Guan Yu died and Liu Bei cried, but Zhang Fei died and Liu Bei didn t cry, why is there such a big g

Updated on history 2024-05-06
25 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-09

    Guan Yu died, and the reason why Liu Bei cried bitterly was not only because he was his brother, but also because of the loss of Shu Han's future, and Zhang Fei was much inferior to Guan Yu. According to the records of relevant documents, it is not difficult for us to find that if Liu Bei wants to plot the world, Jingzhou is definitely a place that cannot be lost, but such a military important place was lost because of Guan Yu's arrogance, how could Liu Bei not cry bitterly. <>

    Anyone who has read "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" should know that Liu Bei, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei have been inseparable since the "Taoyuan Rebellion", and with the passage of time, the relationship between the three can be said to be getting better and betterIn order to show his trust in them, Liu Bei gave Guan Yu such a military important place as Jingzhou, but the good times did not last long, due to Guan Yu's carelessness, Jingzhou was finally lost, and even Guan Yu died on the battlefield.

    When Liu Bei heard the news, he fainted on the spot, and after waking up, he cried bitterlyAt this time, Liu Guan and Zhang were left with only Liu Bei and Zhang Fei, but those who have read "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" should know that although Zhang Fei is very brave, he has a fatal problem, that is, he likes to beat and scold his subordinates, and it is precisely because of this problem that his subordinates killed him while he was asleep. <>

    And Liu Bei actually knew about Zhang Fei's bad problem all along, and he knew a long time ago that there would definitely be such a result, so he was mentally prepared for it a long time agoTherefore, when the news of Zhang Fei's death came, Liu Bei was not very sad, but just ordered the soldiers to bury Zhang Fei. <>

    To sum up, it is not difficult to see that friendship is of course very important to Liu Bei, but in Liu Bei's heart, Jiangshan is more important than his brotherIt is because of this that Liu Bei will cry bitterly when Guan Yu dies, but Zhang Fei does not have such treatment.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    Because of Guan Yu's death, Liu Bei lost Jingzhou, which was originally held tightly in his hand, and Liu Bei cried Guan Yu even more to cry the world he lost. As for Zhang Fei, Liu Bei understands his temperament, so he has a certain amount of mental preparation.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    Guan Yu is brave and resourceful in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, and Zhang Fei is always causing trouble, Liu Bei naturally likes Guan Yu a little more, Guan Yu was already dead before Zhang Fei died, Liu Bei had a feeling of breaking the jar at this time.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Liu Bei had a strong premonition before Zhang Fei's death, and Liu Bei was also very sorry when Zhang Fei died, but what he wanted more was to avenge his younger brothers, so he was not too sad.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Because I am afraid that the relationship will continue to be outside the play, it will only increase sadness and sadness.

    On November 1, Lu Shuming, who played "Guan Yu" in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", died of a sudden heart attack at the age of 66. 24 days later, Li Jingfei, the teacher of "Zhang Fei" in the play, also passed away, and he was 65 years old. I don't know if it is destined in the dark, the scene of the two leaving is really staged in the play, and countless netizens fell into grief for the departure of the two.

    A fan has recovered this classic. Guan Yu and Zhang Fei interpreted by the two are also insurmountable classics in many versions, and the two have brought such good works under the tribute.

    Sun Yanjun delivered a eulogyThe sudden departure of the two left many of the actors who starred in the play together. Among them, everyone is most concerned about Sun Yanjun who plays "Liu Bei", the three of them are sworn brothers in the play, and the relationship continues outside the play, after Li Jingfei's death, Sun Yanjun also delivered a eulogy. Sun Yanjun exposed the ** of the two many years ago, and wrote this in sadness.

    I don't believe that the premonition will come true, Brother Jing Fei is gone, I can no longer say that Oak is speechless at this time, for heaven to have no pain, Brother Jing Fei went all the way.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Liu Bei said at the time: "Oh, fly to death." Compared with the scene of Liu Bei crying after Guan Yu's death, Zhang Fei's death Liu Bei's performance is indeed too calm, but it does not mean that Zhang Fei's status in Liu Bei's heart is not important, there are actually many details in this, and listen to me slowly.

    Liu Bei really cares about Zhang Fei very much, but Zhang Fei's status in his heart is not as good as Guan Yu. Liu Bei, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei were indeed higher than the sky when they worshipped, but the identities of the three were not equal, Liu Bei, as the eldest brother, was also their lord, so naturally Zhang Fei and Guan Yu were more dedicated to him. But Zhang Fei's intelligence and strategy are not as good as Guan Yu's, so Guan Yu's status in Liu Bei's heart is naturally much higher.

    Guan Yu's death meant a great defeat for Jingzhou. Liu Bei will cry bitterly for Guan Yu, not only because Guan Yu is his second brother and occupies an important place in his heart, but more importantly, because dying means losing Jingzhou. This was bad news for Liu Bei at that time, not only lost his very important general, but also lost the most important city, Liu Bei was heartbroken at that time, so he cried.

    This is to lament the misfortune of his brother and his lost city and country.

    When Zhang Fei died, Liu Bei was already heartbroken, and he no longer had too many words and expressions. The death of Guan Yu itself was a heavy blow to Liu Bei, and now that Zhang Fei has died, and he will not be able to take Jingzhou, this is a multiple blow to Liu Bei, and for Liu Bei at that time, he was helpless and painful in the face of such a situation. So Zhang Fei died, and Liu Bei was already numb, so he realized that he had said four words.

    Taoyuan's three knots are a good story, and the three brothers are ultimately separated by yin and yang, and it is a pity that Liu Bei's great career has not been completed.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    He just said, "Oh, fly to death." Because Zhang Fei's character is there, Liu Bei is also mentally prepared for his death. Moreover, Guan Yu's status in Liu Bei's heart is higher than that of Zhang Fei.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    The main reason is that Guan Yu's death directly led to the loss of his own land and put him in a more passive situation, and Zhang Fei deserved it.

  9. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Because Liu Bei was mentally prepared, they were deeply affectionate in Taoyuan, and after Guan Yu's death, he knew that Zhang Fei would avenge him, so Zhang Fei's death was also expected by him.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Guan Yu and Zhang Fei are both Liu Bei's humerus brothers, who have lived and died together for many years. When the bad news of the death of the two of them reached Liu Bei, Liu Bei was equally grief-stricken

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Liu Bei, as the eldest brother and their lord, naturally Zhang Fei and Guan Yu were more dedicated to him. But Zhang Fei's intelligence and strategy are not as good as Guan Yu's.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Guan Yu and Zhang Fei are both Liu Bei's sworn brothers, and when Guan Yu died, it was like the sky falling, and he was too frightened.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Sleep in the same bed, Enruo brothers. This is the description of the relationship between Liu Bei, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei after Liu Bei, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei became brothers in "Three Kingdoms". Later, Liu Bei began to revolt and conquer the Quartet, but it was very unfortunate that Liu Bei struggled for more than 20 years before he could get a little better and have his own base.

    And over the years, the two brothers Guan Yu and Zhang Fei, no matter what kind of situation they encountered, they never gave up. has always followed the eldest brother Liu Bei, which can be described as a model of both loyalty and righteousness.

    During the expansion period of Liu Bei's career, when he was aggressive in Yizhou, Liu Bei directly handed over the strategic Jingzhou to Guan Yu to be responsible, in addition to Guan Yu's strength, the most important thing is the trust of so many years of brotherly feelings. However, due to Guan Yu's arrogance, he lost Jingzhou and lost his life. When Liu Bei got the news of Guan Yu's death for the first time, he was so sad that he hugged his head and cried.

    From here, it is enough to see that Liu Bei has a deep love for Guan Yu's brotherhood, and has long regarded him as a real relative.

    After Guan Yu's death, only the third brother Zhang Fei was left at this time, although Zhang Fei was brave but did not know how to sympathize with the soldiers, and often whipped the soldiers who made mistakes. Therefore, the root cause was laid, and his subordinates Zhang Da and others took the opportunity to kill Zhang Fei and defected to Sun Quan. When the news of Zhang Fei's tragic death was sent to Liu Bei, Liu Bei frowned, then sighed softly, and only said four words on the spot:

    Belch! Fly to death. It seems that for Liu Bei, it's not a big deal, and it's not sad and sad at all.

    Why is there such a big gap in Liu Bei's reaction to the deaths of Guan Yu and Zhang Fei?

    In fact, it is very simple, first of all, Guan Yu's death means the loss of a powerful general, you must know that Cao Cao in order to entrap Guan Yu, but he made a lot of money back then, and tried everything but still couldn't impress him. Moreover, Jingzhou is a strategic place for Liu Bei, and it was suddenly lost like this, which was difficult to accept for a while. Therefore, Liu Bei is not only crying about Guan Yu's death, but also the most important thing he is crying about the lost Jingzhou, which is his lifeblood and the future of Shu Han.

    On the other hand, although Zhang Fei is brave, his comprehensive ability is much inferior to Guan Yu. Zhang Fei has a reckless temperament, he has no martial arts but no strategy, Liu Bei actually knows in his heart that if he continues like this, he will get into trouble sooner or later, plus Zhang Fei is already old at this time, and his combat effectiveness is far less than before. Therefore, when Liu Bei heard the news of Zhang Fei's death, it was not surprising that his performance was flat.

    After all, Liu Bei is no longer the young man who sells straw sandals, perhaps at that time, love was the most important thing for him. But when he was in charge of the entire Shu Han, for him, what he wanted most at this time was the country, which was his lifelong dream!

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    Because Guan Yu was killed, it meant that Liu Bei lost Jingzhou, and it was difficult to complete the important task of reviving the Han Dynasty, so he cried, and Zhang Fei's death was caused by beating and scolding his subordinates, Liu Bei felt that what Zhang Fei did was indeed wrong, so he reacted to the grief when Guan Yu died.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    When Guan Yu died, he lost Jingzhou and lost tens of thousands of soldiers, which greatly reduced the strength of Shu. And when Zhang Fei died, he was killed by his own men, and he didn't lose anything. And with the blow of Guan Yu's death, Liu Bei looked down on Zhang Fei's death.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    Because Guan Yu was killed, Jingzhou was divided between Sun Wu and Cao Wei, which greatly reduced the strength of Shu Han; And Zhang Fei was killed, Liu Bei had already expected it.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    1. Guan Yu's death is related to the loss of Jingzhou.

    Second, Zhang Fei's death, he had expected Zhang Feiqin's death, but he had expected it, in this case, his murder, Liu Bei had already been psychologically prepared, and accepted it.

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    Because the status of the two brothers in Liu Bei's mind is completely different, Liu Zhusheng really regards Guan Yu's brothers, and Zhang Fei is just a pawn to Liu Bei.

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    Feelings aside, Guan Yu is a "wise general", brave and strategic, famous, and of great help to Shu Han. In contrast, Zhang Fei is at most a tiger general, and his help to Shu Han is yes but not greater.

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    Because Zhang Fei and Guan Yu have different positions in Liu Bei's mind, Guan Yu is a person that Liu Bei treats as a brother, while Zhang Fei is just a pawn used by Liu Bei.

  21. Anonymous users2024-01-20

    Because Guan Yu's death was unexpected by him, Zhang Fei's death, he had already guessed it.

  22. Anonymous users2024-01-19

    Liu Bei's circumstances were different when the two died. When Guan Yu died, Liu Bei was attacking Jingzhou, and losing Guan Yu was equivalent to losing Jingzhou, and when Zhang Fei died, Liu Bei was about to crusade against Eastern Wu, so naturally he didn't have much time to grieve for this.

  23. Anonymous users2024-01-18

    Liu Bei's two performances are very normal in the author's opinion, and there is no meaning of favoritism. As for the reason, there is only one reason: the situation is different, and Liu Bei's handling is naturally different.

  24. Anonymous users2024-01-17

    Guan Yu rode thousands of miles to rescue his sister-in-law and expressed his loyalty, but Zhang Fei really didn't do anything. There is also the fact that Guan Yu died, Liu Bei was heartbroken and didn't want to live. No matter how much Zhang Fei died, he just added more fire.

  25. Anonymous users2024-01-16

    Guan Yu is loyal and wise most of the time, and has been attacking cities and plundering land with him since he was worshipping, so Liu Bei cherishes him very much, and Zhang Fei is a reckless man most of the time, so Liu Bei can only acquiesce to his lower body.

Related questions
15 answers2024-05-06

Dynasty Warriors, is a series of games, and now it is out of Dynasty Warriors 5.

16 answers2024-05-06

Chinese historical records basically do not record the weight, you have to know this, so it is impossible for you to know the real answer, you can only estimate that his height is about 2 meters, the accurate point is more than 190, not more than 210, Lu Bu is only more than 210. And as generals who rush into battle, their bodies should be strong, not fat or too thin. So you can get a rough idea of how much weight you have when you compare an NBA star of similar height.

25 answers2024-05-06

Not necessarily, Guan Yu has always been loyal, if Liu Bei died at that time, I think Guan Yu would find out who killed Liu Bei and cut himself after avenging Liu Bei.

13 answers2024-05-06

It was by chance that Liu Bei met the two of them by chance, and finally got help from the two.

11 answers2024-05-06

Absolutely responsible! And the responsibility is not small! From the loss of Guan Yu Jingzhou to the defeat of Maicheng, for a long time, Zhuge Liang and Liu Bei must have known about this matter, it stands to reason that they should express it to Sun Quan, or send reinforcements to help Guan Yu, you must know that Liu Bei's army, which was closest to Guan Yu at that time, was only less than half a day's journey Zhuge Liang obviously knew that Liu Feng and Guan Yu had a gap! >>>More