Han Xin has never led an army to fight, why is Xiang Yu not even an opponent when he makes a move?

Updated on history 2024-03-01
21 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    It's not that Han Xin hasn't led troops to fight, and he is not as godly as the title says, nothing is a master as soon as he makes a move, even if he is a genius, he has to run in with practice. Han Xin once led troops to fight under Xiang Liang, and only after Xiang Liang died in battle did Han Xin join Xiang Yu's command. Moreover, when Han Xin followed Xiang Liang, he also saw a lot of things about leading troops to fight, so Han Xin's talent for leading troops to fight was not achieved overnight.

    Although Han Xin's ability to lead troops to fight may not be Han Xin's opponent, Han Xin's ability to lead troops to fight did learn a lot from Xiang Yu. No genius is trained in a day, and Han Xin's ability to become an expert in leading troops in battle is not innate. Han Xin is under the command of Xiang Liang and Xiang Yu, although he is not a general, maybe this is the reason why everyone mistakenly thinks that Han Xin did not lead the troops to fight.

    Although Han Xin has not been a big official, Han Xin has been following Xiang Liang and Xiang Yu in the war.

    When Han Xin was under Xiang Yu, he served as a halberd bearer, although this official position was not high, but he was able to follow the general and learn a lot of things. This position is equivalent to Xiang Yu's personal guard next to the general, if it is in the palace, this position is equivalent to the chief eunuch next to the emperor, although he is a slave, he has a lot of power. The one who can understand the emperor's mind best is the old eunuch beside the emperor, and the army can often talk to the generals, and the ones who can understand the generals' intentions are the personal guards, which is equivalent to Han Xin is Xiang Yu's adjutant.

    The general's adjutant, can you not lead troops in battle? The experience of fighting with the army for a long time, but not independently commanding the battle, can be said to have never led the army to fightBut as soon as Han Xin made a move, even Xiang Yu was not an opponent, it must be because of an old saying, that is, knowing oneself and knowing the other side will win all battles, Han Xin has been fighting with Xiang Yu for so many years and is still Xiang Yu's personal guard, and he must know Xiang Yu's routines and fighting habits well。There is also a saying that the blue is better than the blue, Han Xin led the army to fight, and Xiang Yu was not an opponent, that was because Han Xin stood on the shoulders of giants.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, although Han Xin is a military strategist with 100,000 troops under his command, he has never been a leader in a battle, and Xiang Yu is basically an invincible and invincible god of war level, why can't he beat Han Xin? <>

    1. Han Xin's strategic talent is relatively strong in the early days, I believe everyone has heard the story of Han Xin's humiliation under the crotch, it is because of this incident that Han Xin began to grow all the way, and experienced a lot of ups and downs on his road. He was a small general under Xiang Yu, and later turned to Liu Bang because he was not reused by Xiang Yu. It should be said that in terms of troops, Han Xin is no match for Xiang Yu; But in terms of military affairs, Han Xin was stronger than Xiangyu.

    For example, Xiang Yu and Han Xin had a battle when they were in Qin, and in that war, they won more with less. Comparing Xiang Yu's performance in the Battle of Julu, his victory was because Xiang Yu was very powerful and confident, so in terms of momentum, Xiang Yu was still comparable to Han Xin. Xiang Yu's failure was because his strategy and strategic skills were not strong enough for Han Xinqiang.

    Second, Liu Bang's support Han Xin has always been Xiang Yu's junior general before, and it is not difficult to understand or lead the ability to fight for such a long time, and there is also a point of improvement in Liu Bang. Liu Bang loves money and cherishes talents very much, and once told Han Xin that he can fight as much as he wants, and he can use whoever he wants, which gives Han Xin a relatively free play. With Liu Bang's words, Han Xin will not worry about blind command, but can still move his muscles and bones, show his strength and feet, and have no scruples.

    Moreover, Liu Bei also has a strong legion ability and a very far-reaching strategic layout, which Xiang Yu can't compare. When Han Xin worshiped Liu Bang, Liu Bang had already carried out a lot of reform measures, such as reforming the tax system to develop production, and also restoring the military service levy system. The treasury is full.

    You don't need to care about how Xiang Yu fights, you can supply at the front line at any time. <>

    Although Han Xin has never fought, he has fought wisely and bravely, which has been brought to him by his life experience, and it is also because he has talent and throws himself to someone who knows how to value him.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Because the matter of fighting a war does not mean that the longer you lead the troops, the more powerful you will inevitably become, and leading the troops to fight is actually very talented.

    Everyone knows Xiang Yu's prestige, he is the overlord of Western Chu who can be a man who can be a man, but he is also known to be not good at scheming, and this actually has something to do with leading troops, after all, they all have to use their brains, soYou can think that Xiang Yu is very powerful, but don't think that he is also invincible with his troops.

    Han Xin has read poetry and books since he was a child, and he has long memorized books like "The Art of War", and since he was a child, he has often watched generals lead troops to fightSo from these things, he laid the foundation for his ability to lead troops in the future.

    Although everyone knows the story of "talking about war on paper", this story is about completely copying the art of war and not adjusting it according to the actual situation, and Han Xin, as a person who often analyzes war, naturally does not make these mistakes. Although Han Xin had never fought before, from his experience, he was actually a man of many battles.

    Han Shin himself has a wealth of knowledge, which is one thing, and the other is because his opponent is too underestimated. Xiang Yu has always been stubborn and self-serving, and he looks down on everyone except himself, and when he leads his troops to fight Han Xin, who appears for the first time, he naturally won't take it seriously. It's like when Liu Bei led a large army to fight Eastern Wu, and Lu Xun just stepped onto the stage of the Three Kingdoms, the result was that Liu Bei was beaten by Lu Xun, and even directly entrusted the White Emperor City.

    As the saying goes, arrogant soldiers will be defeated, and even the generals who fight have begun to be proud and complacent, so the combat effectiveness of his soldiers will naturally not be very highThen it is actually relatively normal for Han Xin to win.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    Because Liu Bang used Han Xin very much, he gave full play to Han Xin's talents, and Han Xin's own military strategy was also very strong.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Some people say that Han Xin's military talent is self-taught, and there are also rumors that it is because of the guidance and teachings of masters, so Han Xin is so powerful, and even Xiang Yu is not an opponent when he makes a move.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Because he has talent in this area, he didn't become famous before because no one gave him such an opportunity.

  7. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    First of all, it is inseparable from personal ability, and secondly, some people are born with war material, and then it is inseparable from the right time and place.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Mainly because Han Xin has read a lot of military books, is proficient in the art of war, and his martial arts are not weak.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    In the war with Xiang Yu, Han Xin did not have a head-on conflict with Xiang Yu's army, and it was Liu Bang who led the army to fight against Xiang Yu. But Han Xin was brushing the field on the periphery, and it was precisely because of this that Han Xin was able to take Xiang Yu in one fell swoop and laid the foundation. Therefore, Han Xin actually had Feng Dan's absolute combat experience before confronting Xiang Yu, and it is not surprising that Han Xin can win with full preparation for Hongyun.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    It's because although he hasn't led troops to fight, Han Xin's martial arts are very good, and he is also proficient in the art of war, and because he is a very smart person, and his IQ is very high, so Xiang Trembling Gao Yu can't parry him.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    Because some of this person's talents are very good, and this person's planning for some things is very good, so Xiang Yu can't resist.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    Because Xiang Yu's ability is not particularly good, and Xiang Yu's management of his subordinates is not particularly good, it leads to the inability to control Han Xin.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    Because Xiang Yu's cultural level is not very high, and Han Xin is very capable, there is no way to defeat this person.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    It should be better in mathematics, physics and chemistry.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    The military is theoretically strong, but not really strong; Only the strength in actual combat is the real strength!

    Before Han Xin, there was Zhao Kuo, and after Han Xin, there was Ma Yan. Both of these men were theoretically powerhouses, but they both ended up fighting and losing their reputations.

    The root cause of Zhao Kuo and Ma Yan's failure lies in the overnight success of these two people. Without any actual combat experience, the two of them directly crossed the important step of accumulating experience and directly participated in the most important war. Against heavyweight opponents, defeat is inevitable, and even success is a fluke.

    People are self-aware!

    Although Han Xin has great ambitions, he clearly knows how many catties he has.

    Han Xin did not choose to find an assassin to assassinate Qin Shi Huang on his own, as Zhang Liang did; did not choose to be like the heroes of the late Qin Dynasty, gathering people to respond to Chen Sheng.

    These are not what Han Xin is good at, so Han Xin chose to defect to Xiang Liang. Han Xin defected to Xiang Liang, did Han Xin see the strength of the Xiang family at that time, or did he defect to whoever came to him? This is unverifiable, and it doesn't really matter!

    The important thing is that Han Shin took his first step, and it was also his most crucial step.

    Under Xiang Liang, Han Xin accumulated his initial experience. When Xiang Liang died, Han Xin continued to follow Xiang Yu, and Xiang Yu appointed him as Langzhong. It should be seen that Han Xin is actually gradually improving in Xiang Yu's place.

    During this period, Han Xin began to offer advice to Xiang Yujin, but he was never accepted by Xiang Yu. There are two reasons for this, one is that Han Xin did not enter Xiang Yu's decision-making level, and the other is that Han Xin's strategies are likely to be inferior to Fan Zeng and others.

    Han Xin had accumulated a wealth of experience with Xiang Yu, but he had not been able to continue to improve. At this time, Han Xin made another important choice in his life, changing jobs! Han Xin jumped to Liu Bang.

    Han Xin, who jumped to Liu Bang, is no longer the Han Xin who has no work experience. Therefore, Han Xin was able to seize the opportunity in time, and Liu Bang decided to start cultivating Han Xin.

    Liu Bang did not let Han Xin command the army at once, but gradually escalated. From here, you can know why those who kill dogs, drive cars, and blow funerals can become a generation of famous generals!

    Han Xin's biography records, "The king of Han raised his troops east out of Chencang and set the three Qins." "This is Han Xin's biography, and it is not written that Han Xin pacified Sanqin. At this time, Han Xin was obviously just one of the generals involved.

    Because Han Xin's performance in these battles was relatively good, Liu Bang continued to give Han Xin more important tasks. Han Xin did an excellent job of occupying Wei and Dai, and at this time Han Xin had already begun to emerge!

    With the cooperation of Zhang Er, Cao Shen and others, Han Xin had already marched towards Zhao Di again. From then on, Han Shin began to embark on the road to the god of war.

    By the time Han Xin conquered the Qi State, Han Xin had accumulated a wealth of practical experience. When Han Xin began to face Xiang Yu, Xiang Yu was already at the end of his crossbow. When Han Xin started to shoot, it was just the last fatal blow to Xiang Yu.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    No. Because when Liu Bang and Xiang Yu pulled Pengcheng for a series, Han Xin had already eliminated the vassal states that posed a threat, and after years of accumulation, Xiang Yu was already the only one who could pose a threat, so it happened that at this time, Liu Bang joined forces with him to defeat Xiang Yu.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    Han Xin studied hard and had a strong talent in military command, and compared with Xiang Yu's large opening and closing of troops, Han Xin's tactics were more flexible.

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-20

    Han Xin is very powerful, and he has a unique talent and courage to lead troops into battle. Although the overlord of Western Chu is also very brave, he is a little proud and underestimates the enemy, so he will be defeated.

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-19

    Because of the large disparity between the two sides, Han Yu led 600,000 troops, Xiang Yu only had 100,000, and Xiang Yu was also arrogant, and Han Yu had the help of the strategist Zhang Liang by his side, Xiang Yu finally had to kill himself in Wujiang.

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-18

    Han Xin's soldiers are like gods, with countless records, winning a hundred battles, first-class command ability, and fighting invincible opponents all over the world, of course, he can defeat Xiang Yu, who is stubborn and self-serving.

  21. Anonymous users2024-01-17

    Han Xinqing Zao, as a great military strategist in history, rarely had the experience of fighting in his life, and the only time was with Xiang Yu, which is the so-called final battle of Haixia. Throughout Han Xin's life, he had never fought, but when he fought Xiang Yu for the first time, Xiang Yu drew a sword in Wujiang and killed himself. What is the reason for this?

    Han Shin was able to win mainly because he was a natural wise man. In the current situation, he was able to assess the situation, choose the appropriate strategy, and finally achieve victory. <>

    1. When Han Xin fought with Xiang Yu, he was actually already the top general in the world. At that time, Han Xin's reputation was basically comparable to Xiang Yu. Although Han Xin did not lead troops to fight, he was a very famous strategist.

    In the last battle, he once led an army of 30,000 to repel the 200,000 army of Zhao. The reason why Han Xin was able to achieve such success, and because of the huge disparity between the enemy and himself, shows that he is very capable of military affairs. Before Xiang Yu, the overlord of Western Chu, fought with Han Xin, he knew Han Xin's ability.

    Before the two fought, Xiang Yu had sent lobbyists to persuade Han Xin to set up his own door, but Han Xin did not listen to Xiang Yu out of loyalty to Liu Bang. Before the battle between Xiang Yu and Han Xin, Xiang Yu was actually unwilling to have a conflict. <>

    Second, the reason for Han Xin's victory was in the battle of Qixia, and the number of soldiers led by Xiang Yu and Han Xin respectively was very different. Han Xin alone led an army of 600,000, while Xiang Yu only had 100,000 people. Therefore, no matter how you beat Xiang Yu, you will suffer.

    The reason why Han Xin was able to win this battle was also because of the attrition tactics he adopted, which also combined with the strategy adopted by Zhang Da Xianliang to draw salaries from the bottom of the kettle, which eventually led to the discouragement of Xiang Yu's army. In this case, Xiang Yu had to break out and kill himself when he fled to Wujiang. Xiang Yu's defeat was to some extent self-inflicted, not defeated by Han Xin.

    Although Han Xin is a person who has never fought before, in this battle of the wall. He occupies the right place and the right people. So in the end, his success was also because Xiang Yu's military spirit was weak, and it was not much related to his personal ability.

Related questions
24 answers2024-03-01

As long as the house has been completed and delivered, the property management fee will be paid, which is just a matter of whether the developer or the owner paysThe main boundary is the completion of delivery, only after the developer notifies the delivery procedures (existing house), the property fee needs to be paid, the delivery inspection should be done, and if there are problems that need to be rectified, you can sign the rectification letter with the developer and the property, and then sign after the rectification is completed, and the property fee will not be paid during the rectification period, so that you can have a guarantee. >>>More

19 answers2024-03-01

Ordinary people don't have the courage to fight like this, because it's too dangerous. Han Shin's battle with fewer victories and more dangerous and unusual battles is most famously the Battle of the Back. The Battle of the Last Water, also known as the Battle of Jingcheng, was recorded in detail in the Book of Han. >>>More