Did Hua Tuo scrape Guan Yu s bones to heal his wounds in real history, and why did he die in the end

I don't think I scraped Guan Yu's bones to heal his wounds. Hua Tuo was killed by Cao Cao's suspicion during the period of Cao Cao**.

I don't think there should be such a thing in history, because it seems that before Guan Yu was injured, Hua Tuo had died.

Hua Tuo was finally killed by Cao Cao's order, Cao Cao had a headache and asked Hua Tuo to help treat the disease. But Hua Tuo's ** plan was to have surgery on his head, but Cao Cao suspected that Hua Tuo was trying to harm him, so he killed him.

In history, Guan Yu did experience "scraping bones to cure poison", but it was not Hua Tuo's doing.

Guan Yu's poison treatment occurred in 219 AD during the attack on Fancheng, he was shot in the right arm by a poisoned arrow, and Hua Tuo died in 208 AD.

And "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" only said that there was a doctor who scraped the bones of Guan Junhou to treat poison, but did not say that it was Mr. Hua. Even if it is Hua Tuo, "Three Kingdoms" will also write down the divine doctor Hua Tuo, after all, Hua Tuo is famous and the protagonist, there must be a record.

Therefore, Hua Tuo did not scrape the bones of Guan Junhou to heal his wounds, but someone else!

In fact, "Romance of the Three Kingdoms: The Biography of Hua Tuo" tells many stories of Hua Tuo's practice of healing, and some of the stories are also legendary, but even so, there is no record of "scraping bones to cure poison" or "scraping bones to remove poison" for anyone.

It is recorded in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms:

The feather tasted the arrow, through its right arm, although the wound healed, every time it rained, the bone often hurt. The doctor said: "The arrow is poisonous, the poison enters the bones, when the arm is broken for wounds, the bones are scraped to remove the poison, and then the suffering is to remove the ear." ”

Yu stretched out his arm and ordered the doctor to split it. Shi Yushi invited the generals to eat and drink oppositely, the blood in the arms flowed away, and the feather cut the wine, and laughed freely.

Translation: Guan Yu was once shot by an arrow and hit his left arm, although he later healed, but it would still attack on rainy days, and Guan Gong was in pain.

After that, Guan Erye asked the doctor, and after the doctor saw it, he said, "Junhou." That arrow contains toxin, which has already entered the bone, and can only cut the surface and scrape the bone to heal the wound, so that your left arm can be completely **. ”

Guan Yu stretched out his left arm and asked the doctor to cut open the wound and scrape the bone to remove the poison. At this time, Guan Yu feasted the generals, and a lot of blood flowed out of his left arm, which was full of utensils, while Guan Junhou only cared about playing chess with Ma Liang, his demeanor was calm, and he did not show any pain. Guan Junhou's heroic image can be seen.

Have you heard the story of Hua Tuo scraping Guan Yu's bones to heal his wounds? We all know that Hua Tuo is a miracle doctor who has made great contributions to mankind in medical skills, and his achievements are the greatest contributions in the history of mankind. Is it true that Hua Tuo scraped Guan Yu's bones to heal his wounds?

We will not doubt Hua Tuo's medical skills, and we believe that such a difficult technique is likely to happen to him. Let me tell you how this story happened.

This story comes from "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", which tells the story of Guan Yusheng after capturing and killing Pang De, attacking Fancheng again, but was shot in the right arm by a poisonous cold arrow.

At the end of the Han Dynasty in China, there was an outstanding medical scientist named Hua Tuo. The story of him scraping the bones of Guan Gong to cure poison is still recited among the people to this day.

Legend has it that once, when Guan Gong was fighting with the enemy of Chun Zhiji, he was hit by an arrow in his right arm. Back at the barracks, his arm was red and swollen and he couldn't move. The military doctors examined him and found that the arrows were coated with poison.

They say that if the poison is allowed to penetrate the human body, it will be incorrigible. Therefore, the best thing to do is to cut off the arm as soon as possible.

Guan Gong listened to the words of the military doctors and said: I am a general, and I have no right arm, how can I fight in the future? I'd rather die than cut off my arm!;