If Guan Yu reuses someone, he will not lose Maicheng, and history may be rewritten?

If Guan Yu could reuse his righteous son Guan Ping at that time and give full play to his military talents, Guan Yu would not have failed in the end because of a small wheat cityIt is really a regrettable thing for contemporary people, in the Three Kingdoms period, Guan Yu is a famous general who everyone loves very much, he is not only very upright but also very brave and good at fighting, but the final outcome is also, some regret to everyone.

1. Guan Yu's own defects in the Maicheng War

And Guan Yu's historical deeds are also very popular for everyone to discuss, because there is basically no defeat about Guan Yu, and the last one is in Maicheng, in Maicheng is also because Guan Yu is a little older, and it is also because his famous horse has some physical exhaustion, plus when attacking the city tower, the last person on the defensive line suddenly took refuge in the enemy, so Guan Yu suffered from the enemy on his back, and finally defeated Manchester City, which is also a very bad thing.

2. The defenders of Jingzhou rebelled

Guan Yu was already suffering from the enemy in the Battle of Maicheng, and he originally wanted to retreat to Jingzhou and fight a battle with the enemy, but he was suddenly told that the second-hand personnel in Jingzhou had defected to the enemy, and Guan Yu has no way to retreat to Jingzhou to recuperate, and Guan Yu is also very regretful, regretting that he did not seriously choose the right person to guard the very important pass of Jingzhou, which is actually not Guan Yu's mistake, after all, some people are very good at disguising themselves.

In people's common concept of history, many heroes in history have to use some talents because they are not correct, which leads to their own bad situation in the endIn fact, this also tells us to seriously polish our eyes, make good use of everyone's advantages, and the correct use of people is actually a very important ability, and these historical stories have given us some more or less lessons.

At that time, if Guan Yu reused Liaohua, history might be rewritten, this person was very smart, and his strategy was also superb, and the previous fraudulent death also convinced many people.

In fact, I think the direction of history is predestined, even if Guan Yu's battle is really won because of the reuse of someone, other things will happen in the future to make history repeat.

Guan Yu is too arrogant, even if he reuses it, he will not listen to the strategies of the people next to him, and there are so many generals who study Guan Yu's character and seize his weaknesses to attack him.

It's hard to say, Guan Yu's character is the same, who is reused now, maybe it will still become in the future, and accidents will happen.

Because Guan Yu was very arrogant to the scholars, Mi Fang and Shiren were resentful of Guan Yu and did not take care to help Guan Yu, so that Guan Yu was defeated and took Maicheng.

Guan Yu has always been kind to the soldiers, but he is very arrogant to the scholars. Mi Fang and Shiren have always hated Guan Yu's contemptuous attitude. When Guan Yu led the troops to the battle, Mi Fang and Shiren were responsible for the first grain and grass military supplies, and the two did not care to help Guan Yu.

Guan Yu released his words and said, "After you go back, you will punish them!" When Mi Fang and Shiren heard this, they were all terrified. When Sun Quan heard about it, he secretly sent people to lure Mi Fang and Shiren down.

Sun Quan ordered Lü Meng to attack Jingzhou as the commander-in-chief, and personally led the army as a backup. The important town of Jingzhou, Jiangling, guarded general Elfang, and the public security guard Shiren surrendered without a fight because they had a disagreement with Guan Yu.

At this time, after Guan Yu learned that Nanjun was lost, he immediately retreated south. On the way back to the division, Guan Yu sent envoys to contact Lü Meng many times, and Lü Meng treated Guan Yu's envoys well each time, allowed various tours in the city, and expressed condolences to the relatives of Guan Yu's subordinates.

When the envoy returned, Guan Yu's subordinates privately asked him about the situation at home, knowing that the family was safe, and he was treated more than before, so Guan Yu's soldiers had no intention of fighting again, and the soldiers gradually dispersed and retreated to Maicheng.

In December of the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an, Guan Yu led more than ten horsemen to escape, all the way to Linfang, which was only one or twenty miles away from Yizhou, and was ambushed by Ma Zhong, the general of Pan Zhang's department, and was captured, and his eldest son Guan Ping was killed in Linfang.

Guan Yu's story:

In the nineteenth year of Jian'an, when Liu Bei attacked Luocheng, the military advisor Pang Tong was killed, and Liu Bei called Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun, and Zhuge Liang into Sichuan to support. Guan Yu was stationed in Jingzhou. After Liu Bei pacified Shu, he supervised Jingzhou affairs with Guan Yu Dong, and authorized him to take charge of the parts controlled by Liu Bei in the Jingzhou area, including the four southern counties of Jingzhou and Jiangling, the southern county administrative office borrowed from Eastern Wu, and the nearby public security.

Guan Yu actually guarded the five counties of Jingzhou. Zhuge Liang, Fa Zheng, Zhang Fei, and Guan Yu each rewarded **500 catties, **1,000 catties, 50 million coins, and 1,000 brocade silks.

Guan Yu heard that Ma Chao had surrendered to Liu Bei, and he didn't know Ma Chao in the past, so he wrote to Zhuge Liang and asked who Ma Chao's martial arts talent could be compared with.

Zhuge Liang knew that Guan Yu was arrogant, so he replied: "Ma Mengqi has both civil and military qualities, fierce and outstanding, can be described as a generation of handsome heroes, belonging to the category of Duo Bu and Peng Yue, and can be kept abreast of Zhang Yide, but not as good as your beautiful bearded prince." "Guan Yu has a beautiful long beard, so Zhuge Liang calls him a beautiful beard.

After reading Zhuge Liang's reply, Guan Yu was very happy and handed it over to the guest staff for circulation.

Guan Yu violated Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang's Longzhong countermeasures, and the most important decision and deployment of Longzhong's countermeasures was to connect Sun Quan externally to counter Cao Cao, and to repair political principles internally to gather strength; When there is a change in the world, he ordered a general to march the army of Jingzhou to Cao Wei, and Liu Bei's handsome troops set off from Qinzhou and marched towards Wei.

At that time, I think that there was a change in the world, which was a large-scale war between Wu and Wei, but this did not happen at that time, but there have always been small-scale military wars between Shu and Wei. After Guan Yu won the war against Cao Ren and Yu Ban, he underestimated the international situation at that time and rashly marched, resulting in the emptiness of Jingzhou's troops and leaving an opportunity for Eastern Wu to take advantage of.

There is also Guan Yu himself who is proud of his talents, and he punished Liu Bei's brother-in-law Mi Fang if he was not satisfied with it, just because he did not do a good job of grain and grass before leaving the army, Guan Yu threatened to win and come back to clean him up, which caused Mi Fang's resentment towards Guan Yu, and what was even more terrible was that Guan Yu also handed over his rear to Mi Fang, and as soon as the Eastern Wu army entered the city, Mi Fang surrendered.

Guan Yu's personality traits:

1. Loyalty. Guan Yu's loyalty mainly reflects that since he followed Liu Bei, he has never left and lived and died. Cao Cao increased the reward and wanted to keep him, but after Guan Yu learned of Liu Bei's whereabouts, he immediately sealed the gold seal and followed Liu Bei.

2. Arrogance. Guan Yu looked down on Cao Ren and insisted on marching into Fancheng, but he attacked for more than half a year but did not capture it. Guan Yu looked down on Pound, who was carrying the coffin and fighting to the death, but on the battlefield, he was shot in the arm by Pound with an arrow, and had to go back to the camp to rest, hanging up the exemption card.

3. Arrogance. Liu was named the king of Hanzhong, and Guan Yu was very dissatisfied that Huang Zhong was also named the 5 tiger generals after learning that he and Zhang Fei, Ma Chao, and Huang Zhong were named generals, obviously arrogant.

4. Love soldiers. As a general, Guan Yu can treat soldiers sincerely, which is rare in the late Eastern Han Dynasty, which emphasizes the concept of hierarchy. It is precisely because Guan Yu loves and treats soldiers well that he can lead the army well and become dominant for a while.

Guan Yu was a hero all his life, but in the end he was defeated and took Maicheng, no one to save him, not to mention that all parties wanted to win over Guan Yu's strength, just saying that no one in the Shu State camp to save was an accident but it was also reasonable, which can be seen from the following aspects:

Clause. First, no one to save is related to Guan Yu's personal quality, to a certain extent, Guan Yu belongs to the foolish loyalty, only loyal to Liu Bei, not loyal to the great cause of Shu, Guan Yu is brave and good at fighting, no one can match, there is no doubt about it, but he himself is in front of many major rights and wrongs, brotherhood is higher than the great cause of Shu, in other words, the great cause of Shu needs to give way to Liu Guanzhang and the three of them, brotherhood took pictures before the Jiangshan Sheji of Shu, it is because of this character, Guan Yu invisibly offended many people, It's just because he is Liu Bei's sworn brother, so in the same camp he did not show obvious anti-Guan Yu or disobedient voice of Guan Yu, on the other hand, Guan Yu has a brilliant and undefeated record in his life, so no matter from the situation of worship or flattery, Guan Yu will not have an accident, and when Guan Yu really has an accident, those people in the Shu camp have a reason not to save Guan Yu in any way, which Liu Bei is also powerless, which is also the sad part of Guan Yu's heroic life.

Clause. Second, put aside the great cause of Shu, just talk about brotherhood, no matter when Taoyuan is married, no matter if any of the three brothers have an accident, the other two will be rescued thousands of miles away, but Guan Yu defeated Maicheng at the same time Liu Bei was burned by Lu Xun and was unable to save, Zhang Fei guarded Langzhong, that is, the place where Brazil County was governed, and Zhuge Liang at this time was in Chengdu, more than 1,500 miles apart, no matter which route could not be rescued, the heart was strong and the rest was insufficient.

Clause. 3. At that time, the information dissemination was not developed, and it was estimated that the news was received from Chengdu, and Guan Yu had not yet been sent to rescue Guan Yu had been killed, so Guan Yu was defeated and no one could save Maicheng, which was both a certain number and a fate, and he was grieving and whining.

Because the transmission of information was not developed in ancient times, he was already dead when others received the information, so there was no one to save him.

Liu Bei didn't expect that Sun Quan would betray the alliance at this time, so Guan Yu's defeat at that time did not reach Liu Bei's army. Guan Yu was killed in Linfu to Chengdu, more than a thousand kilometers. According to the current road conditions, it will take half a month to hike. So Liu Bei didn't have time to save Guan Yu.

Because the war was urgent at that time, it was an emergency, and others had no time to go to the rescue.

<> Guan Yu is brave and good at fighting, righteous and loyal, but he has some character shortcomings, such as arbitrariness, arrogance and self-confidence, and he is so happy with his achievements and his eyes are too high. Guan Yurusi's temperament is short, and it will not be fatal to the generals who lead the troops, but for the commanders who open up the territory and expand the territory, he will kill him.

Guan Yu's lonely Northern Expedition went from a great victory to a defeat, and even a bad reputation, and his head was different, all of which had a great deal to do with his arrogant temperament, overdoing things and carelessness. Despite Guan Yu's strengths and weaknesses, his loyalty is still remembered by future generations.

When Zhuge Liang entered Sichuan to support Liu Bei and handed over Jingzhou to Guan Yu, he repeatedly instructed Guan Yu to have a good relationship with Eastern Wu. Guan Yu agreed on the surface, but in fact he didn't pay attention to the relationship with Eastern Wu at all, and finally provoked Sun Quan to make up his mind to attack Jingzhou with his arrogance. As a result, Jingzhou was lost, and he was defeated and died.

The lack of principle and short-sightedness lead to the delay of fighters and affect the overall situation. Guarding Jingzhou, Sun Quan originally intended to be friendly, but Guan Yu said, my tiger girl can match your dog! caused Wu Shu to turn against each other and start a war, and Guan Yu himself was discredited because of this, and his life was not guaranteed, but it's a pity!

If Guan Yu escapes from Maicheng, history will not be rewritten. The reason is that Guan Yu has lost Jingzhou, and the people and horses have been lost, just like the eagle that has plucked its feathers, it has also reached a certain age, no longer young, and often has arrow wounds**, although he has lost his sharpness when he was young, but with Guan Yu's character, he will definitely attack Wu Guo like Liu Bei's opinion, and he will never persuade Liu Bei to endure this breath for the time being, and then try Jingzhou when the opportunity is ripe, Guan Yu is known for his pride, there is no doubt about this.

Guan Yu lost Jingzhou, even if he fled back, it may not be able to change the division of the Three Kingdoms. Guan Yu is just one person, and Jingzhou can have a large number of troops and resources, and it is a place where soldiers must fight.

Regarding although he is proud and complacent, there is no one in his eyes, and Jingzhou is lost by mistake, but Jin is barefoot, and no one is perfect. Guan Shengren's achievements are high, his achievements are brilliant, and his righteousness is thin and cloudy, and his great shining point is still in the history of China for thousands of years, and it will last forever.

The disadvantage is that Guan Yu is particularly proud and complacent. If the ending is changed, it will definitely be rewritten, because Guan Yu is a brave and resourceful person, and if this shortcoming is changed, it will be very powerful.

Guan Yu is too arrogant, if it is rewritten, the ending will definitely be the same, because Guan Yu is not only arrogant in this matter, but also may fail in other things.

This disadvantage is pride. If this shortcoming is changed, the ending will also be rewritten, and the ending of Shu Han will also change.

Guan Yu is too arrogant and self-serving.

Guan Yu, the word cloud is long, Hedong Jieren (now southwest of Linyi, Shandong), is a famous general of Shu during the Three Kingdoms period, and is respected by the world as the "martial saint", and Confucius is equally famous.

Guan Yu was born in the lower class society, since he was a child, he was as evil as a child, at the age of 19, he came to Jiezhou City from Xia Feng Village, and wanted to ask to see the county guard to express his ambition to serve the country. There he met Han Shouyi, killed the bully Lu Xiong in the city, and rescued the girl in the city.

After that, he fled to another country overnight, and when he encountered the officers and soldiers guarding the pass, in a hurry, he pointed to the pass and said that his surname was Guan. After being exiled to Zhuo County, it happened to meet the Eastern Han Dynasty to suppress the Yellow Turban Uprising. He met Liu Bei and Zhang Fei here, and the three were like-minded and became brothers of the opposite sex.

In the twenty-fourth year of Han Jian'an, Shu general Guan Yu was intercepted by Wu General when he defeated Maicheng, and was beheaded in Linfang. Later"Go to the wheat city"Yu is in a desperate situation.

In the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an in the Eastern Han Dynasty (219 AD), the Shu general Guan Yu lost Jingzhou and retreated to Maicheng, where he performed a tragedy through the ages. Maicheng is famous at home and abroad.