Why is there a Diao Chan in Guan Yu s tomb, and who is the other female corpse in the tomb?

I don't know where to start with this question. First of all, the character of Diao Chan is fictional from "Romance of the Three Kingdoms". Therefore, this problem must start with Diao Chan to understand a little.

Diao Chan's historical prototype is a slave maid in Dong Zhuo's mansion, and of course it is understandable to be a concubine. Because Lu Bu had an affair with him, he was discovered by Dong Zhuo, and Dong Zhuo almost killed Lu Bu for this. This incident directly led to Lu Bu finally betraying Dong Zhuo, throwing himself into Wang Yun's banner, and finally killing Dong Zhuo.

And in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", Wang Yun's serial plan and Diao Chan's maneuvering between Dong Zhuo and Lu Bu are all fictional based on the above historical events. <>

Since there is no such person as Diao Chan in history, how can Guan Yu be buried with Diao Chan in the tomb? I'm afraid that this is still a folk legend, based on Guan Yu's Shenyong in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" and Lu Bu's death after Diao Chan had no follow-up, so some people made it up again, Diao Chan was killed by Guan Yu, and of course some people made it up, Diao Chan was accepted as a concubine by Cao Cao.

So the first half of this question may be based on the folklore of "Cao Cao took Diao Chan as a concubine", thinking that after Guan Yu's death, because the head was sent to Cao Cao, and Guan Yu was Cao Cao's favorite general, Cao Cao killed Diao Chan to bury Guan Yu.

But even so, can it be consummated? It's simply impossible! Because this has made Cao Cao and Guan Yu change from heroes or traitors to dirty villains.

Cao Cao didn't even want to be buried alive when he died, but warned his wife and concubine: If you don't have a place to go, you will live in Tongquetai and work as a female worker or something. <>

Not to mention Guan Yu, he died miserably enough, his head was here with Cao Cao, and his body was with Sun Quan, but he also arranged a "Diao Chan burial" for him, what kind of logic is this? It doesn't make sense at all.

After talking about the issue of Diao Chan, let's take a look at "Another Female Corpse in Guan Yu's Tomb". According to historical records, there are three tombs of Guan Yu, and Cao Cao established one, which is the most famous "Guan Ling". Guan Yu's hometown of Jiezhou, Shanxi, built a "clothed mound".

Liu Bei of Shu Han also built a "clothed mound". Which Guan Yu's tomb was excavated and the two female corpses were found? Didn't say it either!

However, from this problem, another problem is involved: some people say that the Qinglong Yanyue Knife was unearthed in Guan Yu's tomb! It must be known that Guan Yu in history is not the "Qinglong Yanyue Knife" used at all, because this weapon has only appeared since the Song Dynasty, so it is a fiction of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms".

So just like "the two female corpses in Guan Yu's tomb", they all seem inexplicable. <>

There are three tombs of Guan Yu, two of which are empty and are just "clothes mounds", only in this Guan Mausoleum established by Cao Cao, there is a head of Guan Yu. It can't be said that it was found in those two "clothed mounds", right? It can only be this Guan Ling.

It's a pity that the author has read the information of Guanling for a long time, and there has never been such a record. Even if it happened a long time ago, who traveled through the past? One has no one to travel through the past, and the other is no historical record, so this matter can only be passed down by word of mouth to the present, which is nothing more than a folk legend.

Therefore, the author can only answer this question: there will be no Diao Chan in Guan Yu's tomb to be buried, and the other one will never be Diao Chan.

I don't know who the other female corpse is, in fact, there is no Diao Chan in history, Diao Chan is just a fictional character in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" and other **, and the official history is not as described in **, as for who the other female corpse is, there is no way to know.

Because Guan Yu particularly loves Diao Chan, Diao Chan was buried with him after Guan Yu's death, and the other female corpse in the tomb was Guan Yu's wife.

It should be his wife, Diao Chan likes Lu Bu, so much time has passed, and we can't guess whether it is Diao Chan in Guan Yu's tomb.

Because this is a gift from Cao Cao, and the other entity is his original wife before his death, this is the identity of the two people.

I don't think it can be Diao Chan, because many practical factors determine that Guan Yu can't be buried with Diao Chan. As for some of the reasons, let's briefly analyze them below.

First of all, there is no specific information about Diao Chan in history, she may be a character made up for the storyline in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. In fact, we all know that there is a character Diao Chan from some opera programs or the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, and the actual history books have never left a word for Diao Chan. You must know that if it was really Wang Yun who gave Diao Chan to Dong Zhuo and caused Lu Bu to rebel, then Diao Chan would leave a little information in the historical records of Liliang Shirt.

Since there is no record of Diao Chan in history, I feel that Diao Chan may not exist in history, and naturally it is impossible to be buried with Guan Yu.

Secondly, the description of Diao Chan in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is also very limited, and Diao Chan has also been possessed by Dong Zhuo and Lu Bu, so it stands to reason that he is not worthy of Guan Yu's identity. Assuming that there is really a Diao Chan person in history, she did play a role in the confrontation between Dong Zhuo and Lu Bu as described in **, but it is impossible to be buried with Guan Yu. You must know that people at that time paid great attention to their own honor, and some people were even willing to die in order to preserve their honor.

And Guan Yu is naturally a person who attaches great importance to his own reputation, but Diao Chan has been owned by Dong Zhuo and Lu Bu, even if he really followed Guan Yu later, he is not worthy of Guan Yu in terms of name, and it is impossible to be buried with Guan Yu.

In the end, the two corpses in Guan Yu's tomb were dressed very ordinarily, and they did not match Diao Chan's identity. Even if there is really a person like Diao Chan, and the issue of fame is not considered, then when the two are buried together, Diao Chan should be dressed up beautifully. But the two corpses in Guan Yu's tomb were just wearing ordinary clothes, and they didn't even have any jewelry, which also didn't match Diao Chan's identity.

Yes, I feel like it's Diao. But now there really isn't any evidence to be sure, it's speculation.

I don't think so, Diao Chan's corpse will definitely not appear in Guan Yu's tomb, this statement has no scientific basis.

It is very likely that one of them is Diao Chan, because these experts have looked through a lot of information and determined that the identity of one of them is Diao Chan.

It is very likely that it was just tomb robbers, because the time of their death was not a single period, and the difference was very large, so there was such a speculation.

The identities of the two female corpses have not yet been clarified, some say they are Diao Chan, some say they are two tomb robbers.

The identities of the two female corpses in Guan Yu's tomb have been a mystery so far, although experts have been researching, but have not found the true identity of the female corpses.

No, it should be Cao Cao's yin kiss for him.

In the history of ancient tombs in China, the tomb of Guan Yu is definitely as legendary as his owner. Unlike other emperors, Guan Yu did not build his own tomb, and the current Guan Yu tomb was built for him by later generations. In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Guan Yu is a hero admired by everyone, whether it is Cao Cao or Sun Quan, they all respect Guan Yu.

It doesn't have to do with Guan Yu, maybe it was just put in when the descendants buried Guan Yu.

I think they should have made the tomb robbers, but unfortunately they were killed by the mechanism inside.

It was supposed to be a tomb robber, who touched the mechanism inside while robbing the tomb.

I think it's a tomb robber from the Three Kingdoms who touched the mechanism, couldn't get out, and starved to death.

The two of them were tomb robbers, and they died because they touched the mechanism in Guan Yu's tomb.

After expert research, the two women guessed that they were not buried, and it was possible that the tomb robbers were accidentally killed by the authorities.

Big room, second room or his sister and.

It is the corpse of Big and Small Joe when he was a child.

It's his mom and his sister. Hahaha.

The "two female bones" in Cao Cao's tomb are neither Diao Chan nor Xiao Qiao. Diao Chan disappeared after the city of Chang'an was broken. Xiao Qiao has been widowing Zhou Yu in Jiangdong. It could not be the female bones in Cao Cao's tomb.

The bones in Cao Cao's tomb belong to three people, one man and two women. One of the males naturally thought that it was Cao Cao, the owner of the tomb. As for the discussion of the two female bones, there are different opinions.

And because the age measurement of older women does not match the age of death of Bian (Cao Cao's stepwife) in the literature, it has become a major supporting argument for the tomb dumping faction. As for the identification of young women, there is little to say. Some think that it is an ordinary maid, and it may be a martyrdom; Some say that it is a female bodyguard; There is speculation that it is Mrs. Huan, the mother of Cao Chong; Some think that it is Cao Cao's young concubine.

But these claims have no basis and are not supported by other parties, so they can only be said.

Day·· Finally looking for his tomb? I don't know if I've been stolen??? View the original post