Zhang Xiu s father and son were not allowed to die well, was it the result of Cao Cao s revenge?

Zhang Xiu's death, comprehensive historical background analysis,There is no possibility of revenge, but the death of Zhang Xiu's son, Zhang Quan,It can be considered that there isThere is an element of revenge.

Zhang Xiu died in 207 A.D. on the way to follow Cao Cao's northern expedition to Wuhuan because of his grudge relationship with Cao CaoIn addition, the cause of his death was not specifically explained in the history books, so there are many speculations about the cause of his death in later generations, and we can analyze it from the historical background at that time.

Although Zhang Xiu was a warlord with his own military and political strength, he did not have a clear political mind and lofty political aspirations, and surrendered to Cao Cao for the first time in 192 AD. Later, because Cao Cao occupied his aunt, he lost face, and privately wooed a general under Zhang Xiu, which provoked Zhang Xiu to worry about his life, so he started first. Raid Cao Ying launched the Battle of Wancheng, in which Cao Cao's eldest son, nephew, and favorite general all died at the hands of Zhang Xiu's father and sonThe battle was a heavy blow to Cao Cao, and a military defeat would give a pretext to the pro-Han faction within him.

The important thing is that the general and his relatives were killed, and he must have been full of hatred for Zhang Xiu.

Later, in 199, Zhang Xiu listened to Jia Xu's suggestion and surrendered to Cao Cao again. The Battle of Guandu had not really started a full-scale war, and Cao Cao, who was weak at that time, was not favored by the outside world, for example, there were rumors that Cao Cao would be defeated. Cao Cao did not kill Zhang Xiu, because he focused on the current situation and the great cause, and also in order to make a moral image for the world that understands the righteousness and repays grievances with virtue.

Therefore, Cao Cao's statement of revenge against Zhang Xiuyi is not valid, which is not conducive to the rapid realization of his great cause. This has also become the reason why Cao Pi, who has the heart to win the heir, will not retaliate against Zhang Xiu.

Zhang Xiu died on the way to fight WuhuanOne said that he was forced to die, but there is no historical evidence to support itCao Cao put the great cause of the current situation first, and also relied on Zhang Xiu's military and political power, so he did not retaliate. LaterZhang Xiu's son Zhang QuanLater, because of his involvement in the Wei sarcasm case,He was stripped of his title by Cao Pi and ordered to be killedIt is true that there are other political aims, but there is also an element of revenge. Unloading the mill and killing the donkey, the gentleman takes revenge, ten years is not too late, and this is also the most appropriate time.

Zhang Xiu's father and son did not die well, it may be Cao Cao's revenge, but he also has a reason.

The death of Zhang Xiu's father and son is related to Cao Cao's father and son, and it is not clear how to say the specifics.

The death of Zhang Xiu's father and son must have something to do with Cao Cao, but the specifics are not clear.

Yes, Cao Cao let him live for an extra seven or eight years, in fact, to get a good name for himself.

Cao Cao let Zhang Xiu live more.

Seven or eight years, it's not bad.

No, Cao Cao is busy recovering the world all day, how can he have time to retaliate.

Personally, I think that Zhang Xiu's death, based on comprehensive historical analysis, is not possible out of revenge, but Zhang Quan may have a certain element of revenge.

followed Cao Cao on the expedition to Chi Dan Zhizhang Xiu, and which of his sons was killed in the end to save Cao Cao?

a.Cao Zhang. b.Cao Ang.

Correct answer: B

Cao Ang. 197), the character Zixuan, Peiguo Qiao County (now Bozhou, Anhui) people. Cao Cao's eldest son, Liu's family, was killed, but his biological mother died early and was raised by the Ding family.

At the age of twenty, he was raised to filial piety. In the second year of Jian'an (197), he went out with Cao Cao to fight against Zhang Xiu, Zhang Xiu surrendered and rebelled, and Cao Ang was killed to save Cao Cao. In the second year of Emperor Wen of Wei (221), he was posthumously named Feng Mourning Gong, and in the fifth year of Huang Chu (224), he was further posthumously named Feng Mourning King.

In the third year of Taihe (229 years of Chi Nai), he changed his name to King Fengchou.

Zhang Xiu should be regarded as Cao Cao's killer, but in the face of Zhang Xiu's surrender again, Cao Cao did not mention the matter of avenging his son, but showed special enthusiasm, and even later formed an in-law with the other party, in fact, Cao Cao did this mainly for the following two reasons. <>

It can be said that Cao Cao is actually helpless to do this, because if I accept Zhang Xiu's surrender, then Cao Cao can avoid being attacked by the enemy. You must know that the contradiction between Cao Cao and Yuan Shao was difficult to reconcile at that time, and sooner or later the two sides would fight. But at that time, Yuan Shao's strength was indeed stronger than Cao Cao, and what Cao Cao needed to do at this time was to stabilize Zhang Xiu first, because Zhang Xiu happened to be in the waist position in Cao Cao's sphere of influence, if Zhang Xiu was difficult, then Cao Cao would definitely not be able to stand it.

Therefore, in this case, Cao Cao can only choose to accept the surrender of the other party, because this can not only enhance his own strength, but also avoid future troubles. <>

As we have said above, Cao Cao's strength is not as good as Yuan Shao's as a whole, so what Cao Cao needs to do is to quickly expand his strength and recruit more talents. Zhang Xiu's surrender was very helpful to Cao Cao, although Cao Cao also had many talents, but in fact, most of them were from a few big clans in Yingchuan, if all the power was concentrated in the hands of these people, it would be very unfavorable to Cao Cao. Therefore, Cao Cao needs to recruit more talents, and Zhang Xiu's arrival can solve his urgent needs.

In addition, Cao Cao at this time also needs to improve his reputation, Cao Cao's enthusiasm for Zhang Xiu actually has an element of show, because this means telling everyone that he is very magnanimous. Once Cao Cao's fame improves, then there will inevitably be more and more talents who come to take refuge, so Cao Cao's chess game is very good.

1. The situation was unfavorable to Cao Cao, and Zhang Xiu's surrender could avoid being attacked by the enemy. 2. Cao Cao urgently needs to recruit talents, and Zhang Xiu's arrival will be of great help to Cao Cao, 3. It is more beneficial to accept Zhang Xiu than to push him to Yuan Shao.

Cao Cao's acceptance of Zhang Xiu, the enemy of the murderer, was forced by the needs of the situation, and Zhang Xiu's surrender could avoid the situation of Cao Cao's belly and back being attacked by the enemy.

Because of the situation, Cao Cao needs talents, and Zhang Xiu is a talent, so Cao Cao will accept Zhang Xiu, the enemy who killed his son.

Zhang Xiu killed Cao Cao's eldest son, Cao Ang.

Zhang Xiu, the son of the hussar general Zhang Ji. The warlord who seized Wancheng in the late Eastern Han Dynasty and one of the heroes in the late Han Dynasty. During the Cao Wei period, he was a fellow villager with Duan Xuan, Jia Xu, and Empress Guo of the Ming Dynasty, and he was also a representative of the Liangzhou Hao Group.

At the beginning, he accompanied Zhang Ji on the expedition, and after Zhang Ji's death, he united with Liu Biao. Later, Cao Cao was surrendered, and because he was dissatisfied with his words and deeds, he raided Cao Cao and made peace with Liu Biao. On the eve of the Battle of Guandu, he followed Jia Xu's advice to surrender to Cao Cao again, participated in the Battle of Guandu, and became the general of Poqiang and was named the Marquis of Xuanwei.

From the expedition to Nanpi and defeated Yuan Tan. Later, he married Cao Cao. On the way to Wuhuan (207) in the Northern Expedition to Wuhuan, he died of illness and became the Marquis.

In some folk commentaries, Zhang Xiu was named "Marquis of Wancheng", known as the "Gun King of the North", and made a tiger-headed golden gun. Zhang Xiu is the great apprentice of the martial arts master Tong Yuan. During the battle of Wancheng, Hu Che'er stole Dian Wei's double halberd, and then was able to pick Dian Wei with a gun.

His "Hundred Birds and Phoenix Spear" is powerful all over the world.

Because Cao Cao felt that Zhang Xiu did the right thing, it was his son's mistake that killed him, and Zhang Xiu was a talent, and Cao Cao's favorite thing was talent, so he didn't kill Zhang Xiu.

Because Cao Cao was recruiting talents from all over the world to take refuge in himself at that time, he wanted to show his desire for talent by accommodating Zhang Xiu, who even had the hatred of killing his son.

Because Zhang Xiu was still useful to himself for the sake of face at that time, in order to unify the country, he temporarily put aside his grievances.

This is to buy people's hearts, after all, Cao Cao's reputation at that time was not this key to pure filial piety, so he would use this kind of clever way to buy people's hearts, so as to enhance his own power.

Because Cao Cao is a person who takes care of the overall situation, Yuan Yinyu Shao of the North Lao Shengfang is eyeing him, and only Zhang Xiu takes refuge in himself, so he has the opportunity to fight Lao Shao with Yuan Shibo, so there is no revenge.

Because Cao Cao was very smart, he felt that killing Zhang Xiu could not resurrect his son, so it was better to let Zhang Xiu die for himself.