Guan Yu s death, is Zhuge Liang responsible?

The evaluation of historical figures is generally the opinion of the benevolent and the wise.

I give some advice from my point of view in the hope that it will help you:

As far as Guan Yu is concerned, the failure is mainly due to his arrogance, ignoring that Lu Xun is a scholar and does not understand military affairs, but despises the deployment of Jingzhou, and transfers all the important troops, and those who remain.

It is worth noting that the Eastern Wu captured Jingzhou, did not kill Jingzhou, and carried out a series of measures to reassure the people, and won the people.

Heart. In one is that Guan Yu doesn't know that Dongwu married Guan Yu, yes.

Soochow's strategy. Judging from the development of the situation at that time, it was too late for the city to send troops, and from the leadership point of view, Shu was not united internally at that time, and the two generals sent by Zhuge Liang to guard the vicinity of Jingzhou would quickly come to the aid if Jingzhou was in any danger, but as a result, they did not support. It further led to the fate of Guan Yu being captured.

From the perspective of the country's security, Zhuge Liang has a certain responsibility, as the eastern barrier of Shu, he should send one more person to help garrison Jingzhou, and another should have a comprehensive understanding of Guan Yu's attack on Fancheng, so as to deploy troops and propose some good rescue measures. , as a result, Zhuge Liang didn't do it, and Zhuge Liang had a lot of opinions about Guan Yu, the two were not in harmony, but they were emotional at the critical moment, so far, it has caused a huge tragedy.

There should be no responsibility.

If there is a responsibility, it is that Liang clearly knows that Guan's character is arrogant and self-serving, and he still asks him to guard the military plane, and does not return it to other brave and resourceful people to defend! For example, Zilong is also fine!

It may be inappropriate to use Guan Yu to Zhenjing, but I don't think it's appropriate to blame it entirely on Zhuge Liang's personal emotional factors. Whether it is a Liang fan or a black Liang faction, there is one thing that cannot be denied, that is, Zhuge Liang's calmness - this person's actions do not have any impulse to act rashly, which is obviously reflected in the control of Jing, Yi, the seven capture of Meng and even the admonition of Liu Bei to kill Liu Feng. This almost cruel and calm attitude shows that Kong Ming is completely loyal to Ji Han, and it is impossible to spend Jingzhou on his own grudge to destroy Guan Yu.

Jingzhou is the foundation of Ji Han, and Fazheng Pang Tong had plans to give up Jingzhou but was vetoed by Zhuge Liang, which shows that in the land of Jingzhou, Zhuge Liang will never give it up easily.

As for letting Guan Yu town Jingzhou - besides Guan Yu, who can you find to watch your own base camp? Zhao Yun has always been Liu Bei's close guard before and after, and his military exploits are not enough to establish his authority; Zhang Fei's explosive barrel, who dares to touch it; Feng Xiao hung up at that time, and Liu Bei was stuck in a dilemma on the way to Shu; Fa Zheng is still in Xichuan - who else is there besides Guan Yu. In fact, Zhuge Liang may not be at ease with Guan Yu, and it can be seen from his letter to Yun Chang (blowing Guan Yu is the letter of "beautiful bearded man") He knows Guan Yu's arrogant and unbearable character very well, and has even been trying to appease him, otherwise he would not have sent that kind of letter at all, just like in Romance, what kind of ghost painting charm is in the east, Jingzhou is afraid of danger, and Guan Yu will not be able to fight soon?

Everyone knows that Shu Han has Zhuge Liang, but they don't know that there is Lu Boyan in Eastern Wu, that guy is two years younger than Kong Ming, Taoguang is obscure until he is middle-aged, and finally offered a plan to shoot Guan Yu with Lu Meng, and later burned Liu Bei in Yiling, but who told him not to be angry before? Can you expect Kong Ming to know all the gods and monsters hidden in the city in the heavens and the earth?

Therefore, Guan Yu's death, Zhuge Liang, as a think tank, of course has the responsibility, underestimated the opponent, and had luck. But blaming him entirely is inappropriate.

Zhuge Liang, as the chief of the general staff of the three armies of Shu State, has to bear certain leadership responsibilities Knowing what Guan Yu's personality is, knowing the importance of Jingzhou, but he recognizes Guan Yu's defense of Jingzhou Guan Yu only has the talent of an army and does not have the ability to command the war zone He has no overall view He only looks at what is in front of him.

No, the main reason is that Guan Yu is arrogant and self-serving, and Zhuge Liang has no talent in military affairs, and Liu Bei doesn't believe in him very much, Liu Bei trusts Fazheng.

There are many of them. He first let him defend the dangerous place (that is, Jingzhou), and then let him attack Cao Ren, although Jingxiang is far away from Chengdu, but he does not know any news during the period, which can be said to be a death without help.

No, it was Liu Bei who believed in Guan Yu too much.

In his character, arrogant, love to wear high hats. In the nineteenth year of Jian'an, when Liu Bei fought in Chengdu, Ma Chao came to defect to Liu Bei. Because Guan Yu was not familiar with Ma Chao, he wrote a letter to Zhuge Liang, saying that what kind of person is this Ma Chao?

As soon as Zhuge Liang read the letter, he understood that Guan Yu wanted to PK with Ma Chao, and he could only win and not lose. Zhuge Liang immediately replied with a letter saying that Ma Chao is very remarkable, a rare talent, and can be said to be the master of a lifetime, the most outstanding person in this era; But, compared to the beautiful bearded man, ** is comparable to the beautiful bearded man's peerless group. This Guan Yu was very happy after reading the letter, and then showed this letter to everyone, you see, Ma Chao is a masterpiece of the world.

About the death was completely Liu Bei's arrangement with him, borrowing a knife to kill people.

In fact, Zhuge Liang should hate Guan Yu very much.