If Chongzhen and Zhao Gou were swapped, would the history of the Southern Song Dynasty and the South

Will change, Zhao Gou escaped from danger in time, and only established the Southern Song Dynasty after going south, continuing the Song Dynasty, while Chongzhen at the end of the Ming Dynasty stuck to the city of Beijing, unwilling to move south, and sat back and waited, which eventually led to the death of the Ming Dynasty.

There will be no change, the Southern Song Dynasty and the Southern Ming Dynasty have different endings, not because of the emperor's problems, but because of the problems within the imperial court.

If Chongzhen and Zhao Gou were exchanged, the history of the Southern Song Dynasty and the Southern Ming Dynasty would not change, because these two people had their own flaws, which was the reason for their failure.

No, because the institutional atmosphere of the Song Dynasty and the Ming Dynasty was different, at the end of the Ming Dynasty, the national strength was actually not weak, but it still died, because of the institutional problems of the Ming Dynasty.

No. Because the Ming Dynasty has accumulated a lot of difficulties in that situation, it is not possible for anyone to change the course of history.

No, Chongzhen is very good-looking, and he is unwilling to bear the reputation of losing his ancestral Sheji, so he will not go south to establish the Southern Song Dynasty.

I think so. Because the Ming Dynasty army still had a certain combat effectiveness at that time, if it could move south, it would definitely change.

Personally, I think it's hard. Because the Ming army was not an opponent of the Qing Dynasty, it was difficult to last so long in the end.

I don't think so. Because the Qing Dynasty did not allow the existence of the Southern Ming, this kind of thing would not occur.

Emperor Chongzhen is the last emperor of the Ming Dynasty, his life is relatively diligent, has always been determined to help the Ming Dynasty, do not want to let the ancestors' foundation be destroyed in their own hands, so after succeeding to the throne, killed Wei Zhongxian, who had been doing evil before, and also promulgated a lot of reforms, wanting to save the Ming Dynasty in fire and water, but the result still failed, after Li Zicheng broke into Beijing, Chongzhen also hanged himself. Some people can't help but ask, if Emperor Chongzhen did not hang himself, but moved south like the Southern Song Dynasty and then established a new Ming Dynasty regime, would the result be different? In my opinion, the possibility of the Ming Dynasty moving south is very small.

Because the national conditions of the Ming Dynasty and the Southern Song Dynasty before it were completely different.

At that time, the Ming Dynasty was already terminally ill and lingering after decades of tossing by Wei Zhongxian, showing a trend of accumulation and difficulty in returning. There were three main social problems in the Ming Dynasty at that time: one was that the peasant uprising in the Ming Dynasty at that time had intensified, and it could not be solved by setting up a separate ** in another place; Another is within the ruling group, with the death of Wei Zhongxian, the eunuch group was defeated, and the civil official group was dominant, and sometimes the emperor had no choice; The last one was the rise of the Houjin state above the Ming Dynasty at that time, and it became more and more restless and wanted to invade the Ming Dynasty.

It can be said that the Ming Dynasty inherited by Emperor Chongzhen is already a rotten mess that can't be worse, and after his generation, it is completely impossible to ** these problems, so the demise of the Ming Dynasty is inevitable.

On the other hand, in the previous Song Dynasty, their external troubles at that time - that is, Liaojin was eyeing the Song Dynasty and the people were still very high in their expectations for the emperor, and they were always looking forward to recovering the lost territory.

I think that if Chongzhen had not hanged himself, choosing to move south like the Song Dynasty might not necessarily allow the Ming Dynasty to be in a safe corner, because at that time, the Ming Dynasty was no longer able to be saved by changing positions.

If Chongzhen did not question it and chose to move south like the Song Dynasty, would it allow the Ming Dynasty to be in a safe corner? I think it's unlikely, because Emperor Chongzhen's power had been disintegrated at that time, and he had no ability to confront Li Zicheng at all, so even if he moved south at that time, Li Zicheng would not let him go later.

No, because in fact, King Li Zicheng fought from the south to Shandong, and because of Chongzhen's stubbornness, he didn't even leave to cover his army, which even the possibility of moving south is gone, and there are not many troops in the south of the Ming Dynasty, even if there are many more refugees than the army in the south, it will not change.

I don't think it's possible, because at that time, the Ming Dynasty had fallen into a very chaotic era, and it was very sensitive to move the dynasty before it was sorted out.

I think that if Chongzhen had moved south, it would have changed the history of the Ming Dynasty. Moving the capital was still very important to a country in ancient times. It's not that easy to make this decision.

I don't think so, because the Ming Dynasty at that time was already very corrupt, and although the Song Dynasty was defeated, there were still many talented people in the Song Dynasty who were doing their best to restore the country.

I think it's very possible. If he chooses to move south like the Song Dynasty, the result will be to stabilize the people's hearts and establish the country.

I think it's possible, but not everything is the same, and if you can succeed in doing the same thing, there really won't be anything difficult in the world.

Since Zhu Di moved the capital, an iron law has been set, and since then the Ming Dynasty has not been able to move the capital, so the emperors of the Song Dynasty have had this idea but dare not put it into practice.

This is mainly due to the fact that Zhao Gou, who was scared, habitually ran away with his tail between his legs. And Chongzhen's royal power has been absolutely stable, and Daming has never been afraid of anyone. Therefore, there is no need to negotiate peace or move the capital.

Answer: Mainly because there are too many people around him, they all speak, and Chongzhen himself has no idea. caused him to sway from side to side and couldn't make up his mind.

This has something to do with Zhu Di, and when he moved the capital, he set a rule. Therefore, everyone did not dare to move the capital, and they still kept this rule in mind.

After the fall of the Ming Dynasty, the remnants of the Ming Dynasty also established the Southern Ming Dynasty, which is equivalent to the Southern Song Dynasty after the Northern Song Dynasty. And Nanming's royal family is basically wiped out, although in the end Emperor Chongzhen sent several of his sons out of Beijing, but they were either arrested or there was no news, and Hongguang, who inherited the throne of Nanming, was also able to ascend the throne because of the support of Nanming's warlords.

At that time, when the Southern Ming Dynasty was established, it still owned a lot of land, basically including more than half of the territory of the Ming Dynasty. However, these territories are not under the control of Hongguang, there are many warlords in the vast land of Nanming, and these warlords do not say whether they support Hongguang or not, and even if they support Hongguang, he cannot mobilize. It can be said that there are many warlords in power in the Southern Ming Dynasty, and these warlords are just like Zhao Gou in the Southern Song Dynasty.

During the Southern Song Dynasty, the imperial family moved south relatively completely, but when it came to the Southern Ming Dynasty, it was a hasty southward rush, which in itself was very different, and in the Southern Ming Dynasty, there were too many people vying for power and profit, and too many people were short-sighted.

The Southern Song Dynasty did not have the scandal of competing for the throne like the Southern Ming, and the hundred officials only supported Zhao Gou as the legitimate heir, while the Southern Ming Dynasty was different, and the Southern Ming Dynasty each supported several heirs, and the reason why the Southern Ming Dynasty was inferior to the Southern Song Dynasty was mainly due to the internal disunity of the Southern Ming.

Because the court of the Southern Ming Dynasty was very corrupt after the founding of the People's Republic of China, and the monarch of the Southern Ming Dynasty has always been very incompetent, the national strength of the Southern Ming Dynasty has always been inferior to that of the Southern Song Dynasty.