Which one is better, Tian Feng and Xu Yu under Yuan Shao at the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty?

My personal opinion is that after excluding character and other messy reasons, Xu You is an extremely terrifying person, he can stand in any angle, any position to find the opponent's weaknesses in an instant, and can put forward extremely correct and vicious strategies. Xu Yu once thought that Yuan Shao proposed to blackmail the Son of Heaven to make the princes earlier than Mao Jue, which shows his political sensitivity.

As for Tian Feng, he is a strategic talent, and his analysis of the situation is very thorough, but he is still far from Xu Yu's terrifying strategy.

Xu Yu died in his own character, if he was Zhuge Liang's kind of person, I am afraid that Zhuge Liang would be difficult to match.

Each has its own merits, and the two have not compared.

Each has its own merits, it is difficult to distinguish between high and low, and at that time there was no instrument to measure IQ, and I don't know who has the highest IQ of the two!

All right. Tian Feng said that he should seek to enrich the country and strengthen the army, and improve himself, and Yuan Shao controlled the four largest and richest states in the Central Plains. The disadvantage is that it also gives Cao Cao time to develop.

Xu You is demanding, with the fastest way, to solve the big trouble. In fact, Xu You's strategy, combined with Yuan Shao's powerful army, could completely defeat Cao Cao.

But Yuan Shao's stubbornness, indecisiveness, and suspicion of his subordinates made Yuan Shao miss several opportunities to win. Xu Youxin was discouraged and disappointed, and finally took refuge in Cao Cao.

I'm sorry, I can't tell who is right, Tian Feng Chi Mu and Xu You.

Tian Feng and Xu Youma Sui played an important role in Yuan Shao's battle of Guandu, but their strategies and perspectives differed. Tian Feng's strategy was designed on the basis that Yuan Shao did not send troops, and he advocated not sending troops, not fighting with Cao Cao at Guandu, but interfering with Cao Cao, so as to achieve the goal of winning without a fight. Xu You, on the other hand, was designed when Yuan Shao sent troops, and he helped Cao Cao pacify Jizhou, but was killed in the military camp.

Therefore, although Tian Feng and Xu You's strategies and views are different, they both have their rationality and value. It is not easy to tell who is right, as the final decision needs to be made on a case-by-case basis.

Tian Feng is even more powerful.

Xu Yu is righteous and squanders money, has a deep sense of righteousness, and has many friends. Knowledgeable, handsome and chic. In ** "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", Xu You was friendly with Cao Cao when he was young, and later became Yuan Shao's adviser, giving advice to Yuan Shao many times, and attacking Cao Cao's capital Xuchang.

At the time of the Battle of Guandu, Xu You defected to Cao Cao because his family had broken the law and was hospitalized, and provided important information, suggesting that Cao Cao attack Wuchao, and the result was a complete victory. After the battle of Guandu, Xu You followed Cao Cao to Yecheng, spoke wildly, insulted Cao Cao, despised Cao's soldiers, and was killed by Xu Chu in a rage.

As for Tian Feng, he is much better than Xu You, but his talent is not in the conspiracy, in terms of intelligence Xu You is indeed the most ghost ideas under Yuan Shao, but smart is smart, relying on ghost ideas to achieve partial victories at most. And Tian Feng's strategy for Yuan Shao is analyzed at the macro level. Although because of Yuan Shao's failure, we can't say that if we follow Tianpi Town's Yinfeng's plan, we will definitely succeed, but in the situation at that time, Tian Feng's suggestion was obviously better than starting a war, and of course the battle was not impossible to fight.

It's just that Tian Feng, who has followed Yuan Shao for so many years, still can't grasp Yuan Shao's pulse and forced himself to the Jedi, and the aspect of burning the banquet is also a lack of his ability to deal with things, but this is really difficult, Yuan Shao may not know that Tian Feng's strategy is more secure, but he still chose to go to war, I don't know if Tian Feng thought about the deep reason at that time.

During the battle of Guotu Guandu, he strongly advocated taking the opportunity to sneak attack Cao Ying, and after the failure of this plan, in order to avoid punishment, he blamed Zhang He and Gao Ran, who led the army to attack Cao Ying, causing the two to turn their backs on Yuan and surrender to Cao. After Yuan Shao's death, he served his eldest son Yuan Tan, Guo Tu offered a plan for Yuan Tan, ** Yuan Shang, but was found out by the trial, which led to the brothers fighting, and persuaded Yuan Tan to join Cao Cao to attack Yuan Shang, in order to reap the benefits of the fisherman, after Yuan Shang failed, Yuan Tan rebelled against Cao Cao, Cao Cao attacked, Yuan Tan's army was defeated, and Guo Tu was killed by Cao Cao with Yuan Tan in 205.

Tian Feng. Although he was not particularly famous in the Eastern Han Dynasty, he was definitely a top strategist, and he asked Yuan Shao three times.

Offer a plan to defeat Cao Cao in the future.

But Yuan Shao refused to listen. So much so that Cao Cao also sighed after hearing all this: If Yuan Shao listened to Tian Feng's plan, the victory or defeat may not be known.

This is because Tian Feng offered his advice to Yuan Shao for the first timeLet Yuan Shao snatch the Son of Heaven from Cao Cao, he can command the world like Cao Cao, and make his side more righteous. The second dedication wasBattle of GuanduBefore, Tian Feng suggested taking advantage of Cao Cao to attackLiu Bei, should attack Xuchang immediately, but Yuan Shao refused to send troops because of his son's illness, if Yuan Shao did this, Cao Cao would not even have a base, let alone fight for hegemony in the north. The third time was Tian Feng's suggestion not to start the Guandu War, but to send a few more people to harass him, and he could drag Cao Cao down in three years at most, and if Yuan Shao listened to his advice, he could almost exchange the minimum price for the biggest victory.

1. Tian Feng can be regarded as a top shed mill strategist in the Eastern Han Dynasty

Tian Feng was not particularly famous among all the strategists of the Eastern Han Dynasty, because he did not meet a wise lord.

Tian Feng was originally Han Fu.

His adviser, Yuan Shao, personally came to the door to invite him out of the mountain after seizing Hebei. But as Yuan Shao's strength increased, he began to listen more and more to his opinions, so Tian Feng planned for Yuan Shao three times at a critical time, but he didn't pay attention to the rent.

2, Tian Feng planned three times, and each time he hit Cao Cao's vital point

Tian Feng's first plan was to persuade Yuan Shao to sacrifice the Han Dynasty to the emperor.

snatched it from Cao Cao's hands, if Yuan Shao listened to it, then Cao Cao would become passive. The second plan was to let Yuan Shao take advantage of Xuchang's emptiness to attack immediately, if he succeeded, then Cao Cao would return everything to zero, and the third time let Yuan Shao send more troops and horses to harass Cao Cao for three years, if he couldn't do it for three years, he could drag Cao Cao down.

3, Cao Cao later knew that Tian Lian collapsed Feng and felt scared after three plans

Tian Feng was killed after the defeat of Yuan Shao's battle at Guandu, and at this time Cao Cao also learned that Tian Feng had plotted against Yuan Shao three times. Cao Cao once said to the people around him that if Yuan Shao had adopted these three strategies at that time, I am afraid it would be difficult to say who would have won. It's a pity that Yuan Shao is not a wise lord, but whenever one of the three strategies is used, Cao Cao will feel very uncomfortable.

Tian Feng was a famous strategist in the Eastern Han Dynasty, and he was highly talented and condescending in politics. He provided important military and political advice to Yuan Shao, a famous general in the late Eastern Han Dynasty.

If Yuan Shao had listened to Tian Feng's advice at that time, Min Jiaoyuan might have helped him in the process of unifying the Six Kingdoms. Tian Feng had put forward many effective strategies and schemes, and if Yuan Shao could use some of them, Li Kuan, it might bring new opportunities to his career. However, we are not sure how this situation will change history, because history is complex and full of variables, and the result is a combination of many factors.

Tian Feng can be regarded as a top strategist, but because he followed Yuan Shao, the lord, Tian Feng's advice Yuan Shao did not listen to the type of quiet rock, and the queen even killed Tian Feng. If Yuan Shao listened to Tian Feng's proposal for Jianyun, Yuan Shao was likely to unify the world.

I think it's a very bad strategist, because he doesn't understand anything at all, and Yuan Shao listens to him, and it is estimated that he will be beaten when he fights Cao Cao.

In terms of strategy alone, I personally think that Tian Feng is more powerful than Xu You.

1. Although Xu Yu is full of wealth, in essence, there are only a few real strategies.

Xu You has been familiar with the scriptures since he was a child, and he is full of economy. Xu You once did a stupid thing when Emperor Ling of the Han Dynasty, he and Wang Fen, the assassin of Jizhou, wanted to abolish Emperor Ling of the Han Dynasty and establish himself as the emperor, and also wanted to assassinate Emperor Ling of the Han Dynasty, but this matter was revealed, Wang Fen committed suicide, and Xu You fled. Although Emperor Ling of the Han Dynasty was mediocre and incompetent at that time, he was still orthodox, and the rebellion of the Han Dynasty clan did not have a good ending.

Xu You can't accomplish the great cause by Wang Fen and himself alone, this is short-sighted. <>

Xu You's two most important things in history, one of which is that he persuaded Yuan Shao to directly attack Xu Du and take the Son of Heaven over, and Yuan Shao welcomed the princes of the Son of Heaven. But Yuan Shao didn't listen, Yuan Shao wanted to destroy Cao Cao first, and then welcome the Son of Heaven to prove his strength. Second, during the Battle of Guandu, Xu You's family made a mistake in Yecheng and was tried and imprisoned.

Xu You was angry so he took refuge in Cao Cao, and later offered a plan to burn the black nest to help Cao Cao win the battle of Guandu.

Xu You's plan to burn the black nest is not too indicative of this person's strategy in my personal opinion. Xu You is the most dispersed advisor who followed Yuan Shao early, and has a large amount of Yuan Shao's military information, Wuchao is Yuan Shao's grain and grass gathering place, which is also one of the news, it can only be said that Xu You made suggestions based on intelligence. Xu You did not make much contribution after that, and was finally executed by Cao Cao because he often mentioned the merits of this incident.

Second, Tian Feng has great talents, but Yuan Shao doesn't need it.

Tian Feng was originally Han Fu's subordinate, and later took refuge in Yuan Shao. Yuan Shao was able to take down Gongsun Zhan because he used the strategy of Tian Feng of the Juechang clan. On the eve of the Battle of Guandu, Cao Cao led his troops to fight Liu Bei in Xuzhou, and Tian Feng persuaded Yuan Shao to attack Xuchang directly, but Yuan Shao refused on the grounds that his youngest son was sick and had no intention of fighting.

If Yuan Shao Tian Feng's opinion, then Yuan Shao could win. <>

In fact, Tian Feng opposed Yuan Shao's campaign of Guandu, and Tian Feng advocated that Cao Cao should be fought with the method of protracted war. Sent troops to harass Cao Cao, so that Cao Cao was tired of running, and within three years, Cao Cao was destroyed. The cost of a protracted war is small and the profit is high, but unfortunately Yuan Shao did not listen.

He also put Tian Feng in prison, and finally defeated and killed Tian Feng. Personally, I feel that the strategy of the two is completely inferior to Tian Feng compared to Xu Yu.

The former is more powerful, because his resourcefulness is broader and his layout is very far-reaching, which Tian Feng cannot compare.

Xu Yu is even more powerful. It can be seen from the advice given to Yuan Shao by the two in the Battle of Guandu that Xu You's strategy is even more powerful.

Naturally, Tian Feng was more intelligent, and once offered advice to help Yuan Shao exterminate Gongsun Zhan, and then advised Yuan Shao to recuperate, and used the tactics of attacking the east to harass Cao Cao, but he was not killed.