, does he still have such great ambitions?

    In addition, judging from what he asked for Madai when he was dying, I think his heart is still very warm to Liu Bei.

  32. Anonymous users2024-01-06

    After Ma Chao defected to Liu Bei, although his ability to accompany Kaijian was very outstanding, Sun Zhi Liu Bei had always had a grudge against Ma Chao, and he would always suspect Ma Chao's rebellion, so Liu Bei would not reuse Ma Chao.

  33. Anonymous users2024-01-05

    This is because he has not been reused by Liu Bei, and Liu Bei has also made some considerations, so he does not dare to reuse him, and he still has a certain degree of vigilance.

  34. Anonymous users2024-01-04

    Because Liu Bei has a lot of generals. I didn't need Ma Chao to make a move for a while, so I was idle all the time.

Related questions
22 answers2024-02-25

The Five Tiger Generals refer to the five generals who followed Liu Bei to establish the Shu Han regime during the Three Kingdoms period at the end of the Han Dynasty. They are Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Ma Chao, Huang Zhong, and Zhao Yun. As the saying goes, the tiger father has no dog son, and the heroic stories of these five generals will be famous through the ages. >>>More

19 answers2024-02-25

Except for Zhang Fei, it can be called a good death.

Guan Yu and Huang Zhong died in battle. >>>More

26 answers2024-02-25

Guan Yu's children all died, Zhang Fei's son died in battle, his daughter entered the palace, and Zhao Yun had two sons and one daughter. The female and Guan Ping became husband and wife, the second son Zhao Guangzhan died Ma Chao more children, three sons and one daughter, the eldest and the second were all sick and died very early, and the third Ma Cheng returned to the mountains and forests after the destruction of Shu Han. Huang Zhong is even more miserable, he has only one son, who died of illness at an early age and has no queen.

26 answers2024-02-25

There are no five tiger generals in history, only 4, range front, back, left, right, four generals, Zhao Yun is not among them, only Guan Yu (Yun Chang), Zhang Fei (Yide), Ma Chao (Meng Qi), Huang Zhong (Han Sheng), who can fight in the specific sleep, it is estimated that no one has the right answer, in terms of official position, Ma Chao is stronger than Zhao Yun. >>>More

24 answers2024-02-25

Huang Zhong was called a "veteran" at the time, not a veteran. According to the "Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms: The Biography of Fei Poems", "The first lord was the king of Hanzhong, Guan Yu was the former general, and Yu Wen Huang Zhong was the rear general."