Why didn t Liu Bei arrange a right hand man by Guan Yu s side?

A few of his subordinates can pull them over with their fingers.

Because Liu Bei's main focus was on the battle between Hanzhong and Cao Cao at that time, he gave priority to putting resources in Hanzhong, and again Guan Yu's character, he was stubborn and self-serving, and he couldn't listen to other people's opinions, and if he sent a strategist, it was easy to have a lot of contradictions.

In the whole world, the second shopkeeper only obeys Boss Liu's orders, and it is useless for Liu Bei to send strategists to it.

Is it useful to arrange a strategist? Guan Er's eyes are empty, I am the only one, and I think that my martial arts strategy is the best in the world, who can help me. This man's arrogant temperament is destined to be a big thing, only a tragic end.

Liu Bei didn't arrange it, it was Guan Yu who didn't listen to the words of the strategists As long as Guan Yu sticks to Jingzhou, unites the scholars in Jingzhou, and unites Sun Quan, there is no problem in holding Jingzhou The character is too arrogant.

Ma Liang is by Guan Yu's side. Isn't that enough?

What is the standard of a strategist? If it is said that the top is the best, it can only be said that it can't be used, after all, there are not many strategists of this level in the entire Three Kingdoms period, and it is not that Liu Bei does not arrange it.

At that time, Liu Bei's resources were already small, and there were about three top strategists, namely Zhuge Liang, Pang Tong, and Fa Zheng. <>

Let's talk about Liu Bei's "humerus" Zhuge Liang first, Zhuge Liang was originally guarding Jingzhou with Guan Yu, and Pang Tong, who followed Liu Bei into Sichuan, had to let Zhuge Liang enter Sichuan to assist after his death, after which Zhuge Liang has been busy with Shuzhong and Hanzhong affairs, and Zhuge Liang, who is worried about internal affairs, has no time at all, and it is impossible to go back to Jingzhou to guard Jingzhou. Needless to say, Pang Tong died before, which is also one of the reasons why Zhuge Liang entered Sichuan at that time.

And Liu Bei's "mastermind" method in Shuzhong was helping Liu Bei to take and stabilize Xichuan, and he was busy with the battle of Hanzhong, and died less than a year after taking Hanzhong.

In fact, Hanzhong and Shuzhong at that time were more in urgent need of important manpower than Jingzhou, because Jingzhou was roughly stable at that time, Cao Cao's center of gravity at that time was on the side of Hanzhong, and it was an alliance with Sun Quan, and Hanzhong and Shuzhong were initially decided, and they were waiting to be revived. <>

So the top one is impossible.

Slightly inferior, Liu Bei is not without arrangements, and the strategists who followed Guan Yu to guard Jingzhou are mainly Ma Liang and Wang Fu, these two should not be bad.

At that time, there was a saying that "Ma's five good, white eyebrows are the best", this white eyebrows are Ma Liang, among which Ma Jian is also one of Ma's five constants, Ma Liang's brother. Ma Liang is Zhuge Liang's friend. He was also the most important adviser to help Guan Yu defend Jingzhou, and he made great contributions to diplomacy and domestic affairs, especially diplomacy.

When he coordinated the defense of Jingzhou, he repeatedly sent envoys to Eastern Wu to negotiate with Sun Quan. One of his most outstanding diplomacy was when Liu Bei later attacked Wu, and he recruited and persuaded the Wuxi ethnic minorities to assist Liu Bei in his attack on Wu. <>

There is also Wang Fu, who is Liu Bei's adviser in Shuzhong, Liu Bei later saw that Jingzhou was also a little tight at that time, so he was transferred to Jingzhou and appointed him as Jingzhou Yicao to assist Guan Yu, this official position is also an important position.

Although these two people are capable, they can't change Guan Yu's mind, and the only ones who can shake Guan Yu's mind may be the boss Liu Bei, Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun and Zhuge Liang, who can "talk". So everything is decided by Guan Yu alone, their words can only be a reference, and Guan Yu will not listen to what he says.

However, both Wang Fu and Ma Liang fled to Shuzhong after the fall of Jingzhou, and later died in the battle of Yiling in which Liu Bei attacked Wu.

In fact, the strategist is not the key to determining the outcome of the victory, and it is not effective or not, the strategist can only be a suggestion, and the coach who makes the final decision is the key. Is there a shortage of strategists in the battle of Yuan Shaoguandu? Is there a small number of strategists in Cao Cao's battle of Chibi?

Is there a lack of strategists in the battle of Liu Beiyiling? The commander's command error is the main reason for the failure of a campaign.

Because he doesn't need to, Guan Yu does things in a coarse and meticulous way, and he has a very good grasp of it, so Liu Bei has no need to worry at all.

I have the following thoughts on your question!

In the history of the Three Kingdoms, Guan Yu's life is unknown, in fact, the Guan family is a literati family, and his grandfather Guan Shen；Cong Mu is good at teaching, teaching his children with "Yi" and "Spring and Autumn"; Guan Yu's father, Guan Yi, is a very filial person. Guan Yu was born on June 24, the third year of Emperor Huan's Yanxi, and married his wife Hu when he grew up, and gave birth to a son Guan Ping on May 13 of the first year of Emperor Guanghe. Judging from this record, Guan Yu has a wife and children.

Guan Yu and Liu Bei met in Zhuo County, and Guan Yu was alone at that time；In fact, it was the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty, the rise of rebels in various places, the imperial court lived up to its name, and Guan Yu was helpless, so he came out to start a business alone; met Liu Bei, who was also a person who wanted to start a business, and later pulled Zhang Fei in, and the three of them became brothers, and since then they have started the road of entrepreneurship.

Liu Bei treats Guan Yu, Zhang Fei is closer than his own brother, Liu Bei is a benevolent and righteous person, and he treats Guan and Zhang with sincerity；The three of them ate and slept together, without restraint; It's not comfortable to talk about ideals and plan for the future. Later, knowing that Liu Bei was the emperor's uncle, Liu Bei did not change his attitude towards Guan Yu and Zhang Fei at all, let alone any hierarchy, but still as before, he ate together, wore clothes, and slept together. Liu Bei treats them as his own, and Liu Bei has the heart to help the Han family, which is the ideal path of Guan Yu and the person to follow the most; Compared with other princes and generals, Liu Bei has no shelf and no superior actions, Guan Yu feels that Liu Bei is his ideal eldest brother.

Liu Bei treats Guan and Zhang better than his wife and children；In which era, and who else can do this? Liu Bei treats the people as his wife and children, when can a few princes do it? If there were no these, would Guan Yu still be able to follow Liu Bei?

Some people say that Liu Bei's country is crying, I think it is nonsense, Liu Bei was able to divide it into three in the end, relying on benevolence and sincerity to his brother. With these, Guan Yu obeyed Liu Bei's words, and it was also because he was infected by Liu Bei, and at the same time, Liu Bei also gave Guan Yu the stage as much as possible, so that Guan Yu had the prestige of Guan Yu later.

It was because he was impressed by Liu Bei's talent, and because Liu Bei was so powerful, Guan Yu couldn't beat Liu Bei. In fact, Guan Yu is also ambitious, but he just didn't say it.

I think it's because he is more affectionate and righteous, he has no ambition, and only thinks about serving his eldest brother Liu Bei.

Because Guan Yu felt that Liu Bei was a person who was very worthy of dependence. Guan Yu has no ambitions, because Guan Yu only knows how to fight and kill.

This is because Liu Bei is very benevolent and righteous, and it is precisely because of his benevolence and righteousness that many people follow him.

Because of Liu Bei's noble personality, Guan Yu, Zhang Fei and others admired Liu Bei very much, so they followed Liu Bei with all their hearts.

The reason why Guan Yu, Zhang Fei and Zhuge Liang followed Liu Bei with all their hearts was because Liu Bei was a good leader. And Liu Guanzhang and they are all good brothers who worshipped.