Wei Yan has made countless contributions in his life, why was he still framed?

Updated on history 2024-04-25
15 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    Wei Yan has made countless contributions in his life, but in the end he was framed because there were too many insidious villains in the court, and he was not good at palace scheming, and he was finally framed by the people of the court.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    Because Wei Yan was a general at the beginning, Zhuge Liang always looked at him unpleasantly, and in the end, during the Northern Expedition, Wei Yan often opposed Zhuge Liang and had different opinions from Zhuge Liang, so he was killed.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    There is a key point, that is, once Wei Yan used a plan, but Zhuge Liang did not adopt it, and then there was a contradiction, in fact, Wei Yan and Chen Shi were very unhappy with Zhuge Liang's use of troops that time, but it was not explained later, because Zhuge Liang was beautified in the Three Kingdoms, so the evaluation of Wei Yan was unfair. It said that Wei Yan had a backbone in the back of his head or something, it was purely Zhuge Liang's nonsense, in order to kill Wei Yan, and in the end, Wei Yan rebelled, but he was actually forced. Because Wei Yan overturned the altar at that time, he was considered by the superstitious ancients to be the sinner who killed Zhuge Liang, in fact, he had no place in Shu in the later period.

    Zhuge Liang himself does not know how to use people. For example, Ma Yan, such as Wei Yan. I don't know what kind of person Wei Yan is, but he can serve as the Taishou of Hanzhong.

    His status is second only to "Five Tiger Generals", which shows that his status is still very important.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    TV series "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" Wei Yan (played by Wang Xinhai) TV series "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" Wei Yan (played by Liu Wei) fought with Liu Bei at the beginning, with both wisdom and bravery, bravely crowned the three armies, and won Liu Bei's trust. Wei Yan was a lonely person, deeply aware of righteousness, and made many military exploits, especially relied on by Zhuge Liang in the later period. But the character is relatively high, a little rebellious (this "rebellion" is not rebellion in the ancient sense, but in the modern sense, for example, we will say that a certain child is very rebellious), very confident in his own ability, often complaining, do not know how to deal with interpersonal relations in the officialdom, offended many people, especially with Yang Yishi.

    After Zhuge Liang's death, because he was unwilling to withdraw his troops and could not tolerate the military power falling into the hands of his rival Yang Yi, he disobeyed Zhuge Liang's last order to withdraw his troops without authorization, and led the army to burn the plank road and attack Yang Yi. In the end, he was wrongfully accused of rebellion and suffered the tragic consequences of the "three tribes".

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    True rebellion is only forced to rebel. It wasn't counter-offensive at the outset.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    In Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Wei Yan.

    In fact, it is not considered to be unjustly killed. It can only be said that Wei Yan can have such a result, which has a lot to do with his own personality and temper, including the way he does things. If in Zhuge Liang.

    After death, listen to Zhuge Liang's words, then Wei Yan is very likely to be qualified for the position of prime minister and be reused. <>

    You must know that Zhuge Liang is very famous, and Zhuge Liang's subordinates have two generals, one is Yang Yi.

    One is Wei Yan, one is one writer and one martial arts, all of them are indispensable. Before Zhuge Liang died, he was also concerned about his country, so he explained some things to the two generals under him, but Wei Yan thought that he was capable of being the prime minister, so he violated the oath he promised Zhuge Liang to lead the troops, but was opposed by Yang Yi. It was precisely because of Wei Yan's sudden approach that everyone thought that Wei Yan had a rebellious mentality, so Yang Yi formed a mortal enmity with Zhi Hui Wei Yan.

    Wei Yan not only took the lead in occupying the Nangukou area, but also attacked Yang Yi and his army, and Yang Yi was not to be outdone. Therefore, Wei Yan fled to a place with a small number of his soldiers and his son, but at this time he had been charged with rebellion, so he sent someone to arrest Wei Yan, and he had already changed his way and died in the hands of Yang Yi's men. In fact, Wei Yan's own psychology is not bad, but the only thing that makes everyone feel cold is that he did not listen to Zhuge Liang's words.

    You must know that the moment Wei Yan made up his mind to be the prime minister, his heart, including his psychology, changed. <>

    If Wei Yan didn't have such a situation and could listen to Zhuge Liang's words, then he would be able to be reused like Yang Yi, and he would also be praised by future generations. I have to say that Wei Yan's death really made many people sad, and it is still very heart-wrenching for such a capable military general to get such an ending. Therefore, through this matter, everyone can learn certain knowledge and gain certain truths.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    This is true, because he died at the hands of his own family, and he didn't even think about rebelling against some generals in history, but he was still unjustly killed.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Not at all. Because he chose to rebel after Zhuge Liang's death, it is said that his death was deserved.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    This is because someone framed him, so it will lead to him being wronged, which will lead to his death.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Wei Yan has a very outstanding military talent, he followed Liu Bei to fight in the south and the north, and his Meridian Valley plot is also very practical, but unfortunately Wei Yan does not understand power and strategy, and was suppressed by Zhuge Liang all his life, and finally died in the hands of Yang Yi.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Wei Yan's military talent was first-class in Shu, and during Wei Yan's tenure as the Taishou of Hanzhong, he never let Wei take a step forward in Hanzhong. And after his successor, who served as the Taishou of Hanzhong, Hanzhong was soon lost.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Wei Yan's military talent is still very powerful, which can be seen from the fact that he has never had problems in guarding Han; Because his death caused Shu Han to lose a fierce general, and he died at the hands of his own people, so it is a pity.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    And Wei Yan's death was actually not aggrieved, the first of the soldiers to launch the Northern Expedition, Wei Yan contributed a lot, broke Fei Yao and Guo Huai, and pursued them all the way to the hinterland of Wei. The duty is obedience, and Wei Yan, as the leader of the troops, not only failed to fulfill his duties, but also prevented the retreat of the troops. If it weren't for Wang Ping's stopping, I don't know how many people would have died, and such a reckless and irrational act could be regarded as a rebellion.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    Wei Yan was indeed killed by Ma Dai.

    In 234 A.D. (the twelfth year of Jianxing), Zhuge Liang made the fifth Northern Expedition. In the autumn, Zhuge Liang's illness worsened, and he secretly retired from the army after the death of Changshi Yang Yi, Sima Feiyi, and Jiang Wei, etc., so that after Wei Yan broke off, if he delayed or did not obey his orders, he would do as he pleased. Zhuge Liang died, and he was not mourned, Yang Yi ordered Fei Yi to figure out Wei Yan's intentions.

    Wei Yan said: "Although the prime minister is dead, but there is still me, how can the world's major affairs be wasted because of a person's death?"

    Besides, who am I, Wei Yan, and how can I be at the mercy of Yang Yi and be a general after the break? ”

    The army slowly retreated with Yang Yi, Wei Yan was furious, day and night, rushed in front of Yang Yi's army, and burned the pavilion everywhere he walked. Yang Yi and Wei Yan both went to each other to say that the other party had rebelled, and Liu Chan asked Dong Yun and Shi Jiangwan, the governor of the palace, who wanted to rebel, and Dong Jiang and Jiang both guaranteed that Yang Yi suspected Wei Yan. Wei Yan first occupied the mouth of the Nangu and led his army to attack Yang Yi's army, and Yang Yi ordered Wang Ping to defend against Wei Yan in front.

    Wang Ping scolded Wei Yan's vanguard: "Zhuge Gong died, and the bones are not cold, how dare you people do this!" "Wei Yan's army knew that Wei Yan was at fault, and they didn't listen to Wei Yan's orders, so they all dispersed.

    Only Wei Yan and his sons fled to Hanzhong, Yang Yi sent Ma Dai to catch up with Wei Yan and behead him, and dedicated his head to Yang Yi, Yang Yi trampled Wei Yan's head with his feet, and scolded: "Yongnu! Can you do evil again?

    So they exterminated the three tribes of Wei and Yan.

    The Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms recorded: "The original Yanyi did not descend to Wei in the north and returned to the south, but wanted to eliminate the killing instrument and so on." ”

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    The Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms recorded: Yan Shi knew that the song was in Yan, and he didn't use his life, and the army was scattered. Yan Du and several of his sons fled and ran to Hanzhong. Yi sent Ma Dai to chase and behead him, and he gave his head to Yi, and Yi stepped on it, saying: "Yong slave! Can you do evil? "Then the three tribes of Yiyan.

    The Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms is still relatively credible, and it is clearly written on it, "Yuan Yanyi does not surrender to Wei in the north and returns to the south, but wants to eliminate the killing instrument and so on." Wei Yan was at odds with Yang Yi, wanted to kill Yang Yi but did not take the righteousness, and his subordinates were scattered and killed by Ma Dai.

    There is also a saying that Zhuge Liang entrusted the military power to Wei Yan, and Yang Yi was afraid so he designed to kill Wei Yan, Pei Songzhi's note. I still believe in the Three Kingdoms.

Related questions
12 answers2024-04-25

Because An Lushan launched a rebellion at that time, he wrote that poem.

10 answers2024-04-25

got it, because Guo Ziyi was low-key and cautious, so he was able to die well.

31 answers2024-04-25

It's not a threat, or no one in the Son of Heaven likes someone to point fingers in front of him every day, and that kind of person is looking for death.

20 answers2024-04-25

Because he is too arrogant and unruly, he has a bad relationship with **.

12 answers2024-04-25

At the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty, the heroes rose up, and the situation of the Three Kingdoms appeared, and those who have read "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" know that Liu Bei, Cao Cao, and Sun Quan are divided equally The reason why the three of them divide the world equally depends not on the wisdom of a single person but on the people of Wuwen under them, Liu Bei has the two major strategists of Wolong and Phoenix, Sun Quan has Zhou Yu, Cao Cao has Guo Jia and Xun Yu, but Guo Jia died young, so Xun Yu has become an important figure in Cao Cao's establishment of hegemony, but for fans of the Three Kingdoms, they all know that Xun Yu is an out-and-out person who wants to help the Han family, On the day of his death, he was still loyal to the Han family, and we couldn't help but wonder, why didn't he defect to Liu Bei but to Liu Bei's nemesis Cao Cao? Is there some hidden secret behind it? >>>More