If Zhu Di of the Ming Dynasty had not fought Zhu Yunwen, would the Ming Dynasty have changed?

No, history doesn't change because of one person, everything that should happen happens.

It's hard to say, how did the people of the Ming Dynasty lose the country, they lack money. At least Zhu Yunwen wins, and the vassal king will be eliminated. Then, he got in the right place and wasn't so brutal.

In fact, Zhu Yuanzhang has a very good foundation, and Zhu Yunwen will definitely implement benevolent governance and be the best replacement. Therefore, Zhu Yuanzhang saw it thoroughly and chose Zhu Yunwen to succeed him. Don't think that your vision can be on Zhu Yuanzhang.

It's just that he paid too much attention to family affection and failed without being ruthless.

There will be changes, and different people will rule differently.

History can't have ifs, of course, if this is true history, I think the Ming Dynasty will change, after all, no two leaves are exactly the same.

The Ming Dynasty will still change, because the development of history is inevitable and unchangeable.

It won't change, because their minds are so ingrained that it's hard to change.

Maybe not, but I feel that the Yongle period was the most powerful era of the Ming Dynasty, and it was a national territory that the strong Han and the Tang Dynasty did not do! And Zhu Di has the iron strength of his father Zhu Yuanzhang. The emperor who is very ambitious and has a lot of backbone makes China proud of the feudal society When the emperor is strong, the country is strong.

It should be, in that case, the result will be different, and the lychee will be different.

I think the Ming Dynasty will still change, because the development of history is inevitable.

Definitely, because everyone thinks differently and everyone wants differently.

Perhaps, after all, everyone thinks differently, and the policies they implement will be very different.

No, Zhu Yunwen is not suitable to be an emperor at all.

I think if Zhu Di hadn't fought Zhu Yunwen, the Ming Dynasty would have changed.

There will be no substantial changes, it's just that the emperors are different, how many emperors have changed in the Ming Dynasty, isn't it still the Ming Dynasty.

It will definitely Zhu Yunwen admires literature and suppresses martial arts, and likes to cut the feudal domain, and in the end, he will either force the vassal kings in various places to rise up in peace, or he will follow the old path of the Song Dynasty Anyway, it will definitely not be as strong and long as it has been in history.

If the reduction of the feudal domain is successful, the national strength will be further strengthened, and there will be a prosperous era, and it is a heavy burden for the Ming Dynasty to support these feudal princes and relatives, and it will eventually be passed on to the people.

There will be no use of civil power to control the military, the military strength will be improved, and in the long run, there will be a rebellion in the later period, just like in the late Tang Dynasty.

If Zhu Di did not succeed, the Ming Dynasty would almost die.

Yes, after all, a dynasty is not a generation's business, the children and grandchildren are different, the ideas and management methods are also different, and the development of society is naturally different.

There may have been changes in Zhu Yunwen's generation, but the more you go to the back, the less the change is, the change of the throne in the Ming Dynasty is actually very interesting, he is not in the same line, basically back and forth between the various branches. Today, this line becomes the emperor, and maybe the next generation or the next generation will change the lineage of the emperor.

There will definitely be changes, but the history of the Ming Dynasty will not be more than 100 years before the Mongols will come in.

From the level of generals alone, they can't do the Seven Expeditions to the Northern Desert! Half of the north is not protected.

There must have been a change, and the Ming Dynasty may become the Southern Ming Dynasty.

If the Song Dynasty had not perished, Chinese civilization would have exported its proud culture to the world, just like the current American culture exported civilization to the world! Influence the progress of human civilization! Only with civilization can there be science, and only with science can mankind progress!

So human beings cannot go retrograde, cannot destroy civilization, return to barbarism, return to primitive! Then all the years of human efforts will be in vain! Go back to the step of killing each other in order to survive with enough food!

Zhu Yunwen was fooled by a group of rotten Confucians, he was far worse than Zhu Di, and it would be even worse if he defeated Zhu Di in the Ming Dynasty.

In a word, in the invasion of foreign races, Nanjing was used as a reserve capital when the Central Plains collapsed, and it was the only one in the south that completed the unification of the south of the Yellow River, and the only one who completed the unification of China from the south to the north. When China was unified, it was necessary to choose a new capital, and because it was necessary to defend the border, the capital city also had to be moved to the north to deal with the problem of multi-ethnic integration.

Definitely, everyone thinks differently!! If Zhu Di hadn't won, maybe there would be nothing going on in Beijing, and the capital of Ming would be Nanjing!! Everything that follows will change accordingly

Of course, Ming Taizu Zhu Yuanzhang thought about this result, otherwise he would not have come up with various ways to restrict Zhu Di.

I must have thought about it, but I didn't expect it to be so miserable, and the grandson I value the most will end up very badly.

Definitely not, if he thought of such a result, he would definitely dispose of Zhu Di, he is a relatively strong person.

I thought that Zhu Yuanzhang was very strategic, he must have thought of such a result, so he wanted to cut the domain.

Zhu Di, the fourth son of Zhu Yuanzhang, Taizu of the Ming Dynasty, became the emperor.

Ming Chengzu Zhu Di was the third emperor of the Ming Dynasty, reigning from 1402 to 1424. The fourth son of Zhu Yuanzhang, Taizu of the Ming Dynasty, was born in Yingtian, conquered in current affairs, and was named the king of Yan, and then launched the battle of Jingjing, and attacked his nephew Emperor Jianwen, and seized the throne. After his death, the original temple name was "Taizong", and more than 100 years later it was changed to "Chengzu" by Zhu Houxi of Ming Shizong, and the reign of Ming Chengzu was called "Yongle Shengshi".

It should be able to survive until Zhu Yunwen dies, because Zhu Yunwen is not a faint king, he just won't lead troops to fight, but his benevolence will let the people recuperate.

If Zhu Di doesn't rebel, according to Emperor Jianwen's talent, I think he can hold out until he dies, because Emperor Jianwen is a very talented virtuous monarch.

can't support it for a long time, because Zhu Yunwen doesn't have his own opinions when he encounters things, and he doesn't know how to promote the development of things step by step.

It's absolutely no problem in the short term, but it can't last for 276 years like Zhu Di after he usurped the throne. Because Zhu Yunwen is kind and weak, since his father Zhu Biao was sick, he tried to ask how many sons would be as filial as him. Taking a step back, he is a grandchild, even if Zhu Di does not rebel, other vassal kings will rebel after a little ability, because if Zhu Yuanzhang passes the throne to any son, it is easy to say, but if it is passed on to his grandson, other sons have some great emotions.

Speaking of the biggest battle in the Ming Dynasty, we have to mention the famous "Battle of Jingyan", when Zhu Yunwen, the Jianwen Emperor who was originally victorious, buried the throne because of his soft heart. WhileThe reason why Zhu Di rebelled was also because Jianwen Emperor Zhu Yunwen wantonly cut the domain, causing Zhu Di to be unbearable, and then chose to directly raise troops to take away the throne of Jianwen Emperor Zhu Yunwen

First of all, let's talk about when the contradiction between Jianwen Emperor Zhu Yunwen and Zhu Di began, Zhu Di is the son of Zhu Yuanzhang, and he is also recognized as a son who is most like Zhu Yuanzhang, but Zhu Yuanzhang only liked his eldest son Zhu Biao at first, so Zhu Biao was also the undoubted heir to the throne at that time, but Zhu Biao was a short-lived prince and died early. It stands to reason that Zhu Biao is dead, and it should be Zhu Di's turn to be the crown prince, but Zhu Yuanzhang wants to set up Zhu Biao's son, that is, the later Jianwen Emperor Zhu Yunwen as the emperor's grandson, and inherited his throne, Zhu Di's uncle must be unconvinced, after all, Zhu Di is the prince who has the strength to be the emperor.

Secondly, although Zhu Yuanzhang knew that Emperor Jianwen Zhu Yunwen had a weak personality, Zhu Yuanzhang was far-sighted and left a lot of troops for Emperor Jianwen Zhu Yunwen, at least to ensure that Emperor Jianwen Zhu Yunwen's throne would not be taken away. After Jianwen Emperor Zhu Yunwen ascended the throne, when the throne was not stable, he wantonly cut the feudal domain, maybe Jianwen Emperor Zhu Yunwen also relied on the strength of the army left by Zhu Yuanzhang to him, so he dared to attack many vassal kings.

In the end, Zhu Di himself was dissatisfied with Jianwen Emperor Zhu Yunwen as the emperor, and as a result, Jianwen Emperor Zhu Yunwen repeatedly wanted to weaken his strength, Zhu Di was of course not happy, so he directly rebelled and overthrew the rule of Jianwen Emperor Zhu Yunwen. Originally, Emperor Jianwen Zhu Yunwen could defeat Zhu Di, but Emperor Jianwen Zhu Yunwen decreed that Zhu Di was not allowed to be killed, so Zhu Di was able to successfully seize the throne of Zhu Yunwen and Jianwen Emperor Zhu Yunwen alive.

After he saw this situation, he chose to pretend to be crazy, and often yelled or ran like crazy, lowered his head and scattered, and often grabbed other people's things to eat, and then said a lot of nonsense when he spoke.

is to obey Zhu Yunwen's orders, after all, Zhu Yunwen was the emperor at the time, and as the emperor's uncle, he should also carry it out.

Zhu Di pretended to be crazy, because Zhu Yunwen was kind-hearted, and he believed it to be true, which would allow Zhu Di to escape this catastrophe.

was overthrown by Zhu Di.

Is Zhu Yunwen kind? I don't think so, politicians are not allowed to be kind. If you are the emperor, you are still very kind and have no heart, I will kill you first, and I will be the emperor.

Legend has it that he became a monk. The political struggle is cruel, and Zhu Yunwen's failure is that he is too kind.

I don't know if I'm dead or not, it's always been an open case, but this doesn't mean that Zhu Laosi is a bad guy I think that if Yunwen is called emperor, then the Ming Dynasty should be destroyed.

Politicians shouldn't be kind, don't be an emperor if you're kind, the landlord is too simple.

Regarding Zhu Yunwen's death, a historical unsolved case, when Zhu Di set fire to the palace and wanted to force him out, but no one was alive or dead.

Through the ages, Ming Jun Tang Taizong Li Shiming killed his brother and killed his father and was kind again. The result of kindness is that you can't sit in the dragon court, and if others are killed, the consequences are very serious, and it is better to stand on your own ground and be a strong person.

China's political morality has always been a system of the best and the inferior.

This is because when Zhu Di captured the city of Nanjing, he took out a corpse from the fire, and identified it as Zhu Yunwen's body, and ordered the corpse to be buried, falsely claiming that Zhu Yunwen had died, and sent people to find his whereabouts, but in the end he did not find it.

He will naturally disappear in order to save his life, but whether he was caught in the end is a historical proposition.

It is also possible that he has passed away. Otherwise, it is impossible to have no whereabouts all the time, it's just that Zhu Di doesn't want to believe it.