is also a famous general, Zhao Yun, Changbanpo seven in and seven out, why can t Guan Yu kill in Mai

The Romance of the Three Kingdoms is actually adapted from "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" and written by folklore and Luo Guanzhong's own imagination, so the content in it is basically three points of fiction and seven points of reality, and one of the obvious apocryphal plots in it is that Zhao Zilong is seven in and seven out of Changbanpo, many people even think that this is true, but anyone who thinks about it knows that this is basically impossible. Today is based on the old discussion of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", so I will not talk about facts and historical facts. The theme of this time is: Guan Yu and Zhao Yun are both famous generals, why did they die in Maicheng instead of seven in and seven out of Changbanpo like Zhao Yun?

First of all, it is not surprising that Guan Yunchang was already old at this time, and it was not surprising that he was attacked by Pan Zhang and Ma Zhong in the woods and fell under the horse. But some people want to say that Zhao Yun was also trapped in the pit in Changbanpo, why didn't Guan Yu get out of the trap? All I can say is that this is a bit of a rhetoric, or I'll give you a reason:

Haven't you heard of one Lu, two Zhao, three Dianwei, four passes, five horses, and six Zhang Fei??? The public thinks that Zhao Yun is braver than Guan Yu, and from the ranking, he is much braver. <>

After talking about the comparison between the defeated Maicheng and the seven in and seven out from the perspective of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", what is the history like? As mentioned earlier, seven in and seven out is an obvious apocryphal fabrication in Luo Guanzhong's pen, but this paragraph is actually made up on a factual basis, the protagonist is not Zhao Yun but Wen Yang, the history book wrote that Wen Yang only relied on a horse to kill six or seven times in thousands of troops, so that the pursuers did not dare to pursue, and later **, Peking Opera, Henan Opera, etc., put this paragraph on Zhao Yun. In fact, there is no such history as the defeat of Maicheng, Guan Yu is indeed brave, but the flooding of the Seventh Army has historical facts and makes Guan Yu powerful in China, so that Cao Cao has the idea of moving the capital for a while, it can be seen that Guan Yu is not as boasted as Zhao Yun.

In fact, having talked about so much, if you insist on saying that Guan Yu is old in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", and he is indeed not as brave as Zhao Yun in his prime. And there are no such things in history, Zhao Yun is just a nickname guard, and Guan Erye is indeed worthy of his name.

First of all, it was Liu Bei who Cao Cao caught in Changbanpo, and he didn't even know who Zhao Yun was, after all, Zhao Yun's reputation was too low. And Zhao Yun was considered to have "escaped" in the melee, no one paid attention to him, and some people were stupid when it was over: Oh, Zhao Yun is amazing!

Suffice it to say: you have a bit of a brain. Guan Yu was a well-known warlord, and at that time, many forces arrested him together, unlike Zhao Yun, no one knew, and no one could replace him.

Because the environment in which the two were in different places at that time, Guan Yu was surrounded by the enemy's large army at that time, while Zhao Yun of Changbanpo did not face such a large number of troops. That's why Guan Yu was defeated and took Maicheng.

Because Guan Yu was already old at that time, and he was seriously injured, his combat effectiveness had decreased, so he couldn't kill in Maicheng.

The main reason why Guan Yu couldn't kill him was that Cao Cao was very strict with him, and he was not like Zhao Yun, who was a little relaxed, so it could be said that he was not so strict with Zhao Yun, so Zhao Yun could go out.

Zhao Yun and Guan Yu were both fierce generals of Shu, and both of them had very dazzling achievements in the early days of the Three Kingdoms. And in my opinion,Zhao Yun was able to kill seven in and seven out of Cao's army formation because Cao Cao ordered Zhao Yun to be captured alive, so Zhao Yun was given a chance. But Guan Yu was not so lucky, he was designed by Lu Meng to take Jingzhou, so he could only defeat Maicheng

It can be said that the environment in which the two are located is different, which also leads to the different endings of the two.

1. Zhao Yun was able to kill seven in and seven out because Cao Cao ordered Zhao Yun to be captured alive

When he was in Changbanpo, Zhao Yun was trapped by Cao Jun in order to save Liu Chan, but because his performance was too brave, even if he was surrounded by Cao Jun's soldiers, he could still protect Liu Chan well, so his performance also attracted Cao Cao's attention, and successfully made Cao Cao rise to love talent, in this case, Cao Cao was afraid that Zhao Yun would be injured by the soldiers, so he ordered Zhao Yun to be captured alive. But you must know that as soon as this order came out, it also meant that the soldiers could not kill Zhao Yun, so it was inevitable that they would be tied up in the battle with Zhao Yun. But Zhao Yun didn't have any worries about this, and he was bent on breaking through, so he naturally didn't care about it.

It can be said thatCao Cao's order allowed Zhao Yun to find a way to survive in the face of adversity, which is why he was finally able to break through the enemy line and escape.

Second, Guan Yu was taken Jingzhou by Lu Meng

Guan Yu is a military general, who followed Liu Bei and made great achievements, and in the battle of besieging Xiangfan, he also had the performance of flooding the Seventh Army, which can be said to be a powerful shock to China. But his attitude towards Shi Dafu has always been unfriendly, which made Mi Fang, Shiren and others who followed Guan Yu to guard Jingzhou and other places complain. In the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an, Guan Yu and Xu Huang and others fought in Fancheng, and after the defeat, they were stationed in Shuishui, and at the same time, Mi Fang and Shiren surrendered to Lü Meng, resulting in the loss of Jingzhou, so Guan Yu could only retreat all the way south to Maicheng, and finally fell into an ambush and was killed by Wu State.

It can be said thatAlthough Guan Yu was brave and unparalleled, he was betrayed by Mi Fang, Shiren and others, and the whole of Wu had always been very resentful of Liu Bei's behavior of borrowing Jingzhou and not returning it, so naturally he would not let Guan Yu live.

To sum up, Cao Cao's love is so that Zhao Yun got the opportunity to escape in Changbanpo, but Wu Guo resented Guan Yu and naturally would not let Guan Yu go, so although the two were surrounded, the ending was completely different.

Because the environment faced by the two of them is different, the environment faced by Zhao Yun is relatively good, and the environment faced by Guan Yu is relatively bad, so the ending is different.

Because Guan Yu is very vain and arrogant, there is a situation of underestimating the enemy, so it will lead to the defeat of Maicheng.

Because Guan Yu was too kind-hearted, he took the wrong path, and was finally killed by Cao Cao, and Guan Yu was bright and upright all his life.

Because the situation at that time was very dangerous, and Guan Yu had enemies in front and behind, this situation would occur.

At that time, Cao Cao asked his subordinates to capture Zhao Yun alive, and these people naturally would not be killed, so Zhao Yun seized the opportunity to escape.

Zhao Yun is seven in and seven out, after all, he is in the prime of life, and Guan Yu is already old when he walks in Maicheng