Why didn t Guan Yu listen to Zhuge Liang s words in the north to resist Cao Wei, the east and the Ea

1. Guan Yu has always been dismissive of Zhuge Liang's behavior and command, and in his eyes, Zhuge Liang is a person with no real talent and learning, so he naturally won't take Zhuge Liang's suggestion to heart.

Second, the factional struggle within Shu Han is very serious, and Guan Yu, as one of the forces, will naturally be wary of what others say, after all, he doesn't know if Zhuge Liang's strategy is digging a hole for himself.

Because of arrogance. Guan Yu as a famous general. When Dongwu asked for marriage, he said that the tiger girl could marry a dog. Blatantly insulted Sun Quan, the overlord of Eastern Wu.

Because Guan Yu was arrogant and self-serving, he didn't trust Zhuge Liang and didn't bother to cooperate with Dongwu, so it eventually led to the loss of Jingzhou.

Because of self-confidence and arrogance, he felt that his force and martial arts were already one of the strongest generals in the world.

Guan Yu was attacked by Lu Meng in white clothes because of his pride and carelessness, and finally defeated Maicheng, and finally lost his life and Jingzhou. <>

And his eldest brother Liu Bei after learning the news, he was naturally angry, and he was going to raise the whole country's troops to attack Eastern Wu, although hundreds of officials advised, but Liu Bei never listened, so Liu Bei fought Wu This kicked off, but he suffered a failure, that is, because of this, so people often ask why not bring the resourceful Zhuge Liang? Wouldn't it fail that way? <>

The first reason: it is because Liu Bei's whole army is dispatched, but Shu Han still has a big enemy, that is, Cao Wei, Liu Bei needs someone to help him sit in Shu Han, sit in the rear, especially need a very trusting person, this candidate cannot be someone else, it is Zhuge Liang.

The second reason is: in history, Zhuge Liang is a Xiao He-style figure and not a figure like Zhang Liang and Chen Ping, that is to say, Zhuge Liang's legislation, logistics, and government are his strengths. <>

Just like when Liu Bei just occupied Shudi, Liu Bei's strategist was Pang Tong, but it was a pity that Pang Tong died early and was pierced by ten thousand arrows. These can prove that Liu Bei generally fights without Zhuge Liang, and the main task is to let Zhuge Liang sit in the rear and be in charge of logistics. Even Zhuge Liang himself often said:

If Fa Zheng was still there, Liu Bei might not have suffered such a defeat." is enough to show that Zhuge Liang also thinks that he is not a person who is good at making strange plans in the march and fighting. These points are the main reasons why Liu Bei did not take Zhuge Liang to the Eastern Wu.

Because even if he took him to fight Dongwu, he would not provide Liu Bei with any help, and would keep persuading him that he couldn't do it. will tell him a lot of big truths, so he directly led his troops to avenge Guan Yu and let Zhuge Liang stay in Chengdu. Doing so will not only calm you down, but you will also prove that you were once a very good person on the battlefield.

And he also knew that his soldiers and horses were very strong, and the Dongwu side was much worse than himself, so this battle would definitely be won.

Why didn't Liu Bei bring Zhuge Liang with his troops to fight Eastern Wu?

It's useless to take Zhuge Liang with him, not only will he not give him advice, but he will keep chattering in his ear. Tell him some big truths and show his relationship with Soochow. So this will make Liu Bei very annoying, it is better to directly lead the troops to attack the animals, not only to achieve his own goals, but also to prove that he is also very heroic on the battlefield.

And he knows very well that the force he is in is very strong, and he will definitely win against Soochow.

Liu Bei did not bring Zhuge Liang in order to avenge Guan Yu

Because Guan Yu knew very well that defeating Eastern Wu with his own forces was a sure thing, so that he could prove that he was also capable of fighting a war. Even if Zhuge Liang is not by his side, he can still defeat the other party. So he felt that he would lead his troops to fight animals, so that he could not only prove his strength.

And you don't have to listen to Zhuge Liang every day and tell him those big truths in your ear.

A reminder

Liu Bei took revenge on Guan Yu and left Zhuge Liang at home. It was because he was so sure of the victory in this fight, and in the end he did win. But because of the light enemy, he was burned by others.

He didn't take Zhuge Liang with him at that time because Zhuge Liang didn't approve of him going to fight this battle. I also feel that I have the ability to defeat the other party. But after that, he underestimated the enemy, but he directly gave away his own life.

In fact, he had a conflict with Zhuge Liang at that time, because Zhuge Liang didn't let him fight, after all, his strength was not very strong, and he was unwilling to listen to Zhuge Liang's words.

Cao Wei's strength was definitely the strongest of the Three Kingdoms, with a population of much more than four million, Sun Wu with a population of almost 2.3 million, and Shu Han with a population of only 900,000.

In that era, population represented productivity, financial resources, and military resources, no matter how high the industrial technology level of Shu Han was, it still couldn't compete with Cao Wei. In "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", we often see that as soon as Zhuge Liang destroys Cao Wei, how many generals will immediately lead how many troops to support; But as soon as Shu Han lost how many men and horses, it immediately came to the time of danger, in fact, it was similar in the official history. The disparity in population has directly led to a huge gap in national strength.

In fact, every time Shu Han went on the Northern Expedition, Eastern Wu sent troops to help more or less (but most of the time they did not contribute to the work), and Shu Han attacked the Yongliang region in the west; Eastern Wu sent troops to attack the Xu and Henan regions. However, due to the poor cooperation most of the time, it seems that Shu Han has always been fighting alone, in fact, Dongwu has also contributed.

For example, Zhuge Liang's Fifth Northern Expedition. After the withdrawal of the Fourth Northern Expedition in June 231, the state of Wu continued to launch medium-scale military operations against the state of Wei during the period before the Northern Expedition in June 231, and in 233 the lord of Wu personally launched an attack on Hefei New City ("Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms": In the summer of May, the right to send Lu Xun, Zhuge Jin and others to Tunjiang Xia and Chukou, Sun Shao, Zhang Cheng and others to Guangling and Huaiyang, and the right to lead the public to besiege Hefei New Town.

It was when Shu Xiang Zhuge Liang showed martial arts, and the right to say that Emperor Wei Ming could not go far, and the emperor sent troops to help Sima Xuan refuse to Liang. He led the naval army to the east. Before Shouchun, the right was returned, and Sun Shao was also dismissed. , did not win. Moreover, Sun Quan also rebelled against Gongsun Yuan, who was in the rear of Cao Wei.

After Sun Quan's death, Zhuge Ke and Sun Qi also launched the Northern Expedition, no matter what their purpose was, they did at least.

The Sun-Liu alliance is over, and the Three Kingdoms have entered a three-legged period, and Sun Wu is already good if he doesn't sneak attack, and it is even more impossible to help.

From Sun Ce to Sun Quan, Eastern Wu knew that although money and food were not a problem, the army really could not defeat Wei, and if Liu Bei united with him, he was afraid that Wei would one day destroy Shu Han and come back to clean up himself, so he never dared to cross the river rashly, and lived in a corner of the Yangtze River, waiting for the Wei and Han families to pinch each other, and he would benefit from the fisherman.

On the one hand, it was out of consideration for the Northern Expedition, and on the other hand, it was actually aimed at weakening its national strength, hindering its development, and slowing down its pace of development. And what is Cao Wei's coping strategy? One word: drag! Drag you down! From later Sima Yi.

It is not difficult to see the strategy of "sticking to it" many times, dragging the knife and striking later. That's basically it! Another reason is that Cao Wei is from Cao Cao.

There will never be a single outstanding politician again! No, one hand is not good!

In 244 AD, after Cao Shuang took power, he wanted to make military achievements to improve his prestige, so he led an army of 60,000 or 70,000 people to attack Shu, but Wang Ping and Fei Yi sent troops to guard the mountains in advance, and Cao Shuang's subordinates had contradictions, some people wanted to retreat, some people wanted to continue to go in, and finally the army withdrew.

Liu Chan. I once asked Zhuge Liang.

Shu defends according to natural dangers, but can protect the territory and the people, why do you still need the Northern Expedition? Zhuge Liang replied that although Shu is based on natural risks, it can ensure that Shu Han has no worries for 20 years, but after 20 years, Cao Weiqiang's manuscript will grow up, and he will definitely cut down Shu, and he will die if he lives in a corner. Zhuge Liang was a far-sighted politician who knew that once the Central Plains was restored, it was only a matter of time before the South was unified.

Zhuge Liang, who had no logistical problems, killed Cao Wei's 100,000 troops with his outstanding military talents, coupled with the solid alliance of Wu and Shu, and the Eastern Wu Lu Xun Shi Shi noisily threatened Cao Wei, Huainan and Jianghan, Cao Wei did not dare to send a large army into Shu at all, and the less sent became a refueling tactic, and the rear was not safe to send more, and the possibility of defeat was great, once lost, the land of Yongliang was no longer owned by Cao Wei, and Zhuge Liang succeeded in the Northern Expedition.

The first person not to attack Shu Han was Cao Cao! Liu Ye and Sima Yi persuaded Cao Cao to win Longwangshu, but Cao Cao just didn't listen. I don't know why! Liu Ye and Sima Yi didn't know ...... either

Then Emperor Wen and Emperor Ming were unwilling to cut down Shu, grandpa