Yue Fei or Guan Yu Is the Martial Saint Yue Fei or Guan Yu?

I believe that from the perspective of historical facts, Yue Fei is a real national hero. He sacrificed his life and forgot to die, and fought bloody battles again and again, resisting the Jin Kou and recovering the lost territory. Yue Fei's patriotism is undoubted, and Guan Yu is heartfelt to Liu Bei in Luo Guanzhong's Three Kingdoms, and he is chivalrous and a character.

But this is only limited to the image in **, which is very different from history; Besides, even if Guan Yu is really that amazing, it's like"One non-cxy - trainee magician"At that time, Yue was fighting against foreign aggression, while Guan was an internal war among the people", Yue Fei can be said to be a national hero, but Guan cannot be regarded as a ---

- However, there is no doubt that the positive significance of Guan Yu's image in our real life is huge.

Yue Fei's life is a life of patriotism and loyalty. He sacrificed his life and forgot to die, and fought bloody battles again and again, just to resist Jin Kou and regain the lost territory. Yue Fei's patriotic heart is a pure heart shared by thousands of Chinese sons and daughters.

And Guan Yu is the first in the word "righteousness", and he is heartfelt to Liu Bei. Therefore, Yue Fei is a real national hero, and Guan Yu is a chivalrous righteous man.

It was Yue Fei, because he was fighting against foreign invasion at that time, and Guan Yu belonged to the people's internal war.

Yue Fei is a national hero of the Han nationality.

Guan Yu is the hero of Shu Han.

Yue Fei and Guan Yu can't be counted.

They did not resist aggression outside the Chinese nation.

Yue Fei, have you ever seen a history book that says Guan Yu as a national hero?

Yue Fei, because he resisted the Jin soldiers, was very heroic.

Don't believe those nonsense statements, the martial saint was originally Jiang Ziya, and it lasted until the end of the Yuan Dynasty and the beginning of the Ming Dynasty.

Zhu Yuanzhang thinks that Jiang Ziya is not worthy of being a martial saint, the reason is that Jiang Ziya is a businessman, originally an official in business, for his own future, he betrayed businessmen and joined Zhou, and also helped Zhou destroy his motherland, which is a traitor and a traitor, how can this kind of person be worthy of being a martial saint? If you want to do it, Guan Yu will do it, so Guan Yu gradually became the new martial saint.

You must know that Guan Yu is a figure in the Three Kingdoms period, and Yue Fei is a figure in the Southern Song Dynasty. At the beginning of the Ming Dynasty, Guan Yu's status was much higher than Yue Fei's.

Yue Fei became a martial saint during the Wanli period of the Ming Dynasty.

You must know that the Ming Dynasty has been fighting with the northern nomads, and Yue Fei is a representative of resisting the nomads, so Yue Zhenfei's status in the official head has improved rapidly, and finally in the Wanli period of the Ming Dynasty, he became a martial saint who can be ranked with Guan Yu. In other words, during the Wanli period of the Ming Dynasty, the officially canonized martial saints were Guan Yu and Yue Fei.

The reason why it is pointed out as official is because Guan Yu's status in the minds of the people at that time was still higher than Yue Fei.

The reason why the Qing Dynasty worshiped Guan Yu was because of the four famous books of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, at that time the Qing Dynasty did not have any military books, and the only thing that could have something to do with the war was the ** Romance of the Three Kingdoms at that time.

It can be said that the Qing army relied on watching the Romance of the Three Kingdoms to learn to fight a war to complete the unification. It is logical to respect Guan Yu.

If the Qing army did not watch the Romance of the Three Kingdoms at that time, but the ...... of Wu Mu's suicide note.

Therefore, the Martial Saint Trembling has never been Yue Fei who has become Guan Yu.

A person surnamed Yue in Taiwan often posts some articles, Douyin or something, saying that the Qing Dynasty changed Yue Fei's martial saint to Guan Yu.

Probably for the political needs of different periods.

Wusheng generally refers to Guan Yu (a famous general in the late Eastern Han Dynasty). After Guan Yu's death, the people respected him as Guan Gong, and there were many praises in the imperial courts of previous dynasties. During the Yongzheng period of the Qing Dynasty, he was honored as a "martial saint", which was equivalent to the status of "literary saint" Confucius.

In ** "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", he is ranked first among the "Five Tiger Generals" and uses the Qinglong Yanyue Knife. Mao Zonggang called it the "righteousness" among the three uniques of "Romance".

In the ** masterpiece "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", the author (Luo Guanzhong) portrayed Guan Yu as a loyal, righteous and brave, holding the image of a military general with a green dragon glaive knife, tall and powerful and extraordinary martial arts.

Guan Yu's grave siteThere are three Guan Yu tombs in China, one in Guan Lin, Luoyang City, Henan Province, Guan Yu Tomb in Guanzhuang Village, Dianzhuang Township, Yanshi County, Luoyang City, Henan Province, Guan Ling in Dangyang City, Hubei Province, and Guan Yu Tomb in Chengdu, Sichuan Province.

The Martial Saint is Guan Yu, not Yue Fei.

Yue Fei is even more powerful.

Reasons: 1. Yue Fei is a famous strategist, military strategist, national hero, and anti-gold general in the history of Chinese Lixiang. Yue Fei's military talent is known as the most outstanding military commander in the Song, Liao, Jin, and Western Xia periods.

Yue Fei is good at poetry and calligraphy, and his noble character and patriotic spirit have been admired and loved by the people of all generations, and he is respected as an outstanding martyr in China. At the same time, he is also one of the generals with the highest victory rate in the history of the world, and has a very high position in the history of Chinese military affairs.

2. Guan Yu is a famous general in the late Eastern Han Dynasty and the early Shu Han Dynasty, and has always been the object of folk sacrifice, and is respected as "Guan Gong", worshiped as a "martial saint", and is as famous as the "literary saint" Confucius; is also known as "Guan Fuzi"; In the end, he was named "Gaitian Ancient Buddha". In Buddhism, he is called "Garan Bodhisattva". "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" respects him as the head of the "Five Tiger Generals" of Shu Han.

He is extremely loyal and brave, and there are good stories such as slashing Huaxiong with warm wine, riding alone for thousands of miles, going to banquets with a single knife, and flooding the Seventh Army. But his character is arrogant, and there are also regrets such as carelessly losing Jingzhou and losing Maicheng.

Hey?!? Isn't Jin, who confronted the Southern Song Dynasty, surnamed Wanyan? Didn't the supreme ruler of the Qing Dynasty have the surname Aixin Jueluo?

When did these two have a relationship?! It's weird!

The premise of your argument is completely untenable!

And, in fact, Yue Fei is one of the most admired heroes of the Manchus to date. There is no such thing as being hacked.

If you really want to be black, there is only the marketing number that attracts people's attention today.

Guan Yu and Yue Fei are both martial saints.

Tang Dynasty, Tang Taizong Li Shimin respected Jiang Taigong as a martial saint, Tang Suzong period, the beginning of the martial temple, the clan oak posthumously sealed Jiang Taigong as the king of Wucheng, with Jiang Taigong as the main enshrinement, with the Yasheng ten philosophers seventy-two will be enjoyed, when Song Zhenzong, continue to add Jiang Taigong as the king of Zhaolie Wucheng, still with Jiang Taigong as the martial saint, the main worship of the martial temple Zheng Suichun. Ming Taizu shouted the period, abolished the Wu Temple, since then the Wu Temple is extinct, but in the Ming Shenzong period, posthumously Feng Yue Fei as the Yue Sheng Emperor, and at the same time posthumously Feng Guan Yu as the Guan Sheng Emperor, although the Wu Temple is abandoned, but the folk have Yue Fei and Guan Yu two martial saints.

During the Three Kingdoms period, after Guan Yu's death, he was gradually deified and revered as "Guan Gong" by the people, also known as the beautiful bearded prince. The Ming Dynasty began to be called "Guan Sheng Emperor", and since then it has become an officially recognized "martial saint", and the Qing Dynasty continued the tradition of the Ming Dynasty and still respected Guan Yu as a martial saint.

Guan Yu and Yue Fei are both martial saints.

Tang Dynasty, Tang Taizong Li Shimin respected Jiang Taixing Yan Gong as a martial saint, Tang Suzong period, the beginning of the martial temple, posthumously named Jiang Taigong as the king of Wucheng, with Jiang Taigong as the main worship, with Yasheng ten philosophers seventy-two will be enjoyed, when Song Zhenzong, continue to add Jiang Taigong as Zhaolie Wucheng King, still to Jiang Zhi rent the ridge Taigong as the martial saint, the main worship of the martial temple slammed. During the period of Ming Taizu, the Wu Temple was abolished, and since then the Wu Temple has been extinct, but in the Ming Dynasty period, Yue Fei was posthumously crowned as the Yue Sheng Emperor, and at the same time Guan Yu was posthumously sealed as the Guan Sheng Emperor.

During the Three Kingdoms period, after Guan Yu's death, he was gradually deified and revered as "Guan Gong" by the people, also known as the beautiful bearded prince. The Ming Dynasty began to be called "Guan Sheng Emperor", and since then it has become an officially recognized "martial saint", and the Qing Dynasty continued the tradition of the Ming Dynasty and still respected Guan Yu as a martial saint.