From the perspective of Cao Cao s maintenance of rule, is it not a pity for Yang Xiu to die?

Yes, Yang Xiu thinks he is very smart, and he always thinks about Cao Cao's meaning, and Cao Cao can't tolerate him in his eyes.

Yes, Yang Xiu's death was completely self-inflicted, and he always guessed Cao Cao's thoughts that would cause misunderstanding of Cao Cao's forces and affect Cao Cao's rule.

Yes, a person with a character like Yang Xiu will not stay in Cao Ying's camp for a long time, and it is impossible for Cao Cao to tolerate him.

There are reasons for Cao Cao, and there are reasons for Yang Xiu.

Cao Cao: Stubborn, suspicious, jealous and talented.

Yang Xiu: Arrogant and open-mouthed.

Summary: To be a man, you must use people without suspicion, and you don't need to use suspicious people. And don't let it go.

It's for his personal reasons! Liberal.

That's a lot to answer

For example, Cao Cao was stubborn, suspicious, jealous of talented people, and so on

Suspicious, but I think he is protecting his status and rights at the same time, Yang Xiu is really a little arrogant, he doesn't know how to observe words and feelings, and does something that Cao Cao is not happy about, anyway, I think Cao Cao is very good.

Yang Xiu is smart, and even the degree of intelligence has surpassed Cao Cao, the reason for Yang Xiu's death is also defeated by his insolence, every time Cao Cao's careful thinking is made public, he thinks he is very smart, in fact, Cao Cao has long been murderous. The reason for Yang Xiu's death was that he had violated Cao Cao's taboo and had reached the point of lawlessness.

1. The reason for Yang Xiu's death disturbed the morale of the army.

Cao Cao gathered troops and wanted to enter the army, but was rejected by Ma Chao, and wanted to collect the troops and return to the capital, but he was afraid of being laughed at by the Shu soldiers, so he hesitated in his heart, and ran into the cook into chicken soup. Cao Cao saw that there were chicken ribs in the bowl, so he felt it. In the middle of the deep groaning, Xiahou entered the account and asked for the night slogan.

Cao Cao replied casually: "Chicken ribs! Chicken!

Xiahoudun sent an order to all the officials, all of whom were called "chicken ribs!" Yang Xiu, the master of the march, saw the word "chicken ribs", so he asked the accompanying soldiers to pack up and prepare to withdraw their troops, which was also the reason for Yang Xiu's death.

Someone reported it to Xiahoudun. Xiahoudun was taken aback, so he asked Yang Xiu to the tent and asked, "Why are you packing up?"

Yang Xiu said: "Judging from tonight's order, we can know that the King of Wei will soon retreat and return to the capital. Chicken ribs, there is no meat to eat, and it is a pity to lose it.

If the state wheel can not win the army today, the retreat of the army is shameful, there is no benefit here, it is better to go back as soon as possible, and the king of Wei will inevitably return to the dynasty in the future. Therefore, pack your bags first, so as not to panic when it is time to leave. "The reason for Yang Xiu's death was to disturb the morale of the army.

So none of the generals in the barracks were not ready to return to the court. On the evening of the same day, Cao Cao suddenly saw that the soldiers in Xiahoudun's camp were preparing their own suits, and said: "The chief bookkeeper, Yang Zude, knows in advance that the king wants to go back.

The reason for Yang Xiu's death is also this, Cao Cao called Yang Xiu to ask the reason, and said angrily: "How dare you spread rumors and mess with our army's heart!" He ordered the knife and axe man to push Yang Xiu out and behead him, and hung his head outside the gate.

Second, Yang Xiu violated Cao Cao's taboo.

Yang Xiu's special talent is actually his insight into Cao Cao's intentions. In the words of Xiahou Dun, it is "the truth knows that the lungs of King Wei are also excited". Yang Xiu is like a clever psychologist, when "everyone is drunk", he can "wake up alone".

He can always accurately grasp Cao Cao's psychological dynamics. In front of Yang Xiu, Cao Cao was like being stripped of his clothes, and all the secrets were at a glance.

Cao Cao was naturally suspicious, and of course he would not want his subordinates to see him through completely. In front of his subordinates, Cao Cao prefers to maintain a sense of mystery, because only in this way can he better control his subordinates. And most of Cao Cao's subordinates were indeed often confused about Cao Cao's intentions.

But Cao Cao's various tricks could not be concealed from Yang Xiu, and Yang Xiu had just grasped Cao Cao's intentions.

But he refused to hide it in his heart, but repeatedly explained Cao Cao's intentions to others. In this way, the mystery that Cao Cao pursued was gone, and his control over his subordinates was undoubtedly weakened. So, when Yang Xiu once again saw Cao Cao's intention to withdraw from the army from a "chicken threat", and told Xiahou Dun about it without scruples, Cao Cao finally couldn't bear Yang Xiu's patience, and he killed him in the name of "disturbing the hearts of our army".