What did Zhuge Liang do wrong in Romance of the Three Kingdoms ?

Updated on culture 2024-07-24
8 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-13

    Zhuge Liang Sanqi Zhou Yu: Zhou Yu is not a narrow-minded person in history, on the contrary, he is a broad-minded person. And during the Battle of Chibi, Zhou Yu rarely saw Zhuge Liang, and the three qi Zhou Yu from ** came from, which is all fiction.

    Zhao Yun Changbanpo seven in and seven out: There is no such thing, Zhao Yun himself is a petty official, where did he get such a big ability, he just accompanied Liu Bei's family, and there were no seven in and seven out. Zhuge Liang didn't borrow arrows from a straw boat:

    There is no record in the official history, it is pure fiction. Pang Tong did not die in Luofengpo but in Luocheng, and was killed by arrows, not by random arrows. And he didn't offer a serial plan.

    Zhuge Liang burned Bowangpo: The official history records that Zhuge Liang had not yet come out of the mountain at that time, and it was Liu Bei who commanded this battle at that time. Three British Battle Lu Bu:

    There is no record in the official history, and the princes of the Eighteen Roads who participated in the crusade did not have Gongsun Chan at all, Liu Guanzhang was working under Gongsun Chan at that time, so the three Ying battles against Lu Bu were fictitious. Flooding the Seventh Army: According to records, flooding the Seventh Army was not planned by Guan Yu, but a natural disaster.

    Jiang Gan stole books: The official history records that Jiang Gan did steal books, but not in the Battle of Chibi, but earlier. Strength in the Battle of Yiling:

    It is recorded that in the Battle of Yiling, the Shu army did not have 700,000 troops, and the Wu State did not have more than 200,000, the real number is more than 40,000 Shu troops and more than 50,000 Wu States.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-12

    Wrong choice of heirs. Zhuge Liang designated his heir as Jiang Wei, who only knew how to fight. As a result, after Jiang Wei took power, regardless of the strength of the country, he forcibly invaded the Central Plains nine times and lost all his money, accelerating the collapse of Shu.

    I don't know how to deal with the aftermath. Before Zhuge Liang died, he handed over the power to a scholar Yang Yi, and also told him to "be careful of Wei Yan". And Yang Yi and Wei Yan have great contradictions.

    After Yang Yi gained power, he deprived Wei Yan of his military rights, forced Wei Yan to rebel, and was later pursued and killed by Ma Dai. Cronyism. handed over such a heavy place as Street Pavilion to Liu Bei, who repeatedly told him to be careful when he was dying, and did not use outstanding talents such as Zhao Tong and Zhao Guang.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-11

    Liu Bei took Guan Yu and Zhang Fei to ask Zhuge Liang to come out of the mountain to be his military master, Zhuge Liang was not at home when he went the first time, and he was not there when he went the second time.

    When it came to the third time, Zhuge Liang was taking a nap, Liu Bei stood in the courtyard very humbly and waited for Zhuge Liang to wake up without disturbing, Zhang Fei and Guan Yu both thought that Zhuge Liang was very unhappy with procrastination, and Liu Bei still waited humbly. In the end, Zhuge Liang was moved by Liu Bei's sincerity and promised to go out of the mountain to help Liu Bei.

    Extended information: The psychology behind the three visits to the thatched house:

    But we have a question, that is, there were many spiritual idols in ancient China as cultural people, Wen Tianxiang was also a spiritual idol, Yue Fei was also a spiritual idol, and there were many such people, why was Zhuge Liang the only one who was a scholar, a cultural person, and an intellectual in China, and his status was so lofty among the people?

    A very important reason is that the three visits to the thatched house, that is, whether Yue Fei or Wen Tianxiang or not, are not invited by the emperor three times or four, so Zhuge Liang invited him three times alone.

    And the ancient Chinese scholar he has an ambivalence, that is, on the one hand, he wants to come out to do things, the so-called learning to become a literary and martial arts, loan to the emperor's family, his belly full of economy, a belly of knowledge, a body of ability, he has a place to make ah, he wants to use it, he can only find a good boss, because he can't be the boss himself;

    But on the other hand, he is high, his psychology is very fragile, he can't stand the blow, he can't stand the cold reception, he doesn't want to come to the door with a shy face to let people kick out, it is best that all the bosses and all the emperors are respectfully coming to the door to invite him out, and there is only this one such example.

    So Luo Guanzhong, as such a scholar and such a cultural person, can he not make a big fuss about this matter? He must be capitalized and close-up, which I guess may be the psychology behind the "Three Visits to the Thatched House" of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms".

    In fact, in my opinion, whether Liu Bei first looked for Zhuge Liang, or Zhuge Liang who first looked for Liu Bei, whether they met three times and talked three times, or went three times to talk about it, it is not very important, what matters is what they talked about.

    If they really talked about it three times, we can't know the whole content of it, and we only know one conclusive opinion, that is, Zhuge Liang's political genius in the "Longzhong Pair" is vividly and vividly expressed, and the "Longzhong Pair" has also become a famous countermeasure in ancient China.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-10

    The names of the three stories about Zhuge Liang are:

    1. Straw boat borrowing arrows:

    Zhou buried Tan Fangyu was very jealous of Zhuge Liang's talent. One day, when Zhou Yu was discussing the military, he proposed to let Zhuge Liang rush to make 100,000 arrows. Zhuge Liang promised to build it in three days and made a military order. Zhuge Liang later asked Lu Su to help him borrow boats, sergeants and straw handles.

    On the third day, Zhuge Liang asked Lu Su to go with him to fetch arrows. On this day, the fog was so thick that I couldn't see people clearly. Before dawn, Zhuge Liang ordered the boat to be sailed and asked the sergeants to beat drums and shout.

    Cao Cao only told the crossbowmen to shoot arrows at the incoming ships. Both sides of the ship were filled with arrows. Zhuge Liang ordered to return to the division, and at this time it was too late for Cao Cao to chase after him.

    100,000 arrows were "borrowed". Zhou Yu sighed after learning about the borrowing of arrows: I am really inferior to him.

    2, Kong Ming's choice of wife:

    Huang Chengyan, a famous man in Jingzhou, heard that Zhuge Liang wanted to get married, so he went to Zhuge Liang and said to him: "I heard that you want to choose a wife, there is an ugly girl in my family, although her hair is yellow and black, but her talent can match you." So Zhuge Liang agreed to this family affair and married Huang Chengyan's daughter.

    Zhuge Liang's marriage to an ugly wife was ridiculed by the people of the time, and a proverb was circulated because of this, called: "Don't be a Kong Ming to choose a wife, just get an ugly girl."

    3. Empty City Strategy:

    After Ma Tan disobeyed Zhuge Liang's instructions and lost the street pavilion, Sima Yi led a large army to attack the western city where Zhuge Liang was stationed. At that time, Zhuge Liang had no generals around him, so he had to empty the city as a plan and open the city gate to make a mystery. When Sima Yi arrived, he was afraid that there would be an ambush inside, so he withdrew his troops.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-09

    The thirty-seventh chapter Sima Hui recommended the celebrity again Liu Xuande three visits to the grass house The thirty-eighth chapter decided to make a three-point Longzhong decision to fight the Yangtze River Sun family to take revenge The thirty-ninth chapter Jingzhou City Gongzi three scheming Bowangpo military division used troops at the beginning The fortieth chapter Mrs. Cai proposed to present Jingzhou Zhuge Liang burned Xinye The forty-third chapter Zhuge Liang tongue battle group Confucianism Lu Zi Jingli ruled the public opinion The forty-fourth chapter Kong Ming used wisdom to provoke Zhou Yu Sun Quan to break Cao Cao The forty-sixth chapter used a trick Kong Ming to borrow arrows and offered a secret plan Huang Gai was punished The forty-ninth chapter Seven Star Altar Zhuge sacrificed the wind Sanjiangkou Zhou Yu set fire to the fiftieth chapter Zhuge Liang Zhihua Rong Guan Yunchang Yi explained Cao Cao The fifty-first chapter Cao Ren fought the Eastern Wu soldiers Kong Ming was angry with Zhou Gongjin.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    Three points of the world. Liu Biao will soon die, and Xichuan Liu Zhang is incompetent. Take Jingzhou first and then Sichuan.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    Dear,,Don't believe in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms.,It's just a **,,To know the history of the Three Kingdoms,Please watch the Three Kingdoms.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    In the battle of Guandu, the grass boat borrowed arrows, and the city was empty.

Related questions
13 answers2024-07-24

There are many events according to Zhuge Liang, such as the straw boat borrowing arrows, borrowing the east wind, and the empty city plan, which are not recorded in the official history of the Three Kingdoms and the Book of the Later Han Dynasty, and are all fictional in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. >>>More

6 answers2024-07-24

Zhuge Liang often compares himself to Guan Zhong and Le Yi in the Spring and Autumn Period and the Warring States Period. Guan Zhong is civil, Le Yi is martial, which means both civil and military. >>>More

8 answers2024-07-24

It is estimated that Lu Yi should care about this issue!

Zhuge Liang: A feather in the sky through the ages. >>>More

9 answers2024-07-24

This is actually not Zhuge Liang's original intention, it's just that they are enemies, but Zhou Yu can't fight Zhuge Liang every time, and he is relatively narrow-minded, so that's it.

14 answers2024-07-24

There is a very famous scene in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", that is, Zhuge Liang slashed the horse with tears. This story actually caused many people to think deeply, and many netizens said that Zhuge Liang didn't have to kill Ma Tan, after all, Ma Tan's mistakes were insignificant compared to his past contributions. But if you can really consider it from Zhuge Liang's position at that time, you will find that Ma Jian must be killed. >>>More