The 9 year old girl s grandfather, who took care of her for a few more years, what is the reason for

The 9-year-old girl was restricted from high consumption by the court because she could not return the 550,000 yuan purchase price for her father, and was executed as an "old lai".。The cause of the incident was that the girl's father wanted to buy a house, and his wife and mother-in-law did not agree to buy a house, so the girl's father Chen had murderous intent and killed his wife and mother-in-law, and his father Chen was sentenced to death by the court after intentional homicide, and executed, the father did not give the 550,000 yuan obtained from buying a house to the girl, and the girl was only 9 months old at the time, but the girl had to bear the responsibility of "paying off the debt for her father".

1. The story of the girl becoming an old man. The girl's father, Chen, killed his wife and mother-in-law in 2012 to buy a house, and sold the house to Wang the next day, and the 550,000 yuan he earned from buying a house has been squandered. The girl did not get the money to buy a house, and her father sentenced Chen to death for intentional homicide.

Because the house was not successfully transferred, Chen had already been executed, so the buyer Wang sued the girl in court and asked for a legal and valid purchase contract, which was rejected by the court. In 2018, the buyer Wang sued the girl in court again, demanding to terminate the house transfer contract and return the house payment of 550,000 yuan and interest, and the buyer Wang won the support of the court.

2. The court apologizes: we were wrong. The court required the girl to return the purchase price of 550,000 yuan and interest to the buyer, Wang, but because the girl could not afford it, the 9-year-old girl was executed by the court as an "old lai".

is also on the hot search because of "a 9-year-old girl becomes an old man". So the court apologized and responded that "we were wrong". It also explained the cause and process of the verdict, and that juveniles should be cared for, and juveniles should not be executed as old men.

3. Where should girls and home buyers go? After the girl's father, Chen, sold the house, the buyer Wang, also lived in the house, but the house had been seized, and the property had always belonged to the girl. The girl's father had been executed, her mother had been killed by her father, and the money from the sale of the house was gone, and the 9-year-old girl really could not afford such a debt.

But what's wrong with the buyer? Not only did the house not got, but it also lost 550,000 yuan in vain. It seems that the girl is innocent, but the girl's father is in debt, so she should die?

What do you think should be done to be fair?

The murder of his wife and mother by a father in debt has forced a 9-year-old girl to become a "scumbag", and the mortgage owed by the father can only be repaid by the daughter.

Girls are indebted because they inherit the inheritance of their parents, and when they inherit the estate, they also inherit the debt. The father took someone else's money but the house was not completely transferred, and the girl was unwilling to sell it with the original ** after inheritance, and did not give the house or return the money, and the buyer was empty.

The reason why the girl is in debt is not because the girl herself spends too much, but because her father is in debt and dies, which causes the debt to pass on to the daughter.

The main reason for a girl's debt is that she inherited the debt of her deceased parents, which can be said to be very pitiful and helpless, but there is a saying that the father pays the debt to the son.

The girl is in debt because her parents died, but there is a debt of 550,000 yuan, which naturally falls on herself.

YesAfter being restricted from high consumption for 20 days by the Jinshui District Court of Zhengzhou City, Henan Province, Chen Man (pseudonym), a 9-year-old girl, received an enforcement decision to lift the consumption restriction order.

Chen Man's grandfather, Wang Weizhi, said in an interview what his plans are for the futureArrange the child's life and study well. ”

The child is still young, after losing his father, mother, and grandmother, only his grandfather is the only relative, and his grandfather is old and the child is still young, which is really a very poor family. I hope that the child's grandfather will take care of his health, live a long and healthy life, and the girl will be sensible as soon as possible.

The child's life is okay now, because the court did not sentence her to be in debt, and she returned to her normal life.

Now the child's life is very normal, and he goes to school normally under the care of his grandfather, after all, the child is still young and has no ability to repay the debt.

This child is living a good life now, because she has an adoptive father and adoptive mother who loves her very much, and after his mother was killed by her father, she became a human being, and fortunately later met her adoptive father and adoptive mother.

It can be said that this 9-year-old girl has become an old man, and it is very aggrieved and innocent to pay off his father's debts. After all, I am still so young, and I have endured some things that I should not bear at this age, and the big draft has affected my growth and affected my spirit. His father killed his biological mother and grandmother 8 years ago, because his father was very fond of gambling, and it can be said that a 9-year-old girl was only one year old at that time, so you can imagine how pitiful the child was, and then his father sold the house to the buyer Wang.

After Wang paid 550,000 yuan, he failed to transfer the house to him, and after that, the little girl's father was also sentenced to death, and Fang Jingxiaozi naturally returned to the 9-year-old girl. Because after all, this 9-year-old girl is his father's first heir, but according to the normal procedures of the law. The little girl inherited the property that she is obliged to pay off her father's debts, which is not a problem at all from a legal point of view, but everyone ignores it.

That is, this house was actually the joint property of the parents before this, and when the mother was killed, in fact, as a child, he could also become the first heir. This thing seems normal but it is not normal, because the child's father is a gambling debt because he likes to gamble and wants to sell the house to pay off the debt, but as a daughter, she is the heir of her mother, and he has the right to make decisions about the house, and if the child does not agree with his father's behavior, he has no right to sell the house. <>

So when his father killed his mother, he didn't actually have all the rights to the house. This house naturally fell on the little girl, but now the house is sold by the father, and the property is not on the daughter, it can be said that this 9-year-old girl should not pay off the debt for her father, and should not be restricted by the law from all consumption, after all, her father is also selling the house in violation of the regulations, which is legally ineffective, since it is not effective, then the 550,000 yuan should not be repaid by the girl.

Personally, I don't think she should be responsible for paying off her debts, because this little girl is only 9 years old and she has no ability to pay her debts at all.

Of course, he should pay off his father's debts, but not now, after all, he is still young now, and the debt ring is a matter of course.

I don't think so, for a nine-year-old girl, she can't be independent in her own life, what should she do to pay off her father's debts.

The court has now urgently withdrawn the lesbian's height restriction order, and the court issued an apology in the early hours of the morning, saying that such a penalty result is mechanical law enforcement and should be avoided. Personally, I think that the court's statement is very warm, because many things often need to find a balance between legal reason and reasonableness, so as to show the warmth and goodwill of our law enforcement.

1. This incident is a very big tragedy, and what happened to the girl is also very tragic.

The 9-year-old girl suffered very tragically, because her biological father took her mother. After his father was sentenced to death, he found out that his father had sold their house to another buyer 8 years ago, and the other buyer had already given her father 550,000 yuan for the house, and now she needs to bear the debt of 550,000 yuan owed by her father. It is for this reason that the 9-year-old girl was ruled by the court to restrict the high-spending group.

Second, netizens are hotly discussing this incident.

The reason why netizens are hotly discussing this incident is because the 9-year-old girl's experience is too tragic, and at the same time, he has to bear such an additional financial burden. For such a situation, many netizens expressed their willingness to support the 9-year-old girl, and some people believed that the legitimate rights and interests of another home buyer also needed to be protected. <>

3. What is my personal opinion on this matter?

Regarding this matter, the court's statement is that although the law is stipulated, we must take into account the warm law enforcement outside the law, which means that this society needs to have good intentions. I personally agree with this point of view of the court, because in this society, a 9-year-old girl like this is a victim herself, and it is obviously unreasonable to impose her identity as a perpetrator, and I hope that people from all walks of life can also take the initiative to help this 9-year-old girl. <>

This is a loophole in the lawsuit, a nine-year-old girl who is only nine years old has a spending restriction due to her inability to repay her father's debts, and the court has issued a spending limit, which also involves a lot of personal rights. Then the matter was resolved, and the response was that it was wrong.

The court said that the previous trial result was wrong and that it has now revoked the result, and also said that it will tighten the trial in the future to achieve a court that satisfies the people.

The court said that it was not necessary to prove that the girl was going to pay off her father's debts, because the girl did not have an income and did not have the ability to work, so the court did not make a coercive move.

Regarding this matter, the court also considered that its previous judgment was not very reasonable, and reversed the previous judgment.

The court also made its own most correct judgment on such a matter, so it is very fair and just to remove this girl from the scope of the old lai.

Because the father's debt is repaid by the daughter, the father will suffer if he can't pay the girl, so it is normal to become a lai.

Her father was a gambler who wanted to sell the house and killed his wife and mother-in-law, he sold the house and received 550,000 yuan from the buyer, but he was sentenced before the transfer of the house, resulting in his child being forced to become a liar when he was 2 years old.

This was a mistake made by the Zhengzhou Jinshui District Court in execution, which has now been corrected, and the court has apologized.

At the age of 9, most of the time he is still lying in the arms of his parents, enjoying his parents' love for him. But there is a 9-year-old girl who wants to repay a high debt of 550,000 yuan for her father, which immediately attracted heated discussions among netizens, and netizens also have different attitudes and opinions on the court's judgment.

1. Where does the girl's debt come from?

2. Can girls afford to pay their debts?

3. Does the debt need to be inherited?

The girl himself is already an orphan, he himself is a victim of this matter, and now it is really distressing to have him bear a high debt at a young age, this debt should not be borne by the girl, do you agree with me?

I don't think this 9-year-old girl should pay her father's debts because she is not yet able to pay her debts, and she is still a child, so she should not be responsible for paying debts at such a young age.

led to a court judgment that allowed the girl to inherit a high debt of 550,000 yuan. And the girl is still a minor and is a low-income household, so it is not reasonable to inherit the debt in such a situation.

I don't think the girl should pay off her father's debts, because this child's life is miserable enough, and it is unfair for her to have to bear a huge debt before she feels the beauty of this world.

I don't think she should pay these foreign debts for her father, she is a minor and does not have the legal responsibility to bear the debts. I still hope that the broad masses of the people will realize their own debt capacity and borrow money according to their debt capacity.

I don't think a 9-year-old child has the ability to pay off her father's debts, and even if she wants to pay off her debts, she will have to wait until she is an adult and has the ability to work and earn an income to pay off her father's debts.

I think she should pay off her father's debts, but not now, but when she has the ability to do so.

Personally, I don't think this girl, at her current age, should pay her father's debts, because she is a minor and has no ability to pay her debts.

I don't think she should pay off her father's debts, one is that she is still so young, and she didn't raise her at all as a father at that time.

I don't think she should pay off her father's debts, because she is only a child after all, how can she have the ability to bear her father's debts.

I don't think this little girl should pay off her father's debts, because this little girl has no stable financial income at all, and she has no ability to work, so I think this little girl should also focus on studying.