Do 11 year olds need to read the four great books?

I am Xiaomei Society, a fashion community that pays attention to the aesthetics of life, welcome to understand, and live together with **beauty and life.

When I was in school, I wrote four famous books.

There are excerpts in junior high school textbooks, but I don't know what excerpts are available in current middle school textbooks.

The excerpts of the four famous novels in junior high school show that such a storyline can already be understood at this age. 11-year-old children are basically in the middle of elementary school.

Duration. In fact, the earliest contact between children in the four famous novels should be "Journey to the West".

I remember that as soon as I was in the first year of junior high school, my brother gave me a library card for our local library, and I felt like a little adult, I could go in and out of the reading place where adults entered, and the feeling of getting a library card was very ritualistic.

Then the first book I borrowed from the library was "Journey to the West".

For "Journey to the West", children basically don't have much problem understanding, because since early childhood, various versions of "Journey to the West" have filled the screen, not to mention the most classic version of the TV series.

It's all very high. Nowadays, all kinds of games, anime, and TV series abound. <>

For "Dream of Red Mansions".

For 11-year-old children, it may be a little difficult to understand, but reading a book does not necessarily mean that all the storylines can be understood, just imagine, parents read so many picture books when we were young, do we understand the call, no, but we are not under the guidance of our parents to complete one by one, and it has also become the best memory of childhood. Therefore, for 11-year-old children, it is difficult to understand the overall understanding of such a complex social background as "Dream of Red Mansions", but under the guidance of parents, there is no problem in reading through, and parents mainly help to give guidance in the form of classical Chinese.

For "Romance of the Three Kingdoms".

and "Water Margin", I have the impression that I watched it in high school, among which "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is what I like to watch very much, and I don't like to watch "Water Margin" very much, so I really responded to the sentence "I don't watch the Three Kingdoms, I don't watch the Water Margin", I was obsessed with "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" and watched it several times, and "Water Margin".

I watched it several times, but I didn't finish it.

Therefore, for 11-year-old children, who already have a certain analytical ability to understand famous books to a certain extent, or under the guidance of their parents, read famous books with their parents. <>

I'm Tinker Bell.

As a Chinese teacher who has been teaching in the field for more than ten years, I think so:

First of all,The age of children does not "need" to read the four famous books:

From a test-taking perspective:

An 11-year-old is still in primary school. Although the four famous books are all listed as compulsory reading recommended by the Ministry of Education, none of them are among the required reading lists in primary school: "Journey to the West" and "Water Margin" are required reading in junior high school, and "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" and "Dream of Red Mansions" are required reading in high school.

Therefore, from the perspective of exam-taking, 11-year-old children do not need to read the four famous books.

From the point of view of self-cultivation, there is no such thing as "need".

The reason why the four masterpieces are the four masterpieces is because their artistic achievements and ideological connotations are exemplary in ancient times, and they can provide readers with high-quality nourishment for literature and life cultivation, rather than basic nutrients, so they are not among the "musts".

Moreover, each child's cultivation level is different, and the nutrients they need are also different; Among the vast literary classics, there are not only these four books that can provide high-quality nourishment, so the four famous books are really not necessarily what children need.

In fact, whether a child reads the four famous books or not depends mainly on the following factors:

First, interests:

As the saying goes, "interest is the best teacher", if you are interested, you can read all books; If you don't have interest, no matter how good the book is, it's useless.

Second, ability:

As we all know, the four famous books are all written in half Chinese and half vernacular, if the child has less accumulation of literary language and weak literary skills, it is very difficult to read the four famous books.

Moreover, more importantly, the ideological connotation and life wisdom in the four famous works require a certain amount of life experience and reading experience to understand. "Dream of Red Mansions" is particularly obvious, many children with average reading ability cannot basically understand it until high school, let alone 11-year-old children. <>

In this era of shallow reading, classic literature is often less attractive than fast food culture - a "Journey to the West" is far less attractive to children than a "Douluo Continent"; A copy of "Dream of Red Mansions" is far less sought after than "Three Lives, Three Worlds, Ten Miles of Peach Blossoms". And 11-year-olds tend to be more susceptible to peer and peer influences.

Therefore, if there is no good family reading atmosphere, it is very difficult for children to sing solo and high-pitched in the midst of shallow reading and pseudo-reading.

To sum up, I thinkThe subject should not ask others".Do you need to read the four famous books", but ask yourself if you are ready to take your child to read it, and if your child wants to read it, and whether he can read it.

I amStroll along the parenting road

11-year-old children are probably in the fourth or fifth grade of primary school, this age should be able to start to contact the four famous books Children should read widely from an early age, we all know the four famous books, not like ** is vernacular, the meaning is clear at a glance, but classical Chinese, the fourth and fifth grades are just the beginning of contact with classical Chinese, at that time to start reading, not only enough to understand the plot of the four famous books, but also to improve the ability to read classical Chinese. So it's not good to read too young, because it's not good to read, but it's not okay to be too old, we all know that students will face the test of the college entrance examination, at this time, it's too late to be busy with their studies, and how can they have the time and energy to study the four masterpieces, after the third year of junior high school, they have to go all out to cope with the high school entrance examination, some people say that they combine work and rest, but even if they are a combination of work and rest, they don't need to read the four masterpieces that need to be carefully studied, so it's better to read them at an age that has time and energy. <>

Although you can start to contact at the age of 11, there is no need to ask to read all four books, the difficulty of each book is different, and the degree of fun is not the same, so the degree of acceptance of different ages is not the same, you can read a "Journey to the West" first, I believe that many people will have seen the 86 version of Journey to the West played by six young children in their childhood, it should be very familiar with the plot, and then read the Chinese version of the book, I think it is much easier to go back, "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" and "Water Margin" can be read at the same age, One is about the weekend legend of the heroes of all walks of life when the Three Kingdoms were established at the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty, and the other is about the deeds of the heroes of Liangshan in one hundred and eight years, and the content is also quite interesting, it is recommended to read "Dream of Red Mansions" when you grow up, the storyline is slightly more complex than the other three, and it is too tragic, and the feelings of the characters may not be understood at the age of 11.

Therefore, 11-year-old children can read the four famous novels, but they do not need to rush to read them all, and gradually finish reading the four famous Chinese classics.

The four classical masterpieces of China contain the vitality of youth, which is a treasure in the history of Chinese literature and a precious world cultural heritage. If children can read the four famous books well, it will definitely be beneficial to Chinese learning.

But many people are against it, arguing that 11-year-olds don't need to read the Big Four. Actually, this is a wrong view. Many well-known education experts have also pointed out that the four classical Chinese classics should allow primary school students to have a preliminary understanding, and if conditions permit, they should also add these knowledge of the four classics to the content of the examination.

It can be seen that the national education has the respect for classical classics. It can be seen from the test questions of the primary school examination in recent years that there are some words and phrases in the simple exams, but idioms or colloquialisms will appear in the more difficult exams, which has always been the source of the afterword. The more difficult exams put together the plot and content of the characters, and students are asked to analyze the characters' personalities.

As the saying goes, if you don't read "Water Margin", you don't read "Three Kingdoms", but this is not the case, after reading the four famous novels, children will learn how to describe the characters and how to describe the different personalities of the same type of characters. For example, Li Kui and Lu Zhishen belong to the same type of people, but the personalities of the two people are completely different, Lu Zhishen is rough and fine, and his personality is bold, Li Kui has a rude personality, but in this rudeness, he gives people a kind of childlike cuteness. Another example is "Dream of Red Mansions", which describes more than 20 ways to eat eggplant, and there are hundreds of characters depicted, with different personality characteristics.

For example, when "Dream of Red Mansions" describes the appearance of the characters, although they are all very beautiful, through the author's careful description, this beauty reveals its own merits. Therefore, it is especially beneficial for 11-year-old children to read the four famous books for writing.

Bingxin had already started reading "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" when she was four years old, and by the time she was eleven or twelve years old, Grandma Bingxin was able to read through "Dream of Red Mansions", no wonder Grandma Bingxin became a well-known writer. It turns out that people have had this kind of literary heritage since childhood.

Before this question, parents may need to ask themselves such a question, do you need to watch your child read the four famous books, but the child himself needs to read the four famous books? It's not just "yes or no", but in your relationship with your child, does he have the right to choose what he wants to see?

Everyone's child's development stage is different, hobbies and abilities are also different, if a child's ability has reached a certain level, he himself likes it, no matter whether he chooses the four famous books or other reading materials, it is understandable; But if the child's reading ability is not reached, or he is not interested in it, but there is a concept in the parents' mind that you need to read, and you have to understand these things at this age, then this "must" and "should" come from **? In the parent-child relationship, this may be a manifestation of parental power, parents think that the child should do this when he is old, you have to do it, and do not consider the child's own acceptance or interest, willingness, if this is the case, your parent-child relationship is more worthy of vigilance, because since you can force him to read a book he doesn't like, can you also force him to do other things he doesn't like to do?

11 years old age is actually in the transition from childhood to adolescence node, if the child itself is unwilling and you have to push it, then the result is likely to be the rigidity of the parent-child relationship, with the child's personality, body and strength of the gradual growth and maturity, parents may become more and more uncontrollable, the final result may be that the child is not willing to talk to you at all, and is not willing to share anything with you, if the child is forced to read the four masterpieces, although he is unwilling to do so, But I still read it according to your will, but in the end, the result is such an impact on the parent-child relationship, do you want to see it?

Eleven years old is too young, right!! The worldview and values have not yet been seen!! Are you not afraid of precociousness? Personally, I think it's better to watch it after the age of sixteen!!

If a child is of ordinary mind (not a genius), then the best age for him to read the original four masterpieces should be eleven or twelve years old, that is, when he is in the fifth grade. Let children get in touch with the four famous books early, and they should not be excluded. As long as you choose the right version for your child, there is no problem.

Exposing a fifth-grader to the original text does not mean that he will be able to read the original text. Maybe at the beginning, you can only get in touch with some of the storylines inside, and there may be some touching places, but the understanding of books is with you for life.

Elementary school, junior high school, high school, and reading after work, the understanding of each stage is different, and it may be that when you read again at the age of fifty or sixty, you will better understand "the rolling Yangtze River is still passing away", "the green mountains are still there, and the sunset is red several times", "the moon is rare, and the colorful clouds are easy to disperse".

Stimulate children's interest in books:

You can also find some TV series, movies, and cartoons with the theme of "Journey to the West", such as the well-received movies such as "The Return of the Great Sage" and "Journey to the West: Three Dozen White Bone Spirits", and show them to your child, so that he will first become interested in "Journey to the West".

Generally speaking, elementary school can be contacted, but except for geniuses, it is generally about 15-16 years old to let him read the original book.

In principle, there is no age limit, and it can generally be read several times at different ages, but in fact, there is a little bit of attention to age.

Journey to the West can be read at a very young age, and it is more suitable for younger people to read, generally speaking, unless it is engaged in research, as you get older, the interest in the book will become less and less.

Water Margin can also be read at a very young age, and the upper age limit for rereading should be longer than that of "Journey to the West", but interest in this book will decrease with age.

"Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is a book that really has no age limit, if you liked to read it when you were a child, you will generally be interested in it when you grow up. As you grow older and more experienced, your evaluation of the main characters in the Three Kingdoms changes dramatically.

"Dream of Red Mansions" is not suitable for too young children to read, it is difficult to understand, this book is read at different ages, and the perception must be different.

In the past, there was a saying that "the old don't look at the Three Kingdoms, and the young don't look at the Water Margin", thinking that young people are strong in blood, and it is easier to fight bravely and ruthlessly after watching the Water Margin. Although this statement is called "feudal dross", it also reflects the characteristics of these two books from the side, and we should absorb and discard them when we read them.