If Liu Feng rescues Guan Yu, can he get a better result?

Liu Feng rescued Guan Yu and couldn't get a good ending. First of all, because Guan Yu is very proud, he can't be grateful to Liu Feng because of a life-saving grace, and at the same time, Liu Feng's existence has a great impact on Liu Chan's succession, so it is impossible for him to get a good death.

Yes. If Liu Feng rescues Guan Yu, Guan Yu can regroup and recapture Jingzhou, so that Shu Han's territory will be relatively large and the national strength will be relatively strong.

At least there will be no battle of Yiling, but it is not easy to get Jingzhou back, Liu Bei will not listen to Zhuge Liang, and he will go to Jingzhou with an iron heart and will not adjust the spearhead to fight Cao Cao.

No, this will instead hasten his death, because it is also a capital crime to use troops without Liu Bei's order.

No, if Liu Feng rescues Guan Yu, Liu Bei will still attack Wu when he goes to Jingzhou, but with Liu Bei's character and thinking of using troops, he will still be defeated when he encounters Lu Xun's opponent.

Liu FengNo rescueGuan YuFour reasons why:

1. Liu Feng did not have the authority to send troops without authorization.

Liu Bei. After establishing himself as the king of Hanzhong, he gave Guan Yu the power to fake Jieyue, and handed over all the affairs of Jingzhou to Guan Yu, but Liu Feng obviously did not have such an honor. Liu Feng is just a deputy general, and in addition, he is Liu Bei's righteous son, since Liu Chan.

After his birth, his position was already quite awkward. If he directly sent troops without Liu Bei's consent at this time, it was likely to arouse Liu Bei's suspicion or be slandered by others.

Second, Shangyong has just been annexed not long ago, and it is easy to have accidents.

Battle of Xiangfan. It took place in the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an, that is, in 219 AD, Liu Feng and Meng Da.

It is also this year to win the mediocrity. Moreover, in order to win people's hearts, Liu Bei let the original Shangyong Taishou Shen Tan and his younger brother Shen Yi take important positions. If Liu Feng easily dispatched Shangyong's soldiers and horses to help Guan Yu, then something would likely happen in Shangyong City.

Therefore, Liu Feng did not dare to act rashly.

3. Liu Feng and Meng Da are at odds, and the two are fighting for power.

Liu Bei sent the guards to Shangyong, not only Liu Feng, but also Meng Da, who laid down Shangyong with Liu Feng. Although these two people are colleagues, they are not convinced by each other. According to records, in order to suppress Meng Da, Liu Feng once seized Meng Da's set of propaganda honor guards, and the contradiction between the two intensified again.

When Guan Yu asked for help, it was impossible for the two of them to go together, and at the critical moment of the struggle for power, whoever helped Guan Yu was equivalent to giving up the control of Shangyong.

Fourth, when Guan Yu asked for help, he was not in danger.

Liu Bei and Guan Yu are like brothers, if he asks for help at a critical moment, Liu Feng and Meng Da probably won't refuse so happily, but when Guan Yu asked them to send troops, it was the side that had the upper hand, if it wasn't for Eastern Wu.

stabbing a knife in the back, Guan Yu will not end up defeated no matter what, so Liu Feng and Meng Da are not in a hurry to send troops.

If Liu Feng. At that time, he was desperate to save Guan Yu.

There is a high chance that he can successfully save Guan Yu, but unfortunately he refused to rescue him because he was afraid of Cao Jun's prestige, which eventually led to Guan Yu's defeat and death. Liu Feng came from an ordinary background and has always been in Liu Biao.

Served under the account, and later Liu Bei.

Attached to Liu Biao, Liu Feng admired Liu Bei very much in Jingzhou, and often served Liu Bei before and after the saddle, after Liu Bei left Liu Biao, Liu Feng decided to follow Liu Bei loyally, and finally Liu Bei accepted him as his adopted son. <>

Liu Feng has practiced martial arts since childhood, a superb martial arts, followed Liu Bei after birth and death, many times made great achievements, after pacifying Yizhou, Liu Bei named him as the deputy army general, Liu Bei led the army to attack Hanzhong, Liu Feng has been following the left and right, after occupying Hanzhong, Liu Bei's subordinate Meng Da.

Garrisoned in Shangyong, Liu Bei was worried that Meng Da would not be able to support him alone, so Liu Feng led his troops to garrison Shangyong with Meng Da, and appointed Liu Feng as the deputy general in charge of military affairs. <

Guan Yu was stationed in Jingzhou and was attacked by Xu Huang.

In desperation, Guan Yu led the remnants of the army to flee to Maicheng, and after settling down in Maicheng, Guan Yu immediately asked Liu Feng for help, but Liu Feng refused to send troops to rescue Guan Yu after consideration, resulting in Guan Yu finally defeated and killed. In fact, judging from the situation at the time, if Liu Feng sent troops, it was very likely to save Guan Yu, after all, Liu Feng's troops were strong and strong, and he could completely interact with Guan Yu to escape from Maicheng to Shangyong, Shangyong City was strong, with sufficient grain and grass, and was completely able to resist Cao Cao.

of attacks. <>

And even if Liu Feng sent troops, he didn't have to worry about the emptiness of Shangyong City and couldn't resist the enemy, Xu Huang, who stayed behind, had many years of experience in fighting and was a general who had experienced a hundred battles, and he was completely able to resist Cao Jun and Lu Meng and others. Liu Feng made a wrong decision at that time, so that Liu Bei resented him for life, Liu Bei and Guan Yu are sworn brothers, once made a vow to live and die together, Guan Yu's death made Liu Bei painful, carried away by great sadness, he dealt with all the relevant personnel at the time, and also found a reason to liquidate Liu Feng and give Liu Feng death.

It should be possible. Liu Feng also has a lot of soldiers and horses, so it is feasible for him to save Guan Yu. But Liu Feng didn't save it, it's really a pity.

Basically, it couldn't be saved, and Guan Yu's only way to survive at that time was to retreat in the direction of Changsha along the cover of Shangyong and Liu Feng. At that time, Jingzhou had been lost, and several important cities along the line had been occupied by Lü Meng, plus Xu Huang and Cao Zhang were divided into two ways to cooperate with Lü Meng's attack, Liu Feng had just laid down Shangyong at that time, and the army was resting, plus its original strength was not much, how to save this dead end, and with the military level of Lü Meng, Lu Xun and Cao Cao, it was impossible not to think of Liu Feng's factor. So I personally think that Liu Feng will not be able to rescue Guan Yu who is surrounded by many surrounds even if the whole army goes out to rescue him desperately, and it is very likely that he will also be put into it.

Not necessarily, because when they arrive in the place, if they fight, the sword and gun will not have eyes, so it is likely that he will accidentally injure himself.

He couldn't save Guan Yu. Because Guan Yu's situation is very difficult, he has been surrounded by many enemies. It is impossible to save it.

Of course you can, because his strength is also very strong, if he dies to save it at that time, he will definitely save it.

should be able to save Guan Yu, because his strength at that time was also relatively strong, and he was particularly valued.

No, because this is a historical necessity, and even if such a situation occurs, it will be the same result.

Liu FengDon't saveGuan YuThe reasons include the problem of troops, the problem of distance, and Liu Feng's selfishness.

1. Limited troops.

The reason why Guan Yu is in trouble is mainly because of Sun Quan.

's sneak attack plan finally put Guan Yu in a disadvantageous situation. In such a situation, if you want to rescue Guan Yu, you need at least 50,000 soldiers and horses. At that time, Liu Feng was only a partial division, and the soldiers and horses in his hands were really limited.

Although he managed to take down the mediocrity.

However, because he did not grasp the actual management power of the local area, the power in his hands was extremely limited, and he naturally had no ability to rescue Guan Yu in such a poor situation.

2. It is a long way to bury grandchildren.

Shangyong and Maicheng.

The distance is 500 kilometers, although 500 kilometers is not a distance today, but at that time, if you wanted to march a large army, it was necessary to reach it in 15-20 days. In addition, the roads between the two places are sheep's intestine paths, so it is not easy for the army to march smoothly, so by the time Liu Feng arrived, he had already missed the best time to rescue, and he might put himself in a disadvantageous situation.

3, Liu Feng has selfish motives.

Guan Yu didn't like Liu Bei from the beginning.

's adopted son, for Guan Yu, his loyalty is only aimed at Liu Bei, and others can't get his approval. If Liu Bei did not have a son, Liu Feng would take over Shu Han in the future.

So in such a situation, Liu Feng also realized that Guan Yu did not like him, and it was obvious that the follow-up attitude of this general would directly affect whether he could take over Shu Han. So in such a situation, he naturally didn't want Guan Yu to survive, and naturally he would be slack off on rescuing him. Of course, he just hoped that Guan Yu could bend the Qinglian defeat, so that Guan Yu's influence would also be affected, but he didn't expect that this matter would directly lead to Guan Yu's death.

Liu Feng refused to send troops to rescue Guan Yu, and it was recorded in the history books that Liu Feng thought that he had just captured the land of Shangyong, and was worried that sending troops would lead to the emptiness of Shangyong and the loss of the three counties of Shangyong. ** In "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", it is written that it was because Liu Bei wanted to make Liu Feng the crown prince and was dissuaded by Guan Yu, so Liu Feng was dissatisfied with Guan Yu, so he refused to send troops.

Liu Feng was originally called Kou Feng, his uncle Liu Mi and Liu Bei are the same clan, Liu Bei was already in his forties when he attached to Liu Biao in Jingzhou, and had no son, so he adopted Liu Feng's nephew Kou Feng as a righteous son, when Kou Feng was about a teenager, Liu Bei changed his name to Liu Feng, Liu Feng fought bravely, when he captured Xichuan, Liu Feng "fought a battle," and made a lot of military achievements, and later followed Liu Bei to capture Hanzhong.

Because Liu Feng knew that he couldn't save it, first, although his own strength was not bad, it was still a lot worse than the two allied forces of Lu Meng and Cao Cao. Second, Jingzhou has been lost, and the important cities along the line have been occupied by Lü Meng, and it is very difficult to send troops to rescue. Third, Liu Fenggang occupied Shangyong not long ago, at this time, the whole army dispatched to rescue Guan Yu will inevitably lead to the emptiness of the three counties of Shangyong, if you rush to attack, not only can you not save Guan Yu, you may even have to tower into the whole army to be annihilated.