Why are the endings of the old and new versions of Dream of Red Mansions different?

Because the new version is completely based on Gao E's sequel. In fact, many of the things Gao He continued to write were inconsistent with the original work, such as Jia Yun.

and Xiaohong's character image, such as Xiangling.

's tragic fate, these are different from the endings revealed in the first 80 episodes. The screenwriter of the 87 version was smarter, gave up Gao E's sequel, and filmed one closest to Cao Gong.

The ending of the original book, which is the result of the efforts of many red scientists. Now it is estimated that it is a bit difficult to shoot a better ending than this, and the new version cannot be surpassed in terms of ending, so I have to use Gao E's sequel.

The main reason for the different endings of the new and old versions of "Dream of Red Mansions" is the difference in creative concepts and starting points.

When dealing with the ending, the screenwriters of the old version of "Dream of Red Mansions" are more inclined to follow Cao Xueqin's original work, combined with the research results of red studies, to restructure the ending of this tragic story. Although the first 29 episodes are basically faithful to the original book, in the last 7 episodes, they try to find their own way, except for the relatively well-written marriage of Tanchunyuan, the other plots are relatively brief, and this treatment caused controversy at the time.

The new edition of "Dream of Red Mansions" is more inclined to respect the last 40 chapters of the popular version, that is, Gao E's sequel. It does not have much innovation in the ending, and is basically filmed according to Gao E's sequel, and has a more complete interpretation of some classic scenes such as Jia Baoyu becoming a monk wearing a big red felt and worshipping Jia Zheng in the snow.

Therefore, the different endings of the old and new versions of "Dream of Red Mansions" are due to different creative concepts and starting points.

In fact, the real ending of Dream of Red Mansions has been lost, and the current ending is all fabricated.

The screenwriter is different, the director is different, the actors are different, and the meaning of understanding is different, don't you know that the remake is becoming more and more different from the original work?

This newspaper (reporter.

Liu Chang) Li Shaohong's new "Dream of Red Mansions" has been hotly discussed by the audience since it was broadcast on the Hubei TV comprehensive channel on July 19, and the ratings have been rising. After Lin Daiyu's "naked death" and Baoyu's wedding, the plot of the new "Dream of Red Mansions" is also coming to an end. According to the previous broadcast on the terrestrial channel, the new version of "Dream of Red Mansions" is very different from the finale of the 1987 version, and it has also become the biggest controversy of this controversial TV series, but whether this time it is really like the previous ** report that "tragedy turned into comedy", tomorrow night in the finale of the new "Dream of Red Mansions" broadcast on Hubei TV's comprehensive channel, all the mysteries will be revealed.

Director Li Shaohong has long said that this remake is completely based on the 120 editions of "Dream of Red Mansions" published by the Chinese Academy of Arts and published by the People's Literature Publishing House, and the last 40 episodes are continued by Gao E, strictly respecting the original work. The ending is the same as described in the book, but it is very different from the 1987 version of "Dream of Red Mansions", for example, the 1987 version of "Dream of Red Mansions" is Daiyu's death and Baoyu's marriage, and in the new version of "Dream of Red Mansions", Daiyu's death and Baoyu's marriage are at the same time. And Jia Baoyu did not become a beggar in the end in the new version, but took the high school exam, and Jia Fu has had the hope of raising his eyebrows again.

Daiyu died when Baoyu and Baochai got married, and then Jia's mother died, and then Wang Xifeng died of illness, Baoyu and Lan Ge both won the lift, Baoyu went with the monk and Taoist priest after the exam, listening to Jia's mother's words, Baochai seemed to be pregnant, and the attacker married Jiang Yuhan, and the Jia family was revived.

Baoyu married Baochai, Daiyu died, Baoyu became a monk after the middle lift, and the Jia family was revived

Daiyu died, Baoyu became a monk, Baochai became pregnant, and Jiafu was prosperous.

The old lady died, Daiyu died, Baoyu married Baochai, Baoyu and Jia Lan were lifted, the Jia family was restored to its original appearance, Baochai was pregnant, Baoyu saw through Hongchen and became a monk, Sister Feng died, and Sister Qiao was picked up by Grandma Liu. Anyway, the Jia family is soaring again, it's nonsense.

I couldn't figure out how Sister Qiao arranged it that way. What a big family. I can't accommodate my granddaughter.

Summary. There are multiple versions of Dream of Red Mansions, each with a slightly different ending. But overall, the ending of Dream of Red Mansions can be divided into two common versions:

Version 1: The ending of the unfinished version of "A Dream of Red Mansions" After the death of Cao Xueqin, the author of "A Dream of Red Mansions", the unfinished version of "A Dream of Red Mansions" was compiled and published by Cheng Weiyuan, and there is no clear ending in it. After Jia Baoyu sleepwalks through the flowers and meets Daiyu, the author interrupts his creation, leaving an unresolved ending.

Version 2: The Yuelu Edition of the Ending The Yuelu edition of "Dream of Red Mansions" compiled and published by Yuelu Books is one of the versions closest to Cao Xueqin's manuscript. This version splits the entire story into 80 episodes and writes a relatively complete ending at the end of the story.

According to the Yuelu version of the ending, in the story, Jia Baoyu finally left the Rong Mansion, Daiyu died of illness, and the fate of the other characters was different. It should be noted that due to Cao Xueqin's failure to complete the creation of "Dream of Red Mansions", there is a certain amount of controversy and uncertainty about the ending of the story. There may be slight differences between different versions, which require attention when understanding and reading.

Hope this meets your needs and happy reading!

There are multiple versions of the Dream of the Hail Tower, each with a slightly different ending. But in general, the ending of Dream of Red Mansions can be divided into two common versions: version one:

The ending of the unfinished version of "Dream of Red Mansions" After the death of Cao Xueqin, the author of "Dream of Red Mansions", the unfinished version of "Dream of Red Mansions" was compiled and published by Cheng Weiyuan, in which there is no clear ending. After Jia Baoyu sleepwalks through the flowers and meets Daiyu, the author interrupts his creation, leaving an unresolved ending. Version 2:

The Yuelu edition of Dream of Red Mansions, which was compiled and published by Yuelu Books, is one of the closest editions to Cao Xueqin's manuscript. This version splits the entire story into 80 episodes and writes a relatively complete ending at the end of the story. According to the Yuelu version of the ending, in the story, Jia Qi and Fan Baoyu finally left the Rong Mansion, Daiyu died of illness, and the fate of the other characters is different.

It should be noted that due to Cao Xueqin's failure to complete the creation of "Dream of Red Mansions", the ending of the story is controversial and uncertain. There may be slight differences between different versions, which require attention when understanding and reading. Hope this meets your needs and happy reading!

Can you add, I don't quite understand it.

The Yuelu version is one of the most closely excavated versions of Cao Xueqin's manuscript, and the ending is relatively complete. Jia Baoyu left the Rong Mansion, Daiyu died of illness, and the fate of other characters was the same. There are differences and controversies between different editions of the judgment book, and it is necessary to pay attention to it when reading.

1, Gao E's sequel is written that Baoyu and Baochai got married, and at the moment when the two treasures were completed, Daiyu died with envy and incense; Later, Baoyu and Jia Lan were high school jinshi, and the Jia family talked about filming "Mu Huangen, Yan Shize, Lan Gui Qifang", but Baoyu left home.

2, the ending of Cao Xueqin's original work has been dispersed, and now there are some red scholars researching it. At present, the more popular one is Liu Xinwu's research, which says that Daiyu sank into the lake and died, and the two treasures got married. But after getting married, Baoyu became a monk twice because of the nostalgia for Daiyu, Baochai died tragically after being widowed for a few years, and the Jia family was scattered because of the political struggle.

Later, Baoyu and Shi Xiangyun converged and married with the help of Miaoyu, and the once wealthy embroiderers have now become a beggar couple.