Did Guan Yu kill Hua Xiong

1) In history, Huaxiong was beheaded by Sun Jian, and it has nothing to do with Guan Yu, please read Chen Shou's "Three Kingdoms: Sun Poyu's Rebellion Biography"-

Jian Fuxiang collected troops, fought together with the Yang people, broke the Zhuo army, and supervised Huaxiong and so on.

2) ** In "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", Guan Yu's beheading of Huaxiong is very brilliant, but unfortunately it is not a historical fact - Shao said: "It's a pity that my general Yan Liang and Wen Chou have not arrived!" If you have to be alone here, why be afraid of Huaxiong!

Before he finished speaking, the next step shouted: "The young general is willing to cut off Huaxiong's head and dedicate it to the tent!" When everyone looked at it, they saw that his body was nine feet long, his beard was two feet long, his eyes were phoenixes, his eyebrows were lying silkworms, his face was like a heavy jujube, and his voice was like a giant bell, standing in front of the tent.

Shao asked who. Gongsun Zan said: "This Liu Xuande's brother Guan Yu is also."

Shao asked what his current position was. Zan said: "Follow Liu Xuande as a horse archer."

Yuan Shu shouted on the tent: "You deceive my princes and have no generals? Measure an archer, and dare to talk nonsense!

Fight with me! Cao Cao said in a hurry: "The highway is angry."

If this man speaks loudly, he will have courage; Try to teach the horse, if it is not victorious, it is not too late. Yuan Shao said: "If you make an archer fight, you will be laughed at by Huaxiong."

Cao said: "This person has a good appearance, Hua Xiongan knows that he is an archer?" Guan Gong said:

If you don't win, behead somebody. Cao Jiao drank a glass of hot wine and drank with Guan Gong. Guan Gong said:

Pour the wine, and come when you go. "Get out of the tent and pick up the knife and fly on the horse. The princes heard the drums outside the pass, and the shouts were loud, like the sky destroying the earth, and the mountains collapsed, and everyone was shocked.

Just as he was about to listen, at the place where the bell rang, the horse went to the Chinese army, and Yun Chang mentioned Huaxiong's head and threw it on the ground. The wine is still warm. Later generations have a poem to praise it:

The first work of Weizhen Qiankun, the drums of Yuanmen painting sound in winter. Yun Chang stopped Shi heroically, and when the wine was still warm, he cut Huaxiong. ”

Guan Yu's warm wine and beheading Huaxiong is a matter in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Fictive.

The real Huaxiong was killed by Sun Jian. You can just look at the Three Kingdoms of Yizhong Tianpin.

In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, it was Guan Yu who killed.

In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Sun Jian killed.

Nope! The Romance of the Three Kingdoms is**! And with a strong personal bias!

It was Luo Guanzhong who helped him kill him!

It's more real to watch the Three Kingdoms!

No, there is no such thing in history. At that time, he should have been with Liu Bei in the plains.

Guan Yu warmed the wine and beheaded Hua Xiong, refusing to tell historians, there is such a thing, it can be said that Hua Xiong was killed by Guan Yu.

It was Luo Guanzhong who asked Guan Yu to kill, and Guan Yu probably didn't want to kill either.

It was Sun Jian who killed him.