Why did the Ming army resist the Qing army, but the Qing army couldn t resist the invasion army, why

This statement is wrong.

Before the elite of the Ming army was lost, Li Zicheng's peasant rebel army was not at all and was scattered by the Ming army many times.

At the end of the Ming Dynasty, the elite troops of the Ming army were mainly the border troops guarding the nine sides and the border troops guarding the Shanhaiguan.

The border army guarding the nine borders was completely annihilated by the Qing army after the Battle of Songjin, resulting in the emptiness of the domestic army in Guan, and Li Zicheng's peasant rebel army took advantage of the situation and drove all the way into and occupied Beijing.

The combat effectiveness of the invading army is really not flattering, and hundreds of thousands of troops were defeated in a battle at Shanhaiguan, and then they were crushed for thousands of miles.

In contrast, Zhang Xianzhong's Great Western Army's combat effectiveness was okay.

Li Zicheng's army cannot surpass the Ming Dynasty's border army in combat effectiveness, don't look at the Ming Dynasty's border army in the face of the Eight Banners repeatedly defeated, afraid of the enemy like a tiger, fighting the peasant army is not merciless, like a tiger into a flock! There are too many problems in the Ming Dynasty itself, and the two most important points are the national economy and army building!

1. On the issue of overall warfare, the internal party struggle in the Ming Dynasty was too fierce, and the internal attacks on each other led to mutual demolition; On the other hand, the resources of the South cannot be used effectively. On the other hand, the Eight Banners system adopted by the Qing army actually achieved a general war, concentrated resources on the largest scale, and narrowed the gap between everyone.

2. Strategic issues, the Ming army has been in a state of passive beating and repentance, hiding in the fortress group of the western Liaoning corridor and not daring to come out, allowing the Qing army to skip the Inner Mongolia line, the Qing army has full initiative and adopted the strategy of cutting down uncles.

3. On the issue of soldiers, the Mingshen Dynasty follows the military household system, and the status of military households is very low, belonging to the untouchable class, and there is no pride. In peacetime, they mainly focus on farming, lack of training, and have low combat effectiveness.

Of course, it was the Ming army, the Ming Dynasty died, and the fight in the north was made by the peasant army, and the scourge of the rogues was gone, and the Manchu Qing Dynasty entered the customs to pick up leaks, and the south relied on Wu Sangui, and the traitor green camp of Shang Kexi and others fought the world. This group of dogs hid behind and pressed the formation, and the traitor soldiers and the captured ordinary people rushed to the city to be cannon fodder. When the attrition of the defenders of the city is gone, they will attack the city.

Attack and slaughter the city, Nanming is basically the green camp traitor soldiers to beat down, the so-called true Tartar invincible is a joke, Li Dingguo killed the two princes, Yangzhou also killed the Tartar head, this group of dogs do not hide, let the traitor soldiers rush, hundreds of thousands of real Tartars have already ended, the power of the traitor soldiers, is to attack the city can make a little money, full of dogs generally attack the city to burn and rob, slaughter the city, the traitor soldiers steal some stolen goods, share a little soup, there is the motivation to attack.

This is very similar to the fall of the Southern Song Dynasty, the Tartars drove several traitor warlords in the north to fight in the front, the Han people killed the Han people, and they picked up the cheap. If you can't attack it, you will catch the people and rush to the city, and consume it, the traitor's life is worthless, and you will die casually, anyway, it will consume the defenders of the city, and the Tartars will slaughter the city in the end.

Sadly, this is the sadness of the lack of nationalism. In modern times, too, the Virgin of the traitor is desperately trying to detain the national consciousness of the Han nationality and nihilize the Han people. The common people are insensitive, and when foreign dogs call in the future, I don't know how many traitors will lead the party.

The narrow sense of the emperor is not good, but the broad sense (Sinicization of the people of the people) Great China Emperor Hanism must have.

All kinds of independent dogs, cultists, traitors, should be killed.

Because the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom contained a large number of Manchu troops, the Anglo-French alliance launched the Opium War under the pretext of changing the treaty.

Because the Qing ** is not a million army fighting with the great powers. First of all, it is certain that the combat effectiveness of the Qing army is poor, but the most important thing is that more than one million troops of the Qing Dynasty are stationed all over the country, such as the Northeast garrison, the Xinjiang garrison, the Guangxi garrison, the Jiangnan and Jiangbei camps, etc., so that once the troops are dispersed, there will be fewer troops in various places, and it is impossible to transfer all the troops of the whole country to fight at once when fighting, and they are generally fought by local garrisons. For example, there are only tens of thousands of people stationed in the area of Beijing, and naturally they can't defeat the 20,000 British and French allied troops.

For example, Liaoning's defense against Japan, Aihui's defense against Russia, Guangdong, Haifeng, and Jiangnan's camp are very important, and they cannot be easily mobilized, even if the army travels from Guangdong to Beijing, it will take several months, and the battle will be over long by then. So the Qing ** army was always defeated.

Thousands of shameful treaties have been signed, and everyone knows that the Qing Dynasty is a big fat sheep that does not rob white.

Because although the Ming army had advanced firearms and equipment, because the soldiers of the Ming Dynasty army were negligent in training, and the chaos of the Ming Dynasty government, the army's salaries and grass were often poor, so the Qing army lost more than won many victories.

Because the Qing army was a people on the grassland, they were good at fighting, and they were physically strong, and they were often tempered in actual combat, while the Ming army rarely fought, so they could not defeat the Qing army.

Internal and external troubles, domestic uprisings, foreign Jurchens see the needle, eyeing each other, the dynasty is paralyzed, each saves his life, the generals desperately resist and have no power to return to the sky, the gas is exhausted, Chongzhen is very diligent and thrifty, but also pitiful, has not enjoyed the emperor's clean days, to be honest, I personally think that the combat effectiveness of the Manchu Qing is not as good as that of the Han Ming.

The Ming Dynasty was destroyed by Li Zicheng!

Because the Ming Dynasty at that time was already very weak, the military strength was not strong, and the internal contradictions became more and more prominent, and the Qing army was very strong at that time.

Because at the end of the Ming Dynasty, the Ming Dynasty army was basically gone, and there was no support from the world, so it couldn't withstand the Qing army at all.

In history, the last years of the Ming Dynasty were already in internal and external troubles, there were internal rebels of Li Zicheng, Zhang Xianzhong and others, and the external Manchu forces were also extremely strong, plus Wu Sangui let the Qing army enter the customs, which did not stop the Qing army, otherwise the Ming Dynasty would not have perished so quickly.

It may be that in the last years of the Ming Dynasty, the strength was already very weak, so no one could stop the Qin army.

The Qing army was invited in by Wu Sangui when he opened the pass.

I think it was because there were traitors like Wu Sangui in the Ming Dynasty at that time, and on the one hand, the Qing army was also very strong in combat.

Yes, the rulers of the Qing Dynasty were Manchus, and the Manchus were nomads from the northeast with relatively good physical fitness, and the military qualities of the generals were excellent.

Because the combat effectiveness of the Ming army in different periods is different, this is closely related to the national strength of the country; It was not that the Manchu Qing were too strong in combat, but that the late Ming Dynasty was too weak.