Everyone thinks that Zhou Yu or Sima Yi is more capable

If we are ** is "Zhou Yu's six out of Qishan Northern Expedition to the Central Plains to win the possibility", this topic is really a bit big, because the possible outcome of the war between the two countries does not depend entirely on the personal ability of the commander, and the comprehensive national strength of the two warring sides is also an important consideration, including economic conditions (directly affecting the support of grain and grass, equipment, and sergeants), the will of the army and the people (directly affecting morale), the quality of generals (directly affecting the execution of military orders), and the quality of sergeants (the training degree of sergeants directly affects the results of the war). Let's only analyze the abilities of Zhou Yu and Sima Yi as the coach: (1) Wisdom and strategy are the ability performance of the coach's quality, in this regard, because the two have never faced each other head-on in reality, it is difficult to make an objective comparison, plus Zhou Yu's short life, his biggest record is only the Battle of Chibi, in fact, it is difficult to compare, but from the command performance of the two on the battlefield, we are willing to assume that their wisdom and strategy are not up and down; (2) As the commander of the first army, in addition to his personal wisdom and strategy, in fact, what is more important is his character, or it should be described as a character that reflects his personal psychological quality, because the personal character of the commander often directly affects his major strategic command decisions; In this regard, Zhou Yu is obviously weak, Zhou Yu's biggest weakness is a little impetuous, otherwise there would be no three-qi Zhou Yu (although this is only an artistic description of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, not entirely historical), and Sima Yi can endure what others can't bear, and know how to keep quiet when necessary, this is the deep-seated basic character quality of the boss, look at his performance when Zhuge Liang sent him to send him women's clothes, and then look at his performance when he fell ill when he lost power in Wei and then designed a trap to seize power in one fell swoop. It is not difficult to analyze Sima Yi's forbearance personality; From this point of view, Sima Yi is a stable winner over Zhou Yu.

The situation of the Northern Expedition to the Central Plains of the Six Out of Qishan is that the six out of Qishan are the attackers, which seem to be active but in fact they are passive, which involves more support forces (this aspect of the factor has indeed made Zhuge Liang work hard), and Sima Yi, as the defender, is completely different, he has the strong strength of the Wei State as the backing, there is a high city to defend, coupled with his personal forbearance personality, it is not difficult to keep the attacker out of the door and drag him down. Therefore, I think that even if Zhou Yu is replaced and goes out of Qishan to the Central Plains, it is actually no different from Zhuge Liang, it will still be in vain, and the result may be worse than Zhuge Liang.

However, Zhou Yu couldn't hold his breath, even people like Kong Ming didn't succeed in the end, besides, what is more important is the difference in national strength between the two countries, not only because of the main general, Wei is relatively strong.

Zhou Yu was not Sima Yi's military advisor, Zhou Yu was a person of Sun Quan of the Three Kingdoms of Wu, Sima Yi was a person of Cao Cao of the Three Kingdoms of Wei, and Zhou Yu was Sun Quan's military advisor.

The two of them hardly got along, Zhou Yu assisted Sun Ce and Sun Quan, two generations of Jiangdong monarchs, and was the governor of Eastern Wu, not Sima Yi's military advisor.

Judging from the results, it is Sima Yi who is powerful.

However, the times when the two people got along with each other were slightly different, and they were not too comparable.

During the Battle of Chibi, the two sides did not hand each other, Zhou Yu burned Cao's army in the Chibi War, defeated the strong with the weak, and could be described as a hero for a while, but this person was not as good as Sima Yi in terms of materials and resourcefulness, Zhou Yu was good at water warfare, Sima was good at strategizing, and won by strategy, Zhou Yu can be regarded as a general like Han Xin, invincible; And Sima is more like a combination of Liu Bang and Zhang Liang, with wisdom, strategy, and a little bravery (it can be seen through the confrontation with Zhuge Liang that although there were many defeats, the Wei State basically did not lose ground, and at the same time greatly consumed the Shu State), Sima Yi finally laid the foundation of the Sima family and created conditions for the unification of the Three Kingdoms, similar to Cao Cao in this regard, and whether it was Zhuge or Zhou Yu, they were far behind by Sima Yi at this point.

Sima Yi endured humiliation and grew from a small soldier to a hero, while Zhou Yu is a typical rich second generation, who was appreciated and entrusted with important tasks at a young age, and became the governor of the capital smoothly all the way, with a different starting point and different achievements.

It's not that Zhou Yu can't do it, it's just that Sima Yi's characteristics in strategy and strategy are too prominent.

Actually, in the end! It's not awesome! None of them can beat death! You have to die early and die late!! I feel that Zhuge Liang is very pitiful!!

Sima Yi defeated Zhuge Liang, and Zhou Yu lost to Zhuge Liang, so Sima Yi was powerful.

Facts have proved that Sima Yi is the most powerful, in a popular saying, whoever has the last laugh is the winner.

As we all know, Zhou Yu was angry with Zhuge Liang to death, obviously Zhou Yu was the least powerful one, and Zhuge Liang did not have the last laugh, and finally died of exhaustion in Wuzhang Plain, and only Sima Yi unified the Three Kingdoms and established a new dynasty by his descendants, the Jin Dynasty, it can be seen that Sima Yi laughed to the end, which can be described as the most powerful!

Sima Yi affirmed that Zhou Yu was angry with Zhuge Liang, and Zhuge Liang's mistake lost the street pavilion

Sima Yi. Don't talk about the specifics, let's just say that he lived to the end, not only dragged Zhuge Liang to death in time, but also became emperors in his descendants.

History is actually Zhou Yu is powerful, and Zhuge Liang is powerful in fabrication

In history, Zhuge Liang is not as good as Cao Cao, Zhuge Liang is the weakest, and Zhou Yu is the second Sima? Yi first.

In history, Zhou Yu must have been stronger than Zhuge Liang and Sima Yi in terms of foreign war tactics, Zhou Yu is a talent for unifying the army, Zhuge Liang is a talent for governing the country, and Sima Yi is a power strategist.

It's ridiculous to see so many stories of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms as history, and 10 Zhuge Liang can't get a single Zhou Yu.

The awesomeness referred to here is not the person who has the last laugh, but strategy, ability, and the like

Sima Yi. ** Laugh to the end. It's not bad in the official history.

Campaign commanded by Sima Yi.

In the first month of 228, Sima Yi traveled thousands of miles to capture Meng Da, passed on the first Beijing division, and captured more than 10,000 people.

In 230, Sima Yi served as a general, increased the governor, and fake Huang Yue, and participated in the destruction of Shu.

In 231, Sima Yiyi supervised the military forces of Yong and Liang and began to preside over the war against Shu.

Regarding the Fourth Qishan War with Zhuge Liang in 231, the Book of Jin records that Sima Yi defeated Zhuge Liang, beheaded 10,000 prisoners, and sent Zhang He to chase him, but Zhang He was shot in the knee and died. "The Spring and Autumn Period of the Han and Jin Dynasties" records that Zhuge Liang defeated Sima Yi, the first three thousand, and ambushed Zhang He.

In the spring of 234, Zhuge Liang, the prime minister of Shu, led an army of 100,000 out of the valley to attack Wei, and Sima Yi led the army to cross the Weishui River and build a fortress against the water. The two armies confronted each other. Sima Yi in order to avoid a two-front battle! Soochow is also going all out on the Northern Expedition!

In May 234, the Wu army attacked Wei with 100,000 troops in three ways to cooperate with the Shu army. In July, the Wu army was defeated and retreated, and then in August, Zhuge Liang died of illness in the Wuzhang original army.

In the first month of 238, Sima Yi led Niu Jin, Hu Zun and others to ride 40,000 horses to conquer Gongsun Yuan, break Xiangping, and slaughter more than 7,000 people.

In April 241, Sun Quan attacked Wei, Sima Yi led his army south, and Wu's army was defeated. Sima Yi immediately planned to create a military camp in Huainan and Huaibei.

In April 251, Sima Yi led an army against Wang Ling. Wang Ling's whole family is dead!

The campaign commanded by Zhuge Liang.

In the spring of the sixth year of Shu Jianxing 228, Zhuge Liang's first Northern Expedition, lost the street pavilion, beheaded the horse, and degraded himself to the right general.

In the winter of the same year, in 228, Zhuge Liang went out of the pass and surrounded Chencang. The grain ran out and retreated to Hanzhong.

In the seventh year of Shu Jianxing in 229, Zhuge Liang went on another northern expedition and captured Wudu and Yinping, which were close to the two counties of Hanzhong, and the Wei army withdrew immediately after arriving!

In the ninth year of Shu Jianxing 231 Zhuge Liang's fourth northern expedition attacked Qishan and ambushed Zhang He in Mumendao. The Book of Jin records that Sima Yi won a great victory, cut down thousands of plans, and sent Zhang He to chase him and was shot in the knee and killed. "The Spring and Autumn Period of the Han and Jin Dynasties" records that Zhuge Liang won a great victory, with three thousand firsts, and ambushed Zhang He.

In March 234 AD, Zhuge Liang led the whole country and led an army of 100,000 to carry out the fifth northern expedition.

The Wei general Sima Yi led a large army to the south bank of the Weishui River and confronted Zhuge Liang, the prime minister of the Han Dynasty, across the martial arts water.

In July 234 of the same year, the main force of the Wu army that cooperated with the Northern Expedition on the other side was defeated and retreated, and then in August, Zhuge Liang died of illness after hearing about it. It should be said that Zhuge Liang died in the expectation of the Northern Expedition of Wu, when Wu was strong and Shu was weak!

The strength ranking of the three people should be Zhuge Liang first, Sima Yi second, and Zhou Yu third. But this ranking is controversial, and the ranking of strength in the hearts of different people is also different.

Obviously, Sima Yi is the first, Zhuge Liang is just a strategist, Zhou Yu died young, and the person who laughed last laughed the best, Sima Yi not only took the throne, but also inherited his descendants.

It must be Sima Yi, no matter how powerful Zhuge Liang and Zhou Yu are, they have not been able to beat Sima Yi, because after all, they have survived, and their children are also sitting firmly.

I think the strength ranking should look at what kind of strength it is, if it is a military strength ranking, it must be Sima Yi first, if it is according to the strategic strength, Zhuge Liang should not give in.

In fact, Zhuge Liang is not as powerful as we imagined, but the descendants are too beautified, if you want to rank first, I feel that Sima Yi is more suitable.

According to the real history, according to many considerations, I feel that Sima Yi ranks first, Zhou Yu ranks second, and Zhuge Liang ranks third.

There are many ways to draw strength and weakness, for example, whoever laughs last prevails, then Sima Yi is the first, Zhuge Liang is the second, and Zhou Yu is the third.

I think that according to the strategy, Zhuge Liang should be the first, Sima Yi should be the second, and Zhou Yu should be the third.

I think Zhuge Liang should be ranked first, Zhuge Liang is not because he doesn't want to be private, but because Liu Bei doesn't let him stand on his own, Liu Bei is, before he died, let, Liu Chan, recognize Zhuge Liang as, Ya Father, so Zhuge Liang can't stand on his own, although Sima Yi is ambitious, even if he can break it, empty city plan, but often ambition is not a good thing, since ancient times, whoever is the king will perish, legend has it that Cao Cao let Sima Yi destroy the country with a word, so Sima Yi ranked second, why did I let Zhou Yu rank third? Although Zhou Yu is very wise, he is very narrow-minded, and he was angry to death because of Zhuge Liang, but he is also mediocre, but it is not that he is not good, but he also relies on Zhuge Liang to burn Chibi, so Zhou Yu ranks third.

I still think Zhuge Liang is the most powerful, and it can be seen from his work that Liu Bei's three visits to the thatched house are not in vain.

I think Zhuge Liang should be the most powerful, because at that time, Shu was the weakest among the Three Kingdoms, but he single-handedly turned the tide.

The benevolent see the benevolent and the wise see the wise, what does the landlord think? The three are all great sages of the time, and if you look at them from today's perspective, you can only say that "the merits and demerits are left for future generations to comment".

Everyone has a one-sided side to the problem, and this is true of the world, as well as the history books. How the landlord likes to look, that's how it goes.

It's as if I admire Zhuge Liang, but I admire Sima Yi, and at the same time I admire Zhou Yu.

However, my opinion is "born Guo Fengxiao, heroic heroes." The history of the scriptures is hidden in the abdomen, and the hidden armor soldiers in the chest. Strategizing is like Fan Li, and decision-making is like Chen Ping. It's a pity that he lost his body first, and the pillars of the Central Plains fell. ”

People are the main body of sports, primary school likes Zhuge , junior high school likes Sima, high school likes Zhou Yu, and college is filial piety. This is not to say that I am fickle or unfaithful, different periods have different concepts of the times, values and outlook on life are developing. What is worth learning from will be what you like.

Zhuge Liang is strong in political strategy, followed by military; Zhou Yu is a civil and military all-rounder; Sima Yi was mainly strong in the military, supplemented by imperial ambitions. Among the three, Sima Yi, Zhuge Liang, and Zhou Yu.

The two should be equal, in fact, Zhuge Liang was just raised by later generations, Zhou Yu and Sima Yi were smeared in order to reflect him.

Of course, it is Zhuge Liang, this person is called Wolong, and he is looking at the world before he comes out, and the history of the Three Kingdoms develops according to what he says, but because of the mediocrity of the later lord Liu Chan, the Shu Kingdom perished.

Each had its own expertise, Sima Yi paved the way for the Jin Dynasty, Zhou Yu's Battle of Chibi was independently commanded, and Zhuge Liang was better at internal affairs.

According to Professor Yi Zhongtian's analysis, Zhuge Liang is a strategist, (that is, the big picture), not a tactician, and it is said that the empty city plan was invented by Cao Cao. In terms of tactics, I think Cao Cao and Zhou Yu are both more powerful than Zhuge Liang. Zhou Yu is not a narrow-minded person, so in terms of IQ, the two are basically equal, but in terms of emotional intelligence, Zhou Yu did not lose to Zhuge Liang.

In the real Three Kingdoms, Zhuge Liang's ability to govern internal affairs and develop the economy is good, although he did make a lot of mistakes in governing internal affairs. But Zhuge 's military ability is average (compared to Sima and Zhou Yu), and even inferior to Fa Zheng and Wei Yan. Zhou Yu and Sima were only in charge of the military, not in charge of internal affairs.

Therefore, Zhuge is slightly better in terms of comprehensive ability. In terms of military ability alone, Zhuge is worse than the above two.

I've sent you the answer you want, please check your mailbox

It doesn't matter who is great... It's all history. For our descendants, all three of them are powerful.

Zhuge Liang is the most powerful person... Sima Yi's group is the most powerful... Zhou Yu's wife is the most powerful...

thinks he is Zhou Yu, there are too many exaggerated elements in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, and you can't believe it all.