Han Xin s ability is so strong, why can t he be reused after taking refuge in Xiang Yu?

Updated on history 2024-04-30
25 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    The so-called one mountain does not tolerate two tigers, which refers to Han Xin and Xiang Yu。Both of them are very talented people, and their military abilities are also very strong, but their personalities and ideas are not the same, so they can't fight together, they are only suitable for being opponents, so that their talents will not be buried. The two of them are the existence of generals on either side, but when the two are put together, there is not much benefit.

    Han Xin followed Xiang Yu, but he didn't get any benefits。At that time, when Han Xin decided to follow Xiang Yu, Xiang Yu was a nobleman of Chu State, and his ancestor was a general, so Xiang Yu, who had practiced martial arts since childhood, in addition to his high martial arts skills, naturally also had an arrogance that belonged to the children of rich families. His friends were only those nobles of the same status, such as many comrades-in-arms who fought with him later, such as Long Ji and others.

    And Han Xin, as a commoner, Xiang Yu, a son of the nobility, naturally looked down on him, with very serious discrimination. He thinks that Han Xin comes from a poor family, and how can he have any real talent and learning, he can just blow it with his mouth. So even if Han Xin came, Xiang Yu didn't pay much attention to him, and asked him to be a personal guard to beat him, but it was a pity that Han Xin was such a talented person, so he was in such a painless position.

    Xiang Yu is a proud person, so he naturally looks down on Han Xin。Xiang Yu has always only looked at and not listened to other people's opinions, he has his own ideas many times, and he finds that if he doesn't deal with his own ideas, then he doesn't need to use it directly. Xiang Yu led his troops to fight, relying entirely on a fierce force, and rarely used those twists and turns, and the battle of Julu was an example.

    So Han Xin rarely takes others in his eyes, let alone a Han Xin. <>

    The personalities of the two are too different to come together。Han Xin has his own ideas, and Xiang Yu will not reuse them, so it is obvious that there is not much point in continuing to stay here with Xiang Yu at all, so in the end, Han Xin ran away.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    Because Han Xin's background is not good and his reputation in the Chu military camp is not good, Xiang Yu has no Bole who can recognize people. Han Xin was humiliated by the crotch back then, he looked thin and small, others said that he was as timid as a mouse, but he thought that the big husband could bend and stretch, and he didn't care about the things in front of him, when the Chu army and the Qi army confronted each other, Han Xin had made suggestions, but a big general of the Chu army was proud and arrogant and did not suggest, it can be said that he looked down on Han Xin, and later in the battle, Han Xin once again offered a plan, that is, first pretended to retreat to lure the enemy to kill them all, but Long and did not think so, just said that Han Xin was really timid, the general's evaluation, It can be said that the whole army thinks of him, including Xiang Yu, of course.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Because Xiang Yu's personal ability was actually very strong at that time, and Han Xin was actually not dazzling at that time, so he was not reused, and when he arrived under Liu Bang, it was recommended by Xiao He, and Han Xin would have a chance to play.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    The first reason is because Han Xin's background is relatively humble, Xiang Yu is more disdainful, and the second reason is that Xiang Yu does not have the ability to recognize Han Xin, and Xiang Yu is not Han Xin's Bole.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Han Shin. At first, it was actually Xiang Yu who defected.

    But later Han Xin left Xiang Yu and took refuge in Liu Bang.

    Han Xin left Xiang Yu mainly for the following reasons:

    Xiang Yu is indeed a very capable person, and often more capable people are also very proud, so Xiang Yu is actually a bit stubborn, Xiang Yu often feels that what he says is the most correct, and he can't listen to the opinions of others. It was precisely for this reason that Han Xin felt that there was no need to continue to follow Xiang Yu, because he knew that Xiang Yu would not have his own opinions at all, so that his life's skills would not be able to be brought into play. <>

    Han Shin is also a very talented person, and Han Shin feels that he is a thousand miles.

    However, Han Xin felt that Xiang Yu was not his Bole, and Han Xin thought that Xiang Yu could not recognize talents. In Xiang Yu's camp, Han Xin is just a dispensable person, and there is no way to enter the core layer at all, so this point also makes Han Xin feel particularly aggrieved. For Han Xin, he was a person who aspired to become a general, but with Xiang Yu, Han Xin couldn't see hope, so he simply chose to leave in the end.

    Han Xin is like a god, but he has never been appreciated by Xiang Yu, you must know that although Han Xin has no political acumen, he has always been a very ambitious and ambitious person. After following the rain, Han Xin always wanted to get a chance to prove himself, but unfortunately Xiang Yu never gave him this opportunity. In this case, Han Xin found Liu Bang, although he was not reused at first, but in the end he was appreciated by Liu Bang and became Liu Bang's general.

    Therefore, Han Xin felt that it might be better to follow Liu Bang than to follow Xiang Yu, and it was for this reason that Han Xin decided to "give up" Xiang Yu and switch to Liu Bang. <>

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    is because he feels that Xiang Yu doesn't pay attention to the existence of Liu Bang's threat at all, and he is completely a reckless man, not a Ming Jun.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    It's because he knows that Xiang Yu is too indecisive. And it is particularly affectionate and righteous, and this kind of behavior will not be a king at all.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    I think Xiang Yu didn't reuse Han Xin. Xiang Yu knew Han Xin's talent, but he was unwilling to choose to reuse him. This is what makes Han Shin unhappy.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Han Xin is also known as the "God of War", so why can't he be reused by Xiang Yu for such a powerful person? There are several reasons for this.

    OneHan Xin was a famous general in ancient times, he made great contributions to Liu Bang's fight against the country, and his art of war is remembered until now. It was very normal for Han Xin to defect to Xiang Yu at first, but Han Xin didn't stay here for long before choosing to leave, so why did Xiang Yu never reuse Han Xin? The first reason is Han Shin's origin.

    Many people who like history know that Han Xin was very poor and very pitiful when he was a child, his parents died early, he could only choose to live a wandering life, and he suffered the humiliation of his crotch, these things are relatively sensitive in today's society, let alone in ancient times. When he arrived at the barracks, his stories followed him to the barracks, so countless people began to laugh at him and would not respect him, so Xiang Yu would not reuse him.

    IIThe second reason is Han Shin's character. Because Han Shin suffered a lot of hardships when he was a child, he was not good at communicating with others, and this kind of character was very unbearable in the military camp. At that time, many soldiers thought he was a strange person, and gradually began to distance themselves from him, and they did not want to communicate with him.

    At the same time, Han Xin's character has some arrogance, and it is precisely because of these personality reasons that his popularity in the army is relatively poor, so he did not stay in Xiang Yu's army for a long time.

    IIIThe third reason is Xiang Yu's character. This point is also the most important, although Xiang Yu is known as the "Overlord of Chu", special manhood, but in fact his heart is very narrow, it is for this reason that there are no particularly powerful strategists around him, and most people will choose to leave after staying by his side for a while. At the same time, Xiang Yu's personality is very conceited, he always thinks that he is very capable, so he will not reuse Han Xin, because he does not trust Han Xin at all.

    Therefore, there are many reasons why Xiang Yu does not reuse Han Xin.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    This is because for Xiang Yu, he feels that Han Xin's background is very ordinary, and his personality is relatively introverted, he suffered a lot of hardships at a very early stage, and he is not good at communication, so he was not reused by Xiang Yu.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    This is due to Han Shin's low status, and Han Shin's family is not particularly rich, plus Han Shin has already betrayed a monarch. Such perfidious people are not to be used.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    At that time, Xiang Yu was a child of the aristocracy, and sometimes he was arrogant and sometimes discriminated against people from poor families, including Han Xin.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    Maxima often has, but Bole does not often have. Han Xin is a Maxima, he is a genius in military history, but Han Xin, this Maxima, is not something that everyone can discover, in the late Qin period, except for Liu Bei, who would use Han Xin, no one else would use Han Xin.

    After Xiang Liang died, Han Xin fought with Xiang Yu, and later became a halberd, equivalent to a palace guard officer, responsible for guarding the big tent.

    Han Xin has always wanted to come out, he has offered advice to Xiang Yu many times, but he was not valued by Xiang Yu, Xiang Yu is also a military wizard, and his military ability in the late Qin period is stronger than Han Xin, in the military, Xiang Yu himself does not need Han Xin at all, he can win battles, such as the Battle of Julu and the Battle of Pengcheng, all of which were proposed by Xiang Yu himself and led his troops to implement.

    Xiang Yu belongs to the kind of boss with super personal ability, and he has the final say in the march and battle, Although Han Xin has a plan, in Xiang Yu's opinion, it is not as good as his own strategy and tactics, so Han Xin is useless here in Xiang Yu at all, Xiang Yu is winning the battle with Han Xin or not, why should he listen to Han Xin's strategy instead of using his own strategy?

    So Han Xin also found that he couldn't get along with Xiang Yu here, so he could only take refuge in Liu Bang, the second largest force in the world, at first Liu Bang didn't pay attention to Han Xin, and only gave a small official of warehouse management, and later after the recommendation of Xiahou Ying and Xiao He, and after Liu Bang talked with Han Xin, Liu Bang reused Han Xin.

    There are two reasons why Han Shin can show his talents:

    The first is Liu Bang's reuse.

    Liu Bang's generals who do not have super military capabilities are in need of people like Han Xin who can become generals, and the demand is reused, which is the same as enterprise recruitment, if an enterprise lacks a very important leadership position, he will definitely pay attention to talents in this area, this is the demand, if there is no shortage of people, even if you are powerful, you will not be recruited.

    Han Xin is the same way, Xiang Yu doesn't need a general like Han Xin, because Xiang Yu himself is a general, he doesn't need others to help him fight, Xiang Yu fights by himself, although Liu Bang also fights in person, but the military is Liu Bang's shortcoming, Liu Bang needs Han Xin, so he will reuse it.

    The second is that Liu Bang gave an independent platform.

    Han Xin's success, the main reason is that Liu Bang gave Han Xin an independent platform, Liu Bang handed over part of the army and generals to Han Xin's command, and let Xiao He continue to provide Han Xin with food and materials, Han Xin does not need to consider the source of troops and logistics, he only needs to fight in the front, which gives Han Xin a platform to exert his ability, without this platform, Han Xin will not be able to display his ability.

    Xiang Yu couldn't give Han Xin this platform, only Liu Bang would give it, so Han Xin left Xiang Yu and took refuge in Liu Bang.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    Because Xiang Yu is very arrogant, he looks down on Han Xin, and Han Xin's background is not very good, and he also has a lot of bad reputations.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    This is related to Xiang Yu's personality. Xiang Yu is also a rare military wizard, but Xiang Yu is self-righteous and difficult for subordinates to disagree. Therefore, Han Xin could not be reused by Xiang Yu.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    Because Xiang Yu had many generals under him at that time, and Xiang Yu was also a very status-oriented person, he did not agree with Han Xin's skills, so he naturally would not reuse the other party.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    It was because Han Xin was particularly free, he was particularly difficult to manage, and his character was also straightforward, so he was not reused by Xiang Yu back then.

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    It was because Xiang Yu couldn't listen to anyone's dissuasion at that time, and he thought that Han Xin had no skills and was not willing to listen to people.

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    Because Han Xin was not trusted by Xiang Yu at that time, Xiang Yu did not know Han Xin.

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-20

    The main reason is that Han Xin has not been appreciated by Xiang Yu, and Xiang Yu actually does not have too many advantages in employing people, so he will not use people.

  21. Anonymous users2024-01-19

    The military thinking of the two men is not consistent.

  22. Anonymous users2024-01-18

    It's because Han Xin is too conceited, and Xiang Yu is a particularly domineering person, who feels that all his decisions are correct and is not good at listening to other people's advice.

  23. Anonymous users2024-01-17

    Xiang Yu cares a lot about other people's past, Han Xin's reputation is not good, and Xiang Yu can't give Han Xin too much military power.

  24. Anonymous users2024-01-16

    Although Han Xin is very powerful, Han Xin is a very scheming person, and he always wants to make a career out of his own.

  25. Anonymous users2024-01-15

    The reason why Xiang Yu didn't reuse Han Xin was because he thought that Han Xin was better than him, and he was jealous of Han Xin.

Related questions
24 answers2024-04-30

Xiang Yu's failure was due to his failure to retain talents, and his failure to adapt to the situation, and a fatal mistake occurred in the construction of the system. >>>More

26 answers2024-04-30

Although Xu Huang ranked last among Cao Cao's five good generals, his credit was not inferior to the other four. One of the most glorious battles in Xu Huang's life was to defeat Guan Yu in one fell swoop with a weak army and relieve the siege of Fancheng. >>>More

26 answers2024-04-30

Why can Zhu Wu rank first in "Water Margin"? People who watch the Water Margin every day have more or less had this question, which seems to say why Zhu Wu can rank first, thinking that he is high. >>>More

32 answers2024-04-30

Xiang Yu, an interpretation of a perfect tank, all kinds of damage reduction and damage resistance. Two skills, passive, and another weakening. No matter who you are? >>>More

19 answers2024-04-30

Ethnographic characteristics of blacks have been studied on the "metabolic" status of blacks and found that the sweat glands of blacks. >>>More