The girl 12 year old secretly walked the dog to death and killed the octogenarian lady, and no one t

There must be responsibility, minors go to walk the dog without supervision, this is the supervision of the child's education, they did not teach the child how to behave, so let the child go out to walk the dog.

Of course, as the saying goes: the son pays the debt to the father, and the minor child does something wrong, and it must be the guardian who bears the main responsibility, which is beyond doubt.

Yes, the girl is still a minor, so his guardian is responsible, and at the same time, the relevant departments should also educate the girl so that she is aware of her mistakes, and be more vigilant to the people, and pay more attention when walking the dog.

Yes, if the guardian fails to take good care of the accident and causes the accident, he should bear the main responsibility for the case.

Personally, I think that in this case, the guardian should be responsible. Because minors need guardianship from their guardians.

Yes. The girl is not an adult, and the guardian should be responsible for the compensation for the damage caused by the girl walking the dog.

As long as a pet injures a person, the actor who has a causal relationship with the result of the damage in law, regardless of whether he is at fault, must bear the tort liability for compensation. The victim can choose to sue the dog owner or they can choose to sue the perpetrator. Since the girl is a minor, the girl's guardian may be held liable.

Since the girl involved is a minor, the civil liability that she needs to bear is also borne by her guardian.

You have to take responsibility. The little girl did not have the ability to control the dog, but the guardian handed the dog to her, which is also a sign of failure to do a good job of education.

Logically speaking, it is responsible, the guardian did not do a good job of safety measures, and did not educate the child, which led to such a heart-wrenching result, which no one wants to see.

The guardian has the primary responsibility. Because the child is only 12 years old, he cannot bear criminal responsibility, only the guardian is responsible.

Of course, you have to take the main responsibility. If it is an adult, then it is your own responsibility, but unfortunately you are not an adult, so you can't be sentenced, so you can only let the guardian compensate.

It must be responsible, first of all, let minors walk their dogs, causing potential safety hazards, and then the death of the elderly is also because of the dog, not getting the leash, these responsibilities are the main guardians need to bear.

Yes, the girl is a minor, but her actions are close to the crime of negligent death. Although it is not, there is no escape from civil liability, and the family will definitely be held responsible.

I think it is necessary, my country's law stipulates that if a minor commits a crime, the guardian must bear a certain amount of compensation.

1. The main responsibility of raising dogs!

2. What do children know? The child's guardian is responsible!

I think the responsibility of the girl is greater, after all, the dog owner is more wronged, and his dog is stolen, and he has to bear some responsibility after hurting someone.

I think the responsibility of the girl is greater, after all, such behavior is illegal, and the dog owner is not involved.

Girl. Even if the dog is a neighbor's, but after all, it is because the girl did not pay attention to it, causing the old man to trip, and the girl must be more responsible.

Both parties were responsible, but the dog owner was bigger and didn't take good care of his own dog. And girls also have a responsibility not to walk the dog without the consent of others.

In my opinion, it should be a girl, because it was the girl who did not keep the dog on a leash, and the owner of the dog had kept the dog on a leash in the yard before.

You can make a claim, even if it is not criminal liability, there is also civil liability, if it is because of her young age, then find her guardian, and the point is that the dog is not her own, which means that the dog owner is also jointly and severally liable.

It should be possible, after all, this is a human life, people sit at home, and disaster comes from heaven, this is the consequence of that girl not dealing with it well, and such a situation cannot be irresponsible at all.

Although this incident is an accidental death, except for the grandmother, all the participants have civil liability, although the little girl is a minor, but her guardian has to bear the responsibility, and she can definitely claim compensation.

I think it's okay, although it was the girl's unintentional behavior, but it caused the death of the old man, and she should bear a certain amount of expenses.

I think it should be claimed, the girl found that the tripped old lady, did not want to go to the police to deal with it at the first time, so she walked away silently, and personally felt that she was escaping.

Responsible, to be responsible for civil liability, the 12-year-old girl walked someone else's dog, but she was also negligent.

Of course, the girl is responsible, because the girl is only 12 years old and cannot be responsible, so the responsibility of her guardian must be added, because the first thing the girl thought about at the time of the incident was not to save people, but to escape

I think it's responsible, because a 12-year-old girl took a big dog that weighed dozens of pounds heavier than him to walk around the corner, but she didn't think that if an accident happened, she was completely incapable of stopping the big dog from hurting others.

Regardless of whether there is responsibility for tripping or not, walking away indifferently after tripping is the same as a car hitting someone and escaping, I think this is responsible.

The 12-year-old girl did not hold the dog leash, causing the dog leash to fall down and the old man to death. It's also too young, no experience, and frightened.

Responsible, this is their own dog, the girl did not watch and let the dog leash trip the old man, this must be responsible.

An 88-year-old man in Foshan tripped over a dog leash and died, judged to be an accident, and the 12-year-old girl who stole the dog needs to be responsible, because she did not take care of the puppy, and then made the old man fall to death, with the most direct responsibility!

I feel that even in this case, the 12-year-old girl should be held responsible. You have to pay for your mistakes.

Yes, 12-year-old girls do not have the capacity to take responsibility, but their guardians are responsible.

(The old lady who tripped over a dog leash).

On the evening of August 18, 2020, Xingtan Town, Shunde District, Foshan City, reported on the incident of a dog breaking free from a restraint rope and tripping an octogenarian

At 17:21 on August 17, 110 received a report: An elderly man near Luoshui Market, Xingtan Town, Shunde District, was injured and fell to the ground. After receiving the report, the police and medical personnel quickly rushed to the scene to deal with it.

After investigation, Luoshui villager Luo (female, 12 years old) took out another villager Luo's dog tied to the door of the house to play, and when passing through Luoshui Market, the dog broke free from the restraint rope, and the dog rope accidentally tripped over the villager Mai (female, 88 years old) during the run, resulting in Mai's injury and death after being sent to the hospital for treatment. The incident was preliminarily judged to be an accident. At present, the aftermath of the incident is being carried out in an orderly manner.

In the next stage, the relevant departments of Xingtan Town and the villages (residents) will further strengthen the management of dog breeding, and strengthen publicity and education.

This trip, the old man was never able to get up on his own)

And in the process of running wildly, the long dog leash caused the grandmother to fall face to the ground, bleeding from the head, and finally died after ineffective treatment.

The old man was bleeding from his head after tripping, and the rescue was ineffective).

Judging from the surveillance, when the incident happened, she did not directly see that it was the dog leash that tripped the old lady. When she ran over, the old lady was leaning over and falling to the ground, bleeding from the head, any little girl would be scared when she saw the old lady donating blood in one place, and she was only 12 years old, even if she looked at it a few more times at this time, what could she do?

The girl was criticized for "seeing death and not saving" and turned around and left).

Isn't it normal for a girl to go to her parents and tell them what happened so that they can see how to deal with it?

As for whether the dog was secretly taken away by her, there are too many rumors on the Internet to be believed, but we who don't know the truth, blindly accusing and abusing this girl will not bring the dead old lady back to life, but may bring more bad effects to the living people.

So as the old lady's family said, let them deal with this matter quietly, don't give them too much attention, and don't put too much pressure on the girl.

The old man was tripped and the little girl was afraid of being held accountable, which was definitely not a normal behavior. Many people think that the little girl Luo is only 12 years old, and she was frightened when she saw the old man fall. Don't even choose to run awayAlthough there was no criminal responsibility, it was she who tripped the old man on a leash while walking her dog.

The guardian must be responsible for compensation, and at the age of 12, she already has basic judgment ability, but whenever she asks passers-by to call an ambulance. Hopefully, the old man will be able to be rescued in time.

01. Review of the old man who tripped over the incident Near Luoshui Market, Shunde District, Guangdong, two pet dogs ran around the street, with a leash around their necks. It just so happened that this leash tripped over an old man passing by, causing the old man to fall to the ground and die. These two pet dogs belong to large and medium-sized dogs, and the 12-year-old girl secretly took other people's dogs out to play.

It's just that I didn't control it well, and the strength of a medium-sized dog is not something that a child can pull. As a result, the 88-year-old man was implicated and tripped and landed on his face. In addition, the little girl did not call 120 in time for rescue, and the old man missed the rescue opportunity and died.

The owner of the pet dog also said afterwards that his dog was usually tethered to a tree, and it was the little girl Luo who secretly took it away.

02. The old man tripped over the leash. Some people think that the little girl doesn't know about this, I don't agree with this, after the old man tripped over the leash, Luo was running faster and faster. It can be seen from the surveillance ** that she saw the old man fall to the ground and paused.

Then passers-by suspected that her dog had tripped the old man, and she chose to flee the scene. I don't believe it at all if she didn't know that her dog tripped the old man, she wouldn't have paused and ran back. Even when passers-by pointed out, they ran faster and faster, obviously knowing that they were in trouble.

But she didn't know how to deal with it, and finally panicked and chose to run away, and at the age of 12, encountering this situation was beyond her acceptance.

03. According to people familiar with the matter, the little girl's family is not a good family, according to the same villagers, the little girl and her younger brother are habitual thieves, and they often enter the juvenile detention center for stealing things, and their parents rarely care about them. That's why they caused trouble everywhere, and this time it caused a big problem, and the family that was not rich in the first place also caused deaths, which made it even worse. Although this little girl is exempt from criminal responsibility, she still has to be disciplined, otherwise it will be difficult to guarantee that she will not cause a catastrophe next time.

04. The incident was judged to be an accident, and the guardian had to bear civil compensation for the elderly who tripped and died. However, as a guardian, you have to bear civil compensation. Now the family of the old man has negotiated and communicated with the family of the little girl, and has promised not to hold the girl responsible, after all, it is a 12-year-old girl, and she cannot be sued in court.

It is impossible for a 12-year-old to bear criminal responsibility, and as long as the family of the little girl can come forward to apologize and compensate, the family of the old man will not bite the tongue. It's just that after this incident, the little girl really had to discipline her well, obviously knowing that the old man was tripped, and chose to run away and pretend not to know.

Abnormal. A twelve-year-old girl, under normal circumstances, should take appropriate measures to save the elderly in time after knocking down the elderly, such as first aid**, asking for help from people around her, etc., but the girl ran away, and even the girl had no intention of repenting afterwards.

I think it's not normal, and this little girl is responsible for her wrong actions, not running away. If the dog rope trips the elderly, you should help the elderly, what you support is morality, and it is the foundation of being a man. I think the little girl has to stand up and take the initiative to admit her mistakes.

This is not normal. Although she is only a minor girl, many years of school education have taught children to be helpful and responsible, and it is clear that the girl did not do it in this incident. Although she may be scared, she should also call 120 to save the old man, instead of running away.

The little girl explained that she didn't know that the old man was tripped by the dog's rope, she thought the old man was lying there, she said that she would run away quickly and also wanted to return the dog as soon as possible.

Yes, because 12-year-olds are not yet fully mature, it is normal to panic and be scared when encountering such a thing.