Why is Jia Lian in Dream of Red Mansions called Jia Erye ?

According to the habit at that time, the ranking of brothers in the family was all counted, so that Second Master Lian and Second Master Bao conflicted. In fact, Jia Yu is from Ningfu, not Rongfu, and Second Master Lian is corresponding to Uncle Zhen. This point can be found by taking a closer look at the original text of the Red Mansion, for example, Jia's mother does not live in the eldest son Jia Yu, but in the second son Jia Zheng, and from Jia Zheng to Jia Yu, you have to go through the gate (Daiyu can be seen when she enters Jia's mansion), which shows that Jia Yu and Jia Zheng do not live in the same courtyard, and there is also an important plot that is the seventy-fifth time The night banquet is a strange omen and a sad sound to appreciate the new words of the Mid-Autumn Festival (Jia Yu) because he patted Jia Huan's head again and said with a smile:

If we do this in the future, we will not be able to outrun you in the future. "Let's think about it, if Jia Yu is from the Rong Mansion, then Second Master Lian also has the right to inherit the title, how can Jia Yu help Jia Huan. There are other details that I won't mention here.

As for why the author put Jia Yu in the Rong Mansion on the surface, I think it is for the convenience of creation, because Sister Feng and Jia Lian are important characters in the book, if they are placed in the Ning Mansion like Jia Yu, then they can't always come to Daguanyuan and Rong Mansion, so the plot is not easy to arrange. So on the surface, he was put in the Rong Mansion. There is also a theory that the Cao family had an adoptive relationship, that is, Cao Yin's son died early, and Kangxi asked one of Cao Yin's brothers' sons to pass on to Cao Yin (for details, please refer to the chapter of Mr. Zhou Ruchang's "The Dream of Red Mansions", and the author said that the Dream of Red Mansions was written truthfully, and this Jia Yu was this stepson.

Have all the people in question watched "Dream of Red Mansions"? Don't talk nonsense if you haven't seen it! Don't you feel ashamed?

Jia Yu is the eldest son of Jia's mother, of course, a member of the Rong Mansion, and he attacked the title of Duke of Rongguo. Jia Zheng Yifang is not the heir to the title. This is the second time that "Leng Zixing's Speech on Rongguofu" has been clearly explained. The original text is as follows:

After the death of Duke Rong, the eldest son Jia Daishan attacked the official, married the young lady of the Shihou family of Jinling Shixun, and gave birth to two sons, the eldest son Jia Yu and the second son Jia Zheng. Now Dai Shan has long passed away, and Mrs. Tai is still alive. The eldest son, Jia Amnesty, attacked the officials, was calm and neutral, and did not care about household chores.

The second son, Jia Zheng. Judging from the titles of Jia Zhu, Baoyu and Jia Huan, Jia Fu is not in accordance with the big ranking. Jia Yu's eldest son, there is no explanation in the book, the letter is transmitted, the doubt is doubted, I don't know is not known, and I can't take it for granted.

As for Liu Xinwu's nonsense, it's better not to listen to it.

To put it simply, it is a matter of habit, as we all know, Baoyu also has an elder brother Jia Zhu, and this Jia Zhu's age should be about the same as Jia Lian, and at that time Baoyu may have been young or even unborn, and based on Jia Zhu Jia Lian is the young master of Rongguo Mansion and the identity is almost the same, then one is called the uncle, and the other is called the second master It is very common, and Baoyu's second master should be compared with Jia Zhu!

Jia Lian should also have an older brother, so he calls him the second master. But it definitely doesn't refer to Jia Zhu, because Baoyu's second master is from Jia Zhu, maybe this "uncle" died early and other reasons, so without explanation, Liu Xinwu revealed that there are conjectures in the Dream of Red Mansions, you can take a look.

He should have an elder brother named "Jia Mei", and "taking the assumption that there is no meaning" is explained in the fifty-third chapter of the ancient book.

Liu Xinwu said in the revelation that there was a name"Jia Cong", is Jia Yu's eldest son.

I guess I'm dead.

Watch Liu Xinwu reveal the secret of Dream of Red Mansions

There is a detailed explanation of the problem inside.

Jia Lian. The reason why it is called the second master is because according to the ranking of the men in Rongguo Mansion, that is, Jia Lian is under Jia Zhu, so he is naturally the second master. Jia Lian is Jia Amnesty.

's eldest son, the reason why he is called the second master, this is according to the ranking of the men in Rongguo Mansion, that is, he is under Jia Zhu, so he is naturally the second master.

Calculated from the ranking of Jiafu Rongning Erfu, Jia Zhen.

For the longest, Jia Lian is naturally the second master. Judging from the ranking of Rongguo Mansion, if Jia Zhu is the largest and called Uncle Zhu, then Jia Lian ranks second and is the second master of Lian. Jia Zheng.

The son born to Jia Zhu, Jia Baoyu.

Jia Huan, known as Uncle Zhu, Second Master Bao, and Third Master Huan, were not ranked alongside Jia Lian and Jia Zhen.

He and his uncle are called together, one is the eldest and the other is the second master.

Jia Lian is not Jia Yu's second son, Jia Yu is his son. The above answer is patently wrong.

Hello, the problem you are talking about is not the negligence of the author. Because Jia Lian is Jia Yu's second son, and Baoyu is Jia Zheng's second son. The two are not confused. Thank you, I hope my answer solves your problem.

You are all wrong, you don't know the rules of big families: that is, the brother dies and the younger brother dies, not only the rank inheritance, but also the title. Jia Lian was originally the second master, and Jia Zhu was the uncle.

But Jia Zhu died after getting married, but because he was married and had descendants, the ancestral grave was still the uncle who could not be moved, and the ancestral tablet still had his place, so Jia Lian could not be called the uncle, but only the second master; On the other hand, if Jia Zhu dies when he is a minor or becomes a parent, Jia Lian is directly the uncle, and Jia Zhu cannot enter the ancestral grave, and he doesn't even have a tablet. If Jia Zhu has any court title, Second Master Lian can inherit it, and he will be counted as the son of the world. And Jia Baoyu is very clear, although Jia Lian can only be called the second master, that is because Jia Lian can only be called the second master in order to respect Uncle Jia Zhu's family, otherwise how should Jia Zhu's widow be called?

Therefore, in fact, Jia Lian is the uncle, but he is called the second master in his name; And Baoyu is actually the second master. One is the nominal second master, and the other is the actual second master.