Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty is so similar to Emperor Yang of the Sui Dynasty, why did the Han Xing

There are many reasons, but I will only talk about two points: 1The premise of the conquest of Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty in the middle of the Han Dynasty - the Han Dynasty passed through the stage of "rule by inaction" of Emperor Lu, Emperor Wen and Emperor Jing, during this period, the Han Dynasty repaired the wounds caused by the war, and there was considerable development in both the economy and the military, which was also an important reason why Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty could use troops against the Xiongnu.

The Sui Dynasty, on the other hand, began to carry out large-scale and large-scale construction projects, such as canals, after the Great War and without going through a buffer period. Second, Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty was an emperor who changed his mistakes when he knew them. After decades of conquest, the Han Dynasty was also a poor country, and the war consumed a lot of manpower and financial resources, and Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty apologized to the whole world for this, which is the famous "sin has been edicted".

And Emperor Wen of Sui did not have such energy.

The emperor of the late Ming Dynasty was not a good or bad emperor. Much better than his predecessors, much more industrious, but because of the fault of his predecessors, his life had to be hanged... Hehehehehe.

Emperor Yang of Sui was actually a very ambitious emperor who wanted to make a career. It's a pity that Emperor Yang of Sui was too eager to know the void, which led to a peasant uprising. The Beijing-Hangzhou Grand Canal was dug to connect the economic development of the north and the south.

He was too eager for quick success, and he conquered Goguryeo many times, and encountered natural disasters, which overwhelmed the peasants, and finally the Sui Dynasty collapsed.

Although Emperor Yang of the Sui Dynasty and Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty both made great achievements during their reigns and also made great achievements, the final outcome was completely different. The reasons behind this difference are complex and varied.

First, the historical background of the two people when they were monarchs was different, and the period when they took over was different.

Emperor Yang of the Sui Dynasty took over the Sui Dynasty, and the Sui Dynasty at that time was not long after the annexation of the Chen Dynasty, and the Sui Dynasty was relatively stable when it was in the hands of Emperor Wen of Sui. However, Emperor Yang of Sui saw the achievements of his father, and also regarded Emperor Wen of Sui as a role model, thinking that what the former could do, he could also do, but this is not the case, after all, the foundation of the Sui Dynasty is not stable, and greater efforts are still needed. For Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty, when he took over the Han Dynasty, the foundation of the Han Dynasty was stable enough, which was very beneficial for Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty to take over.

Second, the judgment and choice of the situation are different, and the decision will affect the course of history.

Emperor Yang of the Sui Dynasty misjudged the situation of the Sui Dynasty, at that time the Sui Dynasty had not yet reached stability, so he was anxious to expand the territory, he just ignored the judgment of the current situation of the Sui Dynasty, and just blindly indulged in wanting to annex other countries with his predecessors, rather than focusing on stabilizing the status quo, which also became the precursor of the final result of Emperor Yang of the Sui Dynasty. And Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty is different, because the current situation of the Han Dynasty is very beneficial to Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty, it is completely beneficial for Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty to show his talents.

Third, the two people have different personalities and different strategies for governing the country, and even if they both have certain achievements, they still have different evaluations.

After all, life is a distinct individual, and people's personalities are inevitably private things, and the personalities of Emperor Yang of the Sui Dynasty and Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty are completely different. Of course, their personalities will influence their statecraft and strategies to a greater or lesser extent. However, the reason why they have different evaluations in later generations cannot be attributed to their personalities, objectively speaking, it is still related to their historical background.

Emperor Yang of the Sui Dynasty in history was a tyrant, but the same was true of Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty.

Speaking of whether Emperor Yang of Sui is a tyrant, let's take a look at what Emperor Yang of Sui has done in the 14 years of his reign, Emperor Yang of Sui is not like the TV series ** who killed his father and seized power, killed his brother and sister-in-law, did many bad things, and was very unreasonable and mediocre, but is this really the case? In fact, Emperor Yang of Sui in the official history is not like this, he has not done so many bad things, although Emperor Yang of Sui is a tyrant in history, and he has done some bad things, but he can not be a faint monarch, Emperor Yang of Sui has done a lot of meaningful things. <>

Emperor Yang of the Sui Dynasty has a very obvious personal strengths and weaknesses, Emperor Yang of the Sui Dynasty is very strategic, and the strategic vision of this person is far beyond that of his contemporaries, such as the digging of the Beijing-Hangzhou Grand Canal, we all know that the Beijing-Hangzhou Grand Canal running through the north and south played a very important role in the development of China's industrial agriculture later. Therefore, many poets said that Emperor Yang of the Sui Dynasty had made greater achievements in digging the Grand Canal, and Yu was almost as great as he was in controlling the water. <>

Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty was a Ming monarch in the history of the Han Dynasty, and he was also an emperor with great talent in his heart. He ascended the throne at the age of 16, and in the 54 years of his reign, he continued to expand the territory for his country, not inferior to the Mongol Genghis Khan, defeated the Xiongnu, Xianbei and other neighboring countries that plagued the previous dynasty for many years, in the long ancient Chinese feudal history, the Han Dynasty was honored to become one of the three prosperous eras in Chinese history, even if it is advanced and convenient now, it also makes people feel fascinated. But such a virtuous monarch also did a lot of wrong things in his later years and ended up badly.

That's all because Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty pursued immortality and was superstitious about witchcraft. <>

Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty was only a young boy and was not favored by his father, the reason why he was able to ascend the throne and become the emperor was largely due to the help of his father-in-law and wife, but after Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty ascended the throne, their family was cold, Queen Chen was not valued by her husband, and washed her face with tears in the room every day, and then the palace maid around her offered her a strategy, that is, the witchcraft that was very popular in the Han Palace at that time, saying that as long as you can find a master who can control the witchcraft, you can win the favor of the emperor, Empress Chen was also sick and rushed to the doctor, which is understandable to me, she didn't know what the consequences would bring to herself, and later she found a very famous sorcerer in Chang'an City.

People have a long life for decades, and who can guarantee that they will not make some mistakes?

Emperor Yang of the Sui Dynasty was self-serving, which led to the destruction of the Sui Dynasty, and Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty led the Han Dynasty to the top, and he attacked the Xiongnu in the north. Glory for us.

Because their own contributions to the country are different. Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty spent his life fighting for the country, while Emperor Yang of the Sui Dynasty was always greedy for pleasure.

Emperor Yang of the Sui Dynasty's reforms increased the labor and supply of the common people, resulting in higher taxes. If you don't get the people, you will surely perish.

Emperor Yang of the Sui Dynasty was a good emperor who was diligent in the early days of his reign, and then Emperor Yang of the Sui Dynasty was obsessed with the harem and led to the indistinguishability of loyalty and treachery in the court, and then he implemented reforms and the Grand Canal were almost completed, but because of this, the people were not able to make a living, and they were hungry, so some people rebelled against him, which led to the ruin of the country and the collapse of the family.

He built a lot of buildings, exhausted soldiers and silent martial arts, he was greedy for lust, and he was so happy that the opening of the Grand Canal made many people live in misery, and the people were not able to make a living, which laid a political foundation for the subversion of the Sui Dynasty.

Emperor Yang of the Sui Dynasty reformed for the sake of economic development, but encountered many people's resistance on the way to reform, so it failed.

There is a certain amount of controversy between the two, and the expropriation is tyrannical, so great joy, although the people are working and the money is lost, but the merit is in the future generations.

The similarity is that they both reformed the imperial government, Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty deposed the hundred schools of thought and respected Confucianism alone, while Emperor Yang of the Sui Dynasty created the imperial examination system.

During the reign of Emperor Yang of the Sui Dynasty and Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty, they both carried out large-scale foreign conquest wars, Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty opened a sedan chair to fight against the Xiongnu, and Emperor Yang of the Sui Dynasty conquered Goryeo three times, and they all learned that the country was finally impoverished, and the internal contradictions of the country began to intensify.

Yes, he was the king of the dead country, but he also did good deeds, he dug the Grand Canal. The imperial examination system seems to have started at his time...

Tyrants in history: 础, 纣, Qin Shi Huang...

History is written by people. You should think about the problem from your own point of view, and the merits and demerits are still to be commented on by future generations.