Please summarize Li Guang and Wei Qing, why one has no merit and reputation, and the other has no me

In history, there were many people who liked Li Guang, avenged Li Guang, and blamed Wei Qing and Emperor Wu of Han for Li Guang's death. In fact, to a large extent, this is influenced by Tang poetry. Because Li Yuan, the founding emperor of the Tang Dynasty, claimed to be a descendant of Li Hao, the king of Xiliang, and Li Hao claimed to be a descendant of Li Guang.

Therefore, Li Guang's deeds were widely circulated in the Tang Dynasty. Singing the praises of Li Guang is actually singing the praises of the emperor. Therefore, Li Guang has no merit and reputation, while Wei Qing has no merit and no reputation.

Li Guang is a hero of tactics.

And Wei Qing is the hero of strategy.

The state relies more on strategists than warriors.

It is true that during the period of Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty, a total of four large-scale wars against the Xiongnu were launched, and Li Guang participated in each time, but he never made any great achievements, and the marquis of the Han Dynasty was determined by the number of heads of the enemy's army, so Li Guang was not allowed to be a marquis. Some people say that it is because Li Guang is unlucky, and he always does not take advantage of the time and place, but Zhuge Liang said that as a general, he does not know astronomy and geography, and he is also a general. I admit Li Guang's personal charm and tactical thinking, but Li Guang is not a strategist, so his merits have never been on the table.

As for Li Guang's reputation, it is largely due to Sima Qian, and the historical records portray Li Guang too perfectly.

It is said that Wei Qing has no reputation, and Wei Qing, as a generation of famous generals who have made great contributions to our nation, has been admired by soldiers of all generations. However, due to his background and the status of his relatives, for a long time, he has not been evaluated objectively and fairly, and some literati always use a magnifying glass to find fault with him, but the picks and turns are only "He Roumei" and "Li Guang's death". But these two have long since been overturned by everyone.

I think Wei Qing's merits are great, and Wei Qing's battle is better than Huo Qu's; Because almost all the battles against the Xiongnu were commanded by Wei Qing, it was only because of some special reasons that Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty elevated Huo Qubing and belittled Wei Qing.

Wei Qing. Because on the one hand, Wei Qing is handsome, while Li Guang is just a general, with different statuses, and on the other hand, although Li Guang is famous, he has repeatedly dropped the chain in key battles.

I think it should be Wei Qing's merits that are greater. Because Wei Qing drove the Xiongnu out of their territory. Very powerful.

Li Guang is a famous general in the Western Han Dynasty in ancient China, the ancestor is the famous general Li Xin during the Qin Dynasty, in 166 BC, Li Guang began to fight against the Xiongnu in the army, because of his military exploits were named Zhonglang.

During the period of Emperor Jing of the Han Dynasty, he successively served as the Taishou of the seven counties in the northern border of the Western Han Dynasty, and when Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty ascended the throne, he was recalled to the palace to serve as the guard of Weiyang Palace.

In 119 BC, Li Guang lost his way on the way to fight against the Xiongnu, lost the best opportunity to attack the Xiongnu, and did not participate in the war, he felt very ashamed, so he committed suicide in anger.

Historical data proves that Li Guang's death has no necessary relationship with Wei Qing.

1. The background of Li Guang's death: Wei Qing knew where the Xiongnu Shan Yu lived, and led the troops to fight, Li Guang volunteered to be the vanguard and fight to the death with Shan Yu, but the general Wei Qing was secretly warned by Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty, thinking that Li Guang was old and had a bad fate, so don't let him fight against Shan Yu. Let Li Guang and the right general march together and attack from the east road, but the east route army lost its way and failed to arrive on time, and he must be held responsible.

2, Li Guang actually died in his own character weakness.

It was Wei Qing who killed him, but he killed him indirectly, you must know that Wei Qing was a general, Li Guang was the vanguard at that time, Li Guang fought countless battles, why did he act so recklessly? It's impossible to think about. It was Wei Qing who sent Li Guang deep into the desert to be isolated, as long as Li Guang was defeated, Wei Qing could play him at Emperor Wu, he still couldn't live, Li Guang definitely wanted to kill himself instead of involving the three clans.

No, the encyclopedia introduces Li Guang as suicidal. "In the fourth year of Yuanzhen, in the battle of Mobei, Li Guang served as a former general, from the general Wei Qing out of the fortress, ordered to detour the Xiongnu single flank, because he lost his way, failed to participate in the war, and committed suicide in shame. ”

No, Li Guang got lost when he was fighting the Huns, delayed the military plane, and was unwilling to face the sword and pen officials afterwards, so he committed suicide.

No, it was that he lost the war and was more ashamed, so he committed suicide.

Indeed, Li Guang's achievements are not as good as Wei Qing's.

Sima Qian, the author of historical records, had a deep friendship with Li Ling, the grandson of Li Guang.

In order to help Li Ling defend himself, he was tortured by the palace.

The reasons for this are self-explanatory.

Because Sima Qian admired Li Guang in the "Historical Records".

The people need and respect Li Guang-style heroes.

First, Li Guang is good at defending and not good at attacking! The second is that Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty only used Li Guang as a bait, and Li Guang led a small number of infantry in the desert to act as a target to lure out the Xiongnu, and most of the elites of Wei Qing and Huo Qubing were annihilated with several times the strength of the Xiongnu! Therefore, if you don't like the leader, you can only do the "dirty work, tiring work, and hard work" in the team of the unit company, and there is no merit only hard work!

Wei Qing and Huo Quzhi are both capable related households.

It should be recommended by Sima Qian's online post!

TV dramas are sometimes made up, and the actual history is Li Guang's greater credit.

Li Guang and Wei Qing.

In contrast, who has the greatest merit? Of the four generals of the Han Dynasty, the other three were young generals except for Li Guang, and they did not face the male belly. Liu Xiao's reasoning made Wei Qing wait, but not only to look at relatives, but he also hoped that he could cultivate a group of Chinese and Jianjian in the Han Dynasty.

The lack of generals to shoot in the Han Dynasty was the biggest pain since the Han Dynasty because of Liu Heng.

Since. The so-called generals are hard, with a little military work. One will work harder, not afraid of thousands of bones, I am afraid that the general will fall. Now, the opportunity is in Wei Qing and so on.

It's too powerful or Lee Guang. In fact, only this important battle, both sides can have a high degree of judgment The future is dark, then you have to rely on your own strength Wei Qing soldiers horses and horses to the market, let go of your hands and feet, and make one. His army is like a madman, it is chasing the Huns.

The male gulls have seen so much, they have seen it, but they have never seen it. In the face of satellite riders, they will only play the essence of the Huns, panic.

Xiongbao ran in front of it, and the big hero of Weiqing was also, riding alone for thousands of miles.

That's Zhang Zilong, Lu Bu.

The risk of Wei Qing is beginning. This chase, chasing Dragon City. Dragon City, the famous castle of the Huns. The male-bellied family sacrificed the dragon god in Dragon City.

So the famous Dragon City. It is close to this Mongolian Eryuan.

of the west side. Wei Qing was a war, and the male belly was taken by Wei Qing's ridiculous army, about 700 people. Seven hundred**, it seems to be a minority.

However, this number is a big number, which is a big number. Of the three young men, he lost the most miserable, more than 7,000 riders who were like meat bags, eliminated. Gong Cun he Bibai brother gong sun slightly folded, the soldier did not fold, but this is not reasonable, it is running.

Gongzhou is still not the worst, it is actually the old Li Guang. Li Guang, the rider did not follow, he was actually caught by the Huns.

Li Guang's exploits naturally cannot be compared with Wei Qing. Li Guang never had the first credit in the war against the Xiongnu, while Wei Qing was the commander of the Han army attacking the Xiongnu, and single-handedly formulated the strategy and tactics of the war against the Xiongnu.

I think Li Guang's merits are greater, both of them are famous generals of the Han Dynasty, and they both made a lot of military exploits for the Han Dynasty, but I think Li Guang's merits are greater.

Wei Qing's offensive performance is a little bigger, because Wei Qing's force value and emotional intelligence are very high, and his dedication and achievements are greater.