Zhang Liao and Guan Yu, what is the relationship between Zhang Liao and Guan Yu

Zhang Liao and Guan Yu are friends of the same township. Both were in the Three Kingdoms period, both from Shanxi, Zhang Liao was a native of Yanmen Mayi (now Shuozhou, Shanxi), a famous general of Cao Wei during the Three Kingdoms period at the end of the Han Dynasty, and a descendant of Nie Yi. Guan Yu was a native of Xie Liang (now Yuncheng, Shanxi) in Hedong and a famous general in the late Eastern Han Dynasty.

If you compare heads-up ability, the two belong to the same grade, Guan Yu is one of Liu Bei's five tiger generals, and Zhang Liao is one of Cao Cao's five good generals. If compared to the ability to execute tactics, Zhang Liao is an excellent general, who can focus on the overall situation, regardless of personal gains and losses. Guan Yu is also very good, but he has an arrogant personality and is very happy, which is the biggest flaw for the general.

Although Guan Yu and Zhang Liao are their own masters, they have a good friendship. Zhang Liao and Lu Bu were colleagues Ding Yuan and He Jin in his early years, and then belonged to Dong Zhuo, who followed Lu Bu after Dong Zhuo's demise, but he was never reused. In 198 A.D., Cao Cao attacked Pi and defeated Lü Bu, and after beheading Lü Bu, who was brave and brave in the White Gate Tower, he then wanted to behead Zhang Liao, at this time Guan Yu knelt down and begged Cao Cao to reuse Zhang Liao, and vouched for his life.

After Zhang Liao followed Cao Cao, he opened his glorious chapter. Before this, Zhang Liao had not done anything big, and he was much more obscure than Guan Yulai. Before the Battle of Guandu in 200 AD, Cao Cao divided his troops into five ways to attack Liu Bei's garrison Xuzhou, and Liu Bei failed to ask Yuan Shao for help in the north, and was finally defeated due to his weak strength.

Guan Yu fought alone and failed to break out of the encirclement of the Cao army, and finally his old friend Zhang Liao came forward to say that Guan Yu was surrendered and made three appointments, and Guan Zhang finally lived a period of time as a colleague and a master. In the following ten years, Cao Cao consolidated his supremacy in the north, and Zhang Liao accompanied Cao Cao to fight in all directions. Guan Yu followed Liu Bei around, and did not forget his old kindness in the battle of Chibi and let Cao Cao go in Huarong Dao.

Personally, I think that Zhang Liao is a little more powerful in the official history.

It can be seen that Zhang Liao is slightly better than Guan Yu. In addition, a more important point is that Zhang Liao has a strong understanding of the overall situation. Zhang Liao is good at tactical execution, which can be seen from the fact that Zhang Liao led 800 elite soldiers to drive Soochow to hell.

At first, Zhang Liao began to guard Hefei, and later when guarding Hefei, he was in a hurry to turn Sun Quan around. After Zhang Liao defended a certain area, it can be seen from the reaction of Eastern Wu that Zhang Liao was a general in the absolute sense. Compared with Guan Yu, Guan Yu's temperament is not so good.

We all know that Guan Yu is arrogant and sometimes disobeys orders. There is no way out. In general, Zhang Liao may be a little better than Guan Yu, but a little better is just a little more, not much.

It should be Zhang Liao. The battle was slashed, Wuhuan was broken in the north, and Xiaoyaojin broke 100,000 in 800. The main pro-Liu historian and ** are also funny, Guan Yu flooded the Seventh Army, and the Seventh Army was less than 30,000, so it shocked China; Zhang Liao Hefei 7,000 against 100,000, and only used 800 to win first, but he could only shock Jiangdong.

You go to see a doctor first!

Zhang Zhidu You Liao is better than Guan Yu, the following is a comparison between the two;

1. Comparison of personal confrontation ability:

The two belong to the same grade, Guan Yu is one of Liu Bei's five tiger generals, and Zhang Liao is one of Cao Cao's five good generals;

2. Comparison of tactical execution capabilities:

Zhang Liao is an excellent general, focusing on the overall situation, regardless of personal gains and losses;

Guan Yu's execution ability is relatively strong, but he has an arrogant personality and is so happy;

3. Comparison of troop command ability:

Guan Yu and Zhang Liao are both generals who can take charge alone, Zhang Liao defends Hefei, Sun Quan defeats the strong with the weak, Guan Yu defends Jingzhou, flooding the Seventh Army;

Zhang Liao has a better view of the overall situation, can give full play to his greatest combat power, and scatter the most fatal blow to the enemy;

Guan Yu was empty-sighted, and in the face of Sun Quan's marriage, he not only did not accept it, but also spoke disrespectfully;

So to sum up, Zhang Liao is better than Guan Yu.