Do you think TCM is a science? Do you think astrology in the West is science? Why? 10

Men's science, Chinese medicine is something that has been researched in our country for 5,000 years, so it is still very good.

Finally, in a way, very esoteric science. There are a lot of deep truths that are not yet fully understood. Western astrology cannot be compared with him, it can only be said to be pseudoscience.

What is Science? Science is just a discipline equal to Chinese medicine and frames, just a verification method on the road to truth, science is not necessarily positive, correct, so you don't classify everything as science, it can only show that your current thinking is not mature, and your understanding of things itself is still relatively poor.

Traditional Chinese medicine is traditional Chinese medicine, a collateral branch of metaphysics; Astrology is astrology; It has nothing to do with science. Science is a crutch for a blind dimensional creature like a human being. High-level knowledge is like the light of a flashlight, but you are blind and you can't falsify it, and you can't use it directly, so it's not very utilitarian for the blind.

The best thing to use is still the crutch in the hand, which is the most direct, the most down-to-earth, and the most practical.

There is no scientific basis so far, because not everything in the world can be explained by knowledge, I only know that I can understand myself through astrology, and in fact I personally feel quite accurate; There are also people who don't believe it, but it doesn't matter, at least the long history of astrology can prove that it has a certain basis, otherwise it would have been abolished long ago like geocentrism.

There is no scientific basis, and idealism is just a hobby.

First of all, the interpretation of astrology is based on the accumulation of a large number of extensive practical astrolabes, that is, the use of statistics.

The ancients believed that all things are related to each other, so the law can be seen as a small one.

Personalities, events, and stars correspond to countless statistics, and the results of the analysis are obtained.

Secondly, in the process of development, astrology is integrated with a variety of disciplines, including psychology, physical chemistry, and a large number of basic natural sciences.

Orthodox astrology is not actually exclusive to natural science.

Except, of course, those things that are entertaining and fooling people.

Again, astrology is not a so-called divination purpose, and it is also useful in many ways.

For example: psychoanalysis, spiritual upliftment, mathematical research, astronomical research, geographical research, historical significance, chemical and pharmaceutical research, etc.

Finally, the term science does not refer to natural sciences in the narrow sense (e.g., psychology, art, etc., which are not natural sciences), nor is it the evidence-based sciences that are now popular (e.g., Chinese medicine, etc.).

As for the examples, there are too many, turn to the history books yourself, hehe.

In addition, this type of discipline, compared with physical chemistry, only has a different way of explaining problems.

Astrology has no scientific basis. Now astronomers can already know the rules of the hall pants that the brother Sakura is running in dust, and can very correctly ** travel the laws of the movement of the stars. The change of all the celestial phenomena is no longer a mystery.

There is a certain scientific basis for the star sedan chair to accompany the seat. The scientific basis for constellations is the Barnum effect, and the other is the Rosenthal effect. The effect of these two effects on the population is actually the most scientific explanation for the horoscope.

This is actually related to psychology, it is a kind of psychological suggestion, everyone actually doesn't know themselves so well, they can only label themselves, compare them with the horoscope table, this psychological suggestion will make you more and more like the person you want to become, so everyone believes it. I don't know when it began, but the horoscope has slowly infiltrated into our lives. Some people believe in horoscopes, while others scoff at them.

Seepage erection. The scientific principles of constellations.

Many people think that horoscopes are superstitious, but in fact, there is a certain scientific truth in the constellation theory, because the important organs of the fetus, the brain, eyes, spine, limbs and everything begin to develop within three months of pregnancy, which largely determines the quality of the born baby. These three months are more conducive to the development of these organs if they fall in the summer, and not so well in the winter.

It is also true that the best people in the mid-latitudes of the Northern Hemisphere usually have more birthdays in the first half of the year, and the opposite is true in the Southern Hemisphere, and the closer to the equator, the smaller the difference caused by such birthdays. The vast majority of Nobel laureates in the United States have birthdays in the first half of the year.

The climate in the south is good, and birth in the second half of the year will not affect the development of the fetus, so there is a saying that southerners are smarter than northerners. Since this is the case, it seems that there is still some truth in dividing people's personalities according to constellations.

In the eyes of some people, planets and zodiac signs have some kind of relationship with people's personalities, fates, and even a few minutes apart when two people are born will be different. For others, there is no essential difference between astrology and fortune telling. However, the reality is:

The more educated students and white-collar workers, the more popular "astrology" becomes.

This collision of astronomical and astrological perspectives is not the first time in the history of science, and it will never be the last. Astronomer Zhu Jin has used the word "nonsense" many times, but it does not eliminate the doubts in people's minds. Over the past few decades, a series of new discoveries in psychology, physiology, medicine, and earth sciences have only opened up more possibilities, and these discoveries have also suggested that astronomy alone is far from sufficient to prove or falsify astrology.

In English, astrology has the same root word as astronomy. Astronomy can also be combined well with astrology – astronomy can count all the constellations in the sky at the time of a person's birth, as well as the positions of the sun, moon, and planets. Or rather, a person's astrolabe.

And the astrolabe is the beginning of astrology.

Astrology began around 2500 BC. At the heart of its assertion is the connection between the celestial bodies and the human being—in the context of Greek philosophy's two-hundred-year inquiry into the universe and the soul.

According to Aristotle's summary in The Treatise on the Soul, the question of the soul begins with the nature of the soul. At that time, it was believed that the reason why man is human and the soul is soul is because the soul can cause movement and move the body with its own movements. This is the starting principle.

The second principle can be called the principle of perception. Philosophers believe that the soul is able to perceive all things because there are elements in the soul that are identical to the natural elements.

The astrologer's belief in the existence of some kind of cosmic unity comes largely from Plato. Plato said in the Timaeus: "The heavenly bodies are visible, but the soul is not."

The soul is the embodiment of reason and harmony. The way it works is to silently follow its own movements, acting on everything with the same precision. ”

The most obvious question about astrology is: different people are divided into 12 zodiac signs, and there are 7 billion people in the world, are there so many people who are the same? In the eyes of professional astrologers, this question is raised because of a misunderstanding of astrology.

Horoscope is a category of 'news posture or science', not of astrology. "Horoscopes are like our entertainment news – gossip news has nothing to do with astrology. "Serious astrology uses the Sun, Moon, and planets, not just general constellations.

The point that astronomy has questioned the most is also related to horoscopes. Astrology uses 12 constellations located on the ecliptic, and there is a concept called "precession" in astrology, which is the periodic oscillation of the Earth's axis of rotation. Due to the existence of precession, the constellations on the zodiac are no longer 12 as thousands of years ago, but 13, and there is an extra ophiuchus.

How can we explain the fact that the zodiac signs are still used in astrology?

Astrology has always been regarded as a pseudoscience, but all kinds of astrology have spread for thousands of years, and even spread all over the world, and there must be something worth scrutinizing. At the end of the 20th century, chaos theory was established, and astrology finally found a way to be scientifically explained.