Wisdom and cleverness, why is Liu Bang s traitor Yongya and Cao Wuxian s ending completely different

However, the same person who betrayed Liu Bang, Yongya was named the Marquis of Shifang by Liu Bang, and Cao Wuxian was killed by Liu Bang, why is there such a big gap between Yongya and Cao Wuxian's ending In fact, the reason why Yongya was able to be made a marquis is purely because Yongya ran fast Back then, Yongya received a letter of persuasion from King Wei to surrender, and immediately took Fengyi as his own, and Liu Bang, the Duke of Pei, Liu Bang had attacked Fengyi twice, but he didn't take it down If it weren't for Liu Bang's ability to toss and strong communication skills, he borrowed 5,000 elite soldiers from Xiang Yu's uncle Xiang Liang, Yongya may not be defeated, if Yongya is not defeated by Liu Bang, he will not run to Wei.

Because Yongya not only has a higher status than Cao Wuxian, but also has the ability and ability to be a man, he is for the righteousness and the country, and Cao Wuxian is his own selfish interests, so the two have completely different endings.

Because the "Historical Records" and the "Book of Han" do not record the whereabouts of Yongya after defecting to Zhou, but it records the ending of Yongya being named the Marquis of Shifang, so we can roughly infer that after Liu Bang borrowed soldiers from Xiang Liang, Yongya, who guarded Fengyi for Zhou, should not have been captured, but fled with his crowd, that is, although Liu Bang wanted to kill Yongya at that time, he did not have the ability to kill Yongya.

This is because Liu Bang is a very capable person, and he chose to betray it as a helpless move, Cao Wuxian did not end well after the betrayal, and he was just playing his own cleverness.

1. You didn't kill the first time because he escaped quickly. voted for the Wei State and went back to make a living. 2, Yongya Hao Liang Sui brought the people of a city to rebel together, Liu Bang's soldiers have kinship with these people, and they are unwilling to be ruthless.

3. Liu Bang's foothold was unstable, and he didn't have enough energy and time to kill Yongya at that time.

What I understand is that Liu Bang may want to test the other party in this way, want to test his loyalty to the clan hand in this way, and want to see what the other party Qiaozhi will do, and Min Suimin may trust him very much, and because he has some friendship with him, he didn't kill him.

Because of the empty traces of Liu Dan and Bang out of love for talent, he thought that Yongya had been with him for a long time, and also helped him win a lot of battles, and his ability must be more prominent, and it was also to appease the soldiers in the army at that time, Liu Bang was broad-minded, and Liu Bang wanted him to be spurned by the world.

Yongya is a very legendary existence in the history of the Han Dynasty, he grew up with Liu Bang since he was a child, but he was a scheming person, and he once betrayed Liu Bei.

Because Yongya has made many feats. And no longer threaten Liu Bang's rule. But the most important thing is that Zhang Liang suggested that Liu Bang reward Yongya, which not only corrected Liu Bang's disadvantages of nepotism and private reward, but also easily eased the contradiction and avoided a possible turmoil.

His power trick of settling revenge and strengthening the hearts of the people is often concocted by politicians in later generations.

And although Cao Wushu also had military exploits, he was inclined to Xiang Yu, and would rather betray Liu Bang and be Xiang Yu's spy. More importantly, Cao Wuxian's leak almost led to Liu Bang's death.

Liu Bang (256 BC - 195 BC), that is, Emperor Taizu Gao of the Han Dynasty, a native of Zhongyangli in Peifengyi, the founding emperor of the Han Dynasty, and one of the great pioneers of the Han nation and Han culture.

1. Outstanding statesmen, strategists and conductors in Chinese history. It has made outstanding contributions to the development of the Han nationality and the unification of China.

Liu Bang was born in a peasant family, is open-minded and generous, and does not produce. Qin was the chief of the Surabaya Pavilion in Pei County at the time, and died in the Mangdang Mountains due to the release of prisoners. Soon after Chen Sheng's uprising, Liu Bang gathered 3,000 children to respond to the uprising, captured Peixian and other places, called Pei Gong, and soon defected to Xiang Liang, served as the magistrate of Dang County, was named the Marquis of Wu'an, and the soldiers and horses of Dang County.

In October 206 BC, Liu Bang's army was stationed in Bashang, and Prince Ying of Qin surrendered to Liu Bang. The Qin Dynasty was destroyed, Liu Bang abolished the Qin Harsh Law, and made three chapters with the Guanzhong fathers. After the Hongmen banquet, he was named the king of Han and ruled the Bashu region and Hanzhong.

In the early stage of the Chu-Han War, he was repeatedly defeated. But he knew people well, paid attention to accepting advice, could give full play to the talents of his subordinates, and paid attention to uniting the forces of various places to oppose Xiang Yu, and finally turned defeat into victory. After defeating Xiang Yu, unify the world.

On February 28, 202 B.C., Liu Bang was the emperor in Dingtao and the water of Yang, and the capital was Chang'an, known as the Western Han Dynasty.

After ascending the throne, he eliminated Han Xin, Peng Yue, Yingbu, Zang Di and other princes with different surnames, and divided the soil into nine princes and kings with the same surname. On the other hand, it established rules and regulations and adopted a relaxed policy of rest and recuperation to govern the world, allowing soldiers to be demobilized and returned home, exempting them from forced labor, emphasizing agriculture and suppressing business, restoring the broken social economy, and stabilizing the feudal ruling order. It not only appeased the people, but also contributed to the cultural foundation of the Han Dynasty's grace and generosity.

Adopt a policy of peace and proximity to the Xiongnu and open up the customs with the Xiongnu in order to ease the relations between the two sides.

are two different characters, so far apart that there is no comparison.

First, Cao Wuxian is a traitor in Liu Bang's camp, an extremely dangerous person, such a person does not say that Liu Bang is punished, he must be punished quickly in any team, this is a matter of nature, and it is also a matter of right and wrong, if there is no Cao Wuxian's secret pass Xiang Yu, there will be no Liu Bang to pay about the Hongmen banquet, Liu Bang's life is thanks to the love and friendship between Xiang Bo and Zhang Liang, saved from the fall, a risky move Liu Bang walked out of the Hongmen and came back alive, Liu Bang knew Cao Wuxian's secret pass Xiang Yu from the mouth of Xiang Yu, who lacked heart and eyes, Can Cao Wuxian still live? Liu Bang and the brothers must be immediately punished and hated!

Second, Yongya is different, first, Yongya looks down on Liu Bang as a scoundrel from the heart, and looks down on Liu Bang's character, but Yongya is not not not participating in the revolution, and is brave and fearless, resolute in style, is a veteran figure, Liu Bang also knows this in this regard, and admires it in his heart. Second, Yongya is also a Fengpei character, and the brothers of Fengpei Group have a certain amount of friendship, everyone is the first revolutionary, and even a comrade-in-arms in the same trench, in the early stage of the revolution, due to various reasons, Yongya's position is not accurate, but that is temporary, excusable, in general, Yongya followed Liu Bang to fight the world.

Liu Bang didn't kill Yongya because Yongya's prestige in the army was still relatively high at that time, and he coerced so many people in Pei County to oppose Liu Bang, if Liu Bang really killed then he had to kill all the people in Pei County (at that time, Zhang Liang also interceded for the people of Pei County, Liu Bang thought about it, I won't kill the people, then by the way, I also let Yong Ya go). And Yongya didn't move Liu Bang's family.

And Cao Wuxian is different, Cao Wuxian is a general in Liu Bang's army, but he betrayed Liu Bang because of selfish interests, betrayed the master for glory, and became a traitor, from ancient times to the present, a traitor must not be spared. Otherwise, there are endless consequences.

Another point is that Liu Bang had an unstable foothold among the princes of the world during the war with Yongya, and he wanted to appease people's hearts. Especially a talent like Zhang Liang, he wants to attract him.

This is the question that has to be looked at this way. If Liu Bang succeeds in catching Yongya in three beats Feng County, then Liu Bang will also kill him. It's a pity that Yongya ran away.

Later, Yongya defected to Wei Bao of Wei, which is equivalent to a Wei person. Liu Bang was unwilling to have a conflict with Wei before he resolved Han Xin, Yingbu, Peng Yue, as well as Han Wangxin and Lu Xuan, so he didn't kill Yongya for the time being. If it weren't for Zhang Liang's words, maybe Liu Bang would have killed Yongya sooner or later.

However, Liu Bang still understands very well what is a big thing and what is a small thing. These trivial things in the past may not be taken to heart, and they may not be delved into.

And Cao Wushu is the traitor in front of him, so he must be killed. On the other hand, if Cao Wuxian has the ability to escape, and is captured by Liu Bang or surrenders to Liu Bang in a few years, Liu Bang may not kill this useless villain.

Cao Wuxian will not really assist others, he betrayed Liu Bang, and he will not really assist Xiang Yu.

It can only be said that the problem of personal fortune, whether two people live or die is completely determined by the situation, because Liu Bangzhi is in the world, and others are the same, sometimes killing a traitor can make an example of the chicken, and sometimes letting the traitor go can show benevolence and righteousness.

In Jiang Wen's version of "Guan Yunchang", there is a classic line: Which one of Cao Ying's camps is not a general?

But Cao Cao is not a general, not only to observe the character and ability of the general, but also to judge the situation, when to kill, when to release, all depending on the time.

Yongyan is a rebellion, Cao Wuxian is a betrayal, this nature is different. Rebel people abandon their bosses in order to protect themselves at critical times, they are disloyal, but it is human instinct, Liu Bang still respects human nature, and Yongya has merit, Liu Bang hates and hates, but he will not retaliate because of hate, he will not retaliate because others anger him, and even reward it because of Yongya's merits. Because of Cao Wuxian's whistleblowing, Liu Bang almost hung up at the Hongmen banquet.

Yongya never thought that Liu Bang would treat him well, so he was very excited to be named the Marquis of Shifang, and immediately took his family to the title.

In this way, Yongya enjoyed 9 years in Shifang, and finally died peacefully. After his death, his descendants also inherited the title.

Because he was still useful, he was useful to Liu Bang, so Liu Bang didn't kill him and left him alive to the end.

Because Liu Bang wanted to use him to make his position clear, at that time, Liu Bang's subordinates were afraid that Liu Bang would attack him, Liu Bang sealed Yongya, and the others were relieved.