Guan Yu defeated Maicheng, and when Liu Bei burned down the camp, what was Zhuge Liang doing, why di

Updated on history 2024-02-22
12 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    The problem of distance, coupled with the fact that the rout was too fast, would not be able to rescue Zhuge Liang unless he had modern means of communication and transportation.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    There are two main reasons for this:1. Political intentions.

    After the battle of Hanzhong, Liu Bei's strength reached its peak, and Liu Bei's strength, which occupied Yizhou and one-third of Jingzhou's territory, faintly surpassed the signs of Eastern Wu, and the situation of Eastern Wu was very embarrassing, and the second strongest immediately became the end of the old man, and the Nanjun that Guan Yu had been occupying was in the upper reaches of the Yangtze River, which had always caused pressure and hidden dangers to the downstream Eastern Wu.

    The alliance is built on the same strength and foundation, when Liu Bei is stronger than Sun Quan, it is necessary for Sun Quan to plan for the development of Eastern Wu in the future, taking Jingzhou and killing Guan Yu is undoubtedly the best way to attack Liu Bei.

    2, blame Cao Cao.

    Sun Quan killed Guan Yu to divert Liu Bei's contradictions and blame Cao Cao. Sun Quan's mind is more than Cao Cao and Liu Bei, and the capture of Jingzhou will inevitably make Liu Bei angry and ashamed, killing Guan Yu can give the head to Cao Cao, so that Liu Bei can vent his anger on Cao Cao's side, but unfortunately Cao Cao saw through it, Cao Cao buried Guan Yu with the gift of princes, and Cao Cao was a step higher than Sun Quan.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    It's not that he can't save it, but he can't save it, and he didn't expect Guan Yu to lose. At that time, the news of Guan Yu's victory kept coming, and Liu Bei didn't expect Guan Yu to be defeated at all. Moreover, at that time, Liu Bei's army was far away from Jingzhou, and there were troops from Eastern Wu blocking it along the way, so it was impossible to rescue Jingzhou.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    It was because Guan Yu was surrounded by a lot at that time, and the news that he was trapped could not be sent, Liu Bei could not know it at the first time, and Liu Bei was far away from Guan Yu, and it was too late to rescue.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Because Liu Bei was far away in Yizhou at that time, very far away from Jingzhou, Liu Bei didn't know the news at that time, so he didn't rescue Guan Yu.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Zhuge Liang didn't have time to rescue, because the transportation and communication in ancient times were not developed, Guan Yu's defeat was very fast, and Lu Meng chased after him, even if he sent troops immediately after receiving the battle report, it was too late to rescue Guan Yu.

  7. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    It's not that he can't be saved when he sees death, but the distance between Maicheng and Chengdu is too far away, and Zhuge Liang can't know it at the first time.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    When Guan Yu defeated Maicheng, Zhuge Liang was in Yizhou, and the news could not reach Zhuge Liang's ears.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    At the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty, the princes were in dispute, and the beacon fire was endless. In this era of turmoil in the Central Plains and turmoil in the four provinces, the people of the lower classes are not living well, and the rooms are empty, but for heroes with great talents, it is a good opportunity to leave a name in history. In this era of heroes and talents, Wei, Shu, and Wu all have their own proud generals.

    But there are also fierce generals who stumble and return defeated, and those who are lucky can continue to walk, and those who are unlucky may be isolated.

    Recently, someone asked Guan Yu about the defeat of Maicheng, and once passed a book to Zhuge Liang, why did Zhuge Liang not send troops? In fact, on this issue, as long as you know a little bit about the history of the Three Kingdoms, you know that Guan Yu was already in an ambush on all sides at that time, and no matter how much he saved, he could not be saved. Even if Zhuge Liang was like a god and immediately sent troops after learning about the situation, he would suffer from Lu Xun's army stationed on the road.

    Let's not talk about whether Zhuge Liang's army can fight in the face of Lu Xun's army, just talking about the time it takes for them to fight, it can't save Guan Yu, who was defeated in Maicheng and ambushed by Eastern Wu on all sides. In fact, Dongwu sent people to make peace, but Guan Yu looked down on Lu Meng so much, and a general of Dongwu formed a personal feud with Guan Yu, which led to the story later.

    If you go directly to send troops to rescue, it will definitely not work, and it has been mentioned before that on the road where Zhuge Liang sent troops to Maicheng, there will be Lu Xun's army waiting there. At this time, Zhuge Liang had to think of other ways, then another way was to let Liu Feng and Meng Da lead the army to support Guan Yu, but if they did so, they would lose the three counties of Shangyong.

    Of course, it's nothing to lose the three counties of Shangyong, after all, compared to this, it is naturally Guan Yu who is more important, how to say that it is also the life and death brother of their lord Liu Bei, if Zhuge Liang is not saved when he knows that he can be saved, then it will only be Zhuge Liang who will bear the blame.

    But the problem is that even if Liu Feng and Meng Da really led the army to Maicheng to rescue Guan Yu, they would not know the direction of Guan Yu's location, if they really wanted to find the exact location of Guan Yu's location, then they had to equip Guan Yu with a locator? It can be said that when Guan Yu defeated Maicheng at that time, the situation in Jingzhou was already quite a crisis, and it was basically impossible to hold it or save Guan Yu. Now the only two ways don't work, so what awaits Guan Yu is only death.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    It's because they're a little far away, and Shu doesn't have enough troops to support.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    If there is **, Zhuge Liang will definitely rescue, but in ancient times, he could only send horses, Jingzhou to Chengdu, and it would take a few days to go back and forth, and when Zhuge Liang knew the news, Guan Yu would have been cold for a long time.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    No, because the distance between the two places is only 20 miles, he didn't rescue because it was too late.

Related questions
26 answers2024-02-22

There are several reasons why Guan Yu failed to get assistance from Maicheng: >>>More