Why do some people say that the history of the Ming Dynasty in the Qing Dynasty is not credible?

Because the history books of the Qing Dynasty will definitely smear or frame the Ming Dynasty in some things, it is not credible to say that the Ming history of the Qing Dynasty is not credible.

As the saying goes, the winner is the king, the loser is the coward, the Qing Dynasty is the victor, and the history books written by the victors must be biased towards the Qing Dynasty, and naturally there are some elements that slander the history of the Ming Dynasty, so some people say that the Ming history revised by the Qing Dynasty is not credible.

This is because some people believe that there is a certain degree of falsity in the history of the Ming Dynasty that is often revised, so it is not credible, and it is very likely that it was forged and written by others.

Some people say that the reason why the Ming history of the Qing Dynasty is not credible is because a new dynasty must negate the affairs of the previous dynasty, and many of them are fabricated in order to protect the interests of investors.

The history of the Ming Dynasty is not a fiction of the Qing Dynasty. The Ming Dynasty was a dynasty in Chinese history, and Zhu Yuanzhang, the Taizu of the Ming Dynasty.

Established. In the early days, the capital should be Tianfu, and the capital was moved to Shuntianfu during the Ming Dynasty. Sixteen emperors, a total of 276 years.

The territory of the Ming Dynasty encompassed the Han Dynasty, reaching the Sea of Japan in the northeast, the Outer Xing'an Mountains, and then shrinking to the Liao River Valley; reach Yin Mountain in the north, and then retreat to the Great Wall of the Ming Dynasty; West to Hami, Xinjiang, and then retreat to Jiayuguan.

Southwest to Burma and Siam.

in the north, and then turned back to about present-day Yunnan; And in the Qinghai-Tibet area, there was a detention guard, and also recovered Annam.

A brief introduction to other situations in the Ming Dynasty.

In the Ming Dynasty, the handicraft industry and commodity economy flourished, a large amount of commercial capital was transformed into industrial capital, and commercial market towns and capitalism sprouted. Culture and art are becoming secularized. According to the "Ming Shilu".

The peak population is 71.85 million, some scholars point to more than 100 million, and there are also claims that the population of the late Ming Dynasty is nearly 200 million.

Because the compilation of the History of the Qing Dynasty was faced with a huge task of sorting out and translating materials.

A large number of documents and archives of domestic and foreign affairs of the Qing Dynasty are recorded in Manchu; Many official documents were written in Manchu; Especially in the early Qing Dynasty, the Kang, Yong, and Qian dynasties formed the largest number of Manchu archives; There are also many preserved Qing Dynasty inscriptions and pedigrees written in Manchu.

At the same time, the Qing Dynasty has a different place from the previous feudal dynasties, that is, the Qing Dynasty has entered the period of modern globalization, and the Qing Dynasty has frequent exchanges with Japan and European countries, and there are a large number of historical archives related to the Qing Dynasty in the archives of many countries such as Britain, Russia, Germany, France, and Japan; There are also many Qing Dynasty observations written by foreigners as the first parties at that time, as well as important foreign documents for the study of the Qing Dynasty.

There is no Qing history in the 24 histories of the history books, and the Qing Dynasty has been destroyed for more than 100 years, why has the Qing history not been repaired?

How do you know that the history of the Qing Dynasty has not yet been repaired?

Influenced by the official history, that is, the so-called "history of the Ming Dynasty" compiled by the Manchu Qing Dynasty, because the Manchu Qing Dynasty tampered with history and blindly blackened and scandalized the Ming Dynasty in the history of the Ming Dynasty, many historical works treated the Ming Dynasty negatively.

Historians use the history of the Ming Dynasty as a standard. But I don't think that the history of the Ming Dynasty was written by the Qing Dynasty. Such an inferior dynasty of course did everything possible to smear the previous dynasty to flaunt its own orthodoxy!

We can only get a true record of the Ming Dynasty from Korea, Japan, and even European records! It's a pity that they turned a blind eye to this!

Because the people are civilized, the scholars are free, the ideas are free, and the merchants have no reason for taxes, and the world is not as good as the dynasty.