Who is the most powerful of Liu Bei s five tiger generals? Zhao Yun or Ma Chao?

There are no five tiger generals in history, only 4, range front, back, left, right, four generals, Zhao Yun is not among them, only Guan Yu (Yun Chang), Zhang Fei (Yide), Ma Chao (Meng Qi), Huang Zhong (Han Sheng), who can fight in the specific sleep, it is estimated that no one has the right answer, in terms of official position, Ma Chao is stronger than Zhao Yun.

Trouble, thanks!

Liu Bei. can achieve a career, fortunately, he has a group of loyal and capable subordinates under him, except for Zhuge Liang.

In addition to this kind of civil generals with a strong level of governance, there are also a group of generals who are very good at war, among which Guan Yu is more famous.

He is a martial saint of later generations.

Person. Among the generals of the Three Kingdoms era, there is another person who is as famous as Guan Yu, and that is Lu Bu. And Liu Bei also has two generals under him, one of whom has the ability to resist Lu Bu, and the other is able to defeat Guan Yu, and the two of them are Ma Chao and Zhao Yun respectively.

At that time, the general served by Zhao Yun was not recognized by everyone in ancient times, according to Jiupin.

's official rank only accounts for five grades, but in my opinion, Liu Bei back then would definitely not follow the rules and regulations.

Zhao Yun was given an official rank, and Zhao Yun, the general, was specially set up for him by Liu Bei, so it can't be simply said that this is a miscellaneous army. At the same time, Zhao Yundang's general has an auxiliary meaning, there are such official titles in Wu and Shu, and they are all very high-level famous general titles, how many levels Zhao Yun has been promoted in the middle and late stages, if he is a miscellaneous army, then it is a little unrealistic.

So in my opinion, the most normal expression is that Zhao Yun is here, and Guan Yu's former general and Zhang Fei.

's right general, as well as Ma Chao's left general and Huang Zhong.

of the generals all had the same influence. Since these parts belong to the upper and lower sides, the left and right sides are occupied, so Liu Bei only has to open a separate position for Zhao Yun to be General Yi, which is also due to the fact that Zhao Yun can be promoted to the middle and late stages of the Central Protector Army and its general Zhengnan, which is a better foreshadowing. And Zhao Yun is also in charge of the forbidden army.

Supervise the duties and responsibilities of other generals.

It shouldn't be said that he is a younger brother under Liu Bei, and he is not highly valued by everyone in the Shu Kingdom, but his influence needs to be higher than that of ordinary people.

In the end, I concluded that because Ma Chao had a relatively high reputation in the early days, she received Liu Bei's better salary and was given a very high official title, but because of her way of doing things, she was not trusted by Liu Bei and could not grasp the specific rights. Looking back, Zhao Yun was in Shuhan.

From the very beginning, it was valued by Liu Bei, but there are few records of this matter in the historical books, so it is impossible to confirm Zhao Yun's final influence. But at least we can know that the rights he has are indeed very high, and from some of the things that Liu Bei asked him to do, as well as the records of his official title in historical books, we can definitely draw conclusions.

I think it's very likely that it's because Liu Bei doesn't know the art of war, and the second thing is that Liu Bei can't trust Ma Chao's character.

The answer is that it was reused by Liu Bei. As for why he was not named a heavy general, the main reason is that Liu Bei has his own considerations and Zhao Yun attaches great importance to the heavy general. Liu Beifeng is very particular about the four heavy generals, Zhang Fei Guan Yu is a must-seal, belongs to his joint venture, and Liu Bei treats people leniently.

Huang Zhong is the representative general of the Jingzhou faction, and Ma Chao represents the big clan, so he needs this signboard, so there is no problem with the assignment of the four heavy generals Liu Bei.

Some people say that Ma Chao and Zhao Yun are not reused, the main reason is that Liu Bei does not understand the art of war.

Liu Bei still doesn't know the art of war, and he has won a lot of battles when he didn't meet Zhuge Liang when he was young, so it can only be said that he is not the top, the monarch doesn't need to know the art of war, Liu Bang doesn't know the art of war, and he doesn't dominate the world.

Compared with the two, Zhao Yun is naturally more powerful. After all, he is known as a long-winning general, and Zhao Yun is far superior to Ma Chao in terms of combat performance. If you want to compare who is more powerful between the two tiger generals, then you have to look at the battlefield performance of the two.

Ma Chao is famous for the Battle of Tongguan, in the Battle of Tongguan, he stabbed Cao Cao's general Li Tong to death with a single shot, and then chased after Cao Cao, and finally forced Cao Cao to cut his beard and abandon his robe and flee, which can be described as very embarrassing. After this battle, his fame gradually came out, and he was known by everyone as General Shenweitian. <>

But after that, his performance was relatively mediocre. After that, he fought more than 200 rounds with Xu Chu, the first fierce general under Cao Cao, but in the end, the winner was not decided. After this big fight, he later started to fight against Zhang Fei again, and the two also fought for 200 rounds, but he still did not win, and the final outcome was still a draw.

In these wars, except for his heroic performance in the battle of Tongguan, he bravely pursued and killed Cao Cao, and there were no particularly significant achievements. <>

On the other hand, Zhao Yun's record is even more brilliant. At that time, in the Battle of Xiangshan, Zhao Yun returned to save Liu Bei, and was besieged by Cao Cao's fierce generals Xu Zhu, Yu Ban and Li Dian. Xu Chu here is Cao Cao's first fierce general who fought against Ma Chao above.

Zhao Yun, who was besieged by the three of them, fought back bravely and finally retreated, which shows that Zhao Yun's combat effectiveness is far above Ma Chao. <>

Later, in the battle of Fengming Mountain, Zhao Yun was nearly seventy years old at that time, and he was still heroic and impermanent, and after killing 5 people of Han De's father and son at the beginning, he was besieged by 8 generals, and finally still fought his way out of the siege. Judging from Zhao Yun's battlefield performance, he really deserves the title of a victorious general. Resolute and resolute in the face of the enemy, he is really indomitable on the battlefield, and he is becoming more and more courageous.

Therefore, in my opinion, Zhao Yun is much more powerful than Ma Chao.

Zhao Yun is even more powerful, Zhao Yun is not only strong in martial arts, but also Zhao Yun's character has nothing to say, much better than Ma Chao.

Zhao Yun is even more powerful, Zhao Yun is not only very smart, but also very capable, and also very strategic.

**The words of home are just that. In real history, only Cao Cao had five good generals: Zhang Liao and Xu Huang forbade Zhang Jaw to enter, while Liu Bei did not.

And the reason why Luo Guanzhong wants to write like this is because of the following points:

First, not long after Liu Guanzhang became righteous, Zhao Yun came, and he seemed to have the feeling of a fourth brother, and then he showed his majesty in front of Changban Slope, whether it was from the common people or the emperor's family, this kind of loyal general naturally wanted to become a model.

Second, Ma Chao is the son of Ma Teng, who was one of the masterminds of Cao Cao's assassination and was friendly with Liu Bei. Ma Chaoshi lives in Longyou, after the famous family, he is very prestigious in the local area, and even Ma Dai can respond to every call, this kind of loyal descendants, naturally to play up.

Third, Jiang Wei is Zhuge Liang's apprentice, not in the same generation, Wei Yan is a "thief", and he can't hurt Liu Bei's "foresight", so he can't be on the list.

The real history has been submerged in the long river of history, and now it seems that it is just a smile.

When the five tiger generals were ranked in the romance, Wei Yan's contribution was not significant enough, and Jiang Wei had not yet debuted, how could he be qualified. Ma Chaowei is famous, and he has been famous since his ancestors, he is a well-known general in the world, and Cao Cao has a headache, so it is impossible not to comment on it; Zhao Yun has long protected Liu Bei's family, Zhuge Liang and other dignitaries, plus he joined the party early, his roots are red, and there is no problem with the majesty of Changbanpo. These two are recognized by Guan Yu.

The Five Tigers were crowned at a specific time, that is, Liu Bei laid down Xichuan and Hanzhong as queens, and the time seems to be 218 AD. At that time, Jiang Wei had not yet entered Liu Bei's account, and Wei Yan was a person who had just surrendered, and his qualifications were far from Zhao Yungao, Wei Yan was compared with Ma Chao: because Ma Chao made a great contribution when Liu Bei attacked Chengdu, and Wei Yan was not particularly famous during this time period, and he did not work hard.

However, it seems that Zhuge Liang doesn't like Wei Yan very much, maybe Wei Yan is not ranked among the five tigers, and it has something to do with Zhuge Liang.

The Five Tigers of Shu should be, Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Huang Zhong, Jiang Wei, Wei Yan are right, these 5 talents are often fighting, Ma Chao is just an idle official, Zhao Yun is a bodyguard, Wei Yan, Jiang Wei has a lot of achievements, and they can be ranked among the five tiger generals with high qualifications.

At that time, there was no Jiang Wei and Wei Yan. Besides, Ma Chao has a lot of cows, chasing Cao Cao to kill. Zhao Yun He saved Liu's son, this relationship is hard.

Zhao Yun is not a bodyguard, if calculated according to the force value, Zhao Yun will definitely enter the top ten; According to the military strategy, Zhao Yun is no worse than Zhuge Liang in grasping the battle situation, but the strategic view is not very clear.

Are you sure Jiang Wei was in Shu when Liu Bei sealed the Five Tigers? It was Jiang Wei who Zhuge collected after his death. Zhao Yun Ma Chao also had a lot of merit when he received Dongxichuan, Zhao Yun was still Liu Bei's old friend, and the protector was also meritorious.

In "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", the five tiger generals under Liu Bei's tent represent the highest level of combat effectiveness in the book. Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Ma Chao, Huang Zhong, and Zhao Yun were all outstanding at that time. The Five Tiger Generals also had the same status in Liu Bei's camp, but there was a large age gap.

The oldest is Huang Zhong, followed by Guan Yu is ten years younger than Huang Zhong, Zhang Fei is six years younger than Guan Yu, and Zhao Yun is the youngest. The level of combat effectiveness is affected not only by military power, but also by age. With age, the decline of physical functions will lead to a decline in the combat effectiveness of military commanders.

Therefore, in the process of comparison, it is necessary to deduce the capabilities of the five tigers in their heyday by their performance on the battlefield, so as to appear objective.

In terms of combat effectiveness, Zhao Yun should undoubtedly be ranked first. The first battle of Zhao Yun's career, the opponent was not simple, but the second brave hero Wen Chou under Yuan Shao's account. At that time, Wen Chou was chasing and defeating Gongsun Zhan, and seeing that Gongsun would be killed by Wen Chou's hands, a young general suddenly came out and fought fiercely with Wen Chou for sixty rounds, without victory, and each retreated.

Although Wen Chou was killed by Guan Erye, it can be inferred from the original text of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" that this is not Wen Chou's real strength. Before becoming a ghost under Guan Erye's knife, Wen Chou defeated Cao Ying's second ruthless Xu Huang in twenty rounds. Xu Huang fought Xu Chu for 50 rounds without victory.

This shows that Wen Chou is much stronger than Xu Chu. However, Zhao Yun, who has not yet reached his peak state, can actually sit on an equal footing with Wen Chou and imagine its terrifying place.

Zhao Yun's heyday was probably when Liu Bei lived in Jingzhou and went to Hanzhong to fight. During this period, Zhao Yun entered and exited the Changban slope seven times. Cao Cao's army was in the thousands, and he looked left and right, killing more than fifty of Cao Cao's generals, as if he had entered no man's land.

He finally managed to break through the siege. Cao Cao ordered not to release the arrows, which somewhat relieved the pressure on Zhao Yun, who was the only one in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms to do so.

In the Battle of Hanzhong, Zhao Yun led a small army to rescue the besieged Huang Zhong. Even Cao Jun's generals, Zhang He and Xu Huang, were terrified when they saw Zhao Yun's marksmanship. This is enough to show how rebellious Zhao Yun's combat power is at the pinnacle.

Therefore, Zhao Yun's combat effectiveness ranked first among the five tiger generals, and he was worthy of others.

Zhang Liao. This person's combat power can be said to be very powerful, and he is also the most powerful person in his own mind.

I think Zhao Yun's combat power is the strongest, because Zhao Yun is a very witty person and has outstanding abilities, so the most powerful person is Zhao Yun.

The strongest fighter is Guan Yu. Guan Yu's martial arts are very strong, he is very capable in military affairs, and his combat effectiveness is particularly strong.

I think the strongest combat effectiveness is Zhao Yun, because Zhao Yun's combat effectiveness is very strong, and he has achieved very good results, and he is a fierce general.

Guan Yu is the most powerful person among the five tiger generals of Shu Kingdom, everyone is able to follow his orders, just like a big brother, everyone has seen Guan Yu's power.

When Guan Yu was at his peak, he could be said to be invincible, there was no opponent at all, and he had already reached the pinnacle of his life.

Although Guan Yu's martial arts are the best in the world, he is just one person. In the end, Cao Cao and they chose a good method, that is, Wei and Wu united to attack Shu, and they must defeat Guan Yu together, and finally Guan Yu faced this heavy encirclement, and finally because of his own strength, it was really difficult to compete with the two countries, and he was finally killed.

Guan Yu, Guan Yu has been fighting the world with Liu Bei since he was a child, so I personally think it is Guan Yu.

Thinking that Guan Yu is the strongest, it is rumored that Guan Yu's Qinglong Glaive Knife weighs 80 kilograms, and its strength can be said to be very huge, and generally three or four people are not his opponents.

Guan yu. Guan Yu was the first recognized military general in the Three Kingdoms after Lu Bu's death, and no one could surpass him in the entire Three Kingdoms period.

Zhang Fei's force is the strongest, only he has the ability to fight with Lu Bu for 200 rounds without defeat, and he can rank second among the generals of the Three Kingdoms.

I think Huang Zhong is the strongest, because the elderly Huang Zhong can defeat Guan Yu in the prime of life, and Guan Yu is the head of the five tiger generals, so I think Huang Zhong is the strongest.