Do you think Xiang Yu s defeat was providential?

There are many reasons for this, and there are many reasons for his failure.

At that time, Xiang Yu and Liu Bang raised troops against Qin at the same time. Liu Bang first rejected Xiang Yu according to the Qin capital Xianyang. Xiang Yu annihilated the main force of the Qin soldiers and entered Xianyang with an army of 400,000. At that time, in order to avoid the name of "injustice", he did not use superior forces to eliminate Liu Bang, but was later eliminated by Liu Bang.

History is also contingent, and of course character and fate, a leader often takes into account the attitudes of his subordinates when making major decisions. If there had been a brave military advisor or general by his side at that time who had explained to him the great stakes, I think he might have changed his mind, and the tragedy of history might not have happened.

There is no accident in the world, his failure is only because he is Xiang Yu, just like Liu Bei, who received four of the six famous generals of the Three Kingdoms, and lost to Cao Cao, there is no explanation, and his fate should be like this.

Dale Carnegie once said: 85% of people's success depends on interpersonal communication, and 15% depends on talent!! Xiang Yu has 85% talent, but only 15% interpersonal !!

The main reason for Xiang Yu's failure was soft-heartedness。This reason is incredible, Xiang Yu, the overlord of Western Chu, is a famous general at the end of the Qin Dynasty, and he is also an excellent general who can be ranked in history. But Xiang Yu's character is not as brutal as people say, Xiang Yu's brave appearance hides a true, kind and beautiful heart under the appearance, he has always charged head-on to defeat the enemy on the battlefield, and has never used intrigue and trickery by virtue of his own courage and invincibility, which is his principle of doing things, Liu Bang and Xiang Yu are just the opposite.

As a prince, he has to deal with a lot of things every day, and Xiang Yu does not have the basic qualities of a good leader。Xiang Yu believes that as long as he is good to others, others will obey his leadership, which is a serious mistake in political struggle. When the soldier is sick, Xiang Yu will personally care, and when the soldier is injured, Xiang Yu will personally apply medicine, these behaviors have brought the relationship between Xiang Yu and the soldier closer, but these small favors are insignificant when placed on important people.

Xiang Yu treats his generals without rewarding them for their merits, and they are not punished for their mistakes。He only believes in the people who follow him from Jiangdong, and those who give a lot of opinions to Xiang Yu are not reused, and naturally they will not stay by Xiang Yu's side over time, and Han Xin is one of the important people.

Xiang Yu's soft-heartedness is vividly reflected in the historical event of the Hongmen Banquet. Fan Zeng has reminded Xiang Yu many times that Liu Bang will definitely be Xiang Yu's biggest enemy in the future, if he gets rid of Liu Bang and Xiang Yu at this time, the future road will be smooth, and no one will be able to prevent Xiang Yu from unifying the world. However, Xiang Yu retains the benevolence of a woman in his heart, Liu Bang has not yet shown absolute strength, Xiang Yu believes that he does not pose a threat to himself, he lacks long-term political vision, and lacks the courage to make a decision.

The main reason for Xiang Yu's failure was his soft-heartedness. Xiang Yu thinks that as long as he is good to his subordinates, they will obey his management, and he also takes the initiative to care for the soldiers under him in peacetime, and Xiang Yu also takes the initiative to help with medicine when the soldiers are sick. His soft-heartedness was vividly demonstrated at the Hongmen banquet, Fan Zeng reminded Xiang Yu many times that Liu Bang was Xiang Yu's biggest enemy, but he still felt that Liu Bang could not pose a threat to himself and chose not to be prepared, and finally tragedy.

The biggest reason for Xiang Yu's failure is that he has no strategic vision and does not have the talent to lead.

Although Xiang Yu is brave and invincible, with superb tactics and excellent tactics, he is an "incompetent person" in terms of employing people.

Because Xiang Yu was nepotistic in employing people and could not make the best use of his talents, he lost a military genius like Han Xin, and also lost strategists like Zhang Liang and Fan Zeng. So much so that Xiang Bo, who ate inside and out, finally buried his country.

The main reason for Xiang Yu's failure at that time was because he looked down on Liu Bang. The reason why it is unbelievable is because everyone thinks that Xiang Yu is a smart person and should not look down on others.

Because his management system does not conform to the trend of history, he is too conceited. But his forces are strong and he clearly has a big advantage, so the defeat is even more shocking.

His biggest failure is arrogance, nepotism, not knowing how to use talents to work for himself, and only thinking that as long as he has him, he can make Chu strong.

As I said, you can't sell your name as a learning overlord, which has been explained very clearly. Not to mention specific personal gains and losses, right and wrong, the battle of Julu is a hard battle, who else in the world can match the Chu army? The Chu army group entered Xianyang, and Liu Bang should be destroyed with one blow, and it is advisable to chase after the poor Kou.

I sympathize with Xiang Yu, but I have begun to learn to give up similar views, who told him to be self-respecting and self-respecting. How many things in ancient and modern times are laughing and talking. Again, it is advisable to chase after the poor.

Burning the city and killing people, the devil is one, saying that soft-heartedness is false, arrogance is true.

Xiang Yu is brave and good at fighting, why did he lose to Liu Bang, who has been defeated repeatedly? If you talk about the fierce generals in China's real history, Xiang Yu can definitely be among the best, and the fact that he can slash hundreds of people at every turn is really terrifying, in the cognition of Ma Qian of Taishi Company, only the god of war Chiyou has this ability. However, Xiang Yu was so capable of fighting, and in the end he was defeated and lost to Liu Bang, the ancestor of the Han Dynasty.

Why? In fact, this is not surprising, precisely because Xiang Yu is too capable of fighting, in his own words, it is the one who is attacked, the one who is blocked, and the one who is blocked, and the one who is invincible and the one who is invincible, so he will not take others in his eyes, whether it is Liu Bang or Han Xin, in his eyes Xiang Yu, it is garbage.

However, the three stinkers are better than Zhuge Liang. Liu Bang, Han Xin, Yingbu, Peng Yue and others, maybe they can't fight as much as Xiang Yu when they take it out, and they can't sweep Liuhe like him Xiang Yu, but these people get together and twist into a rope, which is what he Xiang Yu can't beat. What's more, Liu Bang, Han Xin, Yingbu, Peng Yue and others may not be inferior to him.

Take Liu Bang as an example, with one hundred and eighty strong men, he took Pei County without blood, and then possessed Surabaya County, and then advanced westward with the power of partial divisions, successively broke through many cities in Qin, and forced Qin Ziying to surrender, this ability is also strong enough, right?

Later, Liu Bang's soldiers eliminated Hanzhong, quickly returned to Sanqin, and continued to take the east and the capital, Pengcheng, although the battle of Pengcheng failed, but it was always able to hold the front line of Xingyang, Chu and Han fought for four years, Xiang Yu has never been able to enter Liu Bang's hinterland Guanzhong, but Liu Bang's men and horses can continue to make trouble in Xiang Yu's rear, and even in the Chu and Han symbols of the end of the soldiers under Pengcheng. Let's talk about Peng Yue, it looks like a reckless man, but in fact he is a natural leader, he always has to judge the situation, and when he broke Qin, he took the initiative to join Liu Bang and attack the Qin army together, in the Chu and Han conflicts, Peng Yue took refuge in Liu Bang's camp, went straight to Xiang Yu's belly and back, and repeatedly captured Xiang Yu's city to make Xiang Yu exhausted.

As for Han Xin, there is no need to elaborate. He has never lost a battle in his life, and when he confronts Xiang Yu, Xiang Yu can only flee in the embattled singing. And Yingbu, in Liu Bang's later years, made Liu Bang's rock like a rebellion, directly embezzled Liu Bang's uncle and brother Liu Jia's Jing State, forced Liu Bang's fourth brother Liu Jiao to retreat strategically, and had no choice but to make Liu Bang personally conquer Yingbu, Liu Bang's eldest son Liu Fei also led 120,000 Qi troops to help, so that Liu Bang stabilized the basic market.

This pioneer who broke the Qin in the early years, although his ability is not as good as Liu Bang, Han Xin and Peng Yue, is by no means good. With so many people engaging in Xiang Yu together, can Xiang Yuyan be undefeated?

And there are many reasons for his failure, which are mainly divided into internal reasons and external reasons:

From the perspective of internal reasons, Xiang Yu is the pride of the sky, and he soon achieved hegemony, and he is inevitably strong and straightforward, and he has no city. He was too violent after countless battles, and after entering the palace of the King of Qin, he slaughtered and burned unpopularly. The most important thing is that compared to Liu Bang, he lacked political sensitivity, and finally fell into an embattled predicament, in fact, he could cross the Wujiang River and start all over again, but he killed himself just because he had no face to face Jiangdong's father.

From the perspective of external reasons, geographical conditions also have a great impact on the success or failure of the war, Liu Bang, who was named the king of Han, occupies the land of Bashu, these places have good natural conditions, developed economy, and strategic position is also very important.

After Xiang Yu occupied the capital of Qin, he divided these three cities to others, but he took the poor Pengcheng as the capital, this place has always been a place for soldiers to fight, the terrain is flat, easy to attack and difficult to defend.