If Fusu and Meng Tian had not committed suicide, how would the history of the Qin Dynasty develop?

I think that if Fusu and Meng Tian do not commit suicide, the Qin Dynasty will eventually perish, Fusu relied on Meng Tian's military strength to conquer Qin II, and there were already contradictions within the Qin Dynasty, coupled with the infighting of the prince, it would eventually perish.

I think the Qin Dynasty may last longer, because the prince of Fusu is very virtuous and a good heir, and the general Meng Tian can fight well and is very brave.

It is estimated that the Qin Dynasty will not fall so early, on the contrary, it will continue to implement the policy left by Qin Shi Huang, then there will be no later chaos in the world, but it is a pity that history is history, and there is no if.

Because someone modified the holy decree left by Qin Shi Huang, Fusu and Meng Tian mistakenly thought that Qin Shi Huang was disgusted with him.

Fusu's suicide had his own reasons, as well as the reasons of the Qin Dynasty system, although Fusu had the general Meng Tian by his side and 300,000 Qin troops, he still chose to commit suicide, leaving behind a regret for the ages!

Fusu committed suicide for his own reasons, Sima Qian commented on Fusu, "Fusu is benevolent", which means that Fusu is benevolent and righteous. Fusu may have been greatly influenced by Confucianism, and he was not usually seen to give advice to Qin Shi Huang, but when Qin Shi Huang wanted to kill Confucianism, he gave advice to Qin Shi Huang. Because of this, Qin Shi Huang relegated him to the frontier and sent him to the Great Wall as a supervisor, and supervised the construction of the Great Wall with Meng Tian!

You must know that during the Warring States Period, it was Legalism that ruled the world, and Confucianism was unpopular.

Therefore, as the eldest son of the emperor, Fusu, because Confucianism was killed, he admonished Qin Shi Huang, and also said, "The world has just been settled, and the people in the remote areas have not yet been attached, and the Confucian scholars have all read poetry and books, imitating Confucius, and now Your Majesty is dealing with them with severe criminal law, I am worried that the world will be unstable." ”

Legalism and Confucianism are incompatible, Legalism advocates the obedience of the people through severe punishment and strict laws, while Confucianism wants to govern the world through benevolence and virtue, and pays attention to "benevolence, righteousness, courtesy, wisdom, and faith". Therefore, this was something that Qin Shi Huang could not tolerate, and Fusu was still the eldest son, so Qin Shi Huang sent him to the Great Wall to see how the people who built the Great Wall should be managed.

The system of the Qin Dynasty was strict, and it was easy for no one to dare to violate the Qin Dynasty Since the Shang Dynasty changed the law, the people were very afraid of the system of the Qin Dynasty, and no one dared to break the law easily, let alone commit the crime of rebellion. Shang Ying made so many contributions to the Qin Dynasty that he was named the Shang Emperor, and when he fled, no one dared to take him in; In the later period of the Qin Dynasty, even if Zhao Gao was so chaotic, no Qin Dynasty officials dared to rebel against the authority of the imperial court.

Therefore, the order of the Qin Dynasty is unchallengeable! Then, when Fusu received the edict tampered with by Zhao Gao and Hu Hai and ordered him to kill himself, he did not know that it was a fake edict, and he did not know that his father Qin Shi Huang was dead, in principle, he did not dare to resist.

Some people say that Meng Tian did not commit suicide, that is because Meng Tian is a general of the Qin Dynasty, and he is a brother to Meng Yi, and the Meng family is a meritorious clan that Qin Shi Huang relied on. So he didn't believe that Qin Shi Huang would let him commit suicide, but even then, although he had an army of 300,000, he didn't dare to rebel, he just handed over the military power to Wang Li, got into the prisoner car himself, and wanted to go to Xianyang to ask Qin Shi Huang for his guilt!

If Fusu didn't commit suicide and led Meng Tian's 300,000 army back to Xianyang, what would be the result?

Because of the false holy decree that came over Fusu to commit suicide, it said that it was the will of King Qin, and Fusu chose to believe in King Qin and his younger brother Hu Hai, so he chose to commit suicide.

Because he didn't want to linger, and he also understood that this situation was inevitable and he would not win, so he chose this way.

Because he was framed at that time, and the internal contradictions in the army were also fierce at that time, he chose to commit suicide.

Because Fusu may believe that the divine decree is true, and he himself is a submissive person, he will commit suicide.

Mainly because it is written on the holy decree that if you don't die, your mother will die for you, and Fusu is a very filial person.

The tragic fate of Fusu is due to both Qin Shi Huang's strength and Fusu's own weakness. Qin Shi Huang was not close to people, the laws of the Qin Dynasty were too harsh, and Fusu had no political acumen.

Fusu is certainly virtuous, but he has his weaknesses as a king. Hu Hai was too tyrannical, and he was too benevolent, Qin Shi Huang had just passed away, and the internal affairs were chaotic, leaving behind a mess, and there was no way to quickly stabilize the country without iron and blood. Moreover, with the character of Fusu, even if he was not harmed by Qin Shi Huang's false edict and ascended to the throne at that time, he was likely to fall into other pits in the governance of the court.

I think it depends on whether Fusu has the ambition to become emperor, and if not, then it will have little impact on history. On the contrary, if Fusu had wanted to become emperor, with his eloquence and benevolence, the Qin dynasty would have ruled longer and history would have changed.

I think it will change. Because Fusu is a person who cares about the people and focuses on the interests of the people, and is deeply supported by the people, if he hadn't committed suicide, he would definitely be a Ming Jun.

Even if Fusu hadn't died, the country's history would not have changed. Because Qin Shi Huang suffered many assassinations when he was alive, it can be seen that it will not change because of Fusu's accession to the throne.

Yes, if Fusu does not commit suicide and Fusu and Meng Tian rebel, it is estimated that the Qin Dynasty will exist for at least fifty years, and then China's history will be rewritten.

The answer is yes, any change will lead to different results. Fusu and Hu Hai are two people with completely different personalities, and if Fusu can ascend to the throne, it means that he has defeated his political opponents. In an environment like ancient times, the reign of any person would have a strong personal color, so if Fusu could ascend to the throne, history would be different.

If Fusu does not die, the Qin Dynasty will also perish, because Fusu has a very kind personality, and it is difficult for a kind person to act in troubled times. Sometimes the decision to kill requires ruthlessness.

If the recovery did not commit suicide, the history of the Qin State should change. Because Fusu is a virtuous lord and has won the hearts of the people, he is also very talented in governance.

No, when the people revolted, it had turned into anger against the entire Qin dynasty rather than anger at Qin Shi Huang or Qin II personally. Therefore, Fusu is the successor of the Qin Dynasty in any case, and he stands opposite the people.

Under the circumstances of the Qin Dynasty at that time, people like Fusu were needed.

I think it will change, because Fusu and Hu Hai are completely different people, Fusu is enterprising, and he also cares about the people, so he should change the history of Qin.

In the winter of the 37th year of Qin Shi Huang (210 BC), Zhao Zheng toured the world and unfortunately died of illness when he traveled to the sand dunes. Before Qin Shi Huang died, he summoned Fusu to Xianyang to preside over the funeral and inherit the throne. However, the CRRC government ordered Zhao Gao and Prime Minister Li Si and others to conspire with Zhao Huhai, the youngest son of Qin Shi Huang, to tamper with the edict of the first emperor and make Hu Hai the crown prince, that is, the emperor.

At the same time, another book was given to Meng Tian and Fu Su to die, and "count the sins". Hu Hai's envoy sent a letter to Shangjun, and Fusu opened the edict knowing that he would definitely die, so he prepared to commit suicide in Fusu's tomb. The general Meng Tian was once suspicious, and strongly persuaded Fusu not to commit suicide, "Please re-apply, re-invite and then die, before the twilight."

However, Fusu was generous and benevolent, unwilling to betray his salute, and immediately committed suicide in the Shangjun army.

There are many theories about Fusu's death, and many people are skeptical of the historical records, and the conclusion is still inconclusive.

Some people believe that Fusu saw through the plan of Zhao Gao and others, and it was only because the world was initially decided, and he did not want to provoke a war, nor did he want to meet his brothers to avoid unnecessary disputes, so he resolutely committed suicide. But Fusu's approach was relatively incorrect, and if he became emperor, then China's history would probably have to be rewritten.

was killed by Zhao Gao and Li Si under the false legend of Qin Shi Huang's widow. Both committed suicide.

In 210 BC, Qin Shi Huang died of illness on his way out, and Zhao Gao and Li Si jointly made a fake edict and ordered Fu Su and Meng Tian to commit suicide. Fusu did not argue with the truth and committed suicide. Meng Tian was reluctant to commit suicide and asked to appeal to Hu Hai.

Zhao Gao's envoys imprisoned him. After Meng Tian was imprisoned, Zhao Gao wanted to release him, but he was worried that Meng Tian's brothers would make a comeback, and he would not be able to dictate in front of Hu Hai, so he framed Meng Tian's younger brother Meng Yi in front of Hu Hai for saying bad things about Hu Hai in front of Qin Shi Huang, and finally Hu Hai listened to Zhao Gao's slander, killed Meng Yi, and then sent someone to kill Meng Tian. Meng Tian again asked the messenger to give him a chance to appeal, but the messenger did not agree, and Meng Tian had no choice but to commit suicide by taking poison with hatred.

Fusu committed suicide by order Meng Tian was forced to commit suicide by taking poison