Why is it said that Hua Tuo was killed by Cao Cao, and it was entirely his own fault?

Updated on history 2024-05-10
20 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-10

    Because Hua Tuo actually wanted to use Cao Cao's headache to blackmail Cao Cao, the purpose was to elevate himself, and then let Cao Cao give him an official position. <>

    It is recorded in the Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms: The Biography of Fang Ji: "However, as a scholar, he sees the profession with medicine, and often regrets himself", which means that Hua Tuo found that the status of the profession of doctor is indeed relatively low in the process of treating others. During the Three Kingdoms period, Hua Tuo's reputation was very high, so there were many dignitaries and dignitaries who would seek Hua Tuo for treatment.

    In the eyes of these dignitaries, although Hua Tuo's medical skills are relatively superb, he is only a doctor after all, and his status is very low, and some people even look down on Hua Tuo. After a long time, Hua Tuo himself also felt a special loss, and his personality also changed a lot, so Hua Tuo has been waiting for an opportunity. <>

    Later, this opportunity finally made Hua Tuo wait for Cao Cao, who had always had headaches, and Cao Cao also learned that Hua Tuo's medical skills were relatively superb, so he wanted to invite Hua Tuo to see a doctor for himself. Hua Tuo himself knew that this would be his only chance to enter the official career, and after meeting Cao Cao, he told Cao Cao that Cao Cao's headache was very difficult. And Cao Cao naturally knew that Hua Tuo wanted to take the opportunity to elevate himself, and to put it bluntly, he was blackmailing himself in disguise, so Cao Cao didn't buy it, nor did he meet Hua Tuo's requirements.

    After that, Hua Tuo found an excuse to return to his hometown, and later Cao Cao wanted to go to him again to see a doctor for himself, and Hua Tuo found a lot of excuses to perfunctory, so Cao Cao was angry and directly arrested Hua Tuo. At this time, Cao Cao didn't kill Hua Tuo directly in order to see a doctor, but who knew that Hua Tuo actually said to Cao Cao that if you want to completely cure Cao Cao's disease, you must find an axe to open your skull and take out the lesions inside to succeed. This completely angered Cao Cao, so Cao Cao directly killed Hua Tuo.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-09

    Because there was no basis for craniotomy in ancient times at that time, not to mention that the equipment at that time was not very advanced and there was a great risk, so Hua Tuo took the blame.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    Because he should not reveal his superb medical skills, not everyone can understand craniotomy.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    Hua Tuo (about 145 A.D. 208 A.D.), a character Yuanhua, a native of Peiguo County, was a famous medical scientist in the late Eastern Han Dynasty.

    Hua Tuo, Dong Feng and Zhang Zhongjing are known as the "Three Divine Doctors of Jian'an". When he was young, he traveled abroad to study, and practiced medicine in Anhui, Henan, Shandong, Jiangsu and other places, studying medical skills rather than seeking a career. He has a comprehensive medical skill, especially in surgery, and is skilled in surgery.

    He is also proficient in internal medicine, gynecology, pediatrics, and acupuncture. In his later years, because he was suspected by Cao Cao, he was tortured to death in prison.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    It was because of Cao Cao who died.

    In "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", Cao Cao asked Hua Tuo, a famous doctor who had treated Zhou Tai, to give him a headache for many years, but Hua Tuo thought that Cao Cao's ** needed to split the head, add numbing and boiling anesthesia, and undergo major surgery, and the suspicious Cao Cao thought that Hua Tuo wanted to take the opportunity to kill him, so he imprisoned Hua Tuo and tortured him to death for the crime of assassination.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    It was killed by Cao Cao. Cao Cao had a headache and asked Hua Tuo to treat him, but Cao Cao's head disease was already very serious, and Hua Tuo knew that even if he tried his best to treat him, he could only prolong his life, and if he treated Cao Cao for the rest of his life, he would have to spend the rest of his life. But Hua Tuo missed his hometown, so he said that he would go home to get medical books.

    He didn't go back for a long time after arriving home, and Cao Cao sent people to ask him to go back many times, but Hua Tuo shirked and said that his wife was sick and would not go back. Later, the people sent to find out that Hua Tuo's wife was not sick, and then forcibly escorted Hua Tuo back, and then Cao Cao killed him.

    Before Hua Tuo died, he wanted to pass on the medical book he wrote to a jailer, but the jailer was afraid that he would be implicated and did not ask for it, so Hua Tuo had no choice but to burn the medical book.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    I hate the surname Cao, I myself am a primary school student, and I silently worship Hua Tuo in my heart.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    Historical records record that after Hua Tuo relieved Cao Cao's pain, he returned to his hometown on the grounds that his wife was sick, and made an appointment with Cao Cao to return before leaving. But when the appointed time came, Hua Tuo couldn't come back, on the grounds that his wife's illness had not yet recovered.

    Cao Cao sent people to invite several times, "the number of begging periods is not reversed, Taizu is tired of writing", Cao Cao was angry and painful, sent someone to invite, and specially instructed the messenger: "If Hua Tuo's wife is really sick, give him forty soybeans, if Hua Tuo fools us, he will tie him up for me."

    When the envoy arrived at Hua Tuo's house, Hua Tuo's wife was healthier than Cao Cao, and without saying a word, he took Hua Tuo to Yecheng Prison, tortured, Hua Tuo confessed, and was finally killed.

  9. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    The reason why Cao Cao wanted to kill Hua Tuo was because Hua Tuo wanted to use craniotomy to treat Cao Cao's ** head wind. However, Cao Cao mistakenly thought that Hua Tuo wanted to kill him, so he beheaded Hua Tuo.

    First, why did Cao Cao summon Hua Tuo?

    Hua Tuo has been living in no fixed place when he was alive, and he traveled around to doctors. And the reason why he went to see Cao Cao,Mainly because Cao Cao had a very serious head windEvery day, he had a headache and wanted to split his limbs, so Cao Cao wanted Hua Tuo to heal himself.

    As a famous surgeon in ancient China, Hua Tuo has experienced many surgical diseases. Because Hua Tuo has been famous for a long time, Cao Cao's subordinates invited Hua Tuo over after Cao Cao fell ill.

    Second, why did Cao Cao kill Hua Tuo?

    After Cao Cao saw Hua Tuo, he asked Hua Tuo to immediately treat him. And Hua Tuo, after inquiring about Cao Cao's condition in detail, thought that his ** was in the head.

    Hua Tuo told Cao Cao that he had salivation in his head. If you want to cure the head wind completely, you need to open the skull with an axe and remove the wind saliva from the brain, and the head wind can be cured.

    Although Hua Tuo's ** plan is very good,But when Cao Cao heard this, he was furious。He thinks that Hua Tuo is doing this to take the opportunity to kill himself.

    Hua Tuo was also very scared when he saw Cao Cao angry, and hurriedly explained to Cao Cao. Li Yu but Cao Cao didn't listen to Hua Tuo's explanation at all, and immediately threw him into prison.

    Thirdly, what is my opinion?

    I think Hua Tuo's ** plan is credible, but in the eyes of the ancients, Hua Tuo's plan is simply too crazy.

    And Hua Tuo did not take into account Cao Heng's suspicious nature before treating Cao CaoThat's why I hastily put forward my own ** plan. Therefore, Hua Tuo himself should also bear some responsibility for his death.

    And after Cao Cao killed Hua Tuo, there was no longer any doctor who could give him a headache, and Cao Cao died soon after.

    Summary: The reason why Cao Cao wanted to kill Hua Tuo was because Hua Tuo wanted to use craniotomy to treat him with a head disease. Cao Cao mistakenly thought that Hua Tuo was going to kill him, so he killed Hua Tuo first.

  10. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    The reason why Cao Cao killed Hua Tuo, the main reason for the wild burial was because he was suspicious by nature, Hua Tuo wanted to use a craniotomy to help Cao Cao treat his illness, Cao Cao suspected that Hua Tuo wanted to kill himself in this way, so he imprisoned Hua Tuo in Changzhi Jian, and was finally tortured to death.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    This is because Hua Tuo wanted to give Cao Cao a craniotomy, but Cao Cao didn't understand it, thinking that Hua Tuo wanted to ** himself, so Shou Sancong finally killed Hua Tuo. What he thought was that Hua Tuo wanted to hurt himself, so in order to protect himself, he killed the other party, Sakura, and he was very suspicious.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Cao Cao wanted to kill Hua Pao Hanmo Tuo at that time because Hua Tuo challenged his authority on Chun Xuan, and Hua Tuo wanted to open Cao Lao Mingcao's craniotomy, which was unprecedented in the history of medicine at that time.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Hua Tuo was the only one who could save Cao Cao, why was he killed by Cao Cao? Since ancient times, there have been many speculations and stories about the reason why the divine doctor Hua Tuo was killed. In "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", there is such a story that Cao Cao was seriously ill at the time, and Hua Tuo suggested opening the skull, and the skull could only be cured.

    As a military strategist, he was about to be beheaded, and Cao Cao was narrow-minded, at this time Cao Cao was furious, thinking that Hua Tuo wanted to kill him. So Cao Cao casually found a reason to dispose of Hua Tuo. That's what the saying goes.

    And what is the real history of Hua Tuo's killing?

    The real reason why Hua Tuo was killed was that Hua Tuo lied and committed Cao Cao's taboo, so Cao Cao couldn't bear it anymore and finally killed him Luyin.

    Cao killed Hua Tuo, the miracle doctor, not because Hua Tuo couldn't cure him well or didn't give him medical treatment, but because Hua Tuo cared about the world's patients and didn't want to treat Cao Cao with only one patient, so he often found excuses to ask for leave to go out and didn't come back, saying that his wife was sick and needed to be taken care of. He thought of this method in an attempt to cover up the facts. And Cao Cao has always cherished hopes and expectations for him, and he must have been suspicious of Hua Tuo's shirk.

    So Cao Cao sent someone to urge.

    We all know that Cao Cao is narrow-minded, for the real reason. He sent someone to secretly investigate whether Hua Tuo's wife was really sick, and Cao Cao found out that Hua Tuo had cheated on him. Deception is Cao Cao's bottom line, and Cao Cao said that he could not tolerate this matter, so he took Hua Tuo into custody.

    It can be seen that Cao Cao was very cautious about this matter, and he first investigated on the spot and then imprisoned Hua Tuo, which shows his benevolence and righteousness.

    After being imprisoned, Hua Tuo was not killed immediately, and after a careful trial process, Cao Cao felt that he still needed to be carefully interrogated, and only when Hua Tuo himself confessed to the crime could he order his death.

    Unfortunately, Hua Tuo was killed. The death of a generation of miracle doctors is lamentable, but there is nothing to be done. In fact, the reason why Hua Tuo was killed should be himself, and he should not make up reasons to deceive Cao Cao.

    In feudal society, when the period of the lower level expires, the superior needs to commit a serious crime, let alone for a person with high power like Cao Cao. was deceived, of course Cao Cao couldn't bear it.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Historically, Hua Tuo was killed by Cao Cao. Hua Tuo, Dong Feng and Zhang Zhongjing are known as the "Three Divine Doctors of Jian'an". He has a comprehensive medical skill, especially in surgery, and is skilled in surgery.

    He is also proficient in internal medicine, gynecology, pediatrics, and acupuncture. In his later years, because he was suspected by Cao Cao, he was tortured to death in prison. Huatuo of the Imperial Tomb School was called the "Holy Hand of Surgery" and "the Originator of Surgery" by later generations.

    Witnessing this situation, Hua Tuo hated the feudal tyrants who did all kinds of evil, and was very sympathetic to the oppressed and exploited working people. For this reason, he is not willing to be an official, but would rather defend the golden hoop bell and run everywhere to relieve the suffering of the people. Hua Tuo is not confused by the appearance of symptoms, he streamlines his medication, and is well versed in the interaction between body and mind.

    Hua Tuo does not abuse drugs. Huatuo attaches great importance to preventive health care, "cures people before they get sick", observes the natural ecology, and teaches people to breathe life harmony. However, for terminally ill patients, they do not add injections and drugs to congratulate each other, and tell them calmly.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    The first type: Cao Cao thought that Hua Tuo wanted to fight for power.

    Speaking of power, in fact, in ancient times, the status of doctors was very low, this profession belongs to Fang Ji, Fang Ji is regarded as a "cheap industry" in feudal society, just able to support his family, Hua Tuo is actually very regretful in his heart to medical skills, but he is good at medicine, often saving lives and helping the wounded, perhaps diluting some of his regrets about practicing medicine.

    When treating Cao Cao, Hua Tuo did his best, but because Cao Cao's head wind disease was not able to go to the root at that time, Hua Tuo said to Cao Cao: "This is difficult to help, and it can be extended for years." ”

    That is to say: the prime minister's disease is almost incurable, and continuous progress can prolong some life. The implication is that Cao Cao, who has no way to search and remove the roots, is a blow to Cao Cao.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    It was because Hua Tuo proposed to open Cao Cao's head at that time, but Cao Cao felt that this method was unbelievable and felt that Hua Tuo was going to kill himself.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    Because Hua Tuo did not treat Cao Cao, Hua Tuo would be killed by Cao Cao.

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    Cao Cao had a headache, so he asked Hua Tuo to come **, Hua Tuo wanted to give Cao Cao a craniotomy, Cao Cao was suspicious by nature, because Hua Tuo came to stab himself, so he killed Hua Tuo.

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    Because he felt that Hua Tuo had discovered his secret, in fact, Cao Cao would rather kill 100 by mistake than let go of one. And Hua Tuo was not willing to listen to Cao Cao's words.

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    Because Cao Cao felt that such a god-man could not be obtained by others, and Hua Tuo was unwilling to belong to him, he would be destroyed if he couldn't get it, and this was the real reason.

Related questions
7 answers2024-05-10

Yes, Hua Tuo wanted to open Cao Cao's brain to remove the tumor, and Cao Cao thought that Hua Tuo wanted to harm him, so he killed him.

30 answers2024-05-10

I think Cao Cao's approach is very dialogue, and it is not very wronged, everyone has their own ideas, if he does the same thing as Cao Cao thinks, Cao Cao will not kill him, since Cao Cao chose to kill him, Cao Cao has his own ideas, so they do not agree with each other, so Cao Cao will kill him, this is not questioned,

5 answers2024-05-10

Cao Cao, the famous divine physician Hua Tuo in Chinese history, was killed by Cao Cao, according to literature. Why did Cao Cao kill a doctor who could cure him? There are two main ways to say this: >>>More

14 answers2024-05-10

If Cao Cao hadn't killed Hua Tuo at that time, then his illness would not have been cured by Hua Tuo. Because after Hua Tuo was caught by Cao Cao to treat his headache, he made it clear that even if Cao Cao was cured, then Cao Cao would only live for a few days. At the same time, Hua Tuo also told Cao Cao his method, but Cao Cao at that time was very suspicious, so he thought that Hua Tuo wanted to kill him, so he locked Hua Tuo in prison, which led to Hua Tuo's death. >>>More

7 answers2024-05-10

Cao Cao coerced the Son of Heaven to make the princes have been scolded to the fullest, he for his only reputation, he can't be called the emperor, at that time, if he is called the emperor, it will be more despised, can not convince the public, Cao Cao for the future great cause, would rather not be called the emperor, and he is guilty of the Han.