Guan Yu is obviously both civil and military, and he is better than Zhang Fei, why does Zhuge Liang

Updated on history 2024-05-07
30 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-09

    Zhang Fei and Guan Yu are both capable generals, but Zhuge Liang is closer to Zhang Fei, mainly because Guan Yu is not as easy to get along with as Zhang Fei.

    Guan Yu treats his soldiers very well, but when he gets along with the scholars, he scoffs, that is, he looks down on civilian officials. Zhuge Liang is a proper god operator and a clerical worker, so when working with Guan Yu, there are always some unsatisfactory results. And Zhang Fei is different, Zhang Fei is very respectful of gentlemen, so Zhuge Liang is quite harmonious when he gets along with Zhang Fei.

    Moreover, Guan Yu is very conceited about his ability, he feels that he is very powerful, and he starts fighting if he doesn't agree with him. At that time, after Ma Chao defected to Shu, he made a great contribution to the recovery of Yizhou, and Liu Bei gave Ma Chao various rewards. At this time, Guan Yu was not convinced, picked up the knife and prepared to PK with Ma Chao, and finally Zhuge Liang praised him before calming down the unwillingness in his heart.

    Therefore, sometimes it is quite tiring to get along with people like Guan Yu.

    Moreover, Guan Yu is very wary of Zhuge LiangAt the beginning, Liu Bei's three visits to the thatched house had already made Guan Yu very wary of Zhuge Liang. Originally, Liu Bei valued Guan Yu and Zhang Fei very much, and the three even became brothers, but as soon as Zhuge Liang came, Liu Bei spent most of his energy on Zhuge Liang, and Guan Yu felt that his status was snatched away by Zhuge Liang, so he didn't like Zhuge Liang very much.

    But Zhang Fei is different, he respects Zhuge Liang very much, and he also listens to Zhuge Liang's words, let him do whatever he wants, and after the thing is done, he does not forget to praise Zhuge Liang's clever calculations, and slightly satisfy Zhuge Liang's vanity. Therefore, compared with Guan Yu, Zhuge Liang and Zhang Fei get along better, so Zhuge Liang will be more important to Zhang Fei.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    The problem is very simple, it is because Guan Yu is both civil and military. No matter what you do, you will have an idea of your own. So Zhuge Liang generally doesn't use this kind of person too much.

    Because sometimes being too thoughtful can be bad. On the contrary, Zhang Fei's words are superb in martial arts, but Lao Tzu is not enough, but he is very obedient, and sometimes the things given to him will be completed from the beginning, so Zhuge Liang will definitely reuse Zhang Fei but alienate Guan Yu.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    We all know that Zhang Fei has a problem that he abuses his subordinates and is not very good to the people under him, while Guan Yu knows how to treat soldiers well. On the contrary, Zhang Fei will be very respectful of gentlemen like Zhuge Liang, and Guan Yu will put on a certain posture.

    This led to Zhuge Liang being very careful about proportionality when dealing with Guan Yu, and he also worked very hard to maintain a polite and good relationship. Because Guan Yu is very obsessed with his own ability, he feels that he is very strong, so he will not buy the account of the military advisor. If Guan Yu heard others say that whoever is very capable will not be convinced, and he will never put his position right.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Officially, because Guan Yu was both civil and military, he let him guard Jingzhou! It's reuse!

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Friends who have watched "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" know that the author has a very high evaluation of Guan Yu, and under the coronation of the emperors of the past dynasties, Guan Erye has been named a martial saint, and he is almost the only person in history who can compare with Confucius. However, Guan Yu was far from being so proud when he was alive, at least Zhuge Liang's shed was more exclusive to him, and he deliberately did not use Guan Yu and Zhang Fei in the first battle of Bowangpo that he commanded out of the mountain.

    Even with the benefit of hindsight, he tried his best to remain alienated from Guan Yu, but he trusted Zhang Fei, so there was such an evaluation in "Three Kingdoms"."Yu is kind to the soldiers and proud of the scholars, and Fei loves and respects the gentleman but not the villain"。In other words, people like Guan Yu are too arrogant, although they can share weal and woe with the soldiers, they look down on literati and doctors. On the contrary, Zhang Fei recognized the scholars and doctors, and even admired Zhuge Liang very much, reaching the point of obeying his words.

    Of course, this does not mean that Zhang Fei is stupider than Guan Yu, on the contrary, Zhang Fei is much smarter. Because of the influence of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", most people think that Zhang Fei is a reckless man with a black mouth and a black face, but in history, Zhang Fei is a handsome little white face, and he is not a rude person at all. Zhang Fei not only has elegant calligraphy in history, but is also good at painting beauties, if it is not for the courage of battle, it is difficult for people to believe that he is a military general.

    Moreover, Zhang Fei's ability to command operations is also very strong, according to the water broken bridge, it is not only brave, but also wisdom, he used Cao Cao's suspicion to scare him into not daring to cross the river. The later interpretation of Yan Liang and the big defeat of Zhang He all proved his ability to lead the army into battle, and he was a veritable enemy of 10,000 people! After the Battle of Chibi, Zhou Yu deliberately lent Zhang Fei from Liu Bei to help him attack Nanjun, which he thought afterwards"Zhang Fei is the general of the tiger and bear"。

    And Guo Jia's evaluation of Zhang Fei was even higher, even in front of Guan Yu, he said in front of Cao Cao:"Zhang Fei and Guan Yu are all enemies! "Seeing this, is there a feeling of sudden enlightenment, no wonder Zhuge Liang trusts Zhang Fei and rejects Guan Yu, personality is one aspect, and Zhang Fei is better than Guan Yu in terms of ability.

    It's just that Guan Yu's friendship is too heavy to ride alone, which confuses the eyes of the world, so he always likes to rank him in front, and in the end, it's just because of his feelings. If you had to choose, would you like Guan Yu or Zhang Fei?

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    I think Zhang Fei is smarter, Zhang Fei has always given people the feeling of being reckless, but it does not mean that he is not smart, and he often uses some tricks to turn defeat into victory in battle.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    Personally, I think Guan Yu is smarter, because Guan Yu knows to be good to his subordinates, unlike Zhang Fei, who was killed by his subordinates.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    I think Guan Yu is smarter than Zhang Fei, Guan Yu is too arrogant, offends people every day, and he doesn't look like a smart person.

  9. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Lu Bu can be called the first tiger general during the Three Kingdoms period, so his force is definitely very strong. In the Three Kingdoms, Liu Bei, Zhang Fei and Guan Yu joined forces to make a draw with Lu Bu. As for why Zhang Fei dared to fight Lu Bu alone, but Guan Yu couldn't, I think there should be the following reasons.

    First of all, Zhang Fei is a reckless man, he doesn't think too much about doing things, he can do whatever he wants, when the three brothers went to save Dong Zhuo, because Dong Zhuo didn't give Liu Bei face, Zhang Fei raised a knife to kill Dong Zhuo. Therefore, Zhang Fei is a person who does things without thinking through his brain, and when he heard that Lu Bu was the number one fierce general, he must have been unconvinced in his heart, so he dared to go up directly and fight him, and he had to prove that he was the most powerful. The martial arts gap between them is actually not particularly large, so Zhang Fei was able to walk dozens of rounds in Lu Bu's hands.

    Secondly, Guan Yu is a relatively rational person, so he will not be particularly reckless in going head-to-head with Lu Bu. As for the reason why the three brothers were able to draw with Lu Bu, I don't think Lu Bu is particularly strong, and the three of them should lack some cooperation. Zhang Fei and Guan Yu's force value is actually not much different, and on the other hand, it should be that Lu Bu and Liu Bei were in a cooperative relationship at that time, and he didn't dare to beat Zhang Fei too badly.

    In the end, Zhang Fei relied on his own brute strength to break out of the title of ten thousand enemies. His image is like a horse boy under Liu Bei, mainly used for fighting, of course, Zhang Fei is also the kind of person who is not afraid of things, Guan Yu will think a little more, and he will try to avoid going head-to-head with Lu Bu. There is not much to say about whether they can go head-to-head, their martial arts level is not about the same.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Referring to Guan Yu's killing of Hua Xiong, it can be seen that it is not that Guan Yu does not dare to fight with Lu Bu, but the time is not yet ripe, it can be said that if Zhang Fei does not go to Lu Bu, Guan Yu will definitely go when he sees that no one dares to go, only when he sees what others dare not do, he will do it himself, and if he does it well, he will make others feel that he is awesome, just like if Guan Yu is the first to stand up and cut Hua Xiong in a few rounds, will anyone think Guan Yu is awesome? No, it's a truth compared to Lu Bu. But to be honest, if Guan Yu was one step ahead of Zhang Fei to fight Lu Bu, Lu Bu would definitely cause more trouble, but the ending would definitely be the same, the three brothers beat Lu Bu away, and it was impossible for Guan Yu and Zhang Fei to slaughter Lu Bu in Liu Bei's eyes.

    It can also be seen from the back that it was beneficial for Liu Bei for Lu Bu to be alive at that time.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Why didn't Guan Yu dare to single out Lu Bu, and Zhang Fei was not afraid of Lu Bu alone?

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    The story of Guan Yu's flooding of the Seventh Army has made him pass down through the ages, and Zhang Fei was singled out with Lu Bu at the beginning, because Zhang Fei is a martial artist, but he is bold, and Guan Yu thinks more.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    I think Zhang Feilai is more reckless, although his strength is insufficient, but he dares to challenge. Guan Yu came to be elegant and introverted. I don't think it's that Guan Yu didn't dare to go it alone, but that Zhang Fei didn't give him a chance.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    Zhang Fei's martial arts at that time were higher than Guan Yu's, coupled with Zhang Fei's recklessness, it was just right for a talent like Lu Bu to learn from each other, so Zhang Fei's character laid the foundation for this matter.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    Zhang Fei's personality is reckless if it doesn't sound good, so many times he is just short-tempered and rushes directly, just going head-to-head with Lu Bu, but Guan Yu is relatively calm, he won't rush directly.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    I think this has something to do with the courage of the two people, it should be that Zhang Fei is more courageous, more reckless, and reckless, so Zhang Fei dares to challenge Lu Bu.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    Because Zhang Fei is more reckless, he can do whatever he wants, and he won't think about it so much, so he dares to challenge Lu Bu, but Guan Yu is not such a character, so of course he doesn't dare.

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    I think Zhang Fei challenged Lu Bu alone, there must be his strength, although Guan Yu is stronger than Zhang Fei's strength, but it has a certain idea, so he didn't go to fight Lu Bu alone at that time.

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    Zhang Fei didn't dare to do anything Besides, Zhang Fei was extremely disgusted with the behavior of Lu Bu's three domestic slaves.

    Guan Yu doesn't fight uncertain battles.

    After all, Lu Bu is too famous.

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    In my opinion, Guan Yu didn't dare to single out Lu Bu, but he would think about the problem a little more, and Zhang Fei would show no scheming more often, very direct, and would not think about the consequences at all.

  21. Anonymous users2024-01-20

    Have you ever had a chance to go heads-up? Guan yu? There is always one person rushing out.

    Even if you don't dare, it is estimated that the overall situation is the most important. In case Guan Yu died, the dragons would be leaderless and the whole army would be annihilated. Wasn't it like that in ancient times? There is no commander.

    Fighting, attacking, retreating, normal, and not impulsive. After passing five levels and killing six generals, Guan Yu didn't worry about the other party preparing a master to come out.

  22. Anonymous users2024-01-19

    Zhang Fei singled out Lu Bu once in the Tiger Prison because he saved Gongsun Zhan, this will not be said again, the second heads-up was to grab the horse and follow-up, and Guan Yu did not appear in the whole process. Later, Guan Yu met Lu Bu twice alone and with Zhang Fei, which time did he not dare to step forward?

  23. Anonymous users2024-01-18

    Not fighting does not mean that there is no strength, from Guan Yu Dou Huaxiong, it can be seen that not anyone can charge into battle, at that time, Guan Yu Zhang Fei's status was very low, and he could not be qualified to play if he had the strength, Zhang Fei's ability to fight Lu Bu was determined by Zhang Fei's character.

  24. Anonymous users2024-01-17

    Does it have anything to do with whether you dare or not? Guan Yu and Lu Bu have no enmity, but Zhang Fei wants to compete with Lu Bu!

  25. Anonymous users2024-01-16

    Where did Guan Yu not dare? According to the romance, Guan Yu has already killed Hua Xiong, and this time it was Zhang Fei's turn to show it. Lao Luo originally expressed Sanying, but he didn't think that later readers would mistakenly think that Lu Bu was invincible in the world.

  26. Anonymous users2024-01-15

    Because Guan Yu's platinum level is self-aware, Lu Bu is diamond and I are not at the same level; Zhang Fei has no brains, and he can't beat it.

  27. Anonymous users2024-01-14

    As we all know, although Zhang Fei has good strength, he is a reckless man, and he only thinks about things according to his mood, but Guan Yu is different, he knows that he and Lu Bu are going to fight for nothing, so he doesn't go head-to-head.

  28. Anonymous users2024-01-13

    He Yu Liubei is the same Meng Guan Yu is not stupid to kill him, Cao Cao came to the meritorious soldiers, Jiang is not enough, brother three guards four gates!

  29. Anonymous users2024-01-12

    Guan Yu despised intellectuals and valued his subordinates, and Zhang Fei happened to be the opposite of Guan Yu. So it should be that Guan Yu was dissatisfied with Zhuge Liang at the beginning, but because of Liu Bei, he didn't have a seizure, and there should be no friction between Zhang Fei and Zhuge Liang.

  30. Anonymous users2024-01-11

    Guan Yu and Zhang Fei were very dissatisfied with Zhuge Liang at first, because they felt that Zhuge Liang was too big, and they asked Liu Bei to invite him three times before they were willing to go out of the mountain, and they were very unhappy when they saw that Liu Bei respected him so much, so they were very unhappy.

    Think about it, Zhuge Liang looked like that at the beginning, it is estimated that many people are unhappy, no one knows if he really has talent and strategy, in case it is a lie, right. Moreover, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei originally felt that their martial arts were strong, and they were not convinced by anyone except Liu Bei. Zhang Fei is a little better, at most he is babbling, he can't get used to Zhuge Liang putting on music like this, and he thinks that he underestimated his brother, so he can't be angry.

    As for Guan Yu, he has always been a relatively arrogant person, he feels that his martial arts are invincible in the world, and he has hardly put anyone in his eyes, Kong Ming is just a strategist for him, and he is also a strategist who has not been out of the mountain, and no one knows if he is really a powerful strategist, so his dissatisfaction with Kong Ming is directly manifested on the surface, even if Kong Ming later went down the mountain with them, he also looked down on Kong Ming.

    But this was all their performance at the beginning, and later after Kong Ming showed his strength, they were stunned, and they were already impressed by Kong Ming's clever calculations, Zhang Fei saw Kong Ming and Liu Bei was the same, but Guan Yu was still relatively cold, but he has always been like this, and he has never been very kind to anyone.

Related questions