Three Kingdoms If Guan Yu hadn t died so early, wouldn t Shu have perished so early

Right! If Guan Yu didn't die, Zhang Fei wouldn't be angry, he would fight soldiers every day, and he would be killed by his generals in the end, and Liu Bei wouldn't beat Wu, so Shu wouldn't have perished too early, all of this was caused by Wu.

It shouldn't be, the demise of a country lies in its mechanism and political team and economic strength, in many aspects, even if it doesn't die early, it will die that night, I think it is still problematic to have Zhuge Liang's political team as the theme, and there is no mechanism to reserve talents, so you can only wait quietly for its demise.

There is no if, if this is the case, in Chibi back then, Guan Yu directly killed Cao Cao, and Liu Bei would dominate the world. But that's only if.

It's possible. Any small change can make a big difference. If Guan Yu doesn't die, Zhang Fei won't die, Zhang Fei won't die, Liu Bei won't act rashly, and of course he will survive for a few more years.

Inexistent..

This is an inevitable trend of history.

Because Liu Chan is simply a mediocre emperor.

Hehe Very interesting question If according to the normal development of the Three Kingdoms, Guan Yu did not defeat Maicheng It is very possible that Shu will persist for a few years or even decades I think this matter is mainly due to the short-sightedness of the Sun and Wu regimes In the early stage, although Zhou Yu and Zhuge Liang played a lot of tricks, they were always only on the back, because he knew that the alliance of Wu and Shu was the general trend, and only by uniting could they fight against Cao Wei; After Zhou Yu's death, Lu Su took over the governor, and the problem of Jingzhou was delayed again and again, although hidden dangers were buried, but on the whole it can be said to be a honeymoon period with Shu; But after Lu Su's death, Lü Meng took over, and in order to regain the face of Jingzhou and Sun Quan, he united with Cao Wei, which led to a series of events in the future. But Shu will eventually die, regardless of the lack of talents in the later period of Shu, it is only said that the war potential at that time was mainly population and land, and Shu will collapse sooner or later.

Guan Yu is a very important figure in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, and he is also a very famous general in history. But Guan Yu did not have a good ending in the end, and it can even be said that he died very tragically.

Guan Yu died so miserably mainly for the following reasons:

1.Guan Yu's own personality reasons. Guan Yu has an arrogant personality and only serves those who are stronger than himself.

So, he looked down on his subordinates and others and didn't show enough respect. Because of his personality, he is very easy to offend people. Guan Yu only serves heroes, who can fight better than him, who is more righteous than him, he admires.

It is precisely because of his character that he offended almost everyone except for his own righteous son and cronies Zhou Cang. Then this is also the reason why no one rescued Guan Yu after he was defeated and left Maicheng, and Liu Feng, Meng Da and others even fell to the ground.

2.Although the individual ability is very outstanding, but the ability to fight as a team is not available. Because Guan Yu's own ability is too prominent, so that he can't find an opponent at all, in his eyes, he only recognizes ability, and he can only look at anyone who can fight with him, if all aspects of ability are below him, he doesn't disdain it at all.

And because Guan Yu's ability is too strong, he and other generals can't go together at all, which also leads to the weakening of the team's ability. Therefore, Guan Yu died miserably in the end because he couldn't integrate into the collective, no matter how strong his individual ability was, he couldn't resist a strong enemy.

3.Mistakes in strategic decision-making, too light on the battlefield. The reason why Guan Yu died so miserably in the end was also because of the mistake of strategic decision-making, which led to the defeat of the war, and also caused Guan Yu to fall into the hands of the enemy.

Moreover, because Guan Yu's ability was very strong, he did not attach importance to the enemy and despised the enemy too much, so it led to the defeat of the war and also caused Guan Yu to die very tragically. A very large part of Guan Yu's tragic death was because of himself, he became arrogant because of his strong ability, and he didn't pay attention to the enemy.

I think the main reason why he died for so long is that his overall strength is very strong, and he is too loyal and patriotic, this kind of Zhongjun thinking makes other people very dissatisfied with him, and he did not change his mind after he was defeated and captured, so he died so miserably, because no one wants a person who is not loyal to him.

The reason why he died so miserably in the end was because he was careless, gullible to the slander of some people, and did not grasp the relevant united front and did not pave the way for himself.

It's mainly because I didn't do something particularly right in some things, so I died so miserably.

Because Zhuge Liang's "Longzhong Pair" had already formulated a good strategic policy for Liu Bei, that is, Jingzhou and Yizhou must be obtained to form a horn trend! Great things can be done! If Guan Yu does not die, Jingzhou will become the most important territory for Shu Han, and it is also the turning point of Shu Han in the Three Kingdoms.

It can be said that no one thought that Guan Yu would lose Jingzhou, defeat Maicheng and die at the hands of Lü Meng Sun Quan "Out of the Teacher" wrote about the revival of the Han Dynasty, but there must be Jingzhou, it can be said that Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition, why did it fail? It's not about food and grass, what kind of personnel problems, etc., those are just some factors, but they are not important factors The important factor is the topography, this topography is not the terrain, it is the territory It can be said to be a sphere of influence Let's not forget that Jingzhou is at the crossroads of the north and south and the east and west, and the main transportation route If there is Jingzhou, you can attack Sun Quan in the east, and you can crusade against Cao Cao in the north

I'd rather want Jingzhou than Yizhou (of course, in the case of choosing one of the two), Yizhou is easy to defend and difficult to attack, but you can't get in, and we can't get out It's a dead end! So this puts a heavy burden on Zhuge Liang's future strategic policy!

So if Guan Yu doesn't die, it's hard to say whose world it is! Guan Yu's immortality to achieve the emperor's cause must be Liu Bei!

Guan Yu can't save the situation if he doesn't die, the situation at that time was that Shu was strong and Wei was weak, Wu Guolian's determination to join Wei had been decided, and Jingzhou would definitely lose under the watchful eye of Wei and Wu.