Is Xiahoudun in history very powerful, I heard that he can defeat Guan Yu

Yes, Xiahoudun did defeat Guan Yu, Xiahoudun was going to attack Runan, Liu Bei hurriedly sent Guan Yu to rescue, but was defeated and Runan fell. In the Battle of Xiapi-Tushan, Guan Yu was defeated by Xiahoudun and surrendered to Cao Cao. These are armed confrontations.

Look at Xiahoudun as the Taishou of Henan, guarding the base camp of Cao Cao in Luoyang, rejecting Liu Bei in the south and Sun Quan in the east. There was no civil strife, but instead of being governed more and more powerful and stronger, and it fell without territory.

Look at Guan Yu as the Taishou of Jingzhou, Liu Bei's main base, Cao Cao in the north, and Sun Quan in the east. As a result, there was an internal rebellion, the territory was lost, and he also sent himself to the guillotine, which led to Zhang Fei being assassinated, Huang Zhong being killed, and Liu Bei being defeated. In this way, Guan Yu is too much worse than Xiahoudun.

Guan Yu is even more powerful. Because Guan Yu was the top military general in the Three Kingdoms period, he was the first of the five tiger generals of Shu Han, and his force value was higher than that of Xiahoudun.

I think Guan Yu is even better. Because Guan Yu's martial arts combat effectiveness is very high, coupled with rich combat experience. Therefore, Guan Yu is more powerful.

I think it was Guan Yu, because Guan Yu had been famous for a long time at that time, and the force value was also very high, and many generals who were similar to Xiahoudun's kung fu were beheaded by Guan Yu.

Xiahoudun and Guan Yu go head-to-head, who is more powerful?

Guan Yu is amazing.

Historically, Xia Houdun was not good at commanding troops, but his martial arts were commendable. But in terms of logistics, he has a lot of ideas. After Cao Cao welcomed the Han Dynasty and offered the emperor to Xu, he took Xiahoudun as Chen Liu, Jiyin Taishou, added General Wu, and named Gaoyang Township.

Xiahoudun has been practicing martial arts since he was a child, and has not been exposed to any experience and theory in politics, economics, and water conservancy management, but he is very good at this work, building water conservancy, leading the army to settle fields, surviving the natural disasters of the great drought and locusts, and ensuring grain and grass for the army. Xiahoudun, who had never been in contact with these things, actually did the logistics so well.

Guan Yu was a famous general of Shu during the Three Kingdoms period, and his deeds can be found in "Three Kingdoms, Shu Zhi, Guan Yu Biography". "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" said that Guan Yu was a loyal and righteous character, and Guan Yu's biggest failure in his life was arrogance, failure to unite his colleagues on the left and right, and slackening his vigilance against the defense of Eastern Wu.

The important town of Jingzhou fell to Eastern Wu, which led to a sharp change in the strategy of Lianwu to resist Cao, Zhang Fei was killed, and Liu Bei Yiting was defeated. Shu was struggling to cope with the two-sided war against Wei and Wu, and the decline and fall of Shu originated from this.

Whether it is in force or character, Xiahoudun is better than Guan Yu, but Guan Yu is elevated on TV, Xiahou is also a hero with a very positive character, he doesn't dare to belittle too much on TV, so he can only let the two of them tie and give Guan Yu a step, if Xiahoudun kills Guan Yu directly, he must be sure

In the official history, Xiahoudun is the minister of logistics, and Guan Yu is the commander of the military region, and there is no platform to compare the two.

Xiahoudun is powerful, first of all, there are not many records of Xiahoudun fighting other generals, but there are many battles against Guan Yu, the first battle: Xiahoudun led the army to copy the back and take Runan, Xuande was shocked: "If this is the case, I will be attacked before and after, and there will be no return!"

Urgently send Yun Chang to save him. Both armies went. Within a day, Pegasus came to report that Xiahoudun had broken Runan, Liu Bi abandoned the city and left, and Yun Chang was also repulsed.

The second battle: the battle of Xiapi-Tushan, Guan Yu was lured to the vicinity of Tushan by Xiahoudun, and was blocked by Xu Chu and Xu Huang together, Guan Yu could not pass, and turned to the second road and was blocked by Xiahoudun, at this time Guan Yu knew that he had been fooled, but he desperately wanted to kill out, but he didn't kill for a day, and finally surrendered. It should be noted here that 1

Xu, Xu, and Xiahou are the most difficult to capture Guan Yu alive without hurting Guan, and conversely, it is the most difficult to prevent Guan Yu from being injured. 2.In the Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms, Guan Yu was captured by Cao Cao and surrendered here.

The third battle: It's a thousand miles to ride alone, here Xiahoudun always said that he wanted to capture Guan Yu alive, what does it mean? It must have the ability.

The summary of the three battles is: Xiahoudun is stronger than Xu Chu, and Xiahoudun is far more powerful than Guan Yu. ，

1. In the historical records, Guan Yu and Xiahoudun fought twice, and there was no winner or loser. But both of them were famous generals in the Three Kingdoms period, and they were brave;

2, Xiahoudun, the character Yuan let, Pei Guo people. In the late Han Dynasty, he was a famous general of Cao Wei during the Three Kingdoms period, and a descendant of Xiahou Ying, the founding father of the Western Han Dynasty. As a teenager, he was famous for his courage in the village. Cao Cao raised troops, and Xiahoudun was the regimental bureau of his earliest generals;

3, Guan Yu, the word Changsheng, later changed to the word Yunchang, a native of Xie County, Hedong County, a famous general in the late Eastern Han Dynasty, followed Liu Bei to various banquet places in the early days, was captured by Cao Caosheng, and killed Yuan Shao's general Yan Liang in Baimapo, and Zhang Shuchafei was known as ten thousand enemies.

Guan yu. Because Guan Yu's martial arts are very powerful, and he is brave and good at fighting, I think Guan Yu's strength is stronger and his chances of winning are greater.

Guan Yu's ability should be stronger, because Guan Yu's martial arts are very strong, and Guan Yu's internal strength is also very deep, and he is more strategic when fighting.

It's not powerful, it's just that he dares to bully Guan Yu many times. Xiahoudun defeated Guan Yu many times, and when Xiahoudun conquered Runan, Liu Bei sent Guan Yu to rescue, but was defeated and fled back. During the battle of Pi-Tushan, Guan Yu was defeated and surrendered to Cao Cao.

It's not awesome... It's to bully a few soy sauce players.

Clause.

1. If you look at it from the content of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, you can speculate about the author's thoughts, Guan Yu is the protagonistOne of them, it can't be defeated in heads-up, and Xiahoudun didn't dare to write blindly because he was very powerful in history, so he only wrote that he fought with Guan Yu without winning or losing, and was persuaded by Zhang Liao to come according to **, when the battle of the official mansion cameGuan Yu's chances of winning are very good!

Second, in real history, Xiahoudun and Guan Yu have never fought each other, and the outcome is unknown……And I can tell you very responsibly that in history, generals like them, unless they have a personal hobby, they will not fight alone, and it is unlikely that they will lead the troops to kill them, or if they are injured, what will happen to the hundreds of thousands of people below? And immediately hold ** heads-up this thing, basically the horse goes back and forth, and the winner is immediately clear! It is impossible to fight hundreds of rounds, dozens of pounds of **, tired and tired, and it is definitely an inch long and an inch strong, so, the so-called heads-up fierce man in ** is basically an artistic rendering, the real history of heads-up requires luck, no matter how powerful Guan Yu is, he may be killed by a nobody in a very simple heads-up!

To sum up, the two of them are actually equal in the supremacy of force, but Guan Yu's protagonist's aura is too big, so everyone thinks that Guan Yu is superior! But the so-called benevolent see the benevolent and the wise see the wise, and victory or defeat is no longer of much significance

Xiahoudun must not be Guan Yu's opponent, because he is a person with low eyesight, and after Xiahoudun was blinded by the eye at that time, his combat effectiveness has greatly decreased, and he is not heroic at all.

Xiahoudun was stronger, Xiahoudun had defeated Guan Yu many times, when Xiahoudun conquered Runan, Liu Bei sent Guan Yu to rescue, but was defeated and fled back. During the battle of Pi-Tushan, Guan Yu was defeated and surrendered to Cao Cao.

Guan Yu was honored as the "Martial Saint", after Xiahoudun was shot blind, his combat effectiveness had already dropped greatly, although he was also very strong, but it was still impossible to beat Guan Yu.

The real battlefield is the ability to lead troops, and it is impossible to provoke anyone if you go to war alone, after all, Xiahoudun and Guan Yu have not really fought.

I think so, because in history, Guan Yu did not really pass five levels and kill six generals, and many other successful deeds were contributed by various coincidences.

Guan Yu fought with Xiahou Chun, but it was not a contest of arms, it was a military contest, and in the end Xiahou Chun was defeated, which shows that Xiahou Chun may not be able to win Guan Yu.

I think it still can't, Guan Yu was really powerful at that time, and he killed six generals after five levels, which can reflect Guan Yu's bravery.

I don't think Xiahoudun should be able to win. About it, because after all, he was honored as a martial saint, and his combat effectiveness greatly decreased after Xiahoudun was shot in the eye.

Guan Yu is too conceited, he feels that he is very powerful, and Xiahoudun is a person who has revenge, I like Xiahoudun, Guan Yu is too conceited, annoying Guan Yu.

I think Guan Yu is more powerful, because Guan Yu was a famous general at that time, brave and strategic, and had real combat effectiveness.

Without resourcefulness, martial arts are defeated in good terms, mainly because of on-site command ability.

Xiahoudun is not Guan Gong's opponent in either the official history or the romance, and the difference in force is too great.