Watching the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, I have never understood why Guan Yu took it upon himself

Updated on culture 2024-04-18
29 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    Really read the Three Kingdoms, don't look at the romance: Guan Yu's Northern Expedition really disobeyed the order and acted alone?

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Because Guan Yu was Liu Bei's sworn brother, he thought that he had the ability to make decisions for Liu Bei, so he carried out the Northern Expedition.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Because at that time, Guan Yu's Northern Expedition was to drive Cao Wei's forces out of the Jingzhou territory, and secondly, it was not on his own, Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang knew it.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    It's very simple, the world is divided, originally he guarded Jingzhou is semi-independent, and Liu Bei is in a state of semi-independence, and Liu Bei is fighting against each other, but seeing that Liu Bei is getting bigger and bigger, he is a little anxious, to put it bluntly, ambition makes people perish.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    Because Guan Yu was very confident in the success of the Northern Expedition, he was loyal to Liu Bei, and he was bent on quickly realizing the great cause of reunification, and he was in a hurry to achieve success.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Guan Yu is Liu Bei's sworn brother and has a lot of power, and Liu Bei has taken the throne of Hanzhong as the king of Hanzhong, so Guan Yu wants to respond to Liu Bei.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    I think the main reason is Guan Yu's strong combat ability, and the result of the military order he made in this battle.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    This is because Guan Yu himself is very proud and very confident in himself, so he wants to seize the Central Plains region for Liu Bei.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Guan Yu surrendered to the ban at the beginning, killed Pang De, flooded the Seventh Army, and the momentum was like a bamboo, Zhuge Liang did not expect that he would be attacked by Lu Meng. Later, if he wanted to save it, Yuanshui didn't save it into the fire, it was too late, and Liu Feng, who was similar, Meng Da did not send troops.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Because Zhuge Liang did not calculate Guan Yu's own character, after all, the main reason for losing Jingzhou was that Guan Yu's personality was too proud.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Because Zhuge Liang is not an immortal, anything can be expected. At that time, Guan Yu actually had a great advantage in guarding Jingzhou, and no one expected that he would lose miserably.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    Because he is not a person who can calculate everything, otherwise he would not have to go out of the mountain, he can calculate the demise of Shu Han.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    It can be said that Zhuge Liang and Liu Bei did not order Guan Yu to raise troops for the Northern Expedition, but after Guan Yu's Northern Expedition, neither of them stopped it, which can be regarded as Guan Yu's behavior that Guan Yu thought that the morale of our army was booming and that he wanted to take advantage of the victory to pursue it!

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    It was Zhuge Liang who said it, and Zhuge Liang asked Guan Yu to attack Fancheng.

    But I didn't tell him how to fight.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    It is Zhuge Liang's meaning, the purpose is to get rid of Guan Yu, a person who has no one in his eyes, is arrogant, and has no strategic vision, but is trusted by Liu Bei. This is conducive to the consolidation of the Shu Han regime.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    Guan Yu was the highest military governor of the entire Jingzhou at that time, and was the main person in charge of the defense of Eastern Wu and Cao Cao in Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang when Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang were busy pacifying Xichuan and Hanzhong, and there was no prestige in Jingzhou at that time to compare with the qualifications of the prestige, combined with the development process of Liu Bei Group at that time, Liu Bei had just captured Xichuan, and at the same time he was eyeing Hanzhong, Liu Bei's foundation has been completed, and Guan Yu was named the head of the Five Tiger Generals by Liu Bei at that time, and he launched a northern expedition to prove that he was not surprised at all.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang's order was when Liu Bei was called the king of Hanzhong and gave Guan Yu an official.

    Fei Shifang issued a royal decree and ordered Yun Chang to lead his troops to take Fancheng. 】

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    Strategically necessary, Guan Yu has the power to go on the Northern Expedition!

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-20

    Guan Yu proposed, and then he was asked to send troops just because of this intention!

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-19

    Guan Yu is very loyal and emotional, but Guan Yu is too arrogant! That's why there was a tragic ending of losing Maicheng and being in a different place!

  21. Anonymous users2024-01-18

    Guan Yu's good character traits are that he is very loyal and righteous, very loyal and studious, but people always have two sides, his disadvantage is that he is more arrogant and a little self-righteous.

  22. Anonymous users2024-01-17

    Guan Yu's character in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is characterized by loyalty and righteousness.

  23. Anonymous users2024-01-16

    Guan Yu is by no means an outlaw, he is loyal and courageous; Its brave force is against ten thousand armies, and he goes to the meeting alone; Its wisdom and strategy besieged Fancheng and flooded the Seventh Army; His courage commanded the three armies, talking and laughing. But he is too proud! "I look at Yan Liang, such as inserting a label to sell the first ear!

    Then the hand rises and falls, and one move is done; There is also warm wine to kill Huaxiong, and six generals after five levels"My tiger girl Anken marries your dog! "It was Pride that not only ruined himself, but also Zhuge Liang's entire strategy.

  24. Anonymous users2024-01-15

    Guan Yu is the embodiment of benevolence and righteousness, loyal and brave.

  25. Anonymous users2024-01-14

    A good character is righteousness, and a strange character is arrogance.

  26. Anonymous users2024-01-13

    Not science and technology peak hours broadcast time starts on Monday to: these: this? In this.

  27. Anonymous users2024-01-12

    Loyalty (the main reason for being respected by later generations), conceit (the reason for failure), and small amount (self-confidence in old qualifications, successively suppressed Zhuge Liang and Huang Zhong).

  28. Anonymous users2024-01-11

    Loyalty, arrogance, self-serving.

  29. Anonymous users2024-01-10

    Guan Yu's story, there are too many stories told throughout the ages, these anecdotes have long been heard in the ears, what Guan Yu has passed five levels and killed six generals, he is in Cao Ying's heart in Han, Zhu Yan Liang beheaded Wen Chou, etc., etc., etc., but these are more things in the romance, Luo Guanzhong has artistized the story of the entire Three Kingdoms too much, so that slowly, what most people have heard since childhood is the Three Kingdoms that have been rendered.

    There are undoubtedly two people in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" who have been deified too much, one is the clever Zhuge Liang, and the other is the loyalty and righteousness of Guan Yunchang. Zhuge Liang is too complicated, I don't want to talk about him, let's talk about Guan Yu first.

    The reason why Guan Yu appeared on the historical stage is similar to that in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, because he committed a crime, he ran to Zhuo County, Youzhou, and then followed Liu Bei and Zhang Fei and his party to start a business. However, the relationship between Liu Guanzhang and his brothers is really good, and this is not black or blown.

    Guan Yu followed Liu Bei in fact, in the real sense of the word, did not participate in many major battles, even if "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" deliberately exaggerated Guan Yu's exploits, the same, it has only been exaggerating Guan Yu's virtue and force too much, and it has not said how many crucial sieges have been carried out. There is one thing that has to be said is the word "ten thousand enemies", Guan Yu and Zhang Fei share it.

    Guan Yu was once captured by Cao Cao, Cao Cao did have the intention of collecting Guan Yu, and also gave a lot of gifts, although Guan Yu did not vote for Cao, but in order to express his gratitude, he still helped Cao Cao behead Yan Liang in the army, which is recorded in the official history. At that time, Guan Yu saw Yan Liang's cover, so he rode over without hesitation and beheaded Yan Liang, taking the head, as if entering a no-man's land, he came and went freely. You must know that this Yan Liang is not a vegetarian, in addition, Wan Jun stands, Guan Yu just beheaded the head of the enemy general, and there are few people in the entire official history of the Three Kingdoms who can do it, this is the courage of Wanfu.

    This is Guan Yu's personal strength, and he was therefore given the title of Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion, but in fact, not to mention Guan Yu, that is, Liu Bei has never fought a decent battle when he comes here, so no matter how much Luo Guanzhong touts, he can only make a big fuss about personal heroism. Later, Liu Bei finally had his own company, and Guan Yu, as one of the few generals under his account, was bound to have a difficult task.

    In the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an, Guan Yu attacked Cao Ren in Fancheng, Cao Cao hurriedly sent Yu Ban and Pang De to the rescue, it happened to be autumn, the water of the Xiangjiang River was going to rise, and the time and place were right, how could Guan Yu not take advantage of it. So he ordered people to block the various estuaries of the river, and when the tide rose, he took them in one fell swoop, and prepared many war rafts at the mouth of the Han River. It is conceivable that this battle is bound to become famous.

    Guan Yu flooded the Seventh Army, captured alive in the ban, poor Pang De at that time, it is said that Pang De took the coffin to respond to the battle, which means that if it is not successful, it will become a benevolent, and later Guan Yu could not surrender, so he killed.

    This battle can be regarded as truly famous in the world, shocking the Central Plains, Guan Yu at that time was really unable to compete with him, but this also spoiled Guan Yu, and also bought the foreshadowing for Guan Yu's own death.

Related questions
7 answers2024-04-18

Guan Yu is not married, but he has a godson named Guan Ping!

16 answers2024-04-18

It's not handsome or ugly, it's very popular with girls. It is said ... Haha, awesome. This dude is confident. >>>More

4 answers2024-04-18

Hey, landlord

Didn't you say that junior high school students should be able to understand it? >>>More

4 answers2024-04-18

Three times. Discussion Wen Ming, Dong Zhuo, Ding Yuan.

Feed Jinzhu Li Su said Lu Bu. >>>More

4 answers2024-04-18

I am the deputy head of the team that knows about "Those Things in the Three Kingdoms Period". >>>More