How do you feel about being criminally detained for acting bravely in the face of justice?

As a result, a 17-year-old student at the martial arts school acted bravely, and as a result: "Based on the nature and circumstances of the defendant Guo Ming's crime and his attitude of admitting guilt, according to the relevant provisions of the Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China, Guo Ming committed the crime of intentional injury and was sentenced to two years and six months imprisonment with a three-year suspended sentence. At the same time, the Longmatan District Court of Luzhou City made a judgment on the civil part of the case, ordering Guo Ming to pay Zhang San compensation; Gou Qing paid Zhang San a compensation amount.

>Suspended sentence" is a system in which a specific investigation body examines a convict within a certain period of probation, and decides whether to apply a specific punishment in accordance with the law based on the convict's performance during the probationary period. In other words, although the sentence is given, it is not necessarily that the person will end up in prison, unless the person is usually troublesome and impulsive and violent. That makes sense.

But why pay compensation to the bad guys? Because of righteousness and courage, the compensation of more than 100,000 yuan is not a disaster for an ordinary family? Why can't the bad guys be allowed to taste the consequences? Why can't the bad guy's entire family be made to pay for his actions?

As a netizen said: "The person who formulated this law of legitimate defense back then was definitely a first-class martial arts master, and his skills can be collected and released freely, and he can point to the end!" "Children can get hurt when they play around!

Fighting with bad guys is a matter of risking your life, so how can you worry about hurting and breaking the bad guys first regardless of your personal safety?

To be a bad person, you can act arbitrarily and unscrupulously, and let others pay for your own death; To be a good person, you have to look forward and backward, tie your hands and feet, and only replace yourself as a victim can you save another victim? That's why Chinese would rather be bad guys than good guys!

Criminal detention for acting courageously should be an act of excessive self-defense.

For the determination of whether it is justified defense, the limit of defense, etc., the "rational person hypothesis" should be abandoned, and the defender should be moderately tilted, and the defender should not be required to make the most reasonable choice, and the "who was seriously injured" or "there is **" should not be used as the mechanical judgment standard.

Nowadays, people's hearts are sinister, and sometimes they are afraid of being misunderstood when they do something good.

I think there are fewer and fewer good people now, and they are still detained for good deeds.

This is too bad for the society, and it should be seen that the righteous and brave people are innocent, and there is also recognition.

This kind of thing is very common, and it should be given a good characterization, otherwise who will dare to act bravely in the future!

Acts of righteousness and courage are only legitimate defenses, and should not be detained.

Let's have an excesse. There was a misunderstanding in the middle, maybe there was a misunderstanding.

It should be a good thing to act bravely, why should you be criminally detained.

Summary. How can righteousness and courage constitute legitimate defense?

1. Only when the public interest of the state, the legitimate rights of oneself or others are illegally infringed;

2. It must be when the unlawful infringement is ongoing;

3. It must be to defend the wrongdoer himself, and not to an unrelated third party;

4. Justifiable defense cannot exceed the necessary limit (which can prevent the other party from infringing on itself) and cause undue damage.

Is it okay for a person who has acted bravely to have been administratively detained?

Hello, consult a lawyer for your service, wait for me a moment.

Whether the righteous and courageous act is recognized by Wang Ding, the specific determination results are subject to the investigation results of **. Acts of righteousness and courage were found not to be criminally responsible. However, if it is really found to be the crime of intentional injury, the consequences will be serious. will pursue Sun Hunger and investigate criminal responsibility.

Those who are in administrative detention can also be seen to be brave and courageous.

If you are misunderstood, you can call the police.

How does righteousness and courage constitute justifiable defense1, only when the public interest of the state or the legitimate rights of oneself or others to search for Zen limbs are unlawfully infringed; 2. It must be when the unlawful infringement is ongoing; 3. It must be to defend the wrongdoer himself, and not to the three unrelated third attackers; 4. Justifiable defense cannot exceed the necessary limit (which can prevent the other party from infringing on itself) and cause undue damage.

If you are satisfied, you can like it, or click on my avatar to follow me, so that you can send me a consultation at any time if you have any questions in the dust hall. Thank you for your consultation and have a great day!

The man was detained for 14 days for acting bravely, what did the lawyer say?

Fortunately, the court took into account Mr. Zhao's special circumstances, and although he should be sanctioned and sentenced to four years in prison according to the law, there are still circumstances outside the law, because of Mr. Zhao's particularity, Mr. Zhao's punishment was exempted.

Although this matter seems to have a happy ending, the process of the girl's violence has been stopped, the bad guys have been organized, and Mr. Zhao has not really gone to jail, but there are still some lessons that we should recognize.

The second is this Mr. Zhao, although it is correct to have a heart of righteousness and courage, and it is very rare, but we must also be careful not to act rashly, not to let the good things of righteousness and courage become bad things, while protecting others, we should also protect ourselves, and we must first protect ourselves.

In some emergency situations, for example, when you see someone falling into the water, if you can swim in the water, you should of course go to save people without hesitation, but in this case, although Mr. Zhao rushed to save people when he heard the sound of the cry for help, the starting point is good, but when Mr. Zhao arrived at the scene, the violent behavior seems to have stopped, and legally speaking, if you act rashly, it is easy to put yourself in a very unfavorable situation, just like Mr. Zhao, in a bad situation, They may even face legal sanctions.

However, as a man, although he is given more strength and physique than women physically, he should be used to do serious things and protect weak people, instead of using this advantage to bully others, use the strength he is given to beat people, and carry out violence, which is a very wrong idea and phenomenon. If you want to beat people like Mr. Zhao who wants to protect others bravely, you must also remember to protect yourself.

The lawyer said that if the man did not grasp the degree of righteousness and courage, or if the abuser had been stopped, and the abuser had no way to continue the violation, if he continued to fight with the other party, it would easily become overly defensive.

The man was detained for 14 days after acting bravely, and it turned out that the reason was that the man had kicked the man when he stopped the girl from being violated, causing damage to the other party's internal organs, and after evaluation, the disability reached the second degree.

The lawyer said that he was guilty of intentional injury because he kicked the man in the course of his righteous and courageous act, causing great harm to the man.

The lawyer said that if it can be proved that the man acted bravely, the matter is not very serious, and if he cannot prove it, he will face 60,000 to 200,000 yuan in compensation and four years in prison.

On December 26, 18, Mr. Zhao bravely helped a woman.

Then not long after, the police came, and Mr. Zhao also returned to his house, what Mr. Zhao did not expect was that after three days, he was arrested and taken to the detention center on the charge of intentional injury.

After Mr. Zhao was released, he was still very worried, because he was accused of intentional injury at that time, and if the crime of intentional injury was confirmed, Mr. Zhao would have to pay 200,000 to 600,000 yuan in compensation and be sentenced to four years in prison.

This made Mr. Zhao a little suspicious of life, he was originally righteous and courageous, but now it has become intentional injury, Mr. Zhao said that not only hurt himself, but also hurt his family.

But fortunately, the latest notification now is: justifiable defense, no prosecution.

I don't want the people to help each other at all!

Because the common people help each other, it will strengthen the unity between the common people;

When the common people are united, it will not be good!

That's the root!

didn't dare to help the old lady, was arrested for righteousness and bravery, and the heroes shed blood and tears, etc., all of which made the people dare not help each other and dare not unite;

It is true that there is a little bit of excessive defense, and our country has stipulated the scope of defense, and if he is really completely within that range, it is impossible to have a ** situation.

I think this matter should be carefully investigated, when people are trying to survive, their instinctive reaction is very strong, a person who is righteous and brave does not need to deliberately hurt anyone, I don't think there is excessive defense.

I don't think so, I think his righteousness and courage are very good, do you watch girls being harassed? Society shouldn't be like this, and I want to give him a fair verdict.

The man is too defensive, otherwise he would not be detained, but this is also easy to hurt the heart of righteousness and bravery, who will dare to act bravely in the future.

This is not defense, defense refers to the sexual behavior that resists when you are violated, this is considered righteous and courageous, and it does not constitute great harm to the righteous and courageous behavior, so don't punish the righteous and courageous person.

Of course it's worth it, not everyone has the courage to do righteous and courageous things, but they will definitely feel guilty for not doing righteous and courageous things. Don't be cold, society will give justice to the heroes who are brave and brave.

Doing good deeds is worth it, and our society encourages doing good deeds. However, while doing good deeds, you should also pay attention to protecting yourself and not being taken advantage of by bad people. At the same time, our ** organization should also reward good people and good deeds, rather than criminal detention, which will chill the hearts of good people.

How to define this is to see whether the person who does good deeds will get the credit he deserves for doing good deeds. How is it worthwhile, it is not for those of us who are not involved to discuss, if the good deeds feel worthwhile, it is worth it.

Of course it's worth it, doing good is something we should all do, and if people are apathetic, it's a bad thing.

It is worth it, doing good deeds is something that needs to be admired, but when doing good deeds, the way also needs to be reasonable, legal, and have a degree.